This is non-religious and might be more helpful:
https://mortonsuggestioncom.qc.../Adult-Gift-Bag.html
(it’s actually a page with a lot of Operation Lifesaver swag on it, because their menu wasn’t turning up the good kid stuff.) Keychains, whistles, coloring books and crayons...it’s a nice assortment. Their shipping is expensive, but if you need a lot of product for a club event or whatever, the prices are so low it may even out.