Does anyone else thing Atlas won?
I was waiting for this catalog before ordering from either Lionel or Atlas. The Atlas Models are cheaper and in many cases higher quality. Thoughts?
See the attached PDF. I took the prices from Mr Muffin on a number of items that were practically the same model between Atlas 21/22 and Lionel 2022. Also, the 2021 C2 from Lionel had more favorable prices. The Genesis went up by $90?
Atlas O 30138032 - Premier - F40PH Diesel Locomotive "Amtrak" Phase IV #404 | Lionel L-2233722 - F40PH Amtrak # Phase IV |
$ 557.96 | $ 566.99 |
Atlas O 3007093 - Premier - Amfleet Passenger Car "Amtrak" Phase V $ 112.46 Ea. | Lionel L-2227330 - Amtrak Amfleet Phase V Coach two-Pack $ 327.99 ($164.00 ea.) |
Reading F7's $989.92 for 2 | Lehigh Valley LEGACY F7 AA Set #562, #566 $ 1,079.99 |
Atlas O 3007033B - Horizon Passenger Car "Amtrak" #54041 $ 134.96 ea | Lionel L-2227270 - F40PH Amtrak Phase III 21" Passenger 2-Pack $368.99 ($184.50 ea) |
Atlas O 30138045 - Premier - P-42 Genesis Diesel Locomotive "Amtrak" Phase V #173 $ 557.96 (scale) | Lionel L-2234010 - Genesis Amtrak #100 $ 494.99 (traditional) 2021 2I $404.99 |
LIONEL 2227050 - 2000S WOOD COACH "STRASBURG" #1 (2-CAR) SET 1$ 359.99 | LIONEL L-2227440 - NEW YORK CENTRAL COMBINE/COACH 2-PACK$ 368.99 |
