Skip to main content

OK, OK, I'm a K-line steam power nut. I have six. Including three Berkshires and more. Sold my shay. I do have one beautiful Weaver Milwaukee Road Hiawatha. Would love to see pictures of your best steam. Doesn't have to be huge, just what you like to run and looks good on your layout. k-line steamDon

Attachments

Images (1)
  • k-line steam
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

This model of New Jersey Central #833 is an MTH Premier model with PS-1 that I purchased around 1999. Never run. While it's a good-looking model, I think that MTH used its Premier New York Central Hudson (4-6-4) chassis for this (4-6-2) Pacific. Therefore, the model and firebox are about an inch too long and the trailing axle and cab are a similar distance too far aft.

MELGAR

MELGAR_BLUE_COMET_833_05

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • MELGAR_BLUE_COMET_833_05
Last edited by MELGAR

I likeIMG_1173ww78b these because they do not derail on curves, make plenty of noise rumbling along their assigned closed-loops, and with their chuffs, emit a goodly amount of storm-clouds level of smoke, especially when run simultaneously, like you can see here, and their horns are a real nice blast. IMG_5435IMG_1188IMG_1367IMG_9531When I run my trains, for myself as well as for guests, I enjoy a lot of commotion, action, noise, and smoke. I find nothing to whine about amidst that cacophony of the sights and sounds of model railroading...FrankM at Moon Township,USA

Attachments

Images (7)
  • IMG_5435
  • 5locosiderods
  • ww78b
  • IMG_1188
  • IMG_1367
  • IMG_9531
  • IMG_1173
Last edited by Moonson
Moonson posted:

I likeIMG_1173ww78b these because they do not derail on curves, make plenty of noise rumbling along their assigned closed-loops, and with their chuffs, emit a goodly amount of storm-clouds level of smoke, especially when run simultaneously, like you can see here, and their horns are a real nice blast. IMG_5435IMG_1188IMG_1367IMG_9531When I run my trains, for myself as well as for guests, I enjoy a lot of commotion, action, noise, and smoke. I find nothing to whine about amidst that cacophony of the sights and sounds of model railroading...FrankM at Moon Township,USA

CVRR 132CVRR 121CVRR 195 - CopyGEDC1551GEDC3042

Attachments

Images (5)
  • CVRR 132
  • CVRR 121
  • CVRR 195 - Copy
  • GEDC1551
  • GEDC3042
gandydancer1950 posted: just a few I could get to quickly.....
Moonson posted:

I likeIMG_1173ww78b these because they do not derail on curves, make plenty of noise rumbling along their assigned closed-loops, and with their chuffs, emit a goodly amount of storm-clouds level of smoke, especially when run simultaneously, like you can see here, and their horns are a real nice blast. IMG_5435IMG_1188IMG_1367IMG_9531When I run my trains, for myself as well as for guests, I enjoy a lot of commotion, action, noise, and smoke. I find nothing to whine about amidst that cacophony of the sights and sounds of model railroading...FrankM at Moon Township,USA

CVRR 132CVRR 121CVRR 195 - CopyGEDC1551GEDC3042

 

I might feel differently if I had a layout with wide radius track, but what Moonson said resonates with me. I like locomotives that hug the rails around my 031 curves and can pull 11 or 12 train cars. So I shy away from the gorgeous long steamers shown above, and am very happy with petite and medium-sized steamers like these:

IMG_0284

IMG_1352

IMG_0723[1)20181028_09163820180907_121347

Baby and mid-sized Hudsons, steam switchers, and Pennsy K4s are ideal for me. Big Berk # 736, and the 646 or 2046 also run very well on my layout.

Also, MTH RailKing Steamers that run on O31 are generally very good. The RailKing GS4 Southern Pacific Steamer barely navigates my O31 curves and 022 switches, so it is the maximum-size steamer that my layout can handle.

Don't have a 773, but my guess is that it will run OK, but not great, on my layout, like the MTH Railking GS4.

Arnold

Attachments

Images (5)
  • IMG_0284
  • IMG_1352
  • IMG_0723(1)
  • 20181028_091638
  • 20180907_121347

This thread is going to run for a long time.

At 41,328 pounds of tractive effort, the PRR G5s 4-6-0 was "the most powerful Ten-Wheeler ever built." This MTH Premier model with PS-1 is from the first run in 1999 and, using a BCR, has the most run time of any of my steamers. I own models of the largest steamers but actually prefer to run the smaller engines which are a better fit on my layouts. This engine was definitely a high-quality build by MTH.

MELGAR

MELGAR_PRR_G5S_5740_05

MELGAR_PRR_G5S_5740_06B

Attachments

Images (2)
  • MELGAR_PRR_G5S_5740_05
  • MELGAR_PRR_G5S_5740_06B
Last edited by MELGAR

Another major advantage of the small and medium-sized steamers, compared to the big ones, is affordability.

I'm not diminishing the big steamers in the slightest. They are magnificent and majestic running on large layouts with wide radius curves. However, they tend to be very expensive, often in excess of $1,000, which is not affordable for me and many others. If I had a substantially larger layout with wide curves, I would probably buy one  big boy steamer with big sounds and smoke.

The reason I'm highlighting the small and medium-sized steamers is to share how much fun they are to run, and how affordable. And on a Postwar layout with 031 curves like mine, you can still experience big steam power with medium sized engines like the ones below.

Below is the classic Postwar Lionel 736 pulling a tender and 11 Postwar cars with ease. It is a very smooth and strong runner with Magnetraction. I paid about $400 for it at a train show about 15 years ago:

Below is the MTH NY Central Mohawk with traction tires pulling 5 Postwar extruded aluminum passenger cars.  I  paid about $300 for it in the mid-1990s:

Arnold

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20181105_195307
  • 20181105_200024
Videos (2)
20181105_200501
20181105_201553
Last edited by Arnold D. Cribari
Fendermain posted:

IMG_1992 IMG_1993IMG_1994IMG_1987

Arnold, I concur about small engines as I too have small radius curves. Also, my layout has a prewar theme and small equipment looks better on it. I have included a photo of my Regner live steamer that I run outside.  I could adjust the axles to run on this track but it has a butane burner. Not good for indoors.  Fendermain

Last edited by Fendermain

First I have my X1110, my only modern Lionel engine in the fleet. This came with a 1998 set that I understand was the last ready-to-run set made partially in the USA. It was my only engine I had and ran it to death when it finally kicked the bucket when I was probably 11 or 12, and fell out of running trains for a while. 

00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105200710395_COVER

Since this engine didn't work, I bought my first postwar engine to replace it, a 1948 2026:

00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105200859121_COVER

After that, Christmas was coming up and I wanted to build a village with a railroad in it, rather than the table-top trainless (boring) villages of past years, and I envisioned two different trains running in it, so I bought this rather hagardly looking (great runner, though) 1948 2025:

00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105201119070_COVER

Following that Christmas, my growing addiction to vintage Lionel trains was becoming apparent, and upon a visit to the local train store, I came home with this beautiful 1937 259e:

00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105201310668_COVER

Only a week or two passed before the train show came to town, and I bought my first complete set (may start a new thread on that later), outfit 1427ws from 1948, with a pristine 1948 2026 at the helm:

00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105201754083_COVER

MVIMG_20181105_201902

Then the addiction subsided a little, with some accessories here, some rolling stock there, and even a nice UP 2023, but that ain't steam. The following Christmas, I got a naked, paintless, and non-functional 1946 2020 steam turbine. My dad and I always had fun sitting down at our kitchen table work bench and fixing these up. In fact, almost half of all my engines weren't working when I got them, but they all run now. Anyway we fixed it up and it was pulling cars through the village before Christmas dinner. Throughout the year when I had time, I adorned it with a handsome brown and gold fictional livery to match my MPC PRR Broadway Limited set.00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105202319105_COVERMVIMG_20181029_201832

The next year for Christmas, I got a 1955(?) 2065. I was drawn to it for the feedwater heater which reminded me of my first engine.

00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105202546050_COVER

That following summer, I went to a month-long recording school out in the foothills of southern Ohio (I'm a musician when I'm not hiding away in the basement with my trains) and we stayed in the provided cabins up in the hills. During the downtime I went into town and visited an antique store and found this 1952 2056. It had grey paint on all the pipes and details, and it still exists on the water scoop on the tender. I sat on the porch of my cabin and gingerly scraped off the grey paint with a pocket knife, without flaking off so much as one piece of the original paint.

00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105202659086_COVERIMG_20170609_205632704

Most recently, for Christmas, I received this 1946 221. But it is worth noting, however, that this was no ordinary 221, as one of the previous owners had jammed an old Christmas light in where the headlamp should be. I immediately fell I love with the red headlight. It recently burned out, however, so I replaced it with a normal bulb...that was coated in red.

00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105222743649_COVER00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105222912788_COVER

 

Attachments

Images (13)
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105200710395_COVER
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105200859121_COVER
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105201119070_COVER
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105201310668_COVER
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105201754083_COVER
  • MVIMG_20181105_201902
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105202319105_COVER
  • MVIMG_20181029_201832
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105202546050_COVER
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105202659086_COVER
  • IMG_20170609_205632704
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105222743649_COVER
  • 00100lPORTRAIT_00100_BURST20181105222912788_COVER
Last edited by Wes97
Arnold D. Cribari posted:

Fendermain, I have never seen anything like the engine in your 3rd photo,  which must be your Regner live steamer. Very cool, or maybe I should say hot. Imagine that thing in the hands of a child?

Yes, I believe it was common to have alcohol fueled live steam engines as toys for children as far back as the end of the 19th century.  Actually, I had a stationary live steam engine as a child around 1960. It had an electric heating element that would plug into the wall outlet.  Not happening today!  My Regner was made in the small village of Aurach, Germany.  I currently run it on LGB track but it is adjustable to various gauges.  Fendermain

Last edited by Fendermain

I purchased this Lionel Legacy 6-82272 New Haven Ten-Wheeler #816 about a year ago and it has been running frequently on my single-track branch line railroad ever since. I let it cruise along at about 30 miles-per-hour pulling three boxcars and a caboose. It has a beautiful whistle and actually is a model of a New York Central prototype.

MELGAR

MELGAR_NH_460_816_01MELGAR_NH_460_816_02MELGAR_NH_460_816_03

Attachments

Images (3)
  • MELGAR_NH_460_816_01
  • MELGAR_NH_460_816_02
  • MELGAR_NH_460_816_03
overlandflyer posted:
sncf231e posted:
overlandflyer posted:

i thought the topic was steam....

Nickel Plate 753 at Riverside

That is a nice engine you have! What gauge is it?

The Berkshire is 7½" gauge, 1:8 scale.  oddly with the same scale/ gauge error as traditional O.

P7 GW

this guy is 1" scale, 4¾" gauge.  one of the more accurate live steam gauges.

How many large live steam loco's do you have! Amazing!

Regards

Fred

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×