To me it's not close enough. Substituting a smaller tender for a larger one like what they are doing (especially when the tooling should be available since they used it twice before) is unacceptable. Why not do it right the first time and make people happy? I guess they are banking on people saying "I guess it's close enough." That tender might look ok with a RailKing model, but not the scale Chessie and AFT T1s.