Skip to main content

Hello! Does anyone have a wiring manual for this? Every time I wire it up, it gets super hot and starts steaming. I did read that the ground is a spring connected to a metal pole so I re wired it and it still gets super hot. It melted some of the housing... I do have it running off an MTH block connected to the DCS on fixed voltage so maybe its getting too many volts? 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

stan2004 posted:
Jack118711 posted:

Well I hooked it up to a regular transformer and put it at medium and it still got way hot 

Did you try something lower than "medium"? 

So when you adjusted transformer for minimum acceptable brightness, it was still too hot?  Kind of makes you wonder how the design ever worked in the first place!

 

Exactly!! It would burn too hot even if it was barely lit up

Jack118711 posted:

They work quite well! Only issue is they are too long so the cover doesn’t go on... always something!

 

I had the same problem with the 'round top' LED bulbs in my Lionel die cast bumpers. Found a source that had 'flat top' LEDs and those worked perfectly. Unfortunately, it looks like that site is no longer functioning. Maybe a search on ebay or elsewhere for the flat top style.

As I recall my bumpers have the 'bayonet' type bulbs, but the source I had carried both the screw type and bayonet type LEDs so I know they were both out there at one time. Although they may not still be available now? I will do some searching and see what turns up. I'd like to have more myself. 

One other thing (probably a dumb question too), but you didn't by chance order the 'large top' bulbs? I did notice the linked site had the 'large type' bulbs toward the end of the list...just a thought here.

BobbyD posted:

Did you ever get a copy of the original instructions?

Nope! 

Martin Derouin posted:

These should work better for you:  http://stores.towncountryhobbies.com/led-1447g/   The lens hood should fit over these, this link is for green:  and this link is for red:  http://stores.towncountryhobbies.com/led-1447r/

Marty

$10 for shipping!? Well I’ll probably order them anyway. Thanks for the link!

rtr12 posted:
Jack118711 posted:

They work quite well! Only issue is they are too long so the cover doesn’t go on... always something!

 

I had the same problem with the 'round top' LED bulbs in my Lionel die cast bumpers. Found a source that had 'flat top' LEDs and those worked perfectly. Unfortunately, it looks like that site is no longer functioning. Maybe a search on ebay or elsewhere for the flat top style.

As I recall my bumpers have the 'bayonet' type bulbs, but the source I had carried both the screw type and bayonet type LEDs so I know they were both out there at one time. Although they may not still be available now? I will do some searching and see what turns up. I'd like to have more myself. 

One other thing (probably a dumb question too), but you didn't by chance order the 'large top' bulbs? I did notice the linked site had the 'large type' bulbs toward the end of the list...just a thought here.

These were just EBay specials to see if the base was right :-)

So with the smaller sized LED bulbs is this "case-closed"?  

I don't understand how the fixture can over-heat when the bulb is barely glowing.  Unless there is some undesired resistance in the spring, contact, connector, whatever.  The current is low enough with the LED bulbs that the heat is acceptable...but becomes material with the higher-current incandescents. I would think some voltmeter measurements could isolate the problem...but not worth the bother if you have a solution in hand.

Martin Derouin posted:

I don't know how Town and Country got in there, I use these from Auto-lamination,   http://www.autolumination.com/...nverted_led_bulb.htm   I have been using their bulbs for over 15 years.  Been very happy with them...  Shipping is about $5.00

Marty

Those look just like the ones I have with the flat top, but they were 18 volt AC or DC. (I have command control only, all 18 volt.) The ones linked here are only 14 volt. I looked at their site and they have also some 1445 and 1447 18 volt LED bulbs that look different than the ones I was getting from my now gone supplier. If they are as shown in the picture on the 'Auto...' site they just might work in the Lionel bumpers and I am guessing maybe the OP's signals as well?

Thanks to Stan's promise of a gold star (and my own curiosity), I spent way too much time on this last night.
Having never looked at one of these first hand, and not having anything beyond the pictures to go by, this is what I came up with.
The wiring under the base is deceiving, it does not correlate with the two bulbs equally. To have the GRN bulb ON, current flows from terminal #3, through both the RED bulb and the 75 ohm resistor, to the GRN bulb, then to the spring terminal (#2). In this parrallel/series configuration, current through the RED bulb is low enough as to not illuminate it. To light the RED bulb, terminal #1 is connected to common through the isolated rail and the train's wheels. Current is still flowing through both the RED bulb and the 75 ohm resistor, but this creates 0 volts on both sides of the GRN bulb, thus turning it OFF.
At first I had calculated the flow in each scenario using the published figures for a #1447 bulb (18 V, 150 mA, 2.7 W). But because of the difference in resistance that occurs in an incandescent bulb at voltages other than those specified, I decided to load this into a simulator to see how the bulbs behaved.
Results @ 18 Vrms:
                            GRN On           RED On
GRN bulb =        1.8 W                0 W
RED bulb =         305 mW           2.7 W
75 ohm R =        221 mW           4.34 W

Less than 1/4 Watt from the resistor with the GRN aspect displayed. However, if a train holds the signal RED for a prolonged period, the resistor is producing 4-1/3 Watts.

Jack, I think that removing the resistor was the way to go, given the wasted power and extra heat produced. When using a relay to change aspects it would need to be removed anyway.
> Are the terminals under the base marked?

Dave

P.S    I could be wrong 

K120 Signal Bridge - OGR 3-2018

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • K120 Signal Bridge - OGR 3-2018
Last edited by Dtrainmaster
Dtrainmaster posted:

Thanks to Stan's promise of a gold star.. 

gold star small

Extra credit for the simulation results and nice diagrams!

As I see it, there are two issues.  First was the "melting" issue at the signal head Jack showed in his first picture.  Even though the parts list shows 18V bulbs, I'm thinking it was probably designed for 14V AC Accessory voltage which be a ~40% power reduction.  I'm still not clear on why it burned too hot when barely glowing; unless you meant the mystery resistor in the base burning too hot.

The 2nd issue is the 75 Ohm, 5 Watt resistor in the base.  I suppose the power-rating of the resistor is also a clue.  18V across 75 Ohms is ~4 Watts.  So clearly the resistor was rated for full track voltage which as Dave shows is exactly what happens when Red is on.  I also suppose if we had access to the instructions, we would have seen that this signal only requires an insulated-rail to operate both aspects.  I suspect most guys now use relays, ITADs, 153c contactor plate, whatever with dual-outputs to separately power red and green.  Until I stumbled across the parts list and the resistor, I was assuming it was just two bulbs.

I think with some experimentation you could use those LED replacement bulbs and come up with a resistor of much lower power rating (maybe 1/2 Watt or so, and maybe a resistance 5-10 times greater than 75 Ohms) that you could wire in parallel with the Red LED bulb so that you can still use only the insulated rail to select between Red and Green.

I realize a couple bucks for the LED replacement bulbs is essentially a plug-and-play solution.  OTOH, if you're a DIY-enthusiast, this reminds me of the modern red-green 1-wire (insulated-rail) technique of "starving the Green LED." That is, Red LEDs turn on at about 2V, Green LEDs turn on at about 3V.  So if you have a Green LED on, then put a Red LED in parallel with it, the Red LED will turn on and extinguish the Green LED because the voltage across the two LEDs will clamp at 2V thereby starving the Green LED.  So you could buy some inexpensive red and green 8mm or 10mm LEDs (or whatever size fits in the signal heads), add 25 cents of parts, and make you own low-power signal head that can switch with just an insulated-rail (no relay, no ITAD, no whatever).

Attachments

Images (1)
  • gold star small
Last edited by stan2004

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×