Compared to all of the other choices like Fastrack, Atlas, MTH, these traditional tubular switches seem pretty expensive when new, up to $139 each. I wonder how long Lionel with manufacture these??
Original Post
Replies sorted oldest to newest
Not one of your mentioned switches are compatible with O-gauge tubular track. Ross tinplate would be an alternative and just as expensive. RMT is less but does not really match.
I have 2 lefts and a right if interested $225 for all three.
I do, about 10 or 12 on my layout.
Art
i used one (highly disguised) in my layout expansion connected to Gargraves track I like the reliability of the old lionel switches besides I had a bunch some day if I ever learn how to post pictures I'll take some and include them.
F&G RY posted:RMT is less but does not really match.
RMT/K-Line SuperSnap switches match the "O" profile and mate perfectly. The connectors don't need to be used - they can be cut off if desired and track connections made with regular "O" pins. They are the same dimensions/footprint of a standard 711/721 O-72 switch.
ADCX Rob posted:F&G RY posted:RMT is less but does not really match.
RMT/K-Line SuperSnap switches match the "O" profile and mate perfectly. The connectors don't need to be used - they can be cut off if desired and track connections made with regular "O" pins. They are the same dimensions/footprint of a standard 711/721 O-72 switch.
Another option is to move the tie on the section of track mating up to the RMT switch. Loosen the tabs and slide it back slightly and you won't have to alter the switch in any way. I've had good luck with them on my layout so far.
I just bought two, new, in the box for 120 dollars, total at a train show, last week end. Ebay usually sells 50-60 dollars for them.
I use Lionel No. 711 Prewar O72 switches. They work better than the modern ones and are now much cheaper. You do need to be careful which variation you purchase, but you can get decent looking ones for $50 each these days.
Like most original Lionel equipment, they're pretty much built to last -- and work -- forever.
Steven J. Serenska
If I were buying these switches I would definitely get the older ones. The newer switches that I have used and since gotten rid of, the frogs sat high causing a noticable bump and they also shorted with certain pickup rollers because of the small metal plate under each side of the frog that when the roller hit the frog and the center rail.
