Skip to main content

There is a blue comet 400E on eBay with a starting bid price of $1700.  If I knew how to post the link I would, but if you google lionel blue comet 400E, you'll see what I mean.  Being new to the standard gauge game, but enjoying it immensely I will add, what flaws do you see in this piece?  I'm thinking it was probably repainted, the trim pieces on the side of the boiler should be brass, they are some off silver color that almost looks like plastic, and the cab interior is reversed with a slot, which is different than what I see in Greenberg's book for this model.  Just for fun, any thoughts?
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

 

  Def. restored. The cab slot is on/off for the chugger and a cut out for the e-unit. The side air tanks are die cast and look to have been cleaned rubbing off the thin copper plating. Priced too high for a restoration, but I have seen worse ones bring more money! 

I always caution new entries into the hobby to be weary of books. Just because it is in print does not make it gospel!!!

Originally Posted by The Nighthawk:

I always caution new entries into the hobby to be weary of books. Just because it is in print does not make it gospel!!!

While I do agree. It's only to a point. Most collectors use as many as three trust worthy reference publications. Doyle's publications have no place in the collectors library due to the many proven charges of, plagiarism against him. Greenberg's publications have a proven track record. His newest book raises the bar for Std Gauge. He was in complete control from writing to publishing. I sincerely hope that I'm around when his three volume set covering, Prewar Lionel O-Gauge trains is released sometime in the Fall of 2021. I am convinced that it will be the best Prewar O-Gauge Guide ever written. Of course this is my own opinion. That being said....

 

The new collector should read up on his/ her particular favorite. You should know about each year of manufacture and changes that the manufactures made. And lastly get to know each and every item that's in your circle and every item that touches your circle of expertise. Well, that's my nickels worth. I'll go back to my corner now. 

Last edited by Prewar Pappy

Any collector worth his salt knows the Greenberg books are filled with inaccuracies.  Pioneer collectors had no books...just acquired knowledge.  It is absurd for a new collector to even think about a Blue Comet as it would be like a Chevy guy looking at a Lamborghini.  The mere fact that the poster is asking these questions suggests he is not knowledgeable about Standard Gauge.  Buy only what you know about.

Originally Posted by William 1:
I was just thinking, I would never pay two grand for an o gauge engine of any ilk, but a beauty like that, well...

I think Ron was just trying to help!  Sometimes the written word comes across different than the face to face.  BTW, that 400e looks like a pretty good example to me, FWIW!  

Originally Posted by Ron Blume:

Any collector worth his salt knows the Greenberg books are filled with inaccuracies. 

Any collector worth his salt knows Ron Blume blows a lot of hot air.

 

Knowledge of toy trains or any other collectible evolves over time. NO reference can ever be considered definitive or complete. They strive to be comprehensive and they strive to be accurate (hence the involvement of peers in the compilation of such works), but that's about as far as they can go. They often inspire further inquiry and result in new knowledge, and that's truly what it's all about.

I have already learned a bunch.  It is a great reference book.  I think I know how to use resources.  It's like people who bad rap Wikipedia.  It may not be gospel, but it certainly is a good starting point to gain knowledge on almost any subject.  And go from there.  Plus, since the shipping of my book got a little goofed up due to an error on my end, me and Greenberg are email buddies by now.  I like my book!  My intention was to discuss the engine.  I wasn't looking for someone to tell me it was a good deal and buy it.  Although now I may have to...

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×