Skip to main content

As I get further into O Scale I get the impression that VERY few people have 2R HOME Layouts.  2R equipment is much more scarce than 3R.  Within 70 miles of me (Poughkeepsie,NY), I know of 3 Club 2R layouts, but only 1 person who has a home layout.

I understand the challenges due to size.  It is often pointed out as the reason for the rise of HO post WW2 among scale model railroaders.

Please respond if you have a HOME 2R layout, or know of some near where you live.

Thank you!

Last edited by Allan Miller
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

As I get further into O Scale I get the impression that VERY few people have 2R HOME Layouts.

There are a good number of folks that simply do not advertise that they are model RR'ers, let alone 2R O scale. Some folks are actually rather private.

2R equipment is much more scarce than 3R.  Within 70 miles of me (Poughkeepsie,NY), I know of 3 Club 2R layouts, but only 1 person who has a home layout.

Not seeing that availability of equipment enters into having a layout; it takes very little equipment to actually have a layout.

I understand the challenges due to size.  It is often pointed out as the reason for the rise of HO post WW2 among scale model railroaders.

Size is also not really relevant either - size is dependent on choices made, not actual need

Please respond if you have a HOME 2R layout, or know of some near where you live.

Yup. In a "huge" 11x16 space,   And, there's at least 5 others in the area that I am aware of although that has decreased a wee bit over the past decade with deaths and relocations.

I am Blessed to have a layout in my finished daylight basement. It's an L shape. 20x12, 18x12 roughly. I have 150 feet of mainline ( 2 mainlines separate,  continuous ) Yard is roughly 4 tracks 6ft long that come together at both ends.

I'm in Coeurd Alene, Idaho. Don't know of any 2railers in Coeurd Alene. Making contact with a fellow in Spokane ( 35mi. West ) that reached out to me last week.

Would like to meet more 2railers if any were to be known.

John

Coeurd Alene, Idaho

@mwb posted:

There are a good number of folks that simply do not advertise that they are model RR'ers, let alone 2R O scale. Some folks are actually rather private.

Not seeing that availability of equipment enters into having a layout; it takes very little equipment to actually have a layout.

Size is also not really relevant either - size is dependent on choices made, not actual need

Yup. In a "huge" 11x16 space,   And, there's at least 5 others in the area that I am aware of although that has decreased a wee bit over the past decade with deaths and relocations.

Thank you for the perspective. You have very valid points.  Starting out in O gauge less than 2 years ago I have been surprised how much more prevalent 3R is versus 2R.  Just trying to "get a better handle on it".

@Derailed10o posted:

I am Blessed to have a layout in my finished daylight basement. It's an L shape. 20x12, 18x12 roughly. I have 150 feet of mainline ( 2 mainlines separate,  continuous ) Yard is roughly 4 tracks 6ft long that come together at both ends.

I'm in Coeurd Alene, Idaho. Don't know of any 2railers in Coeurd Alene. Making contact with a fellow in Spokane ( 35mi. West ) that reached out to me last week.

Would like to meet more 2railers if any were to be known.

John

Coeurd Alene, Idaho

Sounds like a great layout.  Wish I had the space to do something similar.

I know of a few here in the Chicago area, and in nearby (well, relatively speaking) Rockford, Illinois.    Any of you whom have attended the March Meet, will know who I am referring to.    Two are home / club layouts, while the others are home layouts.     Like Martin stated, some are quiet about advertising their layouts to the world.   I am a two railer, no layout, but would love the space for one.    I generally do not advertise my collection, not only for security reasons, but to not have people with a bunch of kiddos from knocking on my doors wanting to look at what I own!    Now don't mark me as a snoot.......  I do not mind sharing my hobby with other serious modelers, but most kids, and some adults, just do not understand the  delicate nature of some of our models.   And like many, I don't desire someone grabbing an expensive Overland brass diesel and knocking parts off with heavy handedness.

Last edited by R Nelson

Three quarters of my layout is in Maryland and three quarters of it is in Florida. Seriously, the layout is moving and being reconstructed in Florida. There is a really great group of local FL 2 rail 0 scalers and I don't think they are active on the forums. I have not had enough time to participate in FL as much as I'd like yet to get a feel for it, but I am really excited about this. There are some really great 2 rail modelers I associated with in the DC area and some of them don't really participate on the internet.

I know of a couple of 2 railers in Poughkeepsie where I’m from originally as well,…., but they are private folks, and don’t want to be advertised, and they don’t participate on the forum…..ditto on the one I know of in Midlothian Va. ( I work on his locomotives ) …….if I wasn’t so entrenched with so much 3 rail, I’d rip up the track and go 2 rail …probably even p48 …..

Pat

I live in the SF Bay Area.  I am aware of two home 2-rail O scale layouts.  Both layouts are owned by professional layout builders / modelers.  One layout is in a special upstairs room and the other is in an out building behind the house.  There are possibly 2 other 2-rail layouts but I am unsure if they still exist.  The SF Bay Area has lost 3 home layouts during the last decade because of the owners' deaths.  

There are also about ten 2-rail "collectors" in the area.  They have moderate  to large collections of 2-rail equipment but no place to run it.  I am in the small collector category.  

There are 2 large O scale club layouts in the Bay Area.  One is at the Golden Gate Model Railroad Museum in Richmond and the other is at the Alameda Fair Grounds in Pleasanton.  Both club layouts have existed for 50 + years and share space with smaller scale layouts.  NH Joe

Thank you to all that have replied, and those who may still reply.  Again lots of good perspective.

I do understand the privacy issue.  While I participate on this forum, I keep a low profile about this in my neighborhood.  I have the same feelings as mentioned by R Nelson.  While my models are 3R, I have Brass Steam Locos.  My young grandsons can look, but not handle.  I have given them other trains to play with.  If still interested, when they get older, it will be different.

I am sensitive to real or possible privacy wishes of many modelers. Jeff's beautiful craftsmanship has been shown many times in photos and videos posted to these forums. So has the A&O on occasion. I intentionally didn't mention by name a third layout in Northern Colorado (and potentially others) out of respect.

I was once an "unrepentant" lone wolf HO-scale modeler until my first visit to the A&O. David met with me 1:1 and set me up with a long coal drag powered by his Alco C430, with all the coupler slack run-in. When I heard the couplers stretch I was hooked, and subsequently my life changed for the "more" better.

Many readers might be surprised at the number of 2-rail layouts lurking out-of-sight within a short drive of their homes... (I don't have a secret list of them...)

Last edited by riogrande491

Three quarters of my layout is in Maryland and three quarters of it is in Florida. Seriously, the layout is moving and being reconstructed in Florida. There is a really great group of local FL 2 rail 0 scalers and I don't think they are active on the forums. I have not had enough time to participate in FL as much as I'd like yet to get a feel for it, but I am really excited about this. There are some really great 2 rail modelers I associated with in the DC area and some of them don't really participate on the internet.

You do not say where in FL you are but there used to be a two-rail modular club in southeast in the FTL, WPB area called FLORIDA ATLANTIC LINES. Unfortunately, most of the members have passed on or moved out of the area. I was a member but left in 2015 to move to SC. The below photo is the last set-up near West Palm that I was associated with:

West Palm TCA 14

I am hoping that H was able to take these modules with him when he moved. BTW, that setup ran very well for the duration of the TCA show where we set it up.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • West Palm TCA 14
Last edited by PRRMP54

I very much enjoyed the Allen Keller video series, though only a handful were of 2-rail O scale layouts, with John Armstrong being the one I remember - what a great man he was. OGR did at least a couple, Louis Hertz and Frank Miller's outstanding layouts. TM has done a couple, I think. The older OGRs from the 80s and 90s featured many 2-rail layouts - I've kept those issues because they're the best articles and photography to this day IMO. I don't know if those guys were master model railroaders, but they sure could design and build great layouts - and their writing was top notch.

Last edited by Paul Kallus

Long ago I came to the realization I was never going to have the space (1200 sq feet, geez) for a large layout of any kind.  That being said I have an eight ft by 2 ft O scale switching layout built on 2 inch pink foam.  Older atlas turnouts, atlas flex track, straight DC, two atlas locomotives, a SW and a plymouth plus a bakers dozen weaver cars.  Easily brought out for some fun and easily stored under the 3 rail layout.  I like shelf layouts because they can be completed quickly and offer some operational opportunities without breaking the bank.  My other shelf layout is a 1 x 7 ft HO version of the Gum Stump. 

Over 20 years ago here in central NJ there was a round robin group of 2 railers, I'm not sure if any of the layouts exist to this day but they provided they inspiration to try something.  There is one club in North Jersey and one in South Jersey. 

Thanks again to all that have replied.

After reading some of the earlier replies I tried to find information on the percentage of modellers in a particular scale.  When I subscribed to Model Railroader back in the 1990's they would do surveys' to try to get a handle on the number of people in the hobby.  They would publish the results.  Anyhow trying to find up to date information, had no luck.  As I recall at that time it was about 58% HO, 27% N,  and the remaining 15% O, G, S, Z, TT and whatever else (in decreasing order).  This of course was ONLY 2R.  3R was not considered in those figures.  Kalbach separated those out as Toy Trains.  Yes, now I know about 3R Scale items, but at that point being deep in HO, didn't have a clue!  What I don't remember is the club vs private layout data collected.  That was a asked on the survey, and both was an option.

From these responses there are still 2R personnel layouts out there, if you know where to find them!

@Jerry Davis posted:

Thanks Jerry I will have a look.  There was a YouTube link listed yesterday and replied, I knew what I would be doing for the next 1/2 hour.  Well that turned into 2 hours.  Don't expect to see me one the Forum for the next week.  LOL

Thanks again to all that have replied.

From these responses there are still 2R personnel layouts out there, if you know where to find them!

I am glad you asked that question and glad you came to that conclusion!   

I also have a 2 rail home layout,  and regularly post on this forum.  (Search  HOW I DID IT...  ). Here are a few photos,. The first two I also put on the currently running GG1 thread:

5323

5458

4301

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 5323
  • 5458
  • 4301
Last edited by John Sethian

I am glad you asked that question and glad you came to that conclusion!   

I also have a 2 rail home layout,  and regularly post on this forum.  (Search  HOW I DID IT...  ). Here are a few photos,. The first two I also put on the currently running GG1 thread:

5323

5458

4301

Holy Cow!!!

Using old Real RR photographs and saying they are from your layout just isn't ethical.  I swear I saw the leaves blowing on the trees.  Wait they are still photos, so I guess not.

There are 2 good sized O scale 2 rail home layout in Williamsburg, VA.  I've posted photos of my PRR railroad on the forum quite a few times over the years.  This is my 4th O scale layout since converting to O scale from HO in 1971.  Each layout was larger than its predecessor as career advancement (and kids leaving the nest!) made it possible to purchase homes with better basements.  My pre-retirement layout in Fairfax, VA was featured in the March 2000 issue of MR and was open for visits during NMRA and O Scale conventions.  Look for a follow-up article in 2023.

Fairfax layout's Horseshoe Curve - 3 tracks climbing the wrong way.

IMG_1455

Williamsburg layout's Horsehoe Curve - this time space allowed for 4 tracks climbing in the right direction.

IMG_1762

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_1455
  • IMG_1762
Last edited by Keystoned Ed

Main line and Matt,

My track is code 148 2 rail with an N scale 3rd rail soldered to brads pushed down into the cork road bed. I only did this on the 14 foot straightaways on my pike. The railroad is just a big oval around my third garage. Basically my hobby room . It is airconditioned and heated.

Attachments

Videos (1)
IMG_1754 (3)
@Purplepapa posted:

Since you asked.F37CC82D-709E-4FC4-8B18-00E15E74247274686A3B-46DC-472F-8448-58F11080CB8F528C4CAB-0779-4B5F-A171-806120068406

Love the control panel!  No need for fancy electronics in the locos.

BTW when seeing you model ACL, it brought back memories.  I use to live in Janesville WI, Monhart had ACL E3a #501 stored on a track adjacent to the ex-MILW roadhouse there for a few years.  What a beautiful Loco.  He also had a couple of BL-2, not quite so graceful.  The BL-2's actually were being used to pull freight trains in the 1980/90's.  The E3 was only fired up occasionally.

@Ron H posted:

Main line and Matt,

My track is code 148 2 rail with an N scale 3rd rail soldered to brads pushed down into the cork road bed. I only did this on the 14 foot straightaways on my pike. The railroad is just a big oval around my third garage. Basically my hobby room . It is airconditioned and heated.

Thank you Ron for the explanation on how you "made" the track.  So that is what your Thumping comment was based on when I asked about going Deadrail with 3R locomotives and using 2R track.  Now I have to decide whether to do what you did, or go Deadrail.

You center rail "disappears".  A lot of Real RR track has a nice line of oil running down the middle from what the locos and A/C Compressors leave behind.  If anything track was probably a lot dirtier in the steam days.

Thank you Ron for the explanation on how you "made" the track.  So that is what your Thumping comment was based on when I asked about going Deadrail with 3R locomotives and using 2R track.  Now I have to decide whether to do what you did, or go Deadrail.

You center rail "disappears".  A lot of Real RR track has a nice line of oil running down the middle from what the locos and A/C Compressors leave behind.  If anything track was probably a lot dirtier in the steam days.

I should darken the middle of the track a little more.

thanks for the suggestion.

Ron H

I’ve had O scale/Proto48 basement layouts since getting into O scale in 2008, but have had 3 homes/moves since then so have had to start over quite a lot. Most recently I purchased a new home in November. I hope this will be my last move, knock on wood, and planning to build a 40’ x 29’ Proto48 layout. I’ve retained approximately 58’ of modular sections which I’ve had since the beginning and already have them assembled and will permanently install once I get the basement finished. I have the modules on furniture sliders for the interim and will slide into place once the walls are completed.

BB8F207A-0412-41E1-B320-5E669D7AAA56

9564DE7C-72DE-4176-8C64-DC2970D5FA4F
John

Attachments

Images (2)
  • BB8F207A-0412-41E1-B320-5E669D7AAA56
  • 9564DE7C-72DE-4176-8C64-DC2970D5FA4F
@RRDOC posted:

A good way to "find" 2 Rail O Scale layouts is to attend the O Scale National Convention.  I attended the 2018 convention in the DC area (Rockville).  IIRC there were at least a dozen layouts on the tour.

Our 3 Rail club is visiting a 2 Rail O Scale layout in York, PA this evening.

Bob

In addition, there's NMRA's O-scale SIG:  https://oscalecentral.com/

I have a 13x30 layout that fills the upstairs of my house.  I run 3-rail engines and rolling stock, having converted the engines to BPRC using Deltang-based transmitters and receivers and 9.6 to 12v battery packs, on Code 148 2-rail track now for several years (need to look up when I 1st started it! Oops, it's in my signature line, 2015).  Also used Mianne benchwork to support it all.

I recently started adding scenery, now that I'm sure that the trackwork plan is what I wanted and runs flawlessly, but it's been a slow process, having taking up target shooting and other hobbies.

No recent photos, but here's a couple of the layout once the trackwork (Atlas, Micro-Engineering, and Signature Switch turnouts) was in place and some basic ground cover put down:

DSCN0426DSCN0427

The yard above has been graveled over.

And the layout plan, although it's been slightly re-engineered a couple of times where the sidings are located:

PLAN H 2019

My only regrets are:

1) Not doing this sooner and saving some $$$ (originally had DCS and TMCC and 3-rail track, which was basically junked)

2) Not redoing the knee walls and ceiling BEFORE installing the layout.  I despise sheetrock/drywall and want it gone, but the thought of dismantling the layout now does not sit well with me...not sure I could put it back together without having parts left over!!!  If I ever get froggy I may pull it down and install wood planking.

Attachments

Images (3)
  • DSCN0426
  • DSCN0427
  • PLAN H 2019
Last edited by Bob Delbridge

I have been building a "small" 2 rail layout in a 20' x 21' space.  As I wanted a decent mainline run, I made it an over under with a reverse loop for out and back to the yard.  I really wasn’t doing myself any favors with this design.  I like steam so I needed a turntable in the yard.  Then you have the changes in elevation needed to "go over"!  The small size necessitated pretty much all curves and 3 % grades. (do you know how hard it is to get uniform grades on curves). My yard area is straight and level as is my passenger station area.  Did I mention all track and turnouts and crossings are hand laid.

All my locomotives (like most of us I have about 3 times what I need!!!) are brass, many of the older models painted by me.  They are all equipped with sound decoders and many have been remotored. Loggers: 2 2-6-2T, 1 2-6-6-2T 1 2-4-4-2 Little River, a Willamette, a 3 Truck Climax and a Whitcomb Switcher as well as 2 Lee Snover Boxcabs. Mainline steam 1 2-8-0, 2 2-6-0 and 2 4-6-0.

Not going to go into structure construction and unbuilt kits!!!

I have got a few areas of scenery done to give me the motivation to go on.

I really wished I had 2 rail club in my area!  The layout is taking me forever and I’ve now calculated I will be 125 by the time it’s done!

Plugging away,

Peter

DC396866-0A0E-45C0-9121-7E8E0BEE6A9CE8F33BA1-44EB-4A00-BBE6-18CB43BD3EC718C2B516-F108-4CA3-B3C2-3C2942F2AF318046D42A-C805-4465-AF22-B90CD8A7663BB467738F-27A0-4AFE-B147-CC86CA532CCB

DFE5D81B-321A-4500-B641-AFD3C01AF3F34546AB71-5491-4967-A024-0EB54A6B0A83

Attachments

Images (7)
  • DC396866-0A0E-45C0-9121-7E8E0BEE6A9C
  • E8F33BA1-44EB-4A00-BBE6-18CB43BD3EC7
  • 18C2B516-F108-4CA3-B3C2-3C2942F2AF31
  • 8046D42A-C805-4465-AF22-B90CD8A7663B
  • B467738F-27A0-4AFE-B147-CC86CA532CCB
  • DFE5D81B-321A-4500-B641-AFD3C01AF3F3
  • 4546AB71-5491-4967-A024-0EB54A6B0A83
Last edited by Peter E B

I know you got your answers, but I just moved to the Syracuse, NY area and I don't know anyone here with a 2 rail layout.  I went to the one hobbyshop and he looked at me funny when I said I did O scale 2 rail.  When I lived in Savannah, GA I knew one other person that had O scale 2 rail, but he had an HO layout not O scale.

I am planning to start a small 2 rail (switching) layout  in January or February of 2023.  I think I have room for 3-4' x 16'...small but manageable.  Rather have something than keep my trains in the boxes.

Even more interesting, is how many O scale layouts are designed and used for operation?   

I designed mine that way and have held regular operating sessions since about the mid 1990s.     Most of the guys in my round-robin group that operate and have layouts have HO layouts, some quite large.     But the operations are fun regardless of size.    I want 8 people to operate mine, and I very seldom have less that 8 want to come to an op session.

Dear Fellow OGR 2 Rail O Scalers,

Per the OP request for 2 Rail O Scale layouts I have attached some stills and videos of my 18’x12.5’ layout started in 11/2015.

I utilized mostly commercially made products-Atlas,NCE DCC, Frog juicers ,Woodland Scenics, Mianne benchwork

Trees were hand made as well as most of the buildings .Scenery still a work in progress.

layout was built both genres of model railroading- operations and rail fanning.

Like Marty B stated, mostly rail fanning with my favorite beverage.

a bit of free advise, consider all aspects of the room you put your layout in PRIOR to building it. I am very glad I did, especially the lighting 5K LED!! One of our neighbors thought we were growing medical pot because the garage was so bright !!

Southern New Jersey is the home of the Cherry Valley club just celebrating its 60th year and also at least 4-6 home O Scale 2 rail layouts in the SNJ/ Pa area.

Cherry Valley meets on Tuesday evenings and open for memberships-scale is not important!!

All are welcome to visit my layout, just give me a call or email.A3E9AEBF-67F9-493B-9E93-BFC29F4EB66582D01BCA-ED51-41B4-9B9D-BEDEC2F66DE8652A38B7-730F-4DFF-940B-A3B39BF504A5

John P Dunn Sr. President

West Hayleyton , Emmaus , and Avery RR

609-432-2871 jdunn8888@comcast.net

Attachments

Images (4)
  • A3E9AEBF-67F9-493B-9E93-BFC29F4EB665
  • 82D01BCA-ED51-41B4-9B9D-BEDEC2F66DE8
  • 652A38B7-730F-4DFF-940B-A3B39BF504A5
  • CB6C3F19-66B7-43AE-9891-B79F093C8003
Videos (4)
trim.D1E6218B-ED54-4A8B-8336-E222C98BB7E1
trim.8BE7FDDA-97F0-4165-A64A-5DE08479DA13
trim.429A0677-580F-44F3-976D-9690EC3FA16C
trim.A7BD03D4-A0B3-4CDE-9EC7-F81BEA707741
Last edited by jdunn

I attended the NMRA National Convention in St. Louis.  Two home and one 2-rail club were on the tour schedule.  Here are a few photos.  NH Joe

This is a Missouri Pacific layout that is located in a large attic.  

2-Rail Layouts - 12-Rail Layouts - 22-Rail Layouts - 3

This is the Big Bend Railroad Club.  It is the oldest model railroad club in the St. Louis area.  The club is located in the old Webster Grove Station.  The club bought the station from the Frisco.

2-Rail Layouts - 42-Rail Layouts - 52-Rail Layouts - 62-Rail Layouts - 72-Rail Layouts - 82-Rail Layouts - 9

This is a large Rock Island layout that is located in a large basement.  The owner worked for the Rock Island railroad.

2-Rail Layouts - 102-Rail Layouts - 112-Rail Layouts - 122-Rail Layouts - 13

Attachments

Images (13)
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 1
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 2
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 3
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 4
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 5
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 6
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 7
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 8
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 9
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 10
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 11
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 12
  • 2-Rail Layouts - 13
@jgtrh62 posted:

I’ve had O scale/Proto48 basement layouts since getting into O scale in 2008, but have had 3 homes/moves since then so have had to start over quite a lot. Most recently I purchased a new home in November. I hope this will be my last move, knock on wood, and planning to build a 40’ x 29’ Proto48 layout. I’ve retained approximately 58’ of modular sections which I’ve had since the beginning and already have them assembled and will permanently install once I get the basement finished. I have the modules on furniture sliders for the interim and will slide into place once the walls are completed.

BB8F207A-0412-41E1-B320-5E669D7AAA56

9564DE7C-72DE-4176-8C64-DC2970D5FA4F
John

John,

Last time we spoke you were making the move to HO. I'm glad you are back on track, pun intended.

Dave

I know this much: 2-rail scale home layouts are much more common than 2-rail tinplate O gauge clockwork layouts.  I would be surprised if a half-dozen of those exist in the U.S. 

Back on topic, quite a few years ago I was fortunate to be a guest at a phenomenal 2-rail O gauge home layout in the Kansas City area.  Appalachian coal-hauling railroad with a functional CTC machine and trains operating flawlessly through beautiful scenery.  Very impressive.  Although I concentrate my efforts in a different niche of this hobby, I can certainly appreciate the work that goes into a well-executed layout like that, as well as the other layouts pictured in this thread. 

@Ron H posted:

Main line and Matt,

My track is code 148 2 rail with an N scale 3rd rail soldered to brads pushed down into the cork road bed. I only did this on the 14 foot straightaways on my pike. The railroad is just a big oval around my third garage. Basically my hobby room . It is airconditioned and heated.

Forgot to ask this before.  On the non Straight-aways, what do you have for Track/Switches, and how do you transition to it?

brass mikado rc controlledJim ,

On the other side of the room I transition to the smallest readymade turnouts and track. I forget what code. I did not want to hand build code 148 turnouts. I kind of poofed up the ballast so it is not so obvious to un informed guests. Speaking of guests, it's always the wives that really dig the trains. Not so much their husbands. Pitty.

Ron H

Attachments

Images (1)
  • brass mikado rc controlled
Last edited by Ron H
@Ron H posted:

brass mikado rc controlledJim ,

On the other side of the room I transition to the smallest readymade turnouts and track. I forget what code. I did not want to hand build code 148 turnouts. I kind of poofed up the ballast so it is not so obvious to un informed guests. Speaking of guests, it's always the wives that really dig the trains. Not so much their husbands. Pitty.

Ron H

Thanks Ron.  I found there is only a small percentage of guys that like trains.  Way tougher than finding other "Car Guys" to talk with.

Speaking of cars, I drive an 07 Z06 which runs in the 11s on the street on concrete, not on asphalt. It's been my experience most guys that say they like cars and maybe drive a Datsun Z, Miata or something kind of similar are terrified if I give them an acceleration run in the Z06. But , I've been racing for almost 50 years so I'm used to it.

However I wouldn't ride with an inexperienced super car driver.

@Strummer posted:

Please elaborate...🙂

Mark (back) in Oregon

Years ago, there was an article in OGR where the author hand laid code 148 track with a code 100 center rail. My thought process is to use commercial code 148 flex and install code 83 rail as a center pickup (blackened using neolube).

An earlier article discussed laying a wire supported on brass wood screws, but I'm not sure about the long term stability of that option. I'd also be concerned that the height would potentially cause the equipment to "ride up" on the wire and cause the wheels to climb out of the track.

Scale Trax is code 192 and I'd need to shim the approach tracks by about 1mm to match the height and elevate the center rail separately.

I will document everything I do regarding the build.

@AGHRMatt posted:

Years ago, there was an article in OGR where the author hand laid code 148 track with a code 100 center rail. My thought process is to use commercial code 148 flex and install code 83 rail as a center pickup (blackened using neolube).

An earlier article discussed laying a wire supported on brass wood screws, but I'm not sure about the long term stability of that option. I'd also be concerned that the height would potentially cause the equipment to "ride up" on the wire and cause the wheels to climb out of the track.

Scale Trax is code 192 and I'd need to shim the approach tracks by about 1mm to match the height and elevate the center rail separately.

I will document everything I do regarding the build.

Keep in mind that when you add the center rail, then you would no longer have a 2-rail layout to post in the 2-rail forum.  In other words, you would need to document it perhaps in the 3-rail scale or layout building/planning forums.

guys...this thread is about 2-rail layouts so please keep the discussion to 2 rails please.  This way those folks that are searching using our (less than perfect) search feature are able to find this thread rather than several threads showing up in their search.  The addition of an "almost invisible center rail using two rail track as a base is great and interesting but should be over on the 3-rail scale or track planning forum(s).  Thanks for your understanding.

One of the reason I started this Thread was to find out if 2R Home Layouts (not shelf switching layouts) are practical without needing a huge space.

BigBoy we might be on the same "Track" Pun intended.  That said, I have been also considering what you suggested Matt.  I started a post 3R Blasphemy recently as one idea I had to use 3R equipment on 2R track via dead rail.

So it looks like I may start a tread discussing my quandary.  I will start it under layout planning, since we will be discussing both 2R and 3R options.  That seems like the most appropriate area to me!

Last edited by MainLine Steam

One of the reason I started this Thread was to find out if 2R Home Layouts (not shelf switching layouts) are practical without needing a huge space.

BigBoy we might be on the same "Track" Pun intended.  That said, I have been also considering what you suggested Matt.  I started a post 3R Blasphemy recently as one idea I had to use 3R equipment on 2R track via dead rail.

So it looks like I may start a tread discussing my quandary.  I will start it under layout planning, since we will be discussing both 2R and 3R options.  That seems like the most appropriate area to me!

I will probably catch a little flak for this, but if it can be done in 3RS, it can be done in 2 rail. 

Can you run everything under the sun? Absolutely not. But you can put a layout together and have plenty of entertainment with a reasonable sized space if you're willing to make a few sacrifices.

I have a 2 rail layout. It has a *gasp* 36" minimum radius. I started laying it out in 3 rail and decided to switch it to 2 rail (the pandemic did strange things to people). The space limitations were already set, and it runs perfectly fine.  Its a fictional short line. 4 axle diesels are at home, and a lot of vertical can motor 6 axle diesels will also can run on it without a problem (even an ES44AC, yes, it looks a bit goofy, oh well).  I recognize I cant run huge trains and huge equipment, and its fine by me.  If you're willing to accept whatever limitations you put on yourself, then there isnt any reason why you can't have a 2 rail layout. IMO, the minimum layout size is an 80" circle (36" radius plus overhang). Will that layout be fun? Probably not, but it is "practical" since a train would run.

I will probably catch a little flak for this, but if it can be done in 3RS, it can be done in 2 rail.

Can you run everything under the sun? Absolutely not. But you can put a layout together and have plenty of entertainment with a reasonable sized space if you're willing to make a few sacrifices.

I have a 2 rail layout. It has a *gasp* 36" minimum radius. I started laying it out in 3 rail and decided to switch it to 2 rail (the pandemic did strange things to people). The space limitations were already set, and it runs perfectly fine.  Its a fictional short line. 4 axle diesels are at home, and a lot of vertical can motor 6 axle diesels will also can run on it without a problem (even an ES44AC, yes, it looks a bit goofy, oh well).  I recognize I cant run huge trains and huge equipment, and its fine by me.  If you're willing to accept whatever limitations you put on yourself, then there isnt any reason why you can't have a 2 rail layout. IMO, the minimum layout size is an 80" circle (36" radius plus overhang). Will that layout be fun? Probably not, but it is "practical" since a train would run.

My "problem" is that I like MainLine Steam Locos.  When I inquired on the forum the consensus was Scale Northern (4-8-4) Locos are happiest on 72" Radius and might run on 60" Radius.  Less than that, some will operate, most probably not.

A question for the administrators: Is the poster who calls himself OGR  (without posting an email or other address) a member of the OGR staff or merely  a troll imposing his narrow definition on this topic? Just asking? Curious minds want to know.

I have to laugh at this question....sorry.  OGR is the moderator account that is used by several different members of our team.  If I moderate, you will see my avatar and title.  So, nope this is not a troll and by the way, I agree with the statement made by "OGR".  This is the 2-rail forum and not the 2-rail with a third rail forum....  By the way, per our TOS, if a member has a problem with how we moderate or a question, please don't post something like that in a thread rather contact me directly or you can get to any of the moderators by emailing info@ogaugerr.com.

Last edited by OGR CEO-PUBLISHER

Great photos Erik.

Chris, the move and reconstruction of the layout is going very well, mostly as planned to this point but a few more trips than expected. The structure is going back together better than expected, really pretty easily. I'll have to take some photos of the process.

Dougklink, the layout is moving to Northeast Florida.

I have to check out for a while and get back to the move. Thanks guys.

@wb47 posted:

wonder where eric found that red tractor?

He has a Secret Shrinking Machine.  He would let us know how it works, but then he'd have to kill us!

The one that blows me away is the Scenicruiser!  The photography is impressive too, if I was shooting the pictures, the Green Dumpster across the street would show up in all of them.

Erik and Chris Great Stuff.  All I can say is, Thank you to ALL that have posted and of course.

WOW!

Last edited by MainLine Steam

One of the reason I started this Thread was to find out if 2R Home Layouts (not shelf switching layouts) are practical without needing a huge space.

Why the distinction between "home layout" & "shelf switching layout"..??? They are all model railroad layouts, aren't they? Or is it to do with the mindset promoted in the smaller scales that only multi-level basement empires are "proper" layouts worthy of the name?

My 2-rail O layout is 17ft x 8ft, modern Era Short Line (plus my Soo Line stuff which is my other interest) It's a roundy-roundy with 36" radius curves, #6 switches, and train lengths of 5 to 7 cars. A well designed shelf switcher can be as absorbing to run as a 'large' layout - read the blog & books of Lance Mindheim for more information.

My layout is also in England, UK (like me!!) where 2-rail O scale is currently booming, despite the fact our houses are on average much smaller than those in the USA. Perhaps our ready acceptance of Shelf Switcher layouts and their limitations is part of that boom, rather than slowly dying out as 2-rail O seems to be doing on your side of The Pond?

Last edited by SundayShunter

Why the distinction between "home layout" & "shelf switching layout"..??? They are all model railroad layouts, aren't they? Or is it to do with the mindset promoted in the smaller scales that only multi-level basement empires are "proper" layouts worthy of the name?

My 2-rail O layout is 17ft x 8ft, modern Era Short Line (plus my Soo Line stuff which is my other interest) It's a roundy-roundy with 36" radius curves, #6 switches, and train lengths of 5 to 7 cars. A well designed shelf switcher can be as absorbing to run as a 'large' layout - read the blog & books of Lance Mindheim for more information.

My layout is also in England, UK (like me!!) where 2-rail O scale is currently booming, despite the fact our houses are on average much smaller than those in the USA. Perhaps our ready acceptance of Shelf Switcher layouts and their limitations is part of that boom, rather than slowly dying out as 2-rail O seems to be doing on your side of The Pond?

Sorry for the mis-communication.  Yes switching Layouts do count as real layouts!  I did not me to disparage in any way.

I didn't say it in this thread but I am moving to O from the HO world.  I have found that I personally prefer "Circuit Running" as opposed to switching operations.   Many would say what I do gets old quickly, but for me when running my trains I don't want to have to think that much.  The white noise generated and watching the train goes round and round relaxes me.  So while maybe not as absorbing, "it is my cup of tea".

And Thank you, it is interesting  you have a 2R circuit layout that works in a 17x8 foot space.  Maybe I should look "across the pond" for inspiration.

@MainLine Steam No worries mate, the written word on it's own can easily be mis-interpreted.

Each to their own, this hobby caters for all sorts. Here's a plan of my 17ft x 8ft layout (not to scale). It's just a single oval, with a siding and diverging branch on one side, which leads round to some industrial spurs behind the 'main' on the other side. There is no hidden staging, "inbound" trains are just staged on the main in front of the spurs, and run round the oval a bit to rack up some miles, maybe while outbound cars are collected from the spurs & brought round to the interchange yard - just the siding & main in reality, but 'yard' sounds grander!!!

1884186898_RseauJordan.png.ab8690d4972eae95ad86385a2d7ec5dd

The two main types of operation it's designed for is interchange of trains between a Class 1 & my freelance Short Line on the one side, and then switching cars on the spurs the other side. These ops can easily take an hour or two to complete, or I can just run stuff roundy-roundy if I feel like it.

It's actually comparable in proportion to a 'sacred sheet' 8ft x 4ft layout in HO, but I was determined not to overfill it with track. All the track was hand spiked, & switches mostly use Right-O-Way parts, apart from the curved switch frog and two representations of Self-guarding frogs on the industry spurs that I made myself.

It took a couple of years to complete the spiking. I did it in stages so I always had chance to run something during construction. I started with the spurs, worked round to the switch with the main, laid the main in both directions around the room to meet on the other side, and included the switches for the siding, which was laid last of all. Most of it has been ballasted now, but scenic work & plenty of weeds on the 'bad' tracks are still in progress.

Hope that's of interest to everyone.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 1884186898_RseauJordan.png.ab8690d4972eae95ad86385a2d7ec5dd

During an NMRA event a few months ago, I attended an open house at a local O-scale 2-rail layout.  It was the largest completed O-scale layout I've ever visited in a private home.  Meticulous modeling - several scenes were based on prototype locations.  Unfortunately, the owner was unable to get any of his trains to run.  Note the white gloves visible in the first and last picture. 

IMG_2298IMG_2297IMG_2296

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_2298
  • IMG_2297
  • IMG_2296

More INCREDIBLE Layouts and photography.  I am so glad I started this topic. To all that have posted.

Grantham watched the video, keep pushing ahead.  I am still in the planning stage.  BTW loved the mixed consist, must have been during the VERY early Amtrak days, when they were running Steam Powered Heavyweights.  May 1 1971 err 1951?

With a move on the horizon we've been getting our home ready for the past few months.  However, before that happened I was actively building a Seaboard Air Line O Scale 2-Rail layout depicting Florida in the upstairs portion of our home.  I had designed it so I could also change eras and it could be Santa Fe or Southern Pacific in Southern California as well.

As I've been very industrious throughout my life and I designed the railroad as a large dog bone going down a hallway, through closet, three bedrooms, and across the top of the stairs yet also giving the feeling that you were going somewhere etc.  It was pretty laborious engineering going through walls to make everything look good, though I don't think I will do that again.  In fact one span across a guest bedroom was designed to fold up if we had overnight guests and it worked very well in a couple of tests.   

I also had a Southern Railway switching layout under the loop in one bedroom, but didn't get very far.  And yes, even below that I had a protolanced Florida East Coast in the 1960s (the prototype was destroyed by a hurricane in the early 1930s) in Key West, which did not get very far along either. 

For futures I will definitely go the linear route as I love walking with my train and popping in and out of bedrooms would not have satisfied me long term.  Not to mention guests who were trying to sleep with a 16 car 3 E unit consist of Seaboard's Silver Meteor blasting through in a fury! 

Happy Railroading!3DA4CC33-FE6D-4E22-A392-D60A1920EC2AF99665C2-0499-4B06-9D78-833D1AA08480E4C78818-C58A-4B42-91F7-BDD0BE24FB344326942C-57F1-4DF3-B6F7-8576992FC29D7C3282CB-46C5-49FB-88CB-05596B4E3FDC20D22238-C8DF-4F78-9395-858BA8EC0496F211A209-5BE6-47D1-8151-39BC51721CD7

Attachments

Images (7)
  • 3DA4CC33-FE6D-4E22-A392-D60A1920EC2A: Mock up of Silver Meteor headed to Miami!
  • F99665C2-0499-4B06-9D78-833D1AA08480: Winter Haven, Florida looking south from the SAL station toward the ACL diamond.
  • E4C78818-C58A-4B42-91F7-BDD0BE24FB34: Auburndale, Florida Mock Up
  • 4326942C-57F1-4DF3-B6F7-8576992FC29D: Auburndale, Florida Mock Up
  • 7C3282CB-46C5-49FB-88CB-05596B4E3FDC: Through the Guest Bedroom and collapsable benchwork
  • 20D22238-C8DF-4F78-9395-858BA8EC0496: Guest Bedroom and collapsable benchwork
  • F211A209-5BE6-47D1-8151-39BC51721CD7: Staging Loop in Master Bedroom (Teddy Bear was for wife to avoid walking into the railroad!)

Here’s a couple of videos of home 2-rail layouts. The first is mine, the next several are friend’s of mine, and the last are the excellent Terry Terrance videos that highlight quite a few home layouts. Well worth the watch.

Mine: https://youtu.be/XcRfqYVhcIU

Friends:

https://youtu.be/zi5-Bagz4qI

https://youtu.be/hISD1OBBPK8

https://youtu.be/zDw-lvR4u74

https://youtu.be/sQ3SJ9lgSq0

Terry’s videos:

https://youtu.be/HAjrZ_t6w28

https://youtu.be/WOTT4et0wFw

Here’s a couple of videos of home 2-rail layouts. The first is mine, the next several are friend’s of mine, and the last are the excellent Terry Terrance videos that highlight quite a few home layouts. Well worth the watch.

Mine: https://youtu.be/XcRfqYVhcIU

Friends:

https://youtu.be/zi5-Bagz4qI

https://youtu.be/hISD1OBBPK8

https://youtu.be/zDw-lvR4u74

https://youtu.be/sQ3SJ9lgSq0

Terry’s videos:

https://youtu.be/HAjrZ_t6w28

https://youtu.be/WOTT4et0wFw

Some serious modeling here.  I don't recall seeing any of these in a major magazine - they deserve some ink.

Here's a treat for everyone. This is the layout of Don Smith. I have been watching this layout for years. I have watched each video no less than 30 times. Not only because of the superb modeling but also because it reminds me of what I saw as a youngster in West Virginia, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. I have been asking him for over a year now to do a tour of his layout and I'm so happy he finally did it. The presentation will speak for itself. THIS IS SICK!!!

Dave

Ryan,

Nice work on these scenes. The first one is kind of "Howard Zanish" and in the second one I really like how you blended the river into the backdrop. That's not always easy to do. Thanks for sharing.

Dave

Thanks Dave! Howard is a good friend of mine so I’ve certainly learned some scenery techniques being around him. I’ve still got to add trees, bushes, etc. I appreciate the compliments. I really enjoy doing scenery. It’s one of my favorite parts of the hobby.

Dave, thanks for posting that. Just incredible modeling and detailing. Love the way it goes from rural to city but when viewing the photos it’s a subtle transition where you really can’t see it happening with the view blocks in the layout design. You tend to focus on the scene in front of you. Twenty minutes and I didn’t even need to see a train run to enjoy it.

Years ago I saw a few of his videos and become a fan.  I lucked out as he was selling some weathered cars on eBay. I won one. Not a car I really desired. I do my own weathering and I consider him one of the masters. But it basically was just to study it. It came tagged Industrial Models.

07ADF23F-03DE-4138-9558-CC2D4763C764

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 07ADF23F-03DE-4138-9558-CC2D4763C764
@Dave_C posted:

Dave, thanks for posting that. Just incredible modeling and detailing. Love the way it goes from rural to city but when viewing the photos it’s a subtle transition where you really can’t see it happening with the view blocks in the layout design. You tend to focus on the scene in front of you. Twenty minutes and I didn’t even need to see a train run to enjoy it.

Years ago I saw a few of his videos and become a fan.  I lucked out as he was selling some weathered cars on eBay. I won one. Not a car I really desired. I do my own weathering and I consider him one of the masters. But it basically was just to study it. It came tagged Industrial Models.

07ADF23F-03DE-4138-9558-CC2D4763C764

No problem! Agreed, the transitions are well done. I love scenery and details so I was right at home with the video. Lucky you with one of his models! I missed that period of time.

Dave

Thanks Dave! Howard is a good friend of mine so I’ve certainly learned some scenery techniques being around him. I’ve still got to add trees, bushes, etc. I appreciate the compliments. I really enjoy doing scenery. It’s one of my favorite parts of the hobby.

No problem! He's definitely one we could all learn from. Do you have any of his 1 million dollar buildings on your layout, lol? They are really nice but geez!

Dave

@marty track posted:

This is  Probably what most far layouts look like yes or no please reply20220311_17364220211117_20512920210808_10141120220130_12141320210808_101420

Based on my experience, most O-scale layouts either look like that or they are very small.  Not intended as a criticism, since my 3-rail empire isn't much different - building a layout takes a lot of time, effort, and money.  That's what makes the completeness of the layouts in this thread so amazing.

I've subscribed to Model Railroader for decades and receive the monthly NMRA magazine - don't recall ever seeing most of these layouts in either place, which surprises me.  Perhaps that's due to the focus on HO and N in those publications. 

Seems like an opportunity for OGR - @Allan Miller and @OGR CEO-PUBLISHER, I hope you plan to contact some of these folks regarding articles and/or producing a video.  I know that OGR normally relies on reader submissions, but several of these layouts might be worth some special effort to pursue.  (If I knew any of these layout owners personally, I'd try to do it, but I don't.)

There are some great layouts here! Simply amazing work. Mine is a little different, it is called Georgenstadt and is set in northern Bavaria during the late 1960s. It measures approximately 10 feet by 20 feet, but what makes it different is that it is totally sectional and is broken down every three years due to moves associated with my job. When I retire in 18 months I plan to set it up permanently in my “forever” home with possibly some additions. Miketg

Stellwerk397FC7EFF-4C4F-4568-BE88-A3C44C532BE442F9DF7C-32E4-49CD-AE21-C0555A81169EE033A80D-D1EB-4EFB-B6E6-56C0438079D2

Attachments

Images (4)
  • Stellwerk3
  • 97FC7EFF-4C4F-4568-BE88-A3C44C532BE4
  • 42F9DF7C-32E4-49CD-AE21-C0555A81169E
  • E033A80D-D1EB-4EFB-B6E6-56C0438079D2
Last edited by Miketg
@Mallard4468 posted:

I've subscribed to Model Railroader for decades and receive the monthly NMRA magazine - don't recall ever seeing most of these layouts in either place, which surprises me.  Perhaps that's due to the focus on HO and N in those publications.

Seems like an opportunity for OGR - @Allan Miller and @OGR CEO-PUBLISHER, I hope you plan to contact some of these folks regarding articles and/or producing a video.  I know that OGR normally relies on reader submissions, but several of these layouts might be worth some special effort to pursue.  (If I knew any of these layout owners personally, I'd try to do it, but I don't.)

I agree that these would be great to have in the magazine however it is very difficult to make contact with folks these days due to the lack of accurately published phone numbers, etc.  If someone on this board knows someone with a great layout, by all means contact them and see if you can share their phone number with us!

@mwb posted:

This is not an accurate statement; after a litany of excuses why you could not provide anything, there were no more responds to multiple invitations.  In fact, many are invited, but few respond.

Same here.  I know through private email I have encouraged you to submit to the magazine so I believe your memory is a little faulty here.  We have a very easy set of guidelines and all one has to do is follow those guidelines.  I have never received a submittal from you but I encourage you to do so.  Here is the link:  https://www.ogaugerr.com/faq/get-published/

Guys,

I'm sad to see the who did what and when over being published or not show up in this thread. We have a pretty good thread going here.

I agree wholeheratedly with Chris's statement about this being a pretty good thread. It has also, I think, shown a lot of non-2 railers who are unfamilar with our work what can, and has and is being done. Let's not let this thread get "derailed."

Thanks to the OGR forum for providing this opportunity.

@Miketg posted:

There are some great layouts here! Simply amazing work. Mine is a little different, it is called Georgenstadt and is set in northern Bavaria during the late 1960s. It measures approximately 10 feet by 20 feet, but what makes it different is that it is totally sectional and is broken down every three years due to moves associated with my job. When I retire in 18 months I plan to set it up permanently in my “forever” home with possibly some additions. Miketg

97FC7EFF-4C4F-4568-BE88-A3C44C532BE4

this is wonderful Mike!

Same here.  I know through private email I have encouraged you to submit to the magazine so I believe your memory is a little faulty here.  We have a very easy set of guidelines and all one has to do is follow those guidelines.  I have never received a submittal from you but I encourage you to do so.  Here is the link:  https://www.ogaugerr.com/faq/get-published/

I apologize Mr Arnold, I recall the nice replies in my content here offering to submit for review. I don’t see any private emails however they could have ended up in my spam folder the same with the other guys. I am sorry about the misunderstanding.

Guys,

I'm sad to see the who did what and when over being published or not show up in this thread. We have a pretty good thread going here.

There are thousands of posts per week and so we do not have the staff to be able to look for offerings to submit.  As I said above, we have a process to submit and so Erik or anybody else, if you want to be published, use that process ... I gave the link above.

I agree with Chris and John, lets get back on track here.  The submission of content should be done privately.

Last edited by OGR CEO-PUBLISHER

Thank you again to ALL that have been posting.  The creativity and artistry displayed in this thread is way more than I could have "imagined".  A lot of truly gifted people showing me what can be done.  Well, not necessarily by me, but others with great talent.  I'm more of a technical guy.  Anyhow, keep it coming.

I just showed the wife some of this thread... and, she especially liked the one's where  Eric does his cameo appearances.   "WOW!!!!  It's like watching an episode of the Twilight Zone... except, in COLOR!"

I need to lay off the Mountain Dew.. 🤣 she sounds like a really cool wife! Like mine. ☺️
2AD1B4E7-691F-48BA-8A14-0BB9FCBD182B


Having a good time with the hobby, life is so short , please do enjoy it where you can.

22EAED5B-2EFC-4074-B5CB-20560874F83A5E835C00-5F2E-4790-8696-73D0ED7FCD1353B48D59-EE5A-498D-8807-5C954BEF28CD12D2D448-1D7E-426A-AD1A-996D4A90FE5F6D8AE2DB-628A-45C7-8AC3-0A1C80F3AF639253CF13-5365-40DA-AD01-9AB180CC3E7B42A911EC-4C4F-4325-AC21-2082056D558BF1B39494-5CE6-4449-ACEA-CDD5346D581C00499723-5779-47CC-9DD1-00C6354DD3503D565B9F-E595-4998-A65D-B7B5C2DAE3BA

Attachments

Images (11)
  • 2AD1B4E7-691F-48BA-8A14-0BB9FCBD182B
  • 22EAED5B-2EFC-4074-B5CB-20560874F83A
  • 5E835C00-5F2E-4790-8696-73D0ED7FCD13
  • 53B48D59-EE5A-498D-8807-5C954BEF28CD
  • 12D2D448-1D7E-426A-AD1A-996D4A90FE5F
  • 6D8AE2DB-628A-45C7-8AC3-0A1C80F3AF63
  • 9253CF13-5365-40DA-AD01-9AB180CC3E7B
  • 42A911EC-4C4F-4325-AC21-2082056D558B
  • F1B39494-5CE6-4449-ACEA-CDD5346D581C
  • 00499723-5779-47CC-9DD1-00C6354DD350
  • 3D565B9F-E595-4998-A65D-B7B5C2DAE3BA
Last edited by Erik C Lindgren

I need to lay off the Mountain Dew.. 🤣 she sounds like a really cool wife! Like mine. ☺️
Having a good time with the hobby, life is so short , please do enjoy it where you can.

OH Yeah!  They have to be cool... l(.)(.)k who they married!

I'm just stunned by your (and, all the guys) work in this thread... it's just incredible.  It certainly encourages me to become a better modeler... not too good mind you.

So I think the answer to the original post is that yeah, heaps of us have home layouts in O scale 2-rail.

Some, like mine, are pineboard junctions. Temporary track but running trains.

Others are amazingly realistic!

One day I'll do at least enough scenery to have at least one nice scene on my layout.

I think the real winner is that despite not being mainstream, 2-rail is still a healthy and happy part of the model railroading hobby.

Mick

My guess is 2459 ,2-Rail home layouts.  Let me know the correct answer.

Charlie

Well when I asked the question, thought it was a LOT LESS.

I have been tallying the replies and still not quite to that number, but you may be right.  Should have posted this saying whoever guesses the right amount wins, "something".

So at this point I will say "too high?"  Remember you are only entitled to one guess per 30 day period.

Last edited by MainLine Steam

My guess is 2459 ,2-Rail home layouts.  Let me know the correct answer.

Charlie



This could be a good competition!

I would guess a few more.

I live in a town of 10,000 and there are three 2-rail O scalers, one layout. That gives a vague percentage to start off. Also Britain has a lot of O scale layouts, mostly 2-rail as they gave up the third rail long ago, and plenty of them are micro shunting layouts. There must be some European O scalers, as there are Euro manufacturers like Fulgurex, and some Aussies of course.

Then if we take the 330 odd million in the US and 60 odd million Britain as the main O scale 2-rail countries, and then a few more from Downunder, France and Germany, add a few more randoms in other countries, I'd put my guess at about six thousand O scale 2-rail layouts in the world.

Say 6,250 as a guess!

Mick

This thread got me more curious about 2 rail O and one of the posters here contacted me via email to answer a question I had posted. Turned out he lived near Detroit, which I was going to visit the next week!  He arranged for me to visit three 2 rail and one 3 rail scale layout in less than 24 hours!  It was great!  So this thread has gone way beyond it's original question.

My guess is 2459 ,2-Rail home layouts.  Let me know the correct answer.

Charlie

You 2 railers can add one more to the count. Started my conversion from 3 rail last week. New track is on the way. Being that I am deadrail/Battery powered completely I decided to go 2 rail. It will be quite extensive.  Changes to my layout will help me with Changes to scenery , building, and running trains.

You 2 railers can add one more to the count. Started my conversion from 3 rail last week. New track is on the way. Being that I am deadrail/Battery powered completely I decided to go 2 rail. It will be quite extensive.  Changes to my layout will help me with Changes to scenery , building, and running trains.

Congratulations! I look forward to seeing your journey.

You 2 railers can add one more to the count. Started my conversion from 3 rail last week. New track is on the way. Being that I am deadrail/Battery powered completely I decided to go 2 rail. It will be quite extensive.  Changes to my layout will help me with Changes to scenery , building, and running trains.

Bill please let me know what track you are going to be using.  Are you using "Hi-Rail" wheels, or has the equipment been converted/modified?   Thanks!

Last edited by MainLine Steam

Jim. Yes on the  converted/ modified. I use gargraves phantom high rail tinplate track and switches and a few Ross switches. My plan is to replace the 3 rail with  2 rail track. I will still use the same switches.  I plan on doing a small section first  . I want to make sure that this  will work with my existing high rail Rolling stock. Right now I am in the process of stripping out all track connected wires.

Jim. Yes on the  converted/ modified. I use gargraves phantom high rail tinplate track and switches and a few Ross switches. My plan is to replace the 3 rail with  2 rail track. I will still use the same switches.  I plan on doing a small section first  . I want to make sure that this  will work with my existing high rail Rolling stock. Right now I am in the process of stripping out all track connected wires.

Thanks for letting me know.  Heading to Amherst tomorrow so will be at Ross booth.

@Brad Kowal posted:

There are 2-Rail Club layouts in Neenah and Appleton, WI.  A few private home layouts as well.

Hi Brad - Thanks for adding to the list.  Wish I was aware when I lived in Wisconsin.  Although thinking really want to make it to AirVenture this year.  Haven't been since 2017, moved to NY in early 2018.  So may try to see the club layouts when I come out.

NY, why?

Funny I get that question all the time when I talked to people out here (questioning my sanity?).  Grandkids!

BTW by the time you get to Poughkeepsie, and even further Upstate, not that different from WI.  Except for the crazy cost of living!  But the winters are milder here in Poughkeepsie, we hit 50 deg today.

Last edited by MainLine Steam

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×