Skip to main content

1944 WW2 was winding down ..modelers we're chopping at the bit to buy new pieces for their layout . Large manufacturers were still locked into government contracts and it would take many months - several years to return to model train production. This window of time gave many little start ups sometime to jump into the field to fill the gap ...most jumped / forced out when the "big boys" returned to the field by 1948.
Prewar Ed Alexander provided a model of the PRR GG1.....producing an estimated 100 kits / models 1937-41).
Jack Collier of Oakland , CA hobby shop owner ..and active with the Bay City Model Railroad Club (O & HO scale ) ..produced a GG1 kit designed in 1944 ...for both O and HO scales . O scale GG1 RTR was $250.00 out the door ..huge money at the time .
Walther's partnered with Baldwin of CT ...and produced a GG1 by end of 1947 about half the price ...
Collier's body casting is fine but nose area missed the mark ..chassis is great with full suspension on drivers .
Walther's / Baldwin got the nose right but the chassis was way wrong much so Walther's had to point it out in his catalogs .
Collier pieces seem to have been only made in very small numbers .

Please see link to see the O scale version running

To see the HO version running please see

Cheers Carey



Images (7)
  • IMG_20220806_190404115_HDR
  • IMG_20220806_190347683_HDR
  • IMG_20220806_185635648_HDR
  • Screenshot_20220806-230754~2
  • Screenshot_20220806-224149~2
  • IMG_20220806_191035142_HDR
  • IMG_20220806_191027311_HDR
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Nice find Carey as always.  In your opinion, who produced the first GG1?  There was the Varney prewar HO GG1 that ran on a Mikado chassis if I recall correctly and George Stock's HO GG1s were also introduced prior to WWII in cast aluminum.  I just don't know how early. 

Was the Alexander model the earliest production model of a GG1 in any scale?

The interesting part of this Collier one you posted is how much more scale looking the HO version is over the larger O version.

Add Reply


OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)

Link copied to your clipboard.