@HCF posted:Yes I realize it's not scale. I'm not looking to make a scale model but I am trying to get the essence of the prototype in a non scale loco. Historical reenactors often refer to putting together an "impression" with impressions having varying degrees of accuracy. With this engine I'm looking to craft an impression that's above a toy like state but not to the level of ultra detailed rivet counting. MTH Imperial locomotives are a good example of the balance I'm trying to achieve.
The prototype is an NdeM 4-8-4. My goal is to put together a piece that has the lines and most important details of the prototype but will still negotiate the smaller (O42) curves of my home layout and that won't tower over my other steam locomotives which are mostly post war.
Did not realize that the smokebox door was cast in one piece with the rest of the boiler. That's good to know. Do you have any idea of what direction I might poke in to find an 8 wheel engine shell with level walkways?
I thought a couple of us had discussed this with you before,….I could be wrong, but I vaguely remember some of us suggesting a Railking FEF would be a better starting point for your project,….remove the smoke lifters, and the lines are similar to the Mexican Niagaras ….
Pat 
