Skip to main content

Hi to all - this is my first post so if not done quite right please let me know.  If there is a resource or video explaining posting to the forum please let me know.  I read the rules but could not find a tutorial.

I am fairly new to O railroading.  Had been in HO (and for a while N) since I was a kid in the early 1960's.  Last year I was on Ebay and noticed the prices used O was going for and realized it was on longer out of reach for me.  Now that new detailed HO Steam Locos are $400+ saw a great opportunity to make the switch over.  I had always admired O from afar, but when I could buy new Athearn Blue Boxes in the 1990's for $4 the Price of a Weaver Ultra Line Freight car at $30 seemed like a real stretch.  BTW I like Prototypical Proportions, (HO Roots).

Anyhow we have established I'm cheap and not afraid to admit it.  So my question.  The Williams Loco I mentioned (Come in brown corrugated boxes) seem to be the cheapest Brass O locos out there.  I realize they are not equivalent to a new $1500 3rd rail Version but do they operate, OK?  I have bought a few of the later (1988 to 1999 I guess), Williams Brass (in the printed boxes, fit over a molded EPS 2 piece box).  Loco packed in an old style ice cooler. LOL  Too my failing eyes they are magnificent.  I feel disloyal to Athearn, but they left me pricewise, I didn't leave them!

Anyhow any insight from you seasoned veterans, would be greatly appreciated.  On anything I have asked about.  Thank you to all who may reply!!     

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Welcome!  Are you doing O scale in 2 rail or 3 rail?  I came from HO and N myself and live in both worlds depending on what road names I am modeling and where I operated my trains.

The original Williams Hudsons are hit and miss.  Some are good runners and others have issues.  This is true for a lot of the early Williams / Samhongsa brass steam locomotives.  They got better every year though.  While I don't have this specific locomotive, others on this forum have commented on the challenges with the early Hudson.  Personally, I have ten of the Williams brass steam locomotives (all three rail) and 5 are great runners, 2 are average runners, and 3 need some work.  They are well priced and can be detailed to make very nice locomotives.  I have been keeping my eyes open for a few 2 rail ones that I can strip and modify for my collection.

I still have tons of Athearn Bluebox kits in the same roads I model in O. 

I started in 3 rail, but for my personal modeling, the 2 rail bug got to me.  I model roughly 1953-1960 CNJ & PRR in 2 rail while I model everything else in 3 rail.  I am a self admitted snob on my 2 rail collection, but less so on 3 rail.  I collect western roads and Amtrak in 3 rail as my local 3 rail club is western themed or Amtrak.  I have over 150 scale passenger cars of which about 35 or so are K-Line.  Nice cars.  Most of my cars are Golden Gate Depot.  All correct scale length based on the prototype. 

I also have an affinity for vintage trains and have a reasonable collection of All Nation, Walthers, and Athearn O cars.  O scale is a very interesting space because it is so broad.  You have your scale enthusiasts like myself, some amazing hi-rail 3 rail modelers, those who collect and operate tin-plate, and finally the very loyal traditional O gauge Lionel style trains.  There are not any wrong answers, just a lot of opportunities to enjoy this scale.  I made my switch into O at about age 32.  I started in HO at 7 so I still have more HO years than O behind me, but I love this scale.  Great people, great models, and lots of fun!

Thanks Norton for your insight

Thanks Jonathan for the additional information.

This isn't Ebay so I guess it is OK to say I live in Poughkeepsie, NY, so have to have NY Central trains, that's why I need to get a Hudson of some type.  I actually bought a K-Line ESE 15" set but nothing to pull it with.  When I started I thought no 15" they are too toy like, but then when I started looking at the price of the 21" sets decided they would do for now!  Really like the 18" length best, K-Line skipped that length with the ESE.  Again from starring at Athearns as a kid, as you know there cars were modeled on 72' cars so O gage means 18".  My criteria is Transition period, because love Streamlined cars but also Main Line Steam.  My life was changed in the mid 1990's when I watched Milw 261 roll by pulling 21 private railcars up a grade at 50 mph.  Diesel Rail fanning has just never been the same since!  The midsize Steam locos most museums use just ain't the same.

Add Reply

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
Link copied to your clipboard.