Skip to main content

Last week, out of the blue, my 8155 Monon stopped consistently actuating the non-derailment feature on the straight portion of one of my 022s.  Manually moving the engine through the switch also did not actuate it (most times) until I gave the front truck a little twist to bring the flanges into contact with the rails.  Other engines actuate the 022 with no problem – and the 8155 actuates other switches with no problem.

Given that the front truck has a traction tire, it seems clear what is happening (the traction tire is insulating the wheel from the rail) – but I’m not sure why only on just one switch in just one direction.  And, perhaps more broadly, why isn’t this a consistent problem for all engines with traction tires on the leading truck?  Or is it?

Last edited by JTrains
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The traction tire does insulate the flat part of the wheel from the rail. Often the flange will make contact with the rail to complete the circuit and activate the switch. (as described by JTRAINS)
Perhaps a good cleaning of the flanges of the traction tire wheels, and the rail (including the side that contacts the flange) will solve your issue.
When I saw the problem, it was on single motored engines. To resolve it, I just ran the engines with the motor truck in the rear.

I finally got a couple of minutes to get back to this question this weekend and confirmed the same behavior could be reproduced on an insulated section.  The wheels are about as clean as they can be and I tested them for continuity using a DMM.  What really perplexes me is: why did this just start happening now after dozens of hours of running?  My next step is to replace the traction tire (which has been on for about a year) and see if that makes a difference for some reason.

A random thought occurred to me: is there a way to make a traction tire conductive without introducing other problems? For example, I could put some conductive oil on it, but I guess that defeats the purpose of a traction tire...

Last edited by JTrains

If it continues to cause you problems, just extend the switch's actuating rail by about 3-4" so the  non-traction-tire wheels on your Monon engine activate it. Cut a piece of rail on the adjacent track section and insulate it, then replace the fiber pin on the switch rail with a steel pin and move the fiber pin to the end of the new actuating rail.

non-derail

Attachments

Images (1)
  • non-derail
Last edited by Jerry Nolan
Jerry Nolan posted:

If it continues to cause you problems, just extend the switch's actuating rail by about 3-4" so the  non-traction-tire wheels on your Monon engine activate it. Cut a piece of rail on the adjacent track section and insulate it, then replace the fiber pin on the switch rail with a steel pin and move the fiber pin to the end of the new actuating rail.

non-derail

WOW, it's just that simple.

wild mary posted:
Jerry Nolan posted:

If it continues to cause you problems, just extend the switch's actuating rail by about 3-4" so the  non-traction-tire wheels on your Monon engine activate it. Cut a piece of rail on the adjacent track section and insulate it, then replace the fiber pin on the switch rail with a steel pin and move the fiber pin to the end of the new actuating rail.

non-derail

WOW, it's just that simple.

Indeed it is!    What's perplexing me is why it started happening now - and only on that one switch. I'm going to check the gauging of the rails next (although they were correctly snapped around the Bakelite "guides" in the switch body (to my eyes).

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×