Skip to main content

Alright my OGR forum friends...I'm already looking to expand my standard gauge fleet.  I was hoping you guys/gals can help me get me on the right track. First question-What other passenger cars would look good with a 400e besides the state cars.... if any? Second question-The couplers on the AF 4696 Piper seem to be different. Do only certain cars work with this engine and if you have one do you like it?  Last question.. I was looking at a set of standard gauge passenger cars and it said it had ives couplers? what does that mean?  Thanks for your help!  I learned from my experiences in O gauge that I should ask some questions before impulse buying!

 

Thanks so very much!

 

Sunrise

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

sunrise, you need to get yourself a good reference book on standard gauge.  one of the few in print is Peter Riddle's "America's Standard Gauge Electric Trains", edited by OGR's Alan Miller.  It'll fill in the details of the major manufacturers, both vintage and more contemporary.  It's available on amazon.com.  It will really help you sort through a lot of the misinformation out there on ebay etc.

 

the different manufacturers all had their own proprietary couplers, so you can't mix them without some modifications.   they each have their own characteristics, and as you get to know the trains made by different makers, you will find out what your favorites are.

 

MTH makes replicas of Lionel, Flyer, and Ives standard gauge, and their replicas have the same couplers as the originals - which is to say they don't mix and match.

 

The 400E steamer (in blue) is famous for pulling the blue comet cars, #427-430 series.   It's a big loco, so you'd want the big cars like these or maybe the #418 series.

 

While you're at it. Try, "Trains from Grandfathers Attic" also by, Dr. Peter Riddle. The title is a little deceptive. It takes up where his, "Standard Gauge Electric Trains" left off, IMHO. Excellent reading for those caught up in the, "spell" of Std. Gauge prewar trains.

Sunrise Special,

You have crossed over the threshold. You are now at the point of no return. Sit back, relax and enjoy the ride. Std. Gauge trains are the forefathers of todays hobby. Tinplate Std. Gauge is one of the most exciting areas of the hobby. Have fun and don't forget to share your wonderful newfound pleasure with friends and family.

Pappy, I agree 100%, Grandfather's Attic is another great tinplate book.  It's a little more focused on O gauge tinplate, but still very worth the investment for background info.  His section on restoration in that book is excellent if you're into that at all: when to restore, and how, and when not to.  

 

The photos Riddle uses are very helpful in comparing and sorting out the different manufacturers, couplers, and even the different sizes of Standard Gauge made by one manufacturer like Lionel.

 

The third book that I think of with these two by Riddle, is "Classic Toy Trains" by Gerry and Janet Souter.  This book really takes in the whole sweep of the various manufacturers and how things evolved to the state we're in now.  The Souters have a wry sense of humor that makes for terrific reading.  And again, the photos are really helpful.

 

I was brought up reading books so I always devour what is out there on a subject I'm interested in.   Of course, there can be wrong information in books too, but when the research has been done right, you can learn a lot.

 

Then of course there's the likes of Louis Hertz' "Riding the Tinplate Rails", if you really want to read the classics.  But that's another trip altogether.

 

Sunrise, I was brought up running my dad's Ives standard gauge trains, so I have a built-in bias toward a certain manufacturer and period as to what looks and feels "right".  I don't think I'll ever warm to Lionel with the same connection I feel toward the old Ives.  If you're starting out more neutral, that will be a benefit, you'll be able to look at all of them and decide what characteristics you like in each.

 

And compatibility is really not a problem.   You'll see many examples on these forums where folks have just switched out couplers to run one makers' freight behind another's loco. Others have made custom transition couplers to hook unlike cars together.  It's easy to do, and there aren't any rules to break. 

 

After Ives, my favorites are McCoy, which took me totally by surprise.  I didn't even know about them until just a few years ago, and the trains are much more toylike than the more realistic Ives.  But I just love them, they are the coolest thing.   Who knows, maybe you'll develop a passion for Dorfan or Boucher.

 

Originally Posted by hojack:
<SNIP>The third book that I think of with these two by Riddle, is "Classic Toy Trains" by Gerry and Janet Souter.  This book really takes in the whole sweep of the various manufacturers and how things evolved to the state we're in now.  The Souters have a wry sense of humor that makes for terrific reading.  And again, the photos are really helpful.

 <SNIP>

 

Unfortunately, there are so many errors in their book I couldn't recommend it. It is so bad even some of the captions have significant errors.

 

Ron M

Originally Posted by ron m:

 

Unfortunately, there are so many errors in their book I couldn't recommend it. It is so bad even some of the captions have significant errors.

 

Ron M

 

I was not aware of this.  Admitedly, I have mostly read the pre-war part of the book, as that is my interest.  Are the errors in the chapters on post-war?  Could you point out some examples?  Thanks.  The book is a great read, but I don't want to be recomending it if there are errors.

Originally Posted by hojack:
Originally Posted by ron m:

 

Unfortunately, there are so many errors in their book I couldn't recommend it. It is so bad even some of the captions have significant errors.

 

Ron M

 

I was not aware of this.  Admitedly, I have mostly read the pre-war part of the book, as that is my interest.  Are the errors in the chapters on post-war?  Could you point out some examples?  Thanks.  The book is a great read, but I don't want to be recomending it if there are errors.

Approximately ten years ago I wrote mini-reviews for the TCA's National Headquarters News on these three Souter books:

 

"Modern Toy Trains by Gerry and Janet Souter ISBN 0-7603-1179-0 $14.95. Short and somewhat imprecise history of toy trains from 1970 to the present time. Beautiful photos." (11/02)

 

"American Flyer Classic Toy Trains by Gerry and Janet Souter ISBN 1-58663-574-3 $35.00. A coffee table book. Beautiful photos, but is somewhat marred by historical inaccuracies." (11/02)

 

"Classic Lionel Trains by Gerry and Janet Souter ISBN 0-7603-1138-2 $14.95. Very evidently, there was a rush to publish. Numerous errors and gaffes. The pretty pictures are the only plus." (1/03)

 

The only thing going for the Souters is their photography.

 

Ron M

 

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×