Skip to main content

Getting to finalize track layout and starting on benchwork design. Basically my questions will be the pros and cons as they pertain to my layout/space/walls/ etc. I started a layer in scarm with only L-girder and will continue that for the last part. Height of Joists are 42" for now, since nothing is set in stone, except the walls of the room, all ideas for changes are welcome. I have read and re-read Linn Wescott's "How to Build Model Railroad Benchwork" And using that as a bible so to speak. I am not very good with scarm, as I cannot figure out how to fet the layout up to 42" I'll work on that aspect, but in the mean time here is a jpeg and scarm file of what has been done on design to date.

Happy Thanksgiving to All!

John 2020-11-25a dazL-girder

Attachments

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

John, Did you look into using cantilever construction off the walls or is it even possible with your room. I used that method to get rid of as many legs as possible and it works for me.

This is an old CAD drawing of what I did. I also ran tracks through and down the knee walls but mine is an attic room.

Your layout looks like it will be a winner.

cad_room_1 Train Room and Track

Attachments

Images (2)
  • cad_room_1
  • Train Room and Track

If you use cantilevers, you can either do them with wood or top each bracket with wood I use so you can still use risers to support elevation changes pretty much the same way you’d do with L-girder. You can also use the brackets all around and simply add some indented legs with an L-girder where the decking is deeper. While I favor flat decking, I’m assuming you want the landscape with ravines and hills, so cookie-cutter open decking would be the way to go.

@sidehack posted:

John, Did you look into using cantilever construction off the walls or is it even possible with your room. I used that method to get rid of as many legs as possible and it works for me.

This is an old CAD drawing of what I did. I also ran tracks through and down the knee walls but mine is an attic room.

Your layout looks like it will be a winner.

cad_room_1 Train Room and Track

Hi, Thanks for the awesome drawings! Two of my three walls are plaster board glued to foam insulation boards. Cannot drill deep enough to hit cement. There maybe some metal brackets they used to put up the foam board but I cannot trust them to hold anything. Your benchwork looks like it affords lots of access with lots of stability.

@Aegis21 posted:

Hi, Thanks for the awesome drawings! Two of my three walls are plaster board glued to foam insulation boards. Cannot drill deep enough to hit cement. There maybe some metal brackets they used to put up the foam board but I cannot trust them to hold anything. Your benchwork looks like it affords lots of access with lots of stability.

Well that answers that!  I wasn’t thinking about the exterior concrete walls being covered in that way.  And I used Mianne along my one brick wall because I didn’t want to put lag bolts into the brick wall.

Add Reply

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×