Skip to main content

Hi Folks , I recently acquired the nice little fellow below , originally I was drawn to it by the similarity to the Bing British example that I have shared here with you all ...

After looking thru the photos a lot more closely , my mind is turning slightly towards it perhaps being pre-war Brimtoy ? Wells? or similar ( I really need to find me a set of British Toy Trains but at $50 postage per book on ebay and at most sellers ,its really putting me off buying them )

SO for your delectation and perusal let me entertain you ( lol )..... VVVVVVV

Now If we compare it to Bing British its kinda similar , but mebbe not? ( wheels for sure tho) and tinplate rather than cast chimney...

Either way its definately got a factory added on cylinders and cowcatcher ( for the US market I assume)

So wondering if this is another Stephan Bing UK creation , or as the tinkling in my meager brain possibly indicates an early Mettoy/Brimtoy/Wells creation ? Either way I think the "US-iffication " of it probably lends it to being a not common variant?

@sncf231e and @FRENCHTRAINS

What say you ?

( or indeed anyone )

Last edited by Fatman
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Thanks for looking Fred

@Jim O'C  I think I can safely bet my left knacker the shell is not Hornby

The mech is def not up to the usual robustness of the time and does suggest a "lower" tier manufacturer , which is simlar as well to the Bing British which had a lightweight mech, as well as Brimtoy/Wells/Mettoy

This shot also shows the fitment of the cowcatcher and cylinders , they are fitted in a way that looks to me to be a factory add on to a basic frame . The attachment doesnt speak to me of a layperson add-on ? I could be wrong of course ...

This also came from an estate of a pretty well connected collector here in Aus so I kind of expect some kind of provenance that died with him sadly ... I note the weight is also similar to Mettoy/Brimtoy ?

I remember seeing a Brimtoy/Mettoy fitted with a cowcatcher for an export run somewhere on the web , but for the life of me cant find it

Thanks Bryan ( and WELCOME! )

The 5600 and russet brown is an homage to the LMS railway in the UK , also used by Hornby for their Tank engines (No.1 and 501 series ) I know the L shape cab cutout Brimtoy to which you refer and its interesting that it too has cowcatcher AND buffers as well .. This one tho is stumping me

Darn I was really pinning my hopes on it being recognisable from one of the Foster books ... I have been able to track down pretty much everything in my collection apart from this loco and one other ...

However this one ^^^^ I am pretty sure is a "bespoke " period one off

 

These two Mystery locos will drive me to my grave LOL!!!

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×