While I don't own any, I have no doubt Ross is indeed the gold standard when it comes to overall quality and performance. unfortunately, gold is also a useful adjective applied to the cost. I have a small setup and needed three switches. I went with GGs manual O-54 switches to stay within my budget. When they arrived, I saw right away why the GGs switches were such a bargain. The GG switches are not made with individual wood ties like their track. Instead, the rails are mounted on a black plastic base with the ties molded in. The plastic bases also had a slight "bow" that made me concerned on how they would perform. When connected to the rest of my GG track, the difference in color and depth of the ties was also obvious. It was a nice touch that the manual switches came pre-mounted with Caboose Hobbies ground throws.
I installed the switches with the rest of my GG track. I made sure to screw down the GG switches so as to flatten out the bow in the base. After installation, I spray painted and then ballasted my track (including the GG switches). Once done, the GG switches blended nicely with the rest of my track work. The real test came when it was time to run trains. I am happy to report that my MTH RK steamers and rolling stock operate flawlessly through the switches including the O-54 crossover. The steamers can crawl through the switches without a problem.
Overall, I am content with my GGs decision. If they maintain performance over time I have no complaints. That said, next time around I will likely try Ross. For me, a mix of the two types will be the best approach to balance quality and performance while staying within budget. Its not a one size fits all decision. Each of us will have to make the trades of cost and performance to arrive at the right plan to fit their individual needs and budget.
