Skip to main content

As I re-acquaint myself with model railroading (after a 60+ year layoff) I need to learn one more thing for sure: Which, if any tubular O gauge tracks are compatible? I bought a Lionel train set with FasTrack for my grandson. Besides being expensive, FasTrack appears to be way too touchy for laying out over the carpet. Once I went beyond the small oval track, and bought some more FasTrack (big mistake) I continual fought electrical dead spots. So I switched to tubular tracks that I am familiar with and what a difference. Throw it on the carpet and it works just fine.  So I want to continue with tubular but not sure which tracks are compatible.  Reading from the "Editors Desk" in my recent Classic Toy Trains mag, I see a subtle reference to Lionel prices (My dad couldn't have afforded to buy me a Lionel train set when I was a kid with the current prices), and the list of other manufactures such Atlas O, Williams by Bachmann, MTH, and Menard that are available as alternatives.  The ad in the magazine for Atlas O shows tracks that I am sure are NOT compatible with the traditional three rail tubular track that I have.  The question is are there other sources of tubular tracks (including switches, cross-overs) that are compatible with my Lionel tubular tracks? What do I have to look for when I am looking for tubular tracks?

 

Thank you,

 

Mike

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hey Mike

 

First thing's first. WHen you mention "Lionel tubular" did you buy O27 or regular O? The 27 has brown ties.

 

A lot of the tubular track I believe is compatable between manufacturers, Lionel is pretty well the standard. O27 won't work with regular O gauge stuff so there's that to look out for also.

For compatible track there is RMT or K-Line track in tubular that will mate up to Lionel O gauge tubular without any adapter pins. 

Gargraves will mate to 027 track very well or can mate to O gauge track but will need to be shimmed if using switches near to other kinds of track. 

Ross Custom switches do very well but are expensive for the beginner and may need adapter pins as well.

Atlas track if available is another decent track system.

 

Menards is making O gauge tubular track as well, supposed to be compatible to regular O gauge track.

 

Williams by Bachmann makes O gauge tubular track and is compatible to O gauge tubular track.  Don't buy the E Z track from Williams by Bachmann as it is another type of track similar to Fastrack.

 

Lee Fritz

Welcome back!

 

Lionel still makes tubular track although they are slowing down and ending regular production. 

 

You can use MTH track and Lionel Fastrack with adapter sections (I don't recommend MTH Realtrax). 

 

You can also you adapter pins for Gargraves, Atlas and Ross track but for carpet, those really aren't the best. 

 

You can really make any combination work but often times it doesn't look pretty and operation really isn't desirable. MTH's Realtrax and Lionel's Fastrak are really designed for carpet operation. Tubular track also works fine. Lionel tubular switches are junk - spend the money and go for Ross Custom Switches. They aren't really intended for carpet operation but the quality is the best of the best. 

 

Here is a photo of my old layout prior to expanding it and then tearing it down. That is a Ross switch. Two legs have 0-27 tubular coming out of it, and the third has O Gauge tubular. 

 

 

IMG_0016

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_0016

Eagle,

 Mike 1st many OGR members have been using FasTrack for carpet central layouts for lots of years, and have no real problems using it.  As was asked in a prior post about your Conventional Tubular, is it 027 or O gauge.  Lee Fritz gave you good advise on the RMT -Super Snap & older K Line SS track for O gauge, great stuff that matches Lionel O gauge with out any problems, and the RMT/K-Line switches are bullet proof and accommodate all different kinds of O gauge engines & rolling stock including Tin Plate.

PCRR/Dave  

Last edited by Pine Creek Railroad

If you go with wider curves than O-31:

-the trains will run better

-the trains will look better

-you can run larger locos

-the kids can run the trains faster

-the trains will not slow as much in the curves

-you can run longer cars

-you can run longer trains

 

You can get tubular track in a number of different diameters. Phooey on O-31.

Last edited by RoyBoy

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×