Skip to main content

I was going to put these in the Favorite boxcar post but I think these cars should have their own,  I remember GG-1 and F unit shell on the table at York with all of those boxcars.  I have never seen the passenger cars.

I you have them, post some pics.  will add more when I find them.



Images (1)
  • DSCF3655
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

HSD62,  You asked about passenger cars — here you go.  I purchased these from a place called Ellie’s Lokies I believe in the late 90s.  They were not cheap as the paint job, including the gold lettering is really super.  All the lettering is crisp and the same for the horizontal gold pinstripes along the side.  The Cornell Red is deep and rich.  I really don’t know who did the custom paint work for Frank’s Roundhouse.   Note the pictures below has a scale Pennsylvania car next to it to give a comparison of size.  These have been boxed up and stored for several years and have had little run time.  I’m actually thinking of selling them as I have a Weaver/MTH John Wilkes set for my Lehigh Valley passenger service.  If anyone is interested, send me an email with a reasonable offer.  Otherwise, enjoy the photos…..mceclip0mceclip1mceclip2mceclip4mceclip5mceclip6mceclip7mceclip3


Images (8)
  • mceclip0
  • mceclip1
  • mceclip2
  • mceclip4
  • mceclip3
  • mceclip5
  • mceclip6
  • mceclip7

Here are two of Frank's perhaps lesser known boxcars.  I met Franks when I was a junior in high school. He showed me the largest number of boxed 6464 boxcars I've ever seen.  He offered to sell me a boxed OO gauge set for $100.00.  I was a junior in high school and it may as well have been a million.  He was an extremely nice guy.


Images (2)
  • Polska boxcar
  • menonite boxcar
Last edited by Mike1234

I visited Frank Rash’s “Frank’s Roundhouse” train shop all the time when I was growing up.  I used to watch Frank’s son, Jack, assemble all these awesome cars in the shop.  

The boxcars would arrive to them with the painted/lettered shells separate from the stamped metal floors.  I can’t remember if the doors and door guides were also separate pieces that needed to be installed, or if they were already attached to the body shell.  There would be cases upon cases of decorated bodies, and boxes and boxes of steel floors.  The trucks were also separate—if my memory serves me correctly.  

Jack had to install the trucks on the floors, then attach the shells to the floors.  Then he put the finished cars in those classic stamped, white boxes.  He had quite the process down and was able to turn them out pretty quickly!

I remember thinking how they looked so much bigger and better than the equivalent Lionel boxcars of that period.  I suppose it’s no surprise that a few years later—when I had a job and some disposable income—I bought a LOT of these great cars!

This thread has taken me down memory lane!

Last edited by CNJ #1601

Don't forget the Custom Trains FMs made by Frank's Roundhouse. Well decorated and great pullers. FRH decorated 22 different Trainmasters. I have a PRR FM upgraded to TMCC by GRJ and love to run it with a set of the FRH PRR Madison cars.

For a good overview of the FRH production (boxcars, TOFCs, passenger cars, Trainmaster FMs, and F3s), check out

I've never seen the FRH GG1s mention by the OP but would love to see them. Please post pics if you have them.


SA-1014 D.H FM Trainmaster 101 lrSA-1011 Lackawanna FM 2321 lr


Images (2)
  • SA-1014 D.H FM Trainmaster 101 lr
  • SA-1011 Lackawanna FM 2321 lr

I, too, became instantly enamored of those (and earlier AMT/KMT/Kusan) boxcars because of the many different road names and shades of boxcar red that they were offered in, and that they were slightly more to scale than the 6464 series.

To identify them from a distance at meets (remember them?) just look for the triangular shape along the bottom edge of the plastic shells. That represents, probably, in real life some sort of gusset that ties the body to the frame, but it makes a quick method of identifying them on a shelf or in a box under the table of a dealer.  Also, take a look at the roof walkway on most of them. That detail has a molding error that carries over onto most of all of the box cars. Right near the end, in the tiny spaces that represent the walkway grating, a few of the spaces have become filled in.

Last edited by Arthur P. Bloom

Mark said: "IIRC, Frank’s were approx. the size of Williams boxcars, right? I had a 6 car set of NY Central PCMs, all diff. numbers, that I ran behind a Lionel 8477 GP9. Good lookin’ train."

"Good lookin' train"...absolutely. Their slightly larger size works visually with the 5' gauge track that we use.

Actually, to be more correct, Williams boxcars are the size of Franks. Frank's came before Jerry's. Williams, it seems, bought the tooling. Somebody else (Kader?) has them now.

HSD: That's a very nice collection of B&O cars. One of my grandfathers worked for the B&O. He gave me the Lionel 6468 blue automobile car for one of my early birthdays. The brown/red ones are the ones that we all saw in real life as kids. Finding a brown 6468 for a reasonable price (under $150.00) is difficult. I've been trying for a few decades.

Last edited by Arthur P. Bloom

Add Reply

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
Link copied to your clipboard.