Skip to main content

Reply to "MTH Rail King versus Premier."

You know, this is a funny topic for me because I had a completely different opinion on this subject just a few weeks ago 

 

I like Railking;  I really do.  In fact - every engine I have is Railking at the moment, and only one (The F3 ABA set) is scale.   As I've added Railking engines, I have become more and more aware of the size disparity - the F3's just seem enormous to me when they are on the layout.  It never used to bother me, but as I have grown somewhat in the hobby, it starts to bother me more.  When I see a RK steam engine next to a Premier steam engine on a dealer shelf, it gets really weird.  I'm finding that even the differences in size with rolling stock has become noticeable.   By all means, mix away if it doesn't bother you - for many/most it won't ever be an issue.  Just be aware that some engines compress better than others visually - I've never been able to wrap my brain around a semi-scale GG-1 for example.  The Railking PRR Turbine didn't do it for me either.  That's just me; the engines are fantastic for the money IMO!   

 

However...

 

I have begun to tire of semi-scale.  The offerings don't excite me as much anymore, and I  feel like I'm missing out on a number of things I'd really like to run but can't for lack of O-72 curves.   I'm currently exploring methods to get an O-72 loop into my layout.  My fear is that if I am successful, I will start moving more and more towards the scale offerings.  This is bad for me financially, because as I mentioned above, mixing semi-scale and scale steam is really strange for me.  I realize that there are plenty of Premier/Scale engines that do not require O-72, and that in a way that's not even part of this discussion, but for me it is because at the end of the day, it's about what I WANT to run, which is what this hobby should be 

 

So that's kind of my take - Railking ROCKS, but beware!  It may very well be the "hit" that pushes you over the edge to full-scale (pun intended...) addiction!

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
×