Skip to main content

Reply to "Tachometer Readings"

The time trials I did yesterday with my Marx 999 locomotive produced some interesting results. First let me describe the test rig. I have a loop of 0-31 gauge tubular track, and the total center-rail length is 13.4434'. I have a 275 watt Lionel ZW transformer, and I have power applied in two separate equidistant points along the line. I have a digital multimeter to monitor the track voltage. I used a lock-on to connect the red and black probes. I have an inexpensive clamp-style amp meter to monitor the amperage from the hot wire between the transformer and the track. I also have a 10 turn loop in this hot wire to improve the accuracy of the amp readings. For the time trial, I used the stopwatch feature of my Android phone, and timed the train over 5 laps. I tested just the locomotive at 5.5 VAC, 6 VAC, 6.5 VAC, and 7 VAC. Outside of this narrow band, the locomotive either would not move or would move so fast I was afraid that I'd derail and damage the 80+ year old antique. I then connected a tender, three freight cars, and a caboose and repeated the time trials at 7 VAC, 7.5 VAC, and 8 VAC. This band is even narrower, and again the train would not move at less than 7 VAC, and would run too fast beyond 8 VAC. Below is the velocity calculations and amp draw:

Locomotive Only:

TRACK VOLTAGEElapsed Time MINSpeed FPMMotor RPMSpeed MPHScale MPHAmp ReadingsPower Watts
5.51.142258.8508880.30.6742.81.689.24
60.726092.58541384.91.0567.31.7110.26
6.50.5912113.70361700.81.2982.71.7711.505
70.4160161.57932417.01.84117.51.8613.02



Locomotive pulling five cars:

TRACK VOLTAGEElapsed Time MINSpeed FPMMotor RPMSpeed MPHScale MPHAmp ReadingsPower Watts
71.045864.2733961.40.7346.72.114.7
7.50.5832115.26341724.21.3183.82.1215.9
80.4375153.63892298.21.75111.72.217.6


The most interesting finding is at 7 VAC, the locomotive alone was running at 117.5 MPH (scale), drawing 1.86 amps, 13.02 watts. When I attached the cars to the locomotive and ran it at 7 VAC, it slowed down to 46.7 MPH (scale) drawing 2.1 amps and 14.7 watts. One thing I should point out is that my amp readings would usually spike when the train was on the curve sections, so my amp readings are sort of a composite. It seems as though the majority of the power was consumed just moving the locomotive. The locomotive weighs 1 lb and 12.1 ounces, and the mechanical efficiency of the gear train is typical - i.e. not so good.



Marx 999 Power Profile

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Marx 999 Power Profile
Last edited by Mossback Mike

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
×