Skip to main content

Hi. I have an MTH 30-5174 that has no lights. I traced the lights power (RED/BLACK) to a tiny 6 volt supply that was in bad shape (pics attached). It looks like there was a short somewhere and things on the board heated up to the point that solder melted. I read on another thread to check the bulb sockets for poor insulation. It's on my todo list. However this board seems to be missing parts. 2 resistors (R1 and R2) are not on the board. I can't figure out where they went. Without them there is no connection to the output socket. Also why 2 resistors in parallel? Best I can figure is to handle more current (or less current?) as they feed directly to the output connector. Might anybody have a schematic or a way to find out what value these were?

Thanks!



20230516_18010820230516_180039

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20230516_180108
  • 20230516_180039
Last edited by BobbyDing
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Thank you John, I see there is a spot on the board for another connector that is fed directly from the 6 volts, but it's not used here. I don't have the unit in front of me right now, but I will have to see if the current limiting resistors were moved to the wiring, as this one socket appears to feed both the incandescent and leds. I will probably take you up on your offer. I've already ordered some replacement mica for the heat sinking (old one fell apart). You can expect a DM from me soon.

Thank you again!

Bobby

Thanks gents. Looking closely at the unit this 6V board only powers the two 433 bulbs. The leds come off the ps3 board. You can see in my second pic where the trace for the regulator out pin had lifted off the board (heat I'm guessing) and there was some copper in between the ground and output pins. My attempts to scratch it clean are visible. It's such a simple circuit, yet so many problems. It's working again, but I'm going to install Johns board because it hasn't seen so much drama, along with a ptc for each bulb. I also see one of the paper washers in the bulb socket twisting and not staying centered. I'm guessing that may be the culprit that started the issues. I don't think there are many (if any) parts available for this unit. I may have to install a generic socket.

Bobby

Hi gents, I'm at work presently, but I'll post some better pictures after I get home. Unfortunately I didn't take any full "before" pictures other than this one. I say this because the wiring was a rats nest. Since it's my first mth I assumed this was normal. I've since cleaned up the wiring. I just scanned through the manual pdf and found the b/w picture I'm attaching. It's slightly different than mine, but the two bulbs are there. Presently the only led lighting it has are two directional headlights and signage boards on either side of the roof. I admit I was surprised how bad the lighting looks with these two bulbs. When running only the front and back of the side sillowette windows are lit. The center is dark. For a Christmas trolley the lighting is very unexciting. Just this morning I ordered some 5V led strip lighting for the inner roof that I'm hoping to replace the bulbs ( warm white and some colored leds to experiment with). I'll toss in 1 or two dropping diodes at the output of John's 6V board to power them. I should mention that an all other aspects I really like the trolley. I've added a switch for the dcc/dcs selection and have been enjoying the station stop sounds and announcements during testing.

Bobby

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20230516_000042
  • Screenshot_20230523_195617_Dropbox

Well that picture is the PS-2 3V board.  I am still confused.  Did you upgrade this to PS-3?  Are you guessing at the Model number?  Is this something your putting together?  If you have bulbs in your unit the trolley was a PS-1 or PS-2.  Either way, the PS-2 or PS-3 board can drive all the lighting.  Bulbs for PS-2 and LEDs for PS-3.  The CV board does not need to be in there.  G

Thank you everybody for your insights and assistance. The model of the trolley is 30-5174 and can be found here:

https://mthtrains.com/30-5174-1

Along with the downloadable manual, which is the exact copy of the manual that came in the box with the trolley (Pics attached). On page 35 of the manual it talks about not needing to replace the leds, but also says you may need to replace the interior bulbs. For whatever reason, this ps3 manual uses a ps2 trolley for the photos in its descriptions.

I also found a youtube showing the exact model trolley I have, and it exibits the same lighting issues I've been experiencing. Namely, bright at the two ends and dark in the middle. He does a good job of explaining why this is so.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=...N0bWFzIHRyb2xsZXk%3D

Hopfully this will help clear up any questions.😁

Bobby

PS: Ignore the connected board to the left of the trolley. It is a Bluerail board that was allowing me to control the trolley via bluetooth. I'm still deciding if I want to make it part of the trolley for good. Also, sorry about the upside-down pic.

20230524_001657mp,20230524_00171020230524_00180820230524_00162120230524_001631

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 20230524_001710
  • 20230524_001808
  • 20230524_001621
  • 20230524_001631
@GGG posted:

If they were suppose to be interior lights they could be driven off track power.  Don't know if that is factory with CV board.  Sure seems odd and more cost when the PS-3 board could light the interior and more.  G

I agree. The only thing I could come up with was they wanted them purposefully dim. Or maybe full brightness made too much heat (pretty thin plastic). I really wished they had done more led lighting inside. The bluerail app shows many dcc functions available for controlling a locomotive (if it were a full fledge loco). The function outputs were certainly available. Perhaps it was rushed to get it out for the holidays.

Bobby

Those are Molex Mini-SPOX connectors, available at Digikey or Mouser.

Molex 0022035025

Hey @gunrunnerjohn...

I've always been meaning to ask this question and hope it's not a stupid one.

How do you know or are able to identify the various plugs and sockets used on various circuit boards?

Do you have/use some kind of reference material or is it just chalking it up to experience?

I cant begin to tell you how many times I thought about asking the very question @BobbyDing asked!

@Junior posted:

Hey @gunrunnerjohn...

I've always been meaning to ask this question and hope it's not a stupid one.

How do you know or are able to identify the various plugs and sockets used on various circuit boards?

Do you have/use some kind of reference material or is it just chalking it up to experience?

No stupid questions, only stupid answers.   I still ask lots of questions if I don't know something.  I'm not afraid to admit there is a ton of stuff I don't have a clue about!

As for the connector ID's, it's a combination of knowing from previous experience and doing research to find out when I don't know.  If I'm trying to ID a new connector, I sometimes use Google images and enter what I know about the connector like the pitch and the number of pins.  Then I just scroll through the images to see if I spot it.  I've asked on various forums if I don't know as well.

The trick is to capture that information and keep it where you can find it again!

@BobbyDing posted:

Just an update, the trolley is better lit now with leds powered by @gunrunnerjohn' s CV board instead of the bulbs. The top roof lid still needs to be snapped in. I'm just waiting till I'm 100% sure I like it.

20230612_020421



This photo that I took at the Branford Trolley Museum 2008 Members' Day might give you an idea:

100_1040



And an enclosed car:

100_1010

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 100_1040
  • 100_1010
Last edited by PRRMP54

Sorry, I assumed you were saying I should try using one of your boards that you have created for powering leds in passenger cars because it's adjustable. To do so I would need to know how big it is because there isn't much available room inside the trolley. Thus my question about dimensions. Apologies if I misunderstood.

Bobby

@BobbyDing posted:

Sorry, I assumed you were saying I should try using one of your boards that you have created for powering leds in passenger cars because it's adjustable. To do so I would need to know how big it is because there isn't much available room inside the trolley. Thus my question about dimensions. Apologies if I misunderstood.

I must have really misunderstood, you stated that you were powering the LED's using my LED board!  At least that's what you said previously.

@BobbyDing posted:

Just an update, the trolley is better lit now with leds powered by @gunrunnerjohn' s CV board instead of the bulbs. The top roof lid still needs to be snapped in. I'm just waiting till I'm 100% sure I like it.

The module is 1.1" x 0.55" footprint, and with the regulator tab folded down, it's about 0.5" tall.  I normally stick them to the ceiling of the passenger cars as that's well above the sightline unless you're below the windows and looking up at the roof.

Ok, that explains the confussion. I was referring to the 6V CV board you were kind enough to mail to me a couple months ago 🫡 It's presently powering both sets of leds. I'll head back into the trolley when time allows to see about installing something to allow dimming. I did purchase a small function only dcc board so I could externally control the led lighting, but that would only work when using dcc.

Bobby

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by MTH Electric Trains

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×