Skip to main content

Reply to "Can you identify my 1950's or 1960 train set?"

That Pacific appears to have a diecast trailing truck like the one that's on the Pennsy K-5.  The Chicago and Northwestern 21085 from 1958 and a few years after that had the diecast trailing truck instead of the plain/exposed wheel version like the 282 and 283 that were produced before the 1957/1958 switch to 5 digit numbers in the Flyer line.  I got out a magnifying glass and it looks like a C&NW herald in the 2nd and 4th picture.  There's a tuscan colored Union Pacific 3 bay hopper - that was 24216 from 1958-1960.  The black lumber load flatcar is probably a 24516 NH that ran from 1957-1959, or possibly the 928 NH that ran through 1957.  Yellow boxcar with tuscan roof is a MKT numbered 937 that ran until 1958 or the hyper rare 24016 from 1958 only.  Single dome Gulf tankcar is either a 925 that ran through 1957 or a 24310 that was in the line from 1958-1960.  Yellow generator on a depressed center Erie flatcar is either a 946 from 1957 or 24529 from 1957-1958.  3rd picture looks like a rocket launching flatcar in front of the caboose that's either a 969 from 1957 or a 25045 from 1957-1960.  Caboose looks like a Reading 930 from 1953-1957 or 24603 1957-1958, 24608 from 1957, or 24610 from 1958-1960.  Transformer is indeed a Lionel TW.  Those are very educated guesses on the engine and cars based on what I could make out with the magnifying glass and a couple Greenberg illustrated books on Flyer.

 

Gilbert mixed 3 digit cars with 5 digit cars to fill out sets in 1957 and 1958; 1957 had a number of 3 digit cars appearing in the new 5 digit numbered boxes.  A handful of 5 digit cars like the 24016 MKT boxcar are in the mid to high hundreds for a VG or better car.  Good luck on your hunt - most of the items can be had for not too much $$$.

Last edited by MTN

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
×