Skip to main content

I got my BSA Eagle Scout rank  January 11th 2011. My scout troop has helped take down tables after a local show every year. However, since we had to wear our uniforms when at the show. It was always interesting how many people would stop and ask me about my rank and how much further I was to getting my Eagle rank before I had completed it. Many of the vendors and others would tell me  they are Eagle Scouts or were in the BSA, or had or have family members in the BSA. I have been really looking at getting Lionel's Eagle Scout Boxcar that came out a few years ago. Thoughts on this boxcar? 

 

Never forgot once an Eagle Scout always an Eagle Scout

6-15075_2646

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 6-15075_2646
Last edited by Khayden93
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

My two sons are Eagles and I was a Scoutmaster for many years.    I was buying them the BSA cars and one year they stopped being produced.  They have the Eagle and Life cars.  I asked Mike Reagan about it and he said sales were disappointing and the BSA wasn't the easiest to work with.

 

That being said the car is traditional sized and is what that is.  I personally think every Eagle Scout should have one!

 

I have every BSA item Lionel has released (I think!) and would buy any others they released. 

Eagle Scout circa 1962. Boy Scout from 1954. Had allot fun during that time frame. 

 

Went to the National jamboree in 1958 in Valley Forge, Pa. It was great. Our troop 88 did not do all that well but being in a place with so much history was amazing. 

 

All young men should spend time in the BSA and the military, it teaches you how to be a man, it did me. 

 

 

I was in scouting way back in the last century. My two sons are eagle scouts, and I was a committee member and assistant scoutmaster, and cubmaster, for many years. I have a number of the boy scout boxcars, which I like (Lionel did a good job on them), including the eagle car. I put decals on the side with the names of my two boys, on either side of the eagle badge. 

 

It's also a tribute to my wife. Like many mothers, she used her unique "powers of persuasion" to get those last merit badges earned and push the boys over the top! I should probably put her name on the car as well!  

Originally Posted by sinclair:

I'm an Eagle, and currently my son's Cub Master.  I don't own any BSA trains.  Logo stuff like this really isn't my thing, but it sure does look nice.

 

Originally Posted by david1:

Eagle Scout circa 1962. Boy Scout from 1954. Had allot fun during that time frame. 

 

All young men should spend time in the BSA and the military, it teaches you how to be a man, it did me. 

 

 

I am not into logo cars either, but the BSA is a nice one.

 

My dad would vote for at least on or the other on David's comment.  His statement about the Army was that he is glad he had the experience, but he sure wouldn't want to go back and do it again.  He never was a scout, but he said scouting is what brought me out of my shell and was the best thing for me.  Unfortunately I had Life and was working on Eagle when our scoutmaster retired.  We went through 2 more scoutmasters, and I never got to finish.  It was a great experience however, and I have no regrets.

Last edited by Mark Boyce

I am an Eagle Scout.  1992 (i think) as part of troop 161 in Hyde Park, Reading PA

 

My younger brother is an Eagle as well, and my older son is now a bear in Cub Scouts.

 

I do not have any of these cars but I have considered getting the Eagle one, as part of autobiographical train of things I've done and places I've worked for.

Originally Posted by MartyE:

Eagle Scout 3 Palms Troop 6 Allegheny Trails now known as Laurel Highlands I guess. Circa 1982.

3 Palms!!!   That must have been some merit badge sash.  You and Wyatt have my admiration (along with all the other scouts and scouters.)  

 

I have 2 of the BSA ES44AC's.  My favorite engines (and my 1st Legacy engine.)

 

Another question...........who's been to Philmont?  '03, '05 & '10 for me and hopefully '17

 

I hate to admit it in a train forum but Scouting and backpacking as my two favorites activities.

Last edited by Chris Lord

Eagle Scout class of 2008

Troop 421 Boston Minuteman Council

 

My dad bought one of these cars for me about a year ago.  Although all my trains are (sadly) boxed up in my parent's basement, this one sits in its box on a shelf in my room.  It's a very nice car, although I plan on just keeping it as a display piece even when I do (hopefully soon!) get my trains set back up.

That Car is on my "Need to Get" List.

 

I got my Rank of Eagle back in 2002, Troop 47 (Greater Lowell Council now Yankee Clipper Council) and like most boys got it within 18 days of my 18th birthday.  Then I was an Assistant Scout Master for ~7 years.

 

I've spent half my life in Scouting, and hopefully someday my boy will be into scouting as well.

 

 

I don't have the Eagle Car, but I do own the BSA set.  It is a great conversation starter when I run it at shows.

 

I will be picking it up soon though as I don't want to miss out on the car.

 

Eagle, Class of 1993, Troop 4, Penn's Woods Council (Now Laurel Highlands)

Assitant Cubmaster, Pack 57, Tidewater Council

Father of 2 rising Wolf Scouts

Eagle scout 1968. Went to Philmont Scout Ranch this summer ( third time out!). Philmont has found out that they had railroads on the property a long time back. One of the crews had as part of their conservation project to help restore the line and lay some track! Bummer I did not find out about it before I got out there. I would have loved trying my hand at that!

 

Chris

LVHR

Last edited by lehighline
Eagle Scout 1969; one of my most memorable accomplishments.  All three sons are Eagle Scouts; very proud of each of them.  I served in several positions as an adult; a great opportunity to have a positive influence on young men.  I have most of the BSA items; I think they are great. Best wishes to all the Eagles!

Hello Friends,

A Star Scout as a boy, I never missed a meeting or camping trip. Only a handful of scouts became Eagles in our rural area, but Scouting was the best experience a boy could have. Besides, there was no way I was ever going to obtain Lifesaving merit badge, a "must have" requirement in those days.  I have been a registered scout and scouter for 58 years, joining Cubs when I was eight years old. I wasn't registered while in college, but joined A Phi O fraternity (a scouting affiliated, but not officially recognized organization). In Scouting, you name it, I've done it. Still doing it!  Along the way I raised two Eagle Scout sons and my best railfan and O-guage buddy, my grandson, is waiting for the weather and the current health crisis to allow him to finish his Eagle Project. 

Currently, and for many years I have served as Chairman and now Vice Chair of the local council (NEPA) Eagle Board of Review.  Every month I get to meet the finest young men (and soon young women) in the world. To hear them talk about their journey to Eagle and to see how they have grown and matured into fine young adults and good citizens is one of the most rewarding experiences of my scouting career.  

 

Yours, in Scouting,

Earl

   

 

Hear, hear!!  I still believe the Scouting is the finest experience a young person can have.  While we might not ever build another campfire using two matches and a lot of air, the process of preparing to do so carries over to life.

Before someone mentions adult Scout leaders' who take advantage- there are (as of today) 2.3 million youth (boys AND girls) and 1 million adult leaders in the organization.  Using the accepted average length of service of adult leaders- 3 years- that means in the past 50 years there have been some (1 million X 50/3) 16 MILLION adult leaders.

 

Even 1/10th of one percent of that many people is 176,000 bad actors, or 3500 on average each year for the past 50 of the BSA in America.  For comparison to the 1 million adult Scout leaders, there are approximately 36,000 active Roman Catholic Priests,  and 18,000 Deacons, in the USA.

 

Mike Wyatt

Eagle Scout, 1965

Scoutmaster 1989 1992

Explorer Advisor 1992 - 1993

Last edited by Mike Wyatt

Eagle Scout with 3 palms 1963

National Jamboree - Valley Forge 1964

Camp Edward Staff 1965-67 (Forest Lakes Council - Scranton, PA)

Alpha Phi Omega (Alpha Chapter) - Life Member

You can always identify a former scout. When buying a Christmas Tree from the local Boy Scouts, if the price is $45.00, we hand the leader 3-$20s and tell the troop to keep the change.

Lad

Eagle and Vigil Honor in 1995. Philmont in 1990 and 1996. National Jamboree in 1993. 7 National Order of the Arrow Conferences. Former Lodge Chief of Tonkawa Lodge. Former Staff member of Lost Pines Scout Reservation. Did Cub Scouts, Boy Scouts, Exploring, and Venturing. Still active today.

My paternal grandmother grew up in DC and served as a Girl Scout Guide at the 1937 National Jamboree.

My uncle was in scouts over in Germany while my grandfather was stationed there. 

My nephew earned his Eagle a few years back and got to experience Philmont as well. His nephew is a Tiger Cub.

If anyone is interested here is a list of BSA related items from my collection.  I think (?) this is the entire Lionel BSA list and I''m not aware of any MTH items.   The  Union Pacific Boy Scouts of America LEGACY ES44AC Diesel #2010  is pretty rare.  On the few occasions I see it, it is priced way above MSRP.  It's diecast and for all intents and purposes a twin of the CP VisionLine ES44AC.  

These are the scale items.   Which I usually run when we have scouts at the club.

Union Pacific Boy Scouts of America LEGACY ES44AC Diesel #2010 6-28347
Boy Scouts of America Scale PS-2 Hopper6-27093
Union Pacific Boy Scouts of America 3-Bay Cylindrical Hopper #20106-27449
Union Pacific Boy Scouts of America PS-1 Boxcar #20106-27298
Union Pacific Boy Scouts of America Ca-3 Caboose6-27645

 

KMTBoy Scouts Box Car 
LionelEagle Scout Box car6-15075
LionelBSA 90th Anniversary Box Car6-26237
LionelBoy Scout Box Car6-26275
LionelBoy Scouts of America Christmas Gondola 6-26481
LionelBSA Flatcar with Pinewood Derby Kit6-26654
LionelBSA Flatcar with Trailer6-26666
LionelBoy Scouts of America Scale PS-2 Hopper6-27093
LionelUnion Pacific Boy Scouts of America PS-1 Boxcar #20106-27298
LionelUnion Pacific Boy Scouts of America 3-Bay Cylindrical Hopper #20106-27449
LionelUnion Pacific Boy Scouts of America Ca-3 Caboose6-27645
LionelBoy Scouts of America® Crane 6-37075
LionelBoy Scouts of America® Covered Bridge 6-37130
LionelBSA Scout Law Boxcar6-39319
Lionel"Prepared. For Life"™ Boxcar 6-39358
LionelCub Scout™ Boxcar 6-39360
Lionel Union Pacific Boy Scouts of America LEGACY ES44AC Diesel #2010 6-28347
Lionel Boy Scouts of America 0-8-0 Freight Set (0-8-0 Steam Loco #1910) 6-30123
Lionel Boy Scouts of America 0-8-0 Freight Set (Loco #1910) 6-30161
Lionel Vintage Boy Scouts Figure Pack6-37828

I was a Boy Scout. I enjoyed camping and outings and didn’t care about advancement. All three of my sons took a different approach and are all Eagle Scouts with palms (youngest is the overachiever with 6, others had 3). I was Den leader, ASM, SM, and now back to ASM again. Many great times with the boys at scouting events over the years. I did get the Eagle cars for them. 

CHOO-CHOO MIKE posted:

  Anybody have an Eagle Scout Boxcar for sale . I need one for a soon to be Eagle Scout and fellow train nut. The little guy next to me.

At this point they've become somewhat collectible and the prices I've seen them for sale at show it.  There are a few on eBay right now and they seem to have sold in the recent past for between $80-150.  I bought my brother one a few years ago not too long after they went out of production and definitely paid a hefty price for it even then.

CHOO-CHOO MIKE posted:

  Anybody have an Eagle Scout Boxcar for sale . I need one for a soon to be Eagle Scout and fellow train nut. The little guy next to me.

Mike, unfortunately I can't help you with the search.  Wishing you luck on finding one. 

My eldest earned his Eagle Scout in 2018 and I'm a former Cubmaster and Assistant Scoutmaster (that's my uniform in the avatar).  Never kept any of the Lionel BSA stuff that I had during those years and wish that I did. 

paulp575 posted:

I purchased the BSA boxcar (6-39319 - Boy Scouts® "Scout Law" Add-on Boxcar ) in 2009 and think I have every BSA-licensed item Lionel produced. You can take a look at my current collection (still adding some recently purchased items!) here: http://www.dog-walker.org/trains-modern.htm

Thanks for posting your list.  I realized from it that my list had 3 items mis-categorized.

They were:

Boy Scout Flagpole with Lights6-37948
BSA® Troop Cabin 6-37967
BSA Billboard Set6-37904

 

I also forgot I have a collection from the opposite point of view.  I have about 175 Scout Patches that have trains on them.    One of these days I have to get it photographed and categorized.

A couple of samples

Attachments

Images (5)
  • mceclip0
  • mceclip1
  • mceclip2
  • mceclip3
  • mceclip4

I butted heads with a crooked leader over his pinewood derby rules distributed being followed, but differing from BS printings.... and his kid went to national not me. His kid should have been disqualified too and #3 should have went, but not ,and the higher ups didn't care, so I quit.

But I still support the group in general and most folks that go outdoors with me are Eagles who always assumed from outdoor skills that I was an Eagle too.   (I think I was the first non-Eagle family born in the 1900s,Native American, boating, and logging type elders taught me live outdoors when I was very young. I've spent nearly a month alone in the woods just for kicks (and the berries )

  That said about 50 pup tents would be cool as there is a very old undeveloped camp just West of the Mackinaw Bridge I wouldn't mind modeling someday.

Thanks for all those "Good deeds" too.

I know that line still makes me late sometimes 

Eagle Scout  1964  3 Palms   OA   Asst Scoutmaster  

My sponsor at my Eagle Scout Banquet was Astronaut John Glenn.  

Received my Eagle at the hospital bedside of my Scoutmaster, who was dying of cancer in Kessler AF Base Medical Center. He pinned on 4 Eagles that day, incl his two sons and died two weeks later. Today, I am a civilian clinical pharmacist in that same AF hospital. 

Son is an Eagle Scout, Father was First Class, Grandfather was Scoutmaster and I have his Troop Charter dated 1934  I have my uniform and my BSA Handbook.  

Have the Lionel BSA Set and Add-on Cars.  

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×