Skip to main content

Reply to "1:1 Scale battery-powered electric engines"

I have no real insight into the engineering and economic optimization scheme for battery-powered locomotives (likely way too early for that).  Agreed that there is an important advantage of having weight in the locomotives, but maybe the lead A unit doesn't need as much weight (or power) as the following B units, which could have the batteries and electric traction motors and most of the power.  The not-very-good analogy might be the last of the UP GTEL's where the lead A unit had a small diesel-electric system onboard but all the big horsepower was in the trailing unit containing the turbine and the associated generator and traction motors.

As with all-electric vehicles, a major issue is the time it takes to recharge the batteries.  An interesting comparison is with a gasoline fired car, taking 5 minutes to fill the 15 gal tank is a power equivalent of ~10 MW (!) (think about the combination of voltage and current to get to 10 MW...).  Although ol' Elon is working on it, it still takes time to recharge a Tesla at a supercharging station -- there's also, ultimately, a chemistry limit.  So, seems to me the idea of having a buncha B units that can be exchanged for fully charged units at various way-points is one logical way to approach this.

On other advantage of a fully electrical system is the ability to use regenerative braking in place of dynamic braking - so a fraction of the braking energy is usefully used, as opposed to dynamic breaking, which just dumps heat to the local atmosphere.

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
×