Skip to main content

@DukeGG1 posted:

Sure. Lionel made it in 2018. #85300;  MSRP was $80. Attached photo of mine. They did a nice job with it.  Guy

Ohhh, that's an N5 (not N5c). 

N5c is the streamlined porthole variant.  I hadn't seen an N5c done recently by Lionel so your original post perked my ears up.

I have the N5b they did a few years back.  However, I didn't realize until now they did an early N5 without the crash bars until you posted that picture.  I need to pick one of those up, thanks!

@rplst8 posted:

Ohhh, that's an N5 (not N5c). 

N5c is the streamlined porthole variant.  I hadn't seen an N5c done recently by Lionel so your original post perked my ears up.

I have the N5b they did a few years back.  However, I didn't realize until now they did an early N5 without the crash bars until you posted that picture.  I need to pick one of those up, thanks!

Sorry. I was excited because there finally was a true PRSL caboose. 

Another great catalog from Lionel however I was hoping for a T-1 not the S-1. Still a beautiful engine but too big for me. Think that was the same problem the Pennsy had with the S-1. I guess I will continue to wait for the T-1, come on Lionel you would sell a ton of T-1s vs S-1s make the T-1 soon.

JohnB

I'm glad Lionel is doing well and I am happy that scale size operators will be excited by this catalog. For me, I was hoping to see more stuff for us traditional sized 4x8 train table operators.  Oh well

Lionel announced 8-10 years ago they would not be doing any more Post War Celebration or Conventional Classic type trains. Lionchief is what they replaced that market with. If you want transformer controlled trains you are pretty much left with Williams or RMT. You could do a lot worse than either of those two.

Pete

@Norton posted:

Lionel announced 8-10 years ago they would not be doing any more Post War Celebration or Conventional Classic type trains. Lionchief is what they replaced that market with. If you want transformer controlled trains you are pretty much left with Williams or RMT. You could do a lot worse than either of those two.

Pete

Thanks for the heads up. I do like Lionchief but the number of postwar style sets, lionchief sets and locomotives could have been better. 

@Hancock52 posted:

If you're right that could save me a bundle as I don't think I am interested in a LM version of the AC-12. The catalog illustrations (there's a number of different paint schemes, including the gray boiler version and Daylight) look like scale size engines but of course the truth may be different.

I was about to say that a LM cab forward would require new tooling but Lionel did make an LM AC-12 way back in pre-Legacy days (SKU 6-11107, released 2006/07). I don't think I have ever seen one of these in the flesh but a few pictures I have seen don't show a vast amount of scaling down. Maybe somebody who owns one can comment on that:

LM_CabForward_2006

The fine tooling for the earlier scale TMCC AC-12 has been "recycled" once already. Anyway, I was pleasantly puzzled by the MSRP of c. $1,300 as that's the same if not slightly less than the Legacy cab forwards issued in about 2013. Even as I write that, it seems too good to be true that the new items are scale. 

Not good for me as I have been chasing a scale size gray boiler version for years - 3rd Rail made one in brass many years back.

Maybe they are the MTH Imperial Cab Forwards - Some molds were already purchased  

Last edited by VThokie Steam Fan
@Oneonta posted:

   I like the die-cast 100 ton PRR hoppers, but the $250 price for the two-pack, or $125 a car, is steep......the three 2-packs would list out at $750.....

I wondered why they were more expensive.  Where did you see that they were die-cast? 

Wow, I feel like the prices are totally getting out of hand.  The RPO cars are $30 more than they were in 2018.

@rplst8 posted:

I wondered why they were more expensive.  Where did you see that they were die-cast? 

Wow, I feel like the prices are totally getting out of hand.  The RPO cars are $30 more than they were in 2018.

Check out description in red block in upper left corner of page.....it states die-cast metal body and frame as well as die-cast trucks........    Desirable features, but $125 a car........??

The E7 ABB in Golden State colors is interesting. It's out of my budget ($1500) and an ABB set of E7s is much too long for my layout. Other than that nothing really. Kinda the same issue with volume 1. I don't need a SP Lima GS (have a MTH Premier GS4 and GS6) but the Baldwin GS1 was very interesting, but way out of my price range at almost $2k. As far as freight cars no era specific scale ATSF or SP cars I want. 

Reviewing the catalog a little better, there are only four items that fit my late 40s PRR themed layout.  The South Wind set, the 2-8-8-2 mallet, the PRR 21" Golden State 2-pack, and the Rock Island E7 for the Golden State set I already have.  I have the mallet, a Rock Island E6 set which will do, and too many 21" passenger sets.

That leaves the GS 2-pack.  Those cars would fit nicely into my K-Line/GGD 85' passenger sets as well as add some color so I plan to order those.

meh. Well once again my money is in no danger. There is not a thing here that I have any interest in. I guess it is safe to say the B&O is a very unpopular road to model. I two engines, and when I saw the 2-8-2's I was excited for a second but NO. Even if I got one of them I could not re-letter, head light and bell are in the wrong location for B&O.   Guess I'll just need wait to for my EM-1... boo. 

@CAPPilot posted:

Who watched the Lionel Facebook live video on the catalog earlier today?  Did they say anything about the incorrect E6 pilots on the photos of their E7s?

@Brendan posted:

Finally found the time to watch the video and was disappointed they did not address the incorrect pilot on their E7 diesels. 

I have the first Legacy E7 which also had the incorrect E6 pilots.  In the photo below, the E6 pilot off my E7 is on the left, and the correct E7/E8 pilot is on the right.  I ordered the E8 pilot from Lionel and it looks the same as the one in pictures of the prototype E7.  I have not mounted the E8 pilot yet because the mounting holes are different, so I need to figure out how to do it.

Hopefully Lionel corrects this before the E7s ship.

DSC_0007 [2)

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSC_0007 (2)

meh. Well once again my money is in no danger. There is not a thing here that I have any interest in. I guess it is safe to say the B&O is a very unpopular road to model. I two engines, and when I saw the 2-8-2's I was excited for a second but NO. Even if I got one of them I could not re-letter, head light and bell are in the wrong location for B&O.   Guess I'll just need wait to for my EM-1... boo. 

Lionel came out with a B&O 2-8-2 in the 2017 Signature Edition/Volume 1 catalog. I can't find a picture online of the delivered model but the artwork in the catalog looks correct.

The die-cast metal body, 100 Ton, three-bay, open-top hoppers are being offered in the BLE numbers on the patched ex-THE ROCK modern blue scheme. 

They have never offered or produced the die-cast metal body, 100 Ton, three-bay, open-top hoppers in the original THE ROCK `978-1979 paint scheme. 

I know the BLE patched blue scheme lasted longer, but why not make THE ROCK blue scheme at the same time. 

I would have bought THE ROCK scheme. 

Andrew

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by Lionel, LLC

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×