Skip to main content

Hi all,

 

One of my lighted bumpers is fried.  Not sure if it's the LED or the resistor.

 

I've seen the other threads here about their unreliability.  Oh well. 

 

Can someone tell me what specific parts (LED + resistor) I should look for?  And a good online source would also be much appreciated.

 

Thanks so much!

 

G

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I'm also very tempted to rewire all of these for accessory vs. track power, if that makes a difference.  The other weak ones I got to work all involved crimping and tightening various places on the track.  Not a long-term solution, I think.

 

Buying larger quantities (LED, resistor, and diode?) and making them all more bullet-proof (if that's possible!) would be my preference.

 

I don't mind tinkering. 

Originally Posted by Gl3nn:

Does anyone know if this would work?  The 3mm. To replace the LED/resistor pair.

 

http://www.mouser.com/new/king...right-resistor-LEDs/

 

 

The LED will only see about 8.1 VDC since it half wave rectifies the track voltage of say 18 VAC. So those will be a little low on voltage rating. However, I would just get some 3 mm red LEDs like this one...

http://www.mouser.com/ProductD...acIkGD5vItMYuA%3d%3d

 

It's pretty unlikely that you have a bad 1K resistor on the bottom of the bumper track. Have you measured it to see?

Last edited by cjack

Another good online source is DigiKey which also has the LED cjack recommends for the same price.

 

http://www.digikey.com/product.../754-1710-ND/3084070

 

My experience is DigiKey tends to be cheaper on shipping of lightweight parts like LEDs if you choose the USPS First Class. If you're going to perform surgery anyway, I'd do what GRJ said in the other thread and add a protection diode.

 

FWIW, here's the guts of the MTH Realtrax lighted bumper.  Perhaps overkill but it has a  4-diode bridge to convert track AC to DC, 1.5K resistor, 3mm Red LED.

 

ogr realtrax lighted bumper

Attachments

Images (1)
  • ogr realtrax lighted bumper

Decades ago when my vision and brain worked better I swear I could "see" the flicker from a half-waved LED that didn't have a capacitor...especially when I turned by head.  I can't remember if it was noticeably different if the AC was chopped-sine vs. pure sine as might be encountered on a track-powered LED bumper.

 

I wonder if MTH actually considered the flicker issue and went with 4 diodes because of long-term reliability vs. 1 diode plus an electrolytic cap.

Thank you all for the responses... very helpful.

 

cjack - no, haven't measured it yet.  Will, though.  Spent most of my time jiggling all the other bumpers trying to figure-out what was loose to get them working.  Poor QC, for sure.

 

Could someone help with a diode part number from Mouser or Digikey?  Not too up on all this.  Just enough to be dangerous. 

 

After modifying 6 of these to work on accessory power I can agree with the many previous comments about the lack of QC on these things.  Gunrunnerjohn was spot on with his fix on the wiggly LED, but there were other issues with loose/poor connections on the underside that added to it.

 

But, they work better now... not perfect, but better.

Gentlemen,

   I have a set of the FT wooden style bumpers, and several sets of the original Metal lighted tubular type, in the picture below on the elevated Pittsburgh trolley line, you can see which type I use all the time, they work all the time and do not burn up.  You can keep the wooden FT bumpers, although they look cool IMO they are nothing but junk.

PCRR/Dave

 

 

Last edited by Pine Creek Railroad

I became so aggravated with 7 of those fastrack bumpers I gave up. I only wanted to have a light on my sidings so I could tell if I had switched power to any of them.

 

I ended up cutting all the parts out and installing a 5mm red LED light in the end of the bumper. It's the Evans 7-19V AC/DC/DCC  LEDs. There wired right to the track power.

 

So cosmetically it looks the same but I now have a dependable light when I switch power to any of the sidings. 

 

G13nn you did it the proper way I did it the being electrical challenged way . And by the way I have those resistors if you or John want them. 

 

Larry

 

 

DSCN3166

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSCN3166
Originally Posted by Larry Sr.:

I became so aggravated with 7 of those fastrack bumpers I gave up. I only wanted to have a light on my sidings so I could tell if I had switched power to any of them.

 

I ended up cutting all the parts out and installing a 5mm red LED light in the end of the bumper. It's the Evans 7-19V AC/DC/DCC  LEDs. There wired right to the track power.

 

So cosmetically it looks the same but I now have a dependable light when I switch power to any of the sidings. 

 

G13nn you did it the proper way I did it the being electrical challenged way . And by the way I have those resistors if you or John want them. 

 

Larry

 

 

DSCN3166

larry, how would one go about wiring the LED directly to track power ?

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×