Hey everyone
Thanks for the replies. I ended up finding a Lionel Lighthouse tower from ebay that fits perfect in my area. I need to find the top or make one myself.
I did look into the ceramic ones from Department 56 or Lemax, but they were too small and didn't look right with the custom scale buildings I have on my layout.
I plan to custom paint the day markings, as I am not fond of the red/white pattern.