Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I like the S1, but I was a bit disappointed they didn't include whistle steam in those.  I'm not nearly as enamored by the safety valve steam feature.

Well, like Ryan said the S1 did not have a whistle but instead a horn. Instead of just getting a horn, Lionel decided to go ahead and put a whistle in it. Also, Ryan said that there was nowhere to put a whistle or even the system for the effect so they substituted it with the safety vale effect.

Last edited by Trainmaster04

The flat with stakes and I-Beam load looks interesting (I think that's new, right? Or my memory is not as good as it used to be).  Probably the Angela Trotta Thomas "Well Stocked Shelves - bottom shelf" boxcar.

A light catalog for me in the "must haves" department, which is a good thing (for me, at the moment).  I possibly went a little too heavy on Lionel V1 and the final MTH catalog, so this one will be a nice break if I only order a piece or 2 of rolling stock.

-Dave

The Ten Wheelers are very tempting especially at a very attractive price. The Reading, Blue Mountain & Northern 225 in particular looks quite attractive.

225

Normally I'd groan at the reintroduction of the light Mikados for the umpteenth time, but I'm very curious how they'll do no. 4070. I'm a little surprised it wasn't lettered for the Cuyahoga Valley Line, but I'm very interested in how Lionel does the 5 different whistle options for this locomotive.

4070

Hopefully one of these whistles will be an option!

The Lionmaster Cab Forwards look tempting, but I'm a bit disappointed those don't have whistle steam. Shame...

The Standard O rolling stock I'm happy to see back, and at reasonable prices, too.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 4070
  • 225

I will admit the S-1 is intriguing but I won't pull the trigger until I see one in person.  They do look great in the catalog.  I was hoping for a few more Star Trek items but I guess I'll have to wait another catalog for a Dilithium Ore car.

I'' look through it better tonight but I'm pretty saturated with trains right now so it will have to be something special before I pull the trigger for sure.  Again I will risk waiting to see the delivered products first.

@KOOLjock1 I too was surprised in the Sofa King building.  I figured that was MTH's gimmick but I guess Lionel is taking it over.  Maybe Mike sold them the rights for naming buildings.  

Nothing much. Lots of redoes and repaints using tooling from the Todd Wagner era of product development from over 15 years ago. The Gensets are a big step down from my UP Vision Line version. I purchased a Legacy NYC ten-wheeler the last time it was offered. A thoroughly redone Legacy PRR T1 with the correct tender would have been a bigger hit than a redo of the S1. The Flyer is exceedingly thin.  It is all 'academic' anyway. No more Chionel for this engineer until Lionel finds a place to make this stuff somewhere (anywhere!) else than the PRC. 

Enjoy, if you can.

Bob

Last edited by Bob Bubeck

I'm definitely in for a 4-6-0...which one is the hard thing to figure out. I think I'll have to narrow it down between a Canadian Pacific/Strasburg 972, Boston and Maine or Rutland. 

Was a little bummed about the Southern 4501...was hoping it would be green. MTH did a beautiful one a few years ago I always kind of kicked myself for not picking up. 

The GP7 sets are tempting...that Southern catches my eye and I'm not a Southern guy at all. Despite just taking delivery of the MTH Daylight Cab Forward, something tells me it "might be nice to have a black one...."

Ah decisions, decisions...

The highs of catalog anticipation are matched by the lows of seeing virtually nothing for me. But that's fine. I'm mostly a PW guy who operates with my ZW and is always on the look out for some traditional stuff, especially the PW inspired or classics items. Lionel seems to have all but abandoned that market (notwithstanding the way overpriced SF Set in Volume 1).

Having said that, I had to go back and check but do have a half dozen items coming from Volume 1, all with Q3 and Q4 deliveries. One of these is the Lion Chief 2.0  0-6-0t which will be my first LC 2.0 item and am definitely looking forward to that one.

As is my usual custom will go back over the catalog again, including the hard copy I know will be coming from Ro. Sometimes I find something the 2nd or 3rd time around.

Last edited by johnstrains

I can't get too excited about Lionel catalogs anymore. For the life of me, I don't understand their list pricing structure, which of course does affect discount pricing. Lionel has always said it is the traditional starter set lines that pay the bills and keeps Lionel in business. Little wonder as those have to be high profit items, as the traditional rolling stock list prices are nearly right on par with the separate sale scale rolling stock items, especially considering any tooling costs and higher production costs due to the nature of the product details and production process.

And then there's no actual railroad names on any of the separate sale traditional rolling stock. I suppose the specialized and licensed paint schemes make the on-par with scale item prices seem a little more bearable... but not to me.

The one item that caught my attention in this particular catalog, is how the recently introduced traditional N5 caboose (a modernized SP style caboose) that had been listing for $75-$80, is now branded under the "Standard 0" line for a list price of $60.00. They're probably having it made in Vietnam, but I doubt they're retooling it, so I don't know how a traditionally proportioned car suddenly becomes a scale proportioned car with a lower price to boot????

Oh well, it's not my company. And I do want Lionel to stay in business, so they'll do what they have to do.

But just as certain, I don't see the Brianel Kitbash, Rebuild and Repaint shops having to close their doors any time soon.

Last edited by brianel_k-lineguy

I guess I've been living under a rock, but what's the deal with Sofa King Mattresses?  I mean, I vaguely remember an Saturday Night Live skit about it, but that's it.  When you reply...be kind. 

 

Say it five times, fast.  That is all.

If you still don't see it, Google "sofa king joke" and a lot of explanations will pop up.  Apparently a few business have really been named this over the years, so it's prototypical in some way (unlike the "Wei, Cheetum and Howe" law firm, which I will go out on a limb and suspect probably never has been an actual name of a law firm .  Though the law firm one is less vulgar, just a little disrespectful to the honest lawyers.)

-Dave

Last edited by Dave45681

"I guess I've been living under a rock, but what's the deal with Sofa King Mattresses?  I mean, I vaguely remember an Saturday Night Live skit about it, but that's it.  When you reply...be kind."

Larry,

It's a crass play on words (say it to yourself quickly).  I'm sure very funny to a 15 year old boy, but horrifying to a grandmother looking to buy a sweet gift for her grandchild.

Jon

Something(s) NYC and perhaps the New Haven caboose.  Nice catalog. I may not buy any this time around, but I appreciate the effort Lionel is making to have a line of products that appeal to those who want to spend less money.  In terms of sets, LionChief separate sale command locos and now their new line of freight cars, they are, amazingly, the low price leader for these products, except for Menard's freight cars.  Hopefully they will sell well and their offerings of $40 freight cars, $200 locos and $200-350 sets will be expanded.

@KOOLjock1 posted:

"I guess I've been living under a rock, but what's the deal with Sofa King Mattresses?  I mean, I vaguely remember an Saturday Night Live skit about it, but that's it.  When you reply...be kind."

Larry,

It's a crass play on words (say it to yourself quickly).  I'm sure very funny to a 15 year old boy, but horrifying to a grandmother looking to buy a sweet gift for her grandchild.

Jon

Ah!!!!!!!!!!  Thanks, Jon & Dave.  I don't even think I had to say it 5 times.  I feel smarter now, thanks!!

 

@KOOLjock1 posted:

"I guess I've been living under a rock, but what's the deal with Sofa King Mattresses?  I mean, I vaguely remember an Saturday Night Live skit about it, but that's it.  When you reply...be kind."

Larry,

It's a crass play on words (say it to yourself quickly).  I'm sure very funny to a 15 year old boy, but horrifying to a grandmother looking to buy a sweet gift for her grandchild.

Jon

Well then she probably won't buy it    I think it's funny, personally.

Just an FYI there are few Sofa King furniture stores around.

I think in one of the other topics on here there was a discussion about Pennsy colors and stripes. I believe someone said that they never ever run the green with 5 stripes, but always do so on the red. Is that correct, I can't remember for some reason. I think this was discussed earlier in the year about GG1's and some of the other Diesel's like the E8's.

Sharks are always interesting, may consider Pennsy depending on what else and the stripes answer.

 

Screenshot_20200715-140718

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Screenshot_20200715-140718

I think in one of the other topics on here there was a discussion about Pennsy colors and stripes. I believe someone said that they never ever run the green with 5 stripes, but always do so on the red. Is that correct, I can't remember for some reason. I think this was discussed earlier in the year about GG1's and some of the other Diesel's like the E8's.

Sharks are always interesting, may consider Pennsy depending on what else and the stripes answer.

 

Screenshot_20200715-140718

The first order for freight sharks was delivered in 1949 with the DGLE and 5 stripes scheme.  The stripes originally did not go down the nose, but were extended by the shops.  In the mid-50s when they were repainted, they received the single stripe of a freight locomotive (as in this catalog).  There are plenty of photos showing 5-stripe and 1-stripe sharks running together.  The 5-stripe lasted at least into the mid-60s.

I have the Lionel earlier shark set with 5-stripes.

DSC_0023

There never were any freight sharks painted in Tuscan Red.  The red shark in this catalog is a continuation of Lionel's fantasy line of trains.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSC_0023
Last edited by CAPPilot
@MartyE posted:

I will admit the S-1 is intriguing but I won't pull the trigger until I see one in person.  They do look great in the catalog.  I was hoping for a few more Star Trek items but I guess I'll have to wait another catalog for a Dilithium Ore car.

 

Marty, I agree with you on Star Trek. Also I'm surprised Lionel is not making a Star Wars set with additional cars & accessories, considering how popular Star Wars is along with Star Trek. I am a Star Wars fan but I also do like Star Trek as well.

@Wrawroacx posted:

Marty, I agree with you on Star Trek. Also I'm surprised Lionel is not making a Star Wars set with additional cars & accessories, considering how popular Star Wars is along with Star Trek. I am a Star Wars fan but I also do like Star Trek as well.

I can't imagine what the Star Wars license would cost.  I doubt Star Trek was cheap either though.  

The S1, for sure. I've been lusting after that model waiting for a Legacy version for years now. The NS track inspection theatre car with Wi-Fi is also a shoe-in; I wish it was a 4K camera, but 1080p will do. The real dilemma for me is whether my existing MTH HW Madison PRR passenger set is prototypical enough for the S-1 to pull or do I spring for the streamlined set in the catalog as well. I have an MTH PRR T1 (newly upgraded to PS3) that'll run with those as well, so I guess it's more of a budgetary question than a dilemma regarding the streamliners. 

@CAPPilot posted:

The first order for freight sharks was delivered in 1949 with the DGLE and 5 stripes scheme.  The stripes originally did not go down the nose, but were extended by the shops.  In the mid-50s when they were repainted, they received the single stripe of a freight locomotive (as in this catalog).  There are plenty of photos showing 5-stripe and 1-stripe sharks running together.  The 5-stripe lasted at least into the mid-60s.

I have the Lionel earlier shark set with 5-stripes.

DSC_0023

There never were any freight sharks painted in Tuscan Red.  The red shark in this catalog is a continuation of Lionel's fantasy line of trains.

Yeah, I got the CC2 Sharks as well. I like the color on those better than the one in the catalog, not sure what green it is. Probably settle for the red most likely. I am going to watch the FB catalog review by Ryan shortly, see all of what he says and weigh some stuff based on that.

I am looking at page 20 USRA Light Steam locomotive.  Something does not seem right.  Lionel says this is 30 inches long????  That does not seem to be right when the USRA 2-8-8-2 is listed at 28 inches on page 16.  Now I wonder whether the minimum curve is correct at 036? All I have is 036 curves.  Does 036 sound right to you or do you think this USRA Light is 054Min?  Just wondering.  I will email hobby shop tomorrow.  Thank you 

Clearly Lionel is still pushing the huge 21" passenger cars, of no use to anyone who doesn't have a giant layout. Speaking of giant, that S-1 is over 36" long! You have to make a major investment in track to have enough room to run that thing.  

It appears we've entered the era of non-Vision steam engines approaching 2 grand, and $1000 diesels with the A-A E units. $950 for a Shark A-A, $90-95 cars. You have to hang on for this elevator ride. Surprised that there weren't more LionChief Plus 2 offerings.

Things of interest: 4-6-0 Soo, but probably will find a Pacific at some point and re-label it instead; T&P 4-6-0 (long shot); Cotton Belt Geep (maybe, after seeing what the colors end up actually looking like -  you don't know these days); CNW roof hatch b/c; Central Soya hopper; and ACL LC+ Geep. There's nothing in the "must have" category. Been going back and picking up some stuff from previous catalogs lately, so will be extremely selective on anything new here.

Last edited by breezinup
@Greg - Mi posted:

I am looking at page 20 USRA Light Steam locomotive.  Something does not seem right.  Lionel says this is 30 inches long????  That does not seem to be right when the USRA 2-8-8-2 is listed at 28 inches on page 16.  Now I wonder whether the minimum curve is correct at 036? All I have is 036 curves.  Does 036 sound right to you or do you think this USRA Light is 054Min?  Just wondering.  I will email hobby shop tomorrow.  Thank you 

I had the same thought. Typo?

@Greg - Mi posted:

I am looking at page 20 USRA Light Steam locomotive.  Something does not seem right.  Lionel says this is 30 inches long????  That does not seem to be right when the USRA 2-8-8-2 is listed at 28 inches on page 16.  Now I wonder whether the minimum curve is correct at 036? All I have is 036 curves.  Does 036 sound right to you or do you think this USRA Light is 054Min?  Just wondering.  I will email hobby shop tomorrow.  Thank you 

I have the B&O Legacy Light Mikado, released a year or two ago. It runs fine on 0-42 and I believe will run on 0-31, but I would have to try it. I would be pretty optimistic it would be fine on 0-36 given it's performance and my experience on my 4x8 home layout. 

@SJC posted:

I have the B&O Legacy Light Mikado, released a year or two ago. It runs fine on 0-42 and I believe will run on 0-31, but I would have to try it. I would be pretty optimistic it would be fine on 0-36 given it's performance and my experience on my 4x8 home layout. 

Just looked up the 2012 v1 catalog and it shows the locomotives to be at 20 3/4" and has a min curve of O36. Maybe Lionel was trying to get this catalog out in a hurry and missed this.

Is the light Mikado 4501 right this time? I remember something about the last run or maybe it was another Southern engine(630) that was not correct. I think that might be one solid choice from me other than the Ten Wheelers. Other stuff I'm still mulling over as yet. Some of the passenger cars look good. Ryan said the VL NYC baggage was still around, so I won't be needing that since I have it already. Some of the other cars are past 1949 which I want to model around. The reefers they have in there I was curious, but I think they would still be in that time frame, not sure though.

Is the light Mikado 4501 right this time? I remember something about the last run or maybe it was another Southern engine(630) that was not correct. I think that might be one solid choice from me other than the Ten Wheelers. Other stuff I'm still mulling over as yet. Some of the passenger cars look good. Ryan said the VL NYC baggage was still around, so I won't be needing that since I have it already. Some of the other cars are past 1949 which I want to model around. The reefers they have in there I was curious, but I think they would still be in that time frame, not sure though.

It's a close approximation, but no, 4501 has several details that vary from the model.  For example.... the walkways on either side of the boiler are incorrect.  O scale usually requires using a bit of imagination with any model as very few are accurate 

It's a close approximation, but no, 4501 has several details that vary from the model.  For example.... the walkways on either side of the boiler are incorrect.  O scale usually requires using a bit of imagination with any model as very few are accurate 

Well, walkways are one thing, looks like the bell is in the right place.

Well, walkways are one thing, looks like the bell is in the right place.

Right place yes, correct type sort of. The type of bell she has today is closer to what a 2-8-4 has. Yes, she has had a shelf mounted bell but that was when she was still working for the K&T or pre museum days. It could be argued that it is correct, or incorrect, but Lionel has done a good enough job to recreate it. Also, if they were going to make new tooling for it then modelers would be howling about the prices.

Right place yes, correct type sort of. The type of bell she has today is closer to what a 2-8-4 has. Yes, she has had a shelf mounted bell but that was when she was still working for the K&T or pre museum days. It could be argued that it is correct, or incorrect, but Lionel has done a good enough job to recreate it. Also, if they were going to make new tooling for it then modelers would be howling about the prices.

I asked on their FB page about the length and minimum curve as they are probably both wrong. 30" is a little long for a Mike, and 36 curve? Does it bend in half? Last offerings of Light Mike's was in 2017, they took a 54 curve but I forgot how long they were. I think around or just over 20".

I asked on their FB page about the length and minimum curve as they are probably both wrong. 30" is a little long for a Mike, and 36 curve? Does it bend in half? Last offerings of Light Mike's was in 2017, they took a 54 curve but I forgot how long they were. I think around or just over 20".

Generally they around 21" long.  The k-line version was the same tooling and could manage O31 curves.  Changes in the drawbar would be the only reason for a larger curve rating with this model

@hold*on posted:

Am looking at the prices!  Perhaps individuals in the market for these offerings can file for more government stimulus money.  Thank goodness I've gotten my trains before now.

Agreed. I've been through this catalog several times since yesterday ......what little enthusiasm it evokes is subdued by the pricing..........Usually there is a significant "buzz" for several days following a catalog release, I am not sensing that activity with this release. Glad I purchased my trains before the pricing went stratospheric for the same stuff with a new paint job.........

Just placed a preorder for a Northern Pacific GP7.  First Lionel engine and first Northern Pacific for my layout.  Hope a Legacy control system shows up for Christmas this year but sounds like no rush.  I think I read not to expect this engine before June 2021.  Can’t wait to compare the Lionel to my MTH Engines and learning the Legacy system.

They would make a Frisco Mikado, after I re-lettered an MTH Mikado last year (I did the 4018, like the one in Birmingham).  Kind of like how they made the A&WP #290 after I re-lettered a K-Line Pacific...  Are they following my post on here?  Kind of weird...  I was thinking about painting some E7s to pull my Golden State cars, I have been using some Southern Pacific E8s, well they are in this catalog too!  Not saying mind readers too, but wow...  I might be interested in buying those, but I would like to see the actual production model for the colors compared to my K-Line cars...

I wonder if dealers will split the Southern GP-7 set. As pointed out by DaveJfr0 on the Southern RR topic page, the cars don't match the locomotive. The GP-7 is in the 50s era green but the cars are 1970s - 1980s (especially the caboose). As he said, change the loco to the black tuxedo and offer the green one as a separate sale. I would really like to get this green loco, and if needed will buy the set. I have some Atlas GP35s that the cars and caboose can run behind anyway. 

Ah!!!!!!!!!!  Thanks, Jon & Dave.  I don't even think I had to say it 5 times.  I feel smarter now, thanks!!

 

I did not get it either until I split out parts of the words in my mind.  Maybe whoever picked that didn't realize it either, I wouldn't have. LOL.  With what's going on in the world is that really a big deal.  I think I will buy one now, haha

 

I could want. A lot of remakes at phenomenal prices, (2-8-8-2, GP-7, GENSETS). The 2 freight sets offered hAve no discount over purchasing individual units. $190 for a remake of Weaver's B60 baggage car and RPO'so are ridiculous. I'm nevery going to spend $95 for a plastic freight car.

$375 for a 40 year old GP-7 is not worth it. 90 to 250 dollars for a 9 by 6 inch building makes no sense to me. $400 for a k-line remake of the 18 inch pullmans.

No thanks

For the first time since I got into into 3-rail O-gauge, I see something in a Lionel Catalog that I may actually be willing (but just barely) to spend the money on - An LC+ R.I. GP7.  A lot of cool features for the not too overly exorbitant amount of money.

I also wouldn't mind having the Legacy Rock Island E7 ABA set, along with all the Golden State passenger cars.  But a grand total of around $3,950.00 catalog pricing (cough, hack, choke, puke, nitroglycerin tablets, emergency AED's, etc. etc. ) for 3-rail trains?  I'm not sure if I'd spend that kind of money even IF I won the lottery!  ZOIKS! 

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by Lionel, LLC

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×