Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I had an early set of Williams PRR scale Madison cars never run, but sat on the shelf for around 1o yrs.  I thought I better run them and enjoy them, well......ALL the trucks disintegrated when I touched them.  Needless to say I was not a happy camper.  I got no satisfaction from Williams by Bachman since it was before they bought Williams out.  Talking to a Williams dealer ( who has since passed away)  he said that in the beginning they were using inferior metal in the truck frames and it was known to happen.  I could have got new 6 wheel trucks for all the cars but I decided to sell them for $50.  Lost $225 on the deal.  I bought a set of K-Line cars to replace them.  Sometimes we don't know certain things are junk for a while.  I got over it hahahahah

Had some Williams Madisons years ago which developed the crumbling zinc problem

(due to impurities/other metals getting into the molten zinc, a subject often discussed here), but fortunately only 3 broke, and into large, stable pieces. I epoxied the offending

truck side frames back together and they have been fine ever since. This was 10 years ago, or so.

 

I sold the cars to a friend some years back (he was aware of their past) and they are still fine.

So, the "zinc pest", bad as it is, is not always a tragedy. It can be, but not in every case.

 

Another friend had some K-line passenger cars with crumbling trucks. I have had an occasional MTH zinc freight truck problem. And some 3rd Rail brass boxcar zinc trucks that

just evaporated, even the wheels.

 

But not much of it from anybody.

Originally Posted by trainman60:This dose happen, that is why I always say that quality will stand the test of time. Almost everything runs good right out of the box, but lets see how it stands up to play over the years and in your case a safe shelf.

I had an early set of Williams PRR scale Madison cars never run, but sat on the shelf for around 1o yrs.  I thought I better run them and enjoy them, well......ALL the trucks disintegrated when I touched them.  Needless to say I was not a happy camper.  I got no satisfaction from Williams by Bachman since it was before they bought Williams out.  Talking to a Williams dealer ( who has since passed away)  he said that in the beginning they were using inferior metal in the truck frames and it was known to happen.  I could have got new 6 wheel trucks for all the cars but I decided to sell them for $50.  Lost $225 on the deal.  I bought a set of K-Line cars to replace them.  Sometimes we don't know certain things are junk for a while.  I got over it hahahahah

 

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×