Skip to main content

Advice Needed On Scaler Versus Gauger

Hi Everyone,

I am trying to figure out whether to build my layout in  scale or a hi rail gauge form.  I don't think  any person who does either is better than one or the other as this is about fun.  I am just trying to sort out what things to look at to make me choose a path.  I, as many others, am limited by space.  My train room is only 15' wide and 17' long.  I have chosen S because HO is too small for me and O is a little much for the size of my room.

 I am sure as time progresses larger offerings of S scale will come to market.  What radius do you need to operate S scale?  As I understand it with S gauge you can run anything on a 28" radius?

The only thing I do not care for in S gauge are the large couplers.  The larger flanged wheels, swinging trucks/couplers and taller track profile are OK with me since I am used to the world of O gauge.  The only thing that I do not care for in the scale version is the fact that I think I may need a larger radius than my room size can handle, (limited track plan) and I am not sure if Lionel or M.T.H. offer scale versions of their S locomotives for compatibility?  I have seen where you can have an American Models S gauge converted to TMCC and RS which I think is encouraging and I would have to do that.

One more question if Lionel does produce scale versions can they operate on DCC I know that M.T.H. will?

 Any advice on helping me to sort this out is much appreciated.  And also I would like to run an occasional steam locomotive but as for modeling I'm thinking 70's and 80's.  Heck I guess I'd even run modern locomotives too.

Thank you.

Last edited by Rich Melvin
Original Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
×