@Mallard4468 posted:I don't recall seeing whether or not Chuck's shop sold the set originally. If the set didn't come from his shop, extra kudos to him for trying to help.
I agree with the post above saying that having people chip in is a fine gesture but a slippery slope. Also appalled at the low quality of the motor.
Some ideas: 1) Help the mother to write a letter to Lionel about the situation. Any company that cares about their customers (especially new ones) should be willing to take action even though it's just outside of the warranty period. It would be really disappointing if Lionel won't help out. 2) Find a reliable used PW or MPC engine, and give it to the mother or sell it at cost.
Hopefully, this is an opportunity to build a future hobbyist.
FWIW, I agree with the above statements.
Once had an inexpensive HO Pacific, and the motor looked to be very similar to what's been shown here. In HO, it's "okay", but O...? 
In any case, I hope it works out.
Mark in Oregon
