Skip to main content

Lionel was forced to modify their scale huskystacks to run on smaller radius curves by shortening their 48' containers by 1/2 inch[2 scale feet] shorter wells to clearance truck swing,obiviously not a big issue to their market.Atlas will not make that compromise in keeping with scale dimensions for their containers.

Originally Posted by Greenline:

MTH did not have to shorten their 48 foot containers to meet O-54.

Lionel shortened them to meet O-36.

Atlas stated in their Coming Soon 2016 flyer (earlier in this thread) the following:

3 rail O-72 minimum  radius (as low as 0-54 w/separate drawbar)

I hope this is still true.

MTH is a stand alone plastic car,Lionel like the coming Atlas car was a diecast scale model built strickly for their 3 rail market[0-36], by including  drawbars Atlas is providing a way for those who need a smaller radius to use the 3 car set obviously due to the length of 53' wellcars 36" radius is not doable without serious compromise to the model.JMO

Last edited by hibar
Hi-bar is right.  You can't compare these to standalone husky stack cars.
 
The problem is in the articulation.  If you try to push a 1:48 version of these through O-54 curves, the outside corners on adjacent cars will "hit" and prevent any further "folding".  At that point, the car will have no choice but to derail.
 
Some type of telescoping mechanism or a way to push the wells unprototypically too far apart will solve this.
 
Originally Posted by hibar:
Originally Posted by Greenline:

MTH did not have to shorten their 48 foot containers to meet O-54.

Lionel shortened them to meet O-36.

Atlas stated in their Coming Soon 2016 flyer (earlier in this thread) the following:

3 rail O-72 minimum  radius (as low as 0-54 w/separate drawbar)

I hope this is still true.

MTH is a stand alone plastic car,Lionel like the coming Atlas car was a diecast scale model built strickly for their 3 rail market[0-36], by including  drawbars Atlas is providing a way for those who need a smaller radius to use the 3 car set obviously due to the length of 53' wellcars 36" radius is not doable without serious compromise to the model.JMO

 

Many of us are running O-72 or wider curves for main line but we have to use smaller curves for additional lines and sidings in order to make maximum use of our space. I am very pleased that Atlas will provide alternate connectors that can be installed so the cars will navigate O-54. I will definitely be a buyer of the new car sets and containers.

Got tired of waiting for the 3-car Maxi-Stack sets from Atlas.

 

So I did some searching, and scored three 5-Car sets and a 2-Car set of MTH, and two 5-Car sets of Atlas.  Got ALL the containers as well, a good assortment of 20-footers, 40-footers and 45-footers.  ALL are well below MSRP and my choice of containers. 

 

I am a happy camper and I don't have to wait until April of 2016.  I'm just sayin'. 

Last edited by SantaFeJim
Originally Posted by Greenline:

       
Many of us are running O-72 or wider curves for main line but we have to use smaller curves for additional lines and sidings in order to make maximum use of our space. I am very pleased that Atlas will provide alternate connectors that can be installed so the cars will navigate O-54. I will definitely be a buyer of the new car sets and containers.

       
 
I agree with you,  granted my new layout has O72 for the outer line everything else is smaller.  I should start to look for older versions now. Nick
Last edited by t8afao
Originally Posted by SantaFeJim:

Got tired of waiting for the 3-car Maxi-Stack sets from Atlas.

 

So I did some searching, and scored three 5-Car sets and a 2-Car set of MTH, and two 5-Car sets of Atlas.  Got ALL the containers as well, a good assortment of 20-footers, 40-footers and 45-footers.  ALL are well below MSRP and my choice of containers. 

 

I am a happy camper and I don't have to wait until April of 2016.  I'm just sayin'. 

That's the beauty of the technology treadmill, Jim.  I sold a handful of my Atlas-O Gundersons, and also kept a few too.  Then I picked up a couple of MTH 5-car sets with containers.  So I won't need too many of these newer Atlas cars.  May get a set or two for variety, but that's all.  Certainly don't need to buy alot.

 

David

What do twin-stack have to do with Maxi-IVs?  You guys act as though one is interchangeable with the other, but they are loaded up at different terminals and have different customers.  
 
Sure its your railroad and you can assemble your trains as you see fit, but 53ft containers and 40ft containers are COMPLETELY different businesses.
 
 
Originally Posted by Rocky Mountaineer:
Originally Posted by SantaFeJim:

Got tired of waiting for the 3-car Maxi-Stack sets from Atlas.

 

So I did some searching, and scored three 5-Car sets and a 2-Car set of MTH, and two 5-Car sets of Atlas.  Got ALL the containers as well, a good assortment of 20-footers, 40-footers and 45-footers.  ALL are well below MSRP and my choice of containers. 

 

I am a happy camper and I don't have to wait until April of 2016.  I'm just sayin'. 

That's the beauty of the technology treadmill, Jim.  I sold a handful of my Atlas-O Gundersons, and also kept a few too.  Then I picked up a couple of MTH 5-car sets with containers.  So I won't need too many of these newer Atlas cars.  May get a set or two for variety, but that's all.  Certainly don't need to buy alot.

 

David

 

Originally Posted by Martin H:
What do twin-stack have to do with Maxi-IVs?  You guys act as though one is interchangeable with the other, but they are loaded up at different terminals and have different customers.  
 
Sure its your railroad and you can assemble your trains as you see fit, but 53ft containers and 40ft containers are COMPLETELY different businesses.
 
 
Originally Posted by Rocky Mountaineer:
Originally Posted by SantaFeJim:

Got tired of waiting for the 3-car Maxi-Stack sets from Atlas.

 

So I did some searching, and scored three 5-Car sets and a 2-Car set of MTH, and two 5-Car sets of Atlas.  Got ALL the containers as well, a good assortment of 20-footers, 40-footers and 45-footers.  ALL are well below MSRP and my choice of containers. 

 

I am a happy camper and I don't have to wait until April of 2016.  I'm just sayin'. 

That's the beauty of the technology treadmill, Jim.  I sold a handful of my Atlas-O Gundersons, and also kept a few too.  Then I picked up a couple of MTH 5-car sets with containers.  So I won't need too many of these newer Atlas cars.  May get a set or two for variety, but that's all.  Certainly don't need to buy alot.

 

David

 

 

I don't care if it was 40 footers, 45 footers, 20 footers or 53 footers.  I was looking to build a unit train of containers.  I did just that in a very short time and at a very good price.  As stated earlier "I don't have to wait until April of 2016".

 

Got it NOW and I am enjoying it now.  Do you think I give a crap about different customers and different terminals?  NOPE.  There isn't any terminal at all on our club layout.  Yet we have over 30% of our members running stack/container trains and we are enjoying every minute.

Oh, I thought you gave a crap about real trains and how they are used.
 
My mistake. 
 
(Actually I did know you don't care about prototypes.  I posted my response for the benefit of others who are still becoming familiar with intermodal operations. )
 
Originally Posted by SantaFeJim:
I don't care if it was 40 footers, 45 footers, 20 footers or 53 footers.  I was looking to build a unit train of containers.  I did just that in a very short time and at a very good price.  As stated earlier "I don't have to wait until April of 2016".

 

Got it NOW and I am enjoying it now.  Do you think I give a crap about different customers and different terminals?  NOPE.  There isn't any terminal at all on our club layout.  Yet we have over 30% of our members running stack/container trains and we are enjoying every minute.

 

Last edited by Martin H

I don't have the space to model both and for that reason alone it is not a

big deal to me BUT, I would like to know as much about how the real

railroads operate as I can find out. If anyone wants to make a thread on

all the details of intermodel operations, I would read or watch with great

interest. I think that if a knowledgeable person that could do as good a job

as Erik does on his on his reviews,was to do this, everyone would enjoy and

learn from it. They might not be able to model it, but it would be nice to know.

Originally Posted by TheTrainMaster:

Are these sets available to order yet or are we still waiting to be able to order? Wouldn't want to miss ordering them if orders are being taken.

Dealers are accepting pre-orders now.  Highly recommend Steve Nelson at Mr. Muffin's Trains for Atlas-O and MTH pre-orders.

 

According to the Atlas-O website, dealer orders for these cars are due Nov 11, 2015.

 

David

Originally Posted by Rocky Mountaineer:
Originally Posted by TheTrainMaster:

Are these sets available to order yet or are we still waiting to be able to order? Wouldn't want to miss ordering them if orders are being taken.

Dealers are accepting pre-orders now.  Highly recommend Steve Nelson at Mr. Muffin's Trains for Atlas-O and MTH pre-orders.

 

According to the Atlas-O website, dealer orders for these cars are due Nov 11, 2015.

 

David

Thanks for the info, going to work on getting my order in now! Don't want to miss out on these.

I'm slightly confused in how these sets are listed in relation to the price. On Atlas's website it lists the cars as 'Set A' and 'Set B' with the $290 list price. Public Delivery Track has them listed as 3-car sets for around $265. Mr Muffin's site has them listed as 'Set A/B' for around $260 per set. 

 

What does 'Set A' contain, 3 cars or 6 per set? I know twelve cans will be needed for 6 cars.

Good Day,

 

I realigned the item numbers in the hopes to make more sense of the prices on the sets.

 

Two road numbers are available per item number below. Each unit is a three car set of one road name/road number.  

 

 

3-RAIL ITEM         

 

 
3007400A BNSF (Circle-Cross logo) 
3007400B BNSF (Circle-Cross logo) 
3007401A BRAN 
3007401B BRAN         
3007402A Florida East Coast    
3007402B Florida East Coast 
3007403A TTX Company         
3007403B TTX Company 
  
2-Rail ITEM  
3008400ABNSF (Circle-Cross logo) 
3008400BBNSF (Circle-Cross logo) 
3008401ABRAN 
3008401BBRAN         
3008402AFlorida East Coast    
 3008402BFlorida East Coast 
3008403ATTX Company         
3008403BTTX Company 
Last edited by Swafford
Originally Posted by TheTrainMaster:

I'm slightly confused in how these sets are listed in relation to the price. On Atlas's website it lists the cars as 'Set A' and 'Set B' with the $290 list price. Public Delivery Track has them listed as 3-car sets for around $265. Mr Muffin's site has them listed as 'Set A/B' for around $260 per set. 

 

What does 'Set A' contain, 3 cars or 6 per set? I know twelve cans will be needed for 6 cars.

There are four road numbers per road name, thus four sets of three cars. Each carton, A or B, comes with two sets. Each set is priced at around what you have stated above.

 

  • From Mr. Muffin's

Atlas O Master Gunderson Maxi-IV Well Car - BNSF - Set A - 3 Rail

Atlas O Master Gunderson Maxi-IV Well Car - BNSF - Circle Cross logo - 2 road numbers available - 253012 and 253199 - 3 Rail - AO-3607400-A Order both!

Availability: We are taking pre-orders - select "check" at checkout and we will bill you when they come in!

 

$260.96

 

 

Note that Steve recommends that you order both. If you place 2 in the quantity box, you will receive both road numbers of, in this example, BNSF road numbers from the "A" carton at a total of $521.92. But wait...there's more...Next you get to order the cans...

Last edited by Mill City
Originally Posted by Mill City:
Originally Posted by TheTrainMaster:

I'm slightly confused in how these sets are listed in relation to the price. On Atlas's website it lists the cars as 'Set A' and 'Set B' with the $290 list price. Public Delivery Track has them listed as 3-car sets for around $265. Mr Muffin's site has them listed as 'Set A/B' for around $260 per set. 

 

What does 'Set A' contain, 3 cars or 6 per set? I know twelve cans will be needed for 6 cars.

There are four road numbers per road name, thus four sets of three cars. Each carton, A or B, comes with two sets. Each set is priced at around what you have stated above.

 

  • From Mr. Muffin's

Atlas O Master Gunderson Maxi-IV Well Car - BNSF - Set A - 3 Rail

Atlas O Master Gunderson Maxi-IV Well Car - BNSF - Circle Cross logo - 2 road numbers available - 253012 and 253199 - 3 Rail - AO-3607400-A Order both!

Availability: We are taking pre-orders - select "check" at checkout and we will bill you when they come in!

 

$260.96

 

 

Note that Steve recommends that you order both. If you place 2 in the quantity box, you will receive both road numbers of, in this example, BNSF road numbers from the "A" carton at a total of $521.92. But wait...there's more...Next you get to order the cans...

Okay, I think I am beginning to understand now. Each set basically would have a total of 6 cars with two out of the four road names. Set B would be 6 more cars with the other two road names, and would need a total of twenty-four cans to fill both sets. I think it makes sense now. 

 

I'm not afraid of the cost, i'll have the money well before next spring. Something that is built of high quality I don't mind paying the money for. I appreciate the clarification.

Last edited by TheTrainMaster
Originally Posted by TheTrainMaster:
...

What does 'Set A' contain, 3 cars or 6 per set? I know twelve cans will be needed for 6 cars.

I mentioned this earlier in the thread, and it's the easiest way I can think of to clarify the ordering confusion that Atlas-O has created...

 

  • Think of "Set A" as a master shipping carton that contains TWO 3-car sets:  the -1 and -2 roadnumbers.
  • Likewise, "Set B" is the master shipping carton that contains the other TWO 3-car sets: the -3 and -4 roadnumbers.

 

Why Atlas-O did this is anyone's guess.   They should have forgone the Set A and Set B lingo in the announcement, since the MSRP applies to EACH 3-car set (i.e., the -1, -2, -3, or -4 components within the master shipping carton).

 

We don't necessarily need to order the entire master carton... although some folks will.  But then the price is 2 x MSRP (or the 2X dealer's street-price).

 

Hope that helps.

 

David

Originally Posted by Rocky Mountaineer:
Originally Posted by TheTrainMaster:
...

What does 'Set A' contain, 3 cars or 6 per set? I know twelve cans will be needed for 6 cars.

I mentioned this earlier in the thread, and it's the easiest way I can think of to clarify the ordering confusion that Atlas-O has created...

 

  • Think of "Set A" as a master shipping carton that contains TWO 3-car sets:  the -1 and -2 roadnumbers.
  • Likewise, "Set B" is the master shipping carton that contains the other TWO 3-car sets: the -3 and -4 roadnumbers.

 

Why Atlas-O did this is anyone's guess.   They should have forgone the Set A and Set B lingo in the announcement, since the MSRP applies to EACH 3-car set (i.e., the -1, -2, -3, or -4 components within the master shipping carton).

 

We don't necessarily need to order the entire master carton... although some folks will.  But then the price is 2 x MSRP (or the 2X dealer's street-price).

 

Hope that helps.

 

David

Exactly right. Thanks, David. 

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×