Skip to main content

Reply to "Aerotrain in s scale?????????"

@richabr posted:

It would have been a horrible decision for Gilbert to produce this set. A too limited appeal and lack of dual service for play value would have been a sales disaster.  An RS design was likely too narrow for the drive used at the time. More likely candidates might have been a Trainmaster, RDC, Alco DL600 or a low nosed GE or GM unit. All were capable of using the diesel drive of the time and could have been made in various roadnames.

The RSD-7 wouldn't have been that bad a choice.  Gilbert did the GP7 after all.  It would've been the same basic design: PA motor block under the cab, non-powered truck under the long hood. Just add different sideframes.  It wouldn't have looked any worse than the stretched Blomberg sideframes the GP7 used.

Three roads along bought the RSD-7, with the Alco Demonstrators, all marketable in the 50's: Santa Fe, C&O and Pennsy.

And they could have "stretched the truth" and toss in roads that bought the externally similar RSD-15: DM&IR, Cotton Belt and Southern Pacific.  After all, how many prototype Santa Fe blue and yellow freight PA's were there?

Rusty

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
×