Skip to main content

Reply to "Trolley with reversing bumpers"

Stan as usual has excellent ideas.  I just though I'd add a few lessons learned having implement several trolley scenes on my layout.  I have two bump and go scenes and one dog bone scene all on Super Streets.   One scene is an automated 4 way stop complete with traffic lights.  Another is a taxi scene complete with taxi cueing running 4 taxis.   The one I'm working on now is a simple back and forth with a bump and go similar to subject to this thread.  My plan is to use a solution similar to that of Stan's described above.  I want to pause my trolley at a school mid route.  Here are some things I am considering:

1)  I found my bump and go scenes a little boring with the same reputation each cycle.  The continuous bumping operation is also noisy/distracting.  To mix it up a little, I'm planning on using a timer similar to Stan's recommendation that shuts off power to an insulated section for lets say 20 seconds every couple of minutes.  The timer runs continuously and has no trigger.   I haven't decided on the exact timer settings.  The idea is to provide a degree of randomness to the automation. Relay contacts provide track isolation and active school crossing warnings.

2)  I found it nice to have an on/off switch for the automation.  Then you have 2 ways to run your bump and go.

3)  The speed you run the trolley at needs consideration.  In my case, I was always like running the trolley at minimum speed.  MTH trolleys have better low speed operation then Lionel in my experience.

4)  Even at the lowest speed, trolley's progress over a considerable distance in a short time.   When I figured this all out, I was dealing in milliseconds, not seconds.

5)  Also, the MTH and Lionel trolleys are different lengths which for my automations was a consideration.

6)  For folks using Super Streets, I found that Taxi wheel base was an issue.  The Super Street taxi wheel base is shorter which introduced a couple of issues which required resolution.

7)  My taxi scene uses 4 taxis.  I found the automation was speed sensitive.  Three of the taxis ran at the same speed.  The forth taxi ran faster.  I slowed this taxi to match the others by inserting series diodes in the taxi.

Last edited by shorling
OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653