P51,
Broken switch points are a PITA.
Though I agree with the fellow who suggests a CA tie over the two broken sides, I have never done so myself. I can, however, give you some general layout advice. NEVER go for the quick fix. Always go for the permanent solution even if it means removing and fixing the turnout.
If the turnout is accessible, you can try a manual throw with a different turnout.
Perhaps a San Juan turnout?
Another suggestion is the "Freerails" Forum narrow gauge section.
scrappy