Skip to main content

I have been watching the Stout Auction today. Have you seen the prices on this stuff? Wow, an EMPTY SET BOX, went for $7400.00. That is just crazy in my way of thinking. Most sets, with or without box, are going for $1500 up to $7000. Individual items are going for 100's of dollars. Well, more power to those buying at these prices. I guess they can afford it. Makes it kind of tuff on us little guy,s who just want a specific item or two.

Jeff

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I watch postwar pretty closely and buy when I find what I what at the right price. Agree that there are the outliers like those cited above, but also know that there are excellent deals if you look around and are selective.

I recently picked up an excellent condition Santa Fe F3 2343 AA set at a great price. How many did I take a pass on? Dozens, I'm sure.

Patience...

20210519_11503320210519_115130

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20210519_115033
  • 20210519_115130
Last edited by johnstrains
@Allegheny posted:

Some folks have way to much money and not enough common sense.  $7,400 for an empty box is simply insane.   

Can you please point me toward some of those folks - I have a bunch of boxes that are taking up space.  Probably nothing that would bring much money, though. 

A few years ago, I saw an empty pre-war set box at York - can't recall what it was for - about the top 1/3 had been torn away, and it had $3800 posted on it.  I thought that was absolutely bonkers, but it looks like crazy has no limits.

Last edited by Mallard4468
@Allegheny posted:

Some folks have way to much money and not enough common sense.  $7,400 for an empty box is simply insane.   

"Common sense is not so common."   ...Voltaire

howdumb

But, of course, it's just MHO.

TEHO.

OTOH, budgetary waste is also a pandemic.  Read the knightly gnus lately?

----------------

My Doctor: "Have any members of your family suffered from insanity?"

Me: " No, we all seem to enjoy it"
rim-shot
-------------------
KD

Attachments

Images (2)
  • howdumb
  • rim-shot
Last edited by dkdkrd

I tend to disagree with the OP.  There may be some odd ball outliers and certainly some rare pieces still demanding high prices, but run-of-the mill postwar is getting harder and harder to sell.  I buy a fair number of collections and I'm really only paying as low as possible for them. 

ZW's were selling for up to $325 each at one time.  Now you are lucky to get $100.  I'll only calculate the value in a collection at $50 at best since they invariably need a new power cord, new rollers, and possibly new circuit breakers and rectifiers, plus the time to fix them.

2020 turbines were getting upwards of $150-$200 each.  Now you are lucky to get $100, if you can even sell one.  A moving price might be more like $75 unless in pristine condition with boxes.  They have shown up with great regularity in recent collections I've purchased.

The last train show that I was at a couple of months ago there were tables FULL of common black steam engines of various numbers and none were moving.

I had someone contact me with a small collection with only a 665 w/2046W tender and a couple of cars including a Great Northern 6464 (don't know which one).  He doesn't have and won't put together a list of the rest of the items and doesn't really have a price in mind except a "fair price".  I'm hesitant to even go look at them since it is an hour away and with tolls.  My real concern is that he will be insulted with what I would be willing to pay for them.  There are no boxes and condition is completely unknown.  A 665 w/2046W is a nice engine and generally runs well but I already have one in excellent condition in the boxes so this would be for resale.  How long might it take to sell it and for how much? $75 to $100?  Here's the thing. He wants me to come and look at them as I'm the only person to have contacted him about them.  10 to 15 or 20 years ago, I would have jumped all over the opportunity to purchase this small collection.

Just my humble opinion of the state of postwar Lionel. You are free to disagree.  However, I still love running them and am just going to the basement layout to find out why my 364 log loader isn't working!

If you read the details of the lot, it was part of a set break-up. The Hudson went in the next lot and the Pullmans followed that.

2148WS Box: $7,400

773 Hudson (C9/10) $5,100

3 Pullmans (C9) $4,400

Total $16,900

Stout sold a boxed 2148WS set complete with the loco and cars, rated C10,  in 2017 for $11,000. The next lot after the Pullmans was a C10 Canadian Pacific F3 set for $7,300. That guy probably thought he got a bargain.

It only takes 2 people, or more likely egos, to make wild things happen at an auction.

Last edited by Former Member

Back to the beginning.

  Ok, prices are really going crazy now on Postwar Lionel

I can't agree.

Have you noticed something?  This only happens on a regular basis at Stout, and only on some Postwar Lionel.  I haven't seen it at any other auction site, or with any other auction house.

(It's true that ebay listings will also sometimes reach these levels, but it's very, very rare that they sell at these levels.)

Let's take a deep breath and relax.

Mike

@lionelflyer posted:

I tend to disagree with the OP.  There may be some odd ball outliers and certainly some rare pieces still demanding high prices, but run-of-the mill postwar is getting harder and harder to sell.  I buy a fair number of collections and I'm really only paying as low as possible for them.

ZW's were selling for up to $325 each at one time.  Now you are lucky to get $100.  I'll only calculate the value in a collection at $50 at best since they invariably need a new power cord, new rollers, and possibly new circuit breakers and rectifiers, plus the time to fix them.

2020 turbines were getting upwards of $150-$200 each.  Now you are lucky to get $100, if you can even sell one.  A moving price might be more like $75 unless in pristine condition with boxes.  They have shown up with great regularity in recent collections I've purchased.

The last train show that I was at a couple of months ago there were tables FULL of common black steam engines of various numbers and none were moving.

I had someone contact me with a small collection with only a 665 w/2046W tender and a couple of cars including a Great Northern 6464 (don't know which one).  He doesn't have and won't put together a list of the rest of the items and doesn't really have a price in mind except a "fair price".  I'm hesitant to even go look at them since it is an hour away and with tolls.  My real concern is that he will be insulted with what I would be willing to pay for them.  There are no boxes and condition is completely unknown.  A 665 w/2046W is a nice engine and generally runs well but I already have one in excellent condition in the boxes so this would be for resale.  How long might it take to sell it and for how much? $75 to $100?  Here's the thing. He wants me to come and look at them as I'm the only person to have contacted him about them.  10 to 15 or 20 years ago, I would have jumped all over the opportunity to purchase this small collection.

Just my humble opinion of the state of postwar Lionel. You are free to disagree.  However, I still love running them and am just going to the basement layout to find out why my 364 log loader isn't working!

This gentleman summed up the current state of postwar  perfectly !

I tend to agree that the idea that postwar prices are going crazy based on an auction result is like using a single point to figure out a trend (I had a crazy mathematician try to convince me that is possible using all kinds of theory that went right over my head). It is likely what drove those prices is scarcity of some sort, given the nature of boxes maybe there just aren't too many of those, or the guy had the set and wanted the box. I have seen crazy (to me) stuff on ebay, too, where someone wanted something and was willing to pay top dollar for it.

There are also people out there who remember 30+ years ago and think Lionel is highly collectible so will go crazy with it. What I see with postwar is that unless it is absolutely mint and rare, you just aren't going to get the big prices for it from what I have seen. Operators aren't go to pay big prices, they generally are looking for things they like and want to run, not whether the brake wheel was put on backwards or something, and to an operator I would guess being pristine doesn't matter. Again, if you have something rare, like one of the "automatic train control' sets that allowed for two engines on the same track , prices could be there as a real collectors item.

I ran into a 'gentleman' (I am being kind) at the last train show I went to and he was complaining how his collection just wasn't worth what it once was, that it was unfair he invested so much, etc when he saw what prices were like. The problem is obvious, he didn't think about the laws of collecting, like 1)sometimes it is just a fad 2)long term collectability usually revolves around condition and 3)if you are collecting to make money, good luck, you'll need it.

Postwar will never be "dead",  it will cool off for awhile, then a new group of people discover it for one reason or another and drive sales crazy and up goes the prices again.  Its happened before, and it will happen again.   As to whether it will hit the crazy levels that even common 2343's were fetching nearly $1000 for a clean AA set back in the mid 1990's, who knows?   As always, the deals are out there, the folks smoking ditch weed are out there, so your mileage will vary.    AD

@bigkid posted:


...

I ran into a 'gentleman' (I am being kind) at the last train show I went to and he was complaining how his collection just wasn't worth what it once was, that it was unfair he invested so much, etc when he saw what prices were like. The problem is obvious, he didn't think about the laws of collecting, like 1)sometimes it is just a fad 2)long term collectability usually revolves around condition and 3)if you are collecting to make money, good luck, you'll need it.

Several of those folks have tables at York, especially in the Blue and Silver halls.  I think I could wander through those halls blindfolded and point to the tables where the same stuff will be on display (I hesitate to say "for sale") year after year.  Or the folks who still think that MPC boxcars are worth $20.  It's worth going just for the amusement value.

I can see both sides of this discussion. However, this is not a lone occurrence. In fact, all Stout auctions seem to bring out the big dollars. As mentioned, Ebay sold items do not always bring this trend to the forefront, but Stout auctions does. The high prices seem to be a trend that started a year or two ago for sure. Still, somehow, a $7400 set box seems a little high to me. Just my thoughts of course.

Jeff

I think we all know that there still is demand for truly L/N to Mint super clean postwar Lionel - yesterday’s auction prices for mint stuff didn’t surprise me

What I have noticed is the prices for excellent condition - just a tick off like-new seem to be pretty strong also ???

I posted some postwar rolling stock for sale a little while back and everything sold INSTANTLY - everything was clean and boxed but again a tick off of truly L/N mint

Also no one questioned price etc - just the opposite - most of the people who purchased from me continue to get back asking if I have more to sell 😳

Guys still like Prewar / Postwar trains

@Former Member posted:

If you read the details of the lot, it was part of a set break-up. The Hudson went in the next lot and the Pullmans followed that.

2148WS Box: $7,400

773 Hudson (C9/10) $5,100

3 Pullmans (C9) $4,400

Total $16,900

Stout sold a boxed 2148WS set complete with the loco and cars, rated C10,  in 2017 for $11,000. The next lot after the Pullmans was a C10 Canadian Pacific F3 set for $7,300. That guy probably thought he got a bargain.

It only takes 2 people, or more likely egos, to make wild things happen at an auction.

The same guy bought all of it. He is posting about it on a group page

The only crazy prices I've seen have been on premium condition,hard to find,C8 or better Prewar and Postwar Lionel have been realized at Stout's. It's a top notch outfit and he's great at marketing his auctions to a huge audience of active buyers. I often place bids and occasionally score a piece. I've never been disappointed. It's a great thing he's able to get premium prices for the sellers. I follow and bid at several other auction houses and the prices rarely go this high.

Last edited by Ricky Tanner

If you have millions or tens or hundreds of millions of dollars, as many people do, tens of thousands of dollars is pretty much pocket change . I've always thought that worrying about what other people spend their money on is a self-indulgent and destructive enterprise.

It's good to see that collecting postwar and prewar is healthy because that means that repros are still likely to be made in the future, and that's my main interest.

@mowingman posted:

I can see both sides of this discussion. However, this is not a lone occurrence. In fact, all Stout auctions seem to bring out the big dollars. As mentioned, Ebay sold items do not always bring this trend to the forefront, but Stout auctions does. The high prices seem to be a trend that started a year or two ago for sure. Still, somehow, a $7400 set box seems a little high to me. Just my thoughts of course.

Jeff

Just my opinion, but if I was going to pay top dollar for a rare or pristine item, I'd be more likely to buy from Stout's - I have greater confidence that the item was properly described and graded than I would from an unknown seller on ebay.

@dorfj2 posted:

I think we all know that there still is demand for truly L/N to Mint super clean postwar Lionel - yesterday’s auction prices for mint stuff didn’t surprise me

What I have noticed is the prices for excellent condition - just a tick off like-new seem to be pretty strong also ???

I posted some postwar rolling stock for sale a little while back and everything sold INSTANTLY - everything was clean and boxed but again a tick off of truly L/N mint

Also no one questioned price etc - just the opposite - most of the people who purchased from me continue to get back asking if I have more to sell 😳

Guys still like Prewar / Postwar trains

Joe, You and I have been running on parallel tracks for 40 years with this stuff! I remember times when there were train shows every weekend and I was buying tons of postwar trains. Then sometime in the 1990's we started to see some genuinely minty items come out for sale at pretty hefty prices. There were a few collectors/sellers we knew that we felt comfortable buying from. So, having been accruing for a while, we turned around and sold lesser quality stuff and turned maybe 3 excellent steam locomotives into one minty boxed postwar set.  The size of the collection went down, but the quality went up. You and I used to say we had a successful York if we were able to add one really nice piece to the collection, and condition became everything.

As much as I'm now into modern era Lionel and the Scale Legacy side of the hobby, I sometimes can't resist a minty post war piece.

Last edited by NYC Fan

I guess we live in different worlds here in the model railroading universe .

Collectors willing to spend big dollars on pristine items, good for them, that's what they enjoy doing.

I, at the other end of the spectrum, went to a local train show recently and bought myself a post-war 623 switcher for $50, took it apart and cleaned it up, and it runs (almost) as good as new! And I am happy and content.

What matters is that we all enjoy the hobby in our different ways.

@Craftech posted:

This is simply the same supply chain issue facing a myriad of products this Christmas season.  They started talking about it at the end of the summer and here it is.  It goes right on down the line from new items to used items.  Look at how sky high used cars are priced due to the shortage of new ones.

John

Some time back I was given, for free, a couple old, cheap, toy Christmas train sets with plastic tracks, with no use for me. When i looked up on FB market place for going value, I noticed that there were several of them listed, and nobody buying them.

I figured i will wait until closer to Christmas, and then put them up for sale, hoping for higher demand.

I sold my few pieces of nice postwar Lionel for what I thought was a fair price for buyer and seller.  I have never had a lot to start with and most of it came via bargain auction buys.  I have a few I plan on keeping such as the 2046 my dad got me back around 2004, the 2332, the 773, and the 736. 

As others have mentioned, for average quality postwar I can hardly give it away.  I'll likely donate it back to my TCA division and let them auction it off again. 

@Craftech posted:

This is simply the same supply chain issue facing a myriad of products this Christmas season.  They started talking about it at the end of the summer and here it is.  It goes right on down the line from new items to used items.  Look at how sky high used cars are priced due to the shortage of new ones.

John

John,

It is, but it isn't.  On brand new goods maybe.  But prices on thousands of O Gauge items on the bay have doubled, and even tripled, over the last 18 months.  This isn't because of a shortage.  These folks have huge inventory that isn't turning over because it's priced too high.

With too many sellers the items we see today are the same exact items they were selling 18 months ago.  You can see this quite easily if you picclick to browse the bay because the amount of time that items have been on the market is clearly noted in their piclick listings.

In too many cases you'll notice things that didn't sell when they were first listed, because the prices were too high, so the lister held on to them for the future.  Unfortunately they won't sell now either, months or years later, especially not at two or three times the price.  There's no shortage here.

Mike

Last edited by Mellow Hudson Mike

Seems like prices took a big jump recently. Didn't even seem to be gradual.

As far as steam engines go the new LC+ 2.0 engines in this year's volume 2 catalog are at some Legacy prices from a couple years ago. It's getting to where I doubt you will get a new steam Legacy model for under $750 from here out. I'm glad I preordered my Legacy Camelback from the volume 1 catalog. List was $650. Payed around $570. Doubt you will find Legacy steam models at that price ever again.

Now I only hope it arrives......

Brad

Last edited by B rad

The price of the empty box, as we all know, sold due supply, demand and condition. Many boxes are hard to come by. We tore them open and parents threw the boxes in the trash. There are probably less than 5 of these boxes -in all- including collections and somewhere in public hands. Supply then is non-existent, this may have been the only one known. The demand was at least two who wanted it. The box's condition is also a consideration.   True collectors have the money to amass their collections and the cost, although high for enthusiasts, is not a concern for them. He was probably buying other stuff the next auction. 

Over the past year or so I've recorded the hammer prices for various categories of trains in some of the Stout Auctions.  Below is a summary of the hammer prices for Postwar Lionel items in 4 auctions from the past year or so. Included in the tally is anything train including boxes but it does not include paper such as catalogs, flyers, etc.  As you can see, all four of these auctions have interesting high price tails and all of them have half of their sales at or below $300 (remember, the median is the 50% point).

Post War Lionel Hammer Price

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Post War Lionel Hammer Price
Last edited by Robert S. Butler

There are 19 million millionaires in the US, at least before last week.  I think most of them are multi-millionaires.

If they had only $1M is savings, that set box only cost them .74% of that savings.  If that box was truly rare, that would probably be worth it for a true collector.

As mentioned earlier, I also found it interesting how they sold the whole set by piecing it out, with the box first.  Once they had the box, I am sure they had to have the rest.

Collector quality auctions and empty boxes are not for me.  Perhaps the Smithsonian one day will have a Lionel building, but I would not bet on it.

I am happy with the Postwar prices so far and feel if I am patient I will find what I want.  This family still has our Diesel switcher's, Pacific's, Prairies and Hudson's from the early 50's, and about 2 years ago I 'discovered' the sturdiness and beauty of prewar steamers with stainless steel tires, Baldwin drivers or copper trim.  And then, I caught the Berkshire bug bad, especially the 1946 Smoke Bulb variety which ranged from $300 to $700 with a good 2426W tender.  I slipped into my niche and slowly acquired quality items at the lower end of the price range.

I have added a dozen or more engines (224, 225, 225E, 249E, 263E and 6 Berkshires) and lots of quality postwar rolling stock.  So, if postwar is no longer King, it is far from dead, and as long as inexpensive trains can go round and round, the next generation of 'operators' is assured.  They run them too, just as 'we' did 70 years ago.  Run is Fun.

But...I do think that I may be stuck with a wee bit of Standard Gauge and Tin buildings, sometimes the prices were just too tempting or the items spiffy and unique.  Lesson is to buy not only that which you want, but that which will not be boxed up for another two decades.

Or, wait for the next round of politicians to fund a new building for the Smithsonian...we can vote on that later.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×