Skip to main content

I don't know about the rest of everyone, but I'm looking forward to seeing Gore Verbinski's take on the classic Lone Ranger, perhaps more so than any other film for this year. I'm also happy that Lionel's ready-to-run set does resemble, to some degree, the trains in the movie.

 

Unfortunately, the reviews coming in, so far at least, are more negative than positive. I really hope I'm wrong, since I loved Pirates of the Caribbean and Rango.

 

One thing's for sure though, it'll focus A LOT on the trains and the spectacular over-the-top train action we've come to accept in the recent years. Anyone else looking forward to it, or hoping it turns out good?

Last edited by Mikado 4501
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

While trade reviews have been so-so.....that's good news to me as i agree with them NEVER!

The train footage is wild....and if you have knowledge of trains you'll have to ignore the things like lobster claw couplers and box cars that can run down the track sideways......but I'll be fine as long as it's a decent story.....they can take a few Hollywwod liberties.

 

I kinda wish WbB had gotten the toy license as the locos in the movie look alot like WbB's newer 4-6-0 engine and I could see them do a cool movie train. I may have to myself if it's any good!

Well, with a collection of Fran Strycker (the originator of the Lone Ranger) books, and a fan of all those TV shows back when, I have serious doubts that those of us who lived that are gonna like Tonto with a buzzard sitting on his head.  For me,  the second "True Grit" did not measure up to the first.  I also am of the opinion that the guy who played the Lone Ranger in those, and, kind of eccentrically, tried to live the part forever, got rough treatment from the corporate license holders.  The guy they have playing the Lone Ranger in this version looks just plain skinny, like he was lost at sea for a few months and lived off what he could drag aboard.  But I guess if you sent

off a Cheerios boxtop for a Lone Ranger sparking pistol ring, you'd be hard to please, too.  To this day, I have to swat my hand to keep from starting a collection of cap

pistols including one very rare one I had as a kid and saw on eBay.

I have to see it.  The Lone Ranger.  A really cool Tonto.  And trains.  Hi Ho Silver, away.

 

I really, really wish, that you could stream it ahead of the theater release, like the movie Europa Report (pretty good actually) that we watched tonight from Amazon, a month  b e f o r e  theater release.  I'll skip the lines and noisy theater crowds this weekend, and go see it sometime late next week. 

How bad can it be?  After so many monumental stinkers by Hollywood over the years, this looks like a fun, action packed, shoot em up of the old fashioned kind.  I'll be within 10 degrees of the lens axis at 2 times the diagonal of the screen come this Saturday. 

 

I have been in love with Westerns since I had the complete Hopalong Cassidy outfit when I was 4 or so.  I know I had every cap gun Hubley et al ever made.  Neither me nor my friends became serial killers I'm proud to say.

Originally Posted by Polar Express 1225:

 

Is Lionel making a Lone ranger movie train set? I know they made an o-gauge Lone ranger set a couple years back.

Matt: That Lone Ranger set WAS the tie-in for THIS film... which was plagued with numerous cost over-runs & was almost declared dead more than once.  Perhaps now Lionel can start selling some of those sets if it creates some good marketing tie-ins!  Although Lionel's Lone Ranger set is better than it's tepid "Christmas Story" set... its not by much.  Its unfortunate too, because unlike "Harry Potter,""Thomas," & "A Christmas Story," it was the first time Lionel was actually on time & in line with a movie/TV-related product.  It turned out to be a mistake of all things!

Last edited by RadioRon
Originally Posted by Lafondue:
Originally Posted by Polar Express 1225:

 

Is Lionel making a Lone ranger movie train set? I know they made an o-gauge Lone ranger set a couple years back.

Was catalogued again in the 2013 RTR catalog.

 

Lego has actually a nice one and offer better play value, like always..yes it's non-powered.

 

lego-lone-ranger_constitution_train_chase

"Better play value"...at least in ONE person's opinion.  Nice generalization....  

I plan to see it.  I was a big Clayton Moore, Lone Ranger fan as a kid.  I'm also generally a Johnny Depp fan, and do expect him to steal the show.  He's no Jay Silverheels, but the TV Tonto seemed to serve as the show's conscience as much as the straight man or sidekick.  Unfortunately, the radio & TV show were both before my time, but the reruns on the weekends always had me riveted.  I'm hoping it will come to one of the couple drive-ins we have outside the Dallas/Fort Worth Metroplex...it would be a great way to catch it.

 

I debated getting the Lone Ranger set as a guilty pleasure, but read some cautioning details on quality here so I settled for the Lone Ranger & Outlaw Operating Car by itself.  HI-YO Silver!

I also grew up watching reruns of Clayton Moore and Jay Silverheels, and they made a pretty good impression on me as to what the characters should be like.  I despised the 80's movie version and the attempted reboot in the early 00's.  That being said, I am cautiously optimistic for the upcoming version.

 

If they manage to keep the Lone Ranger's moral code intact, avoid making either character a buffoon, and tell a good story without being preachy or politically correct, then I think it will be all right.

 

I am still tickled with my Lionel Lone Ranger set.

 

Andy

Originally Posted by xrayvizhen:

Does anyone know if any of the original show's music will be in the movie? Because if there's no William Tell Overture then I'm not gonna see it! If no Rossini then it's just another cowboy movie.

 

 

 

As a matter of fact, director Gore Verbinski already confirmed using the William Tell Overture during the movie's climax.

Trains or not, I will NOT be going to the theater to see this new film.  With the price of attending a movie at the theater being what it is (and including the obligatory large buttered popcorn and a small Coke), I reserve my in-theater participation for films that really look good to me.  DVD's are what I usually wait for because I can get them for a fraction of the price.

Originally Posted by Lee Willis:

I have to see it.  The Lone Ranger.  A really cool Tonto.  And trains.  Hi Ho Silver, away.

 

I really, really wish, that you could stream it ahead of the theater release, like the movie Europa Report (pretty good actually) that we watched tonight from Amazon, a month  b e f o r e  theater release.  I'll skip the lines and noisy theater crowds this weekend, and go see it sometime late next week. 

Sorry, but I still like Jay Silverheels as Tonto. 

Originally Posted by Alfred E Neuman:
Originally Posted by POTRZBE:
I have been in love with Westerns since I had the complete Hopalong Cassidy outfit when I was 4 or so.


Even spaghetti westerns?




What, me worry?

Spaghetti westerns, macaroni and cheese westerns, and adult westerns on TV where some days not a shot was fired.  Return with us now to those thrilling days of yesteryear, home to Gunsmoke, Have Gun Will Travel, Yancy Derringer,  Maverick, Cheyenne and so many more.  While I love DVDs and my big screen TV attached to a hard drive my son configured with about 300 HD movies, nothing beats the singular experience of a movie on a big screen with big sound and big popcorn.

Just remember, the critics have been so right about so many films. They hated:

  • The Sound of Music. They really hated this one.
  • Jaws
  • Star Wars
  • Independence Day

Seems they hate films that people like. Go figure.

 

By the way, Scale Rail -- good call on How the West was Won. I like that one, and despite Kevin Costner Silverado and Dances with Wolves. Blazing Saddles was entertaining and pretty much skewered every western movie and social cliche I can think of.

Last edited by AGHRMatt
Originally Posted by scale rail:

Anyway Tonto can't ride a horse. Don

The other Tonto could!  We have tickets to see the 10 am showing at the theater on July 4.  I can hardly wait.  I'll be a fun movie to watch on the big screen, with some buttered popcorn and a good crowd!  Matt

lone ranger

Attachments

Images (1)
  • lone ranger

We have come a long way in making movie 'Sets' since the late forties.  We did not have a TV until '53 so can remember I believe the 7P 30 minute radio show in '47 with me sitting on the floor next to the radio (might have to keep it turned to the station so needed to sit close), mother would be reading or sewing or darning, Dad would be listening from behind the daily newspaper, and my younger sister would be playing on the floor.  Great memories --- hope to keep on making new memories--- just returned home from seeing White House Down tonight --- don't want to ever see that happen for real either - again, we have come a long way from using just a picture on the wall for scenery or maybe an outside mural as big as a billboard--- now they can digialtize anything for scenery . 

Originally Posted by david1:

Looks like a on demand movie! My buddy who saw a preview of the movie is not impressed. It has some good scenes but overall he summed it up word in two words----it sucks. 

 

Why can't Hollywood make a good Lone Ranger movie? 3 movies, 3 flops. 

We don't know that this is a "BAD" L-R movie yet, do we???  In Hollywood, the ONLY flops are those movies that don't make money.  Trust me on that....

Originally Posted by rthomps:
Originally Posted by david1:

Looks like a on demand movie! My buddy who saw a preview of the movie is not impressed. It has some good scenes but overall he summed it up word in two words----it sucks. 

 

Why can't Hollywood make a good Lone Ranger movie? 3 movies, 3 flops. 

We don't know that this is a "BAD" L-R movie yet, do we???  In Hollywood, the ONLY flops are those movies that don't make money.  Trust me on that....

We all have seen a bad movie that still makes money but that is beside the point. I will see the movie tomorrow, but from the reviews I have read it don't seem to be a good movie. I'll let you know.

I saw this movie tonight (it ended about 3 hours ago. Our theatre released it Tuesday.) My girlfriend and I both agree it was a well made movie and worth the price of admission to see in theatres. What has been released in trailers does not do this movie justice. I was expecting a heavily CG'ed movie and went in thinking I would be disappointed, and I was wrong on both counts. There were a few good belly laughs included. The two major train scenes are fantasy, but did not detract from the movie.

Originally Posted by Phillip:

I can't see how they got Tonto to look so bad! Jay Silverheels who played Tonto in the 1949's never ever looked that bad.

 

 

 

If/when you guys see the movie, you will understand why Tonto affixes the bird to his head and why he painted his face the way he did.

 

After going back and re-reading some of the posts I skipped over, I cannot believe the amount of trash talked about this film without it being viewed in whole.

Originally Posted by Paul Kallus:

When I heard it was made by Disney I thought there was a good chance it wouldn't be good. Disney's formula for making movies = make enough action to grab a typical 8 year old's attention and the heck with everything else. Maybe the new Superman movie will get better reviews.

Try Disney's 'Something wicked this way comes' and see what they can do when they want to......GREAT movie most have never seen.

 

Leaving in a few minutes to see LONE......

Originally Posted by AGHRMatt:

Just remember, the critics have been so right about so many films. They hated:

  • The Sound of Music. They really hated this one.
  • Jaws
  • Star Wars
  • Independence Day

I don't know about the others, but Star Wars?  I well remember being part of the 1977 opening-night crowd for SW, and the reviews the next day were ecstatic.  I don't recall ever seeing any negative critical commentary at all.

Originally Posted by Balshis:
Originally Posted by AGHRMatt:

Just remember, the critics have been so right about so many films. They hated:

  • The Sound of Music. They really hated this one.
  • Jaws
  • Star Wars
  • Independence Day

I don't know about the others, but Star Wars?  I well remember being part of the 1977 opening-night crowd for SW, and the reviews the next day were ecstatic.  I don't recall ever seeing any negative critical commentary at all.

Also JAWS is, despite what it inspired afterwards, has gone down as one of the most acclaimed movies of all time, and Steven Speilberg's best.

Originally Posted by Chris Lord:

"Alright, let's do this"   REALLY???  Did they speak like that in the 1870s?  I expected it to be followed by "dude".

Well, FWIW, I have my doubts that they spoke all 1950's "Leave it to Beaver" squeaky-clean back in the 1870s either.

 

As to Johnny Depp and his Native American heritage, it's just been vague hearsay on Depp's part since there's been no official confirmation released to date.

 

I do recall him saying in an interview that he said his version of Tonto will help "put right" the number of times Native Americans have been "badly portrayed" in movies to date.

Originally Posted by Rufus:

Being of direct American Indinan ancestry, I too look forward as to how Tonto will

be portrayed.

 

Johnny Depp will be a good supporting actor.

Unlike the TV version, in this movie Tonto will be the lead character.

I expect it to be an interesting and action packed western movie that most will enjoy.

Originally Posted by ChessieFan72:
Originally Posted by Allan Miller:

I'm going to see the Superman flick tonight.


Honestly, if I had to go back and and choose just one of these two movies to see (S/TLR), I'd choose The Lone Ranger. I couldn't wait for Superman to be over.Way over done on effects.

not wanting to spoil it for anyone not yet seeing this movie, but I do have to agree. Good thing is that if one gets tired one can always close one's eyes and nap!!

Originally Posted by Rufus:
Originally Posted by ChessieFan72:
Originally Posted by Allan Miller:

I'm going to see the Superman flick tonight.


Honestly, if I had to go back and and choose just one of these two movies to see (S/TLR), I'd choose The Lone Ranger. I couldn't wait for Superman to be over.Way over done on effects.

not wanting to spoil it for anyone not yet seeing this movie, but I do have to agree. Good thing is that if one gets tired one can always close one's eyes and nap!!

I actually enjoyed "Man of Steel" enough to see it twice, and that is something I rarely do.  There were certain sections of the battle at the end that dragged on a little -- OK, maybe more than a little -- but that is not enough for me to pan the film.  I enjoyed it primarily because it delved deeper into the symbolism and deeper meaning of the character of Clark Kent/Kal-El and his hero's journey in becoming Superman, and the contrasting themes and philosophies between Earth and Krypton.  Personally, I think that "Man of Steel" is the best Superman film, and the best live-action version of the character that has been made to date.

 

Oh, and there are some trains in it, too.

 

Andy

I thought "Man of Steel" was good!  I've heard mixed reviews about Lone Ranger.  The boss and I are going on a movie date tomorrow to see Lone Ranger...we'll know then.  Some movies are more fun to see at the theaters.  We like going to the movies.  I'm not gonna wait for every movie to come out on Netflix or DVD.  Matt

Saw the movie this afternoon and my buddy was right- it sucks. It has some funny moments but I am very disappointed. Being a big Lone Ranger fan I was hoping for better but I guess Hollywood just can't make a decent Lone Ranger movie. They have had 3 chances and dropped the ball all three times. A waste of money IMO. 

Originally Posted by Allan Miller:

Like I said...I go mostly to get out of the house for a while and to sit back and enjoy a movie while munching some popcorn.  I don't do it often, but it's fine every once in a while.  Last truly decent movie I saw was the recent Bond film.

 

As it is with everything else:  Choice in film fare is a matter of different strokes for different folks.

I'd give the new Superman film a 6 out of 10 - great actors, excellent soundtrack, decent storytelling, but full of over-the-top destruction, melodrama and cliche's. Still one of the better movies this Summer.

 

And all my friends and I very much enjoyed Skyfall

Originally Posted by david1:

Saw the movie this afternoon and my buddy was right- it sucks. It has some funny moments but I am very disappointed. Being a big Lone Ranger fan I was hoping for better but I guess Hollywood just can't make a decent Lone Ranger movie. They have had 3 chances and dropped the ball all three times. A waste of money IMO. 

It was that whole "Jack Sparrow as Tonto" thing wasn't it?  Johnny Depp, worlds most overated actor. Who can forget the other classic that he ruined.

 

 

 

Last edited by RickO
Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×