Skip to main content

I probably won't find any new or working used Flapper type smoke stacks. But I took the engine apart to see if I could improve the smoking becausethe middle stack didn't smoke at all after the first day or so. And this is what I found...

IMG_1472IMG_1479

IMG_1480

Not sure why this happened other than the previous owner had it apart. Maybe pinched the wire going to the second smoke unit or the fact that it rests on a shield and there is no shield on the smoke unit itself like the other two. It looks like the "mot-" wire got the worst of it. All of the fans have run as required but only the middle unit was not smoking. It did get warm on the stack though. I'm thinking the melting was not keeping it from sometimes running the fan at some speed but the "mot-" wire, second unit, was separated in the harness, see the second picture above, when I moved the wires. The unit had a mess inside the batting and resistor. It was the worst of them. Maybe the fan was not quite up to keeping the heat out of the unit.

So it looks like none of the smoke unit wiring is available. I will have to rebuild them or possibly find other 4 wire harnesses in Lionel Parts for other engines.

Anyone have any pointers to four wire harnesses in this size? And 12 wire harnesses? The 12 pin connector also got so hot that the keeper on the "mot-" wire socket snapped off when I tried to remove the socket which had the burned up wire. So that's a pickle if there are no harnesses.

Rats...

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_1472
  • IMG_1479
  • IMG_1480
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I can't see exactly what you have, what's the spacing on those connectors.  All the connectors are available, I stock the 2.5mm, the 2mm, and the 1.5mm connectors that Lionel uses.  I frequently build my own harnesses if I need a custom one.  Those look like either the 2mm or the 2.5mm connectors.  Rebuilding that harness shouldn't be a major issue.

A closer look at the sides of the connectors would help as well.  Those look to be the JST PH 2.0mm connectors from the pictures.

This is the JST EH connector, note the side grooves.

 

This is the JST PH 2.0mm connectors

Attachments

Images (2)
  • mceclip0
  • mceclip1
Last edited by gunrunnerjohn

That's encouraging...I was about to go have a martini.

It's the 2mm spacing. The socket pins are the ones with the short barb as shown here. I have some of them left over from some Cruise M stuff I think is where they came from...maybe some ERR ACC kits.

Anyway here is what they look like. Do you have some Digikey part #s?

IMG_1488IMG_1486IMG_1485IMG_1484

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_1488
  • IMG_1486
  • IMG_1485

They do NOT use the same pins, even though it looks like it!  The appropriate pins are on each connector detail at the bottom of the page.  Don't try to stick the wrong pins into the connector, they will not work.

JST PH Family 2mm Rectangular Connectors

JST EH Family 2.5mm Rectangular Connectors

I use the Engineer PA-09 Crimp Tool to crimp these, it's gone up in price considerably since I bought mine!

Last edited by gunrunnerjohn

Yes I saw that one is .5mm and one is .6mm I guess. The PH takes the narrow ones.

I'm considering just selling this for parts or as is. I found a couple more "warm" wires underneath some of the bundles. Maybe I'll find one new in the box some day. This engine ran fine, great sounds, and all the fans worked and the first and third stacks smoked. The fan worked on the middle stack, but no smoke. The resistor was all gunked up with gooey packing. Great shell, etc. Was missing the 4 windows. I don't have that much in it. So I could move on and not lose much.

Thanks for the help on the connectors. I found all of them on Digikey and the two sizes of pins. So I have $12 coming but they are good for other stuff. Worth learning about the connectors. Thanks.

GRJ, I'm wondering since the burned wire (a single wire looks to be the only source of the other wire insulation melting) starts at the Smoke Fan Control PCB middle smoke unit socket. The wire was connected to a 4 connection pin marked on the back of the board labeled RAW (could be RAU) and goes to the smoke unit 4 connection pin labeled SMK+ (I was wrong when I said above that it went to MOT-). The wire was cooked it's whole length up to the smoke unit plug.  I'm pretty sure the SMK+ end of the resistor was touching the metal smoke unit case at some time. And there is a burn spot from one of the smoke unit screw heads that rests on the inside of the genset shell roof. I'm wondering if I should buy the $42 fan smoke fan control board.

All three RAWs are connected together on the smoke fan control PCB, so they sound like a buss that maybe isn't hurt by grounded the other end of a long wire thru a couple connectors, and a light touch to ground. So maybe I don't need to buy the $42 board

Last edited by cjack

Temporary update...

I started making a new wiring harness with the two sizes of pins and connectors and got ADHD pretty quick, so at that time, I happened to get the idea of searching all the Lionel parts that had Harness in their name since there were no harnesses listed in the Genset list. I came up with hundreds of harnesses, 6 of which looked to answer the length and pin/housing requirements. We shall see, but three of them the same will plug into the 12 pin tiny socket making the large multi connector harness. And the other three look to be the ones that will plug from Smoke PCB to each smoke unit. It's hard to tell if I have all the connector housings figured correctly ( had to down load the pictures and blow them up), but this is so much more fun!

One way or the other...

cjack posted:

It's hard to time a short single video and demo all three stacks...random is random.

You're getting much better smoke out of yours than I do out of mine (despite the fact that it's had relatively little run time). I've been very reluctant to open it up on the basis that getting it back together is likely to be challenging, to say the least. 

Are you still searching for the rain stacks? 

Hancock52 posted:
cjack posted:

It's hard to time a short single video and demo all three stacks...random is random.

You're getting much better smoke out of yours than I do out of mine (despite the fact that it's had relatively little run time). I've been very reluctant to open it up on the basis that getting it back together is likely to be challenging, to say the least. 

Are you still searching for the rain stacks? 

It smokes very well now. I guess that will change over time, but I repacked it with Lionel's latest 008 part number packing which seems to work better than previous material.

I'm still looking for the rain protected stacks. These were so crushed, I straightened them as best I could, that I ended up just super gluing one open.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×