Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

One of the more famous PRR secondary lines ran from Williamsport in Pennslyvania to Sodus Point on Lake Ontario.    It had a branch to Canandaigua and there was pullman service to Canandaigua I think well into the 1950s.    This was the Elmira branch and there is nice magazine size book about it written many years ago.    It ran up through Elmira with a shorts section of trackage rights on the Erie (I think) and on up along Seneca Lake through Watkins Glen.    

I don't think the steam turbine ever got  up there, but lots of I1 2-10-0s ran  up there with coal trains to the lake and also M1/M1a 4-8-s with general freight.    Also the various consolidations and smaller power.  

Lionel has done a similar one with dual stairways that has been listed in a number of previous catalogues. 

This one was a plastic kit by Heljan I think.    The kit has been offered by a few of the plastic building kit suppliers over the years.  

I narrowed this one to fit the 2 tracks and platforms.   The tracks are on 4 inch centers and the bridge as it came would have been off the platform on one side.

That green pedestrian bridge was done by Plasticville about 20 years ago.  They show up at train shows and on eBay from time to time.

Here are several photos with Pennsy flavor from around my Pennsylvania & Western layout.  Click on any photo to see a larger version.

Double-headed Weaver H10s 2-8-0's approaching the grade crossing in Franklin, PA.

H10s in Franklin

MTH AS-616 with custom Trainphone equipment added, new engineer figure and corrected cab number.

P1010198 edit

A pair of 3rd Rail H6sb 2-8-0's are on the inbound steam service track in Annville, PA.

P1010216 edit

A 3rd Rail I1sa 2-10-0 is stopped at an intermediate signal between Lebanon and Summit, PA.  The signals on the left display an Approach indication, meaning that the Yard Limit Signals into Annville are set to Stop.  The signals are from Custom Signals.

P1010252 edit small

This is the freight station and Railway Express office in Summit, PA.

P1010264 edit small

A K-Line B6sb 0-6-0 works the yard in Annville, PA.

PHOTO 16b small

T1 4-4-4-4 #5511 (3rd Rail) drifts into the station at Lebanon, PA.  My layout is set in the 1949-1953 time period, and highway stop signs of that era were yellow with black lettering and sat on a short 4-foot post.  Quite different than today!

PHOTO 22 small

This is the interior of the Korber roundhouse in Annville.  It looks like a quiet day.

roundhouse stacked small

Attachments

Images (8)
  • H10s in Franklin
  • P1010198 edit
  • P1010216 edit
  • P1010252 edit small
  • P1010264 edit small
  • PHOTO 16b small
  • PHOTO 22 small
  • roundhouse stacked small
Last edited by Bob
@GG1 4877 posted:

A sampling of my GG1 fleet.  A repost, but such is life.  Missing 8 additional PRR ones in this photo.

_IGP9649

Fantastic, Jonathan... reminds me of the classic picture (I think it was an illustration) of GG1’s lined up in Philadelphia after bringing fans to the Army/Navy game. Gotta love all GG1’s (except possibly the horrific Conrail Bicentennial version - ugh!!!).

Here are photos of some of my HO PRR.  Most are vintage items.  I also have some interesting PRR N pieces including several PRR steam locomotives, GG1s, and passenger cars.  I should photograph the N, HO and O together for a fun comparision.

International Model Products 60' shorty PRR diner and observation.  This is late into their import period as the frames are bakelite.  I am guessing late 50's early 60's.

20210806_183647_HDR

Unbuilt 1955ish Penn Line E6 Kit.  I have several of these in various states of completion.

20210814_151310

Bowser K4 with super detail kit and extended tender that I built when I was 16.  As I have moved it over the last 35 years, I see it has lost a few details like the bell!

20210814_151420

Blue Line P85 coaches circa 1960's.

20210814_153604

Gilbert HO B6 with a smoke unit.  The motor sticks so far past the cab!

20210814_161242

Heavily modified MDC E6 with Bowser Tender.  I added $100 worth of detail parts to this $30 locomotive around 1995.

E6-HO

My write up for my George Stock vintage GG1s.  George also produced steam locomotives based on PRR prototypes in HO and was also known for his skills in hand brush lettering for O scale and HO scale locomotives. 

George Stock1 copy

George Stock2 copy

A 1960's - 1970's PRR N6 brass cabin.

IMGP1685

Attachments

Images (9)
  • 20210806_183647_HDR
  • 20210814_151310
  • 20210814_151420
  • 20210814_153604
  • 20210814_161242
  • E6-HO
  • George Stock1 copy
  • George Stock2 copy
  • IMGP1685

Here are some shots of the Panhandle's roster:

Double-headed I1s Decapods haul an ore train across the Panhandle bridge.

IMG_0476

East-bound Train 30, the Spirit of St. Louis, passes a Decapod west-bound on the bridge.

IMG_1238

In a scene reminiscent of the Grif Teller painting, the Spirit of St. Louis gracefully arcs off the bridge towards the viewer.

IMG_1023

Finally, we see an west-bound ore drag.  Please excuse the shakiness of the video (it's my first one).

George

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_0476
  • IMG_1238
  • IMG_1023
Videos (1)
IMG_0591

G3750 sharp looking bridge like the ore cars.

@G3750 posted:

Here are some shots of the Panhandle's roster:

Double-headed I1s Decapods haul an ore train across the Panhandle bridge.

IMG_0476

East-bound Train 30, the Spirit of St. Louis, passes a Decapod west-bound on the bridge.

IMG_1238

In a scene reminiscent of the Grif Teller painting, the Spirit of St. Louis gracefully arcs off the bridge towards the viewer.

IMG_1023

Finally, we see an west-bound ore drag.  Please excuse the shakiness of the video (it's my first one).

George

MTH, PRR K-4s meets, at Terryville on the Great Northeastern Railway, the Blue Comet en route to Atlantic City.

021

MTH, RailKing, PRR M1-a at the head end of a long coal train.

M 1 Small

Preparing a Lionel, post war, PRR steam locomotive for its next assignment.

Pennsy Engine in the Yards

The "Federal", headed by an MTH, RailKing, PRR GG-1 reaches full speed, leaving the city of Christopolis on the Great Northeastern Railway headed for Washington, D. C.

The Federal

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 021
  • M 1 Small
  • Pennsy Engine in the Yards
  • The Federal

Well this is my first time on this thread and I find that even though I rode the PRR extensively (commuted to University on the NE corridor while it was still Pennsy) I have very little in the way of PRR equipment.  So here is the best I can do.  New addition for me, the Lionel #6454 PRR boxcar made between 1948-1952.

Lionel 6454 PRR Box

Great pictures everyone, thanks for posting

Don

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Lionel 6454 PRR Box

Unfortunately everything is packed up waiting for my hoped for next and last migration but have some pics.

S1 on test stand.

27E8ADE5-792C-4FCC-B38B-BC44920D0705

The perfect compliment the Fleet of Modern.

376A6971-5364-487B-A181-6E62872E6140

A Lionel metal double door box Santa brought with my first Lionel train set Christmas of 1947 or maybe Santa brought with second set the Lionel "Electronic" set for Christmas 1948.

93FAB9AA-EEE5-4EB3-A059-F04D8D44D31D

A scale S2 by Lionel made in violation of contract with Mike Wolf.

488FDA3D-3935-4071-9493-90E3A521EE0E

A MTH model of the uniquest of all GG1's.

04F60C61-8910-4734-8B51-17B890C59885

A Train Master.

677E5FB2-5F4E-44D2-9595-4DC1E0E6C538

Shrouded K4.

7BCE1157-D1F1-47A5-8EBC-9B8DF2EB365F

A few cabin cars mixed with other roads cabooses.

4E54DEC7-3D59-4292-9088-DEA438E5C656

Ron

Attachments

Images (8)
  • 27E8ADE5-792C-4FCC-B38B-BC44920D0705
  • 376A6971-5364-487B-A181-6E62872E6140
  • 93FAB9AA-EEE5-4EB3-A059-F04D8D44D31D
  • 488FDA3D-3935-4071-9493-90E3A521EE0E
  • 04F60C61-8910-4734-8B51-17B890C59885
  • 677E5FB2-5F4E-44D2-9595-4DC1E0E6C538
  • 7BCE1157-D1F1-47A5-8EBC-9B8DF2EB365F
  • 4E54DEC7-3D59-4292-9088-DEA438E5C656
Last edited by PRRronbh

Well this is my first time on this thread and I find that even though I rode the PRR extensively (commuted to University on the NE corridor while it was still Pennsy) I have very little in the way of PRR equipment.  So here is the best I can do.  New addition for me, the Lionel #6454 PRR boxcar made between 1948-1952.

Lionel 6454 PRR Box

Great pictures everyone, thanks for posting

Don

Nice looking boxcar here are some pictures for you on the shepherd and sheep, We think we got from scenic express about 8 yrs ago I did a search on scenic express and out of stock, item number PR65325 $28.99 maker Preiser, Good luck with your find, did you try ebay?











Attachments

Images (3)
  • mceclip0
  • mceclip1
  • mceclip2

Sitka:  Thanks for the pictures and the compliment on my "lone" piece of PRR equipment.  I looked at my collection inventory and it turns out I do have 1 or 2 more cars but they are in storage (another word for lost ).  I will try your sources and e-bay.  Have looked on the trains portion of e=bay but not the "diecast figures" specific listings.  Oh well, I am off next week and will search then.  Thanks again for your response and information.

Don

Well this is my first time on this thread and I find that even though I rode the PRR extensively (commuted to University on the NE corridor while it was still Pennsy) I have very little in the way of PRR equipment.  So here is the best I can do.  New addition for me, the Lionel #6454 PRR boxcar made between 1948-1952.

Lionel 6454 PRR Box

Great pictures everyone, thanks for posting

Don

Don,

  You are hereby admitted to our exciting club! Glad you are not anti-Pennsy if you rode it as a commuter!

Tom

PRR8976 - No I am certainly not "anti-Pennsy"  in fact just the opposite.  Its just that after collage, all my military / job assignments were in the mid and south west and hence out of Pennsy territory so I just didn't collect much PRR equipment.  I do have the Lionel # 675 locomotive that many have posted and that the general opinion seems to be its a K4 even though the wheel arrangement is not correct.  Anyway .... thank you for the welcome.  

I did find one other piece of rolling stock in my collection but I am afraid that it bears little resemblance to anything  real or scale.  It is however from as early as 1915 and was available until 1925.  It is the Lionel #800 box car.  So Pennsy modelers, here is what you would have had if you had been modeling in the first 1/2 of the 20th century

Lionel 800 Box side 1Lionel 800 Box end

Best wishes and Merry Christmas / Happy Holidays

Don

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Lionel 800 Box side 1
  • Lionel 800 Box end

A little more PRR from my collection:

ABCF7086-E4B1-4CE3-BFED-965E30D063B4

Picked these up nd delivered today from the MPC Era. I saw my dad had them in a very old photo I found but have no idea what happened to them so in his memory I acquired another set.

Finly got some of my Cabin Cars unpack on on display been 7 years [packed up.

My MTH E8's ABBA and the Fleet of Modernism along with several front end cars. I am still looking for a set ofMTH Premier20-2637-1 PRR C Liners fro m 2004  Vol 1 Catalog.

As a Oh By The Way I heard from MTH and the P5a's are on the water and should arrive in mid January and the really big news is the P5a Replacement Shells are about 2 months behind them per "L" at MTH parts.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • ABCF7086-E4B1-4CE3-BFED-965E30D063B4
Videos (2)
4A16FA73-26CD-4079-BEDC-329F31139FCF.medium
5E7642BF-299F-4CB5-ACF2-4D2AD24F0609.medium
@RJT posted:

A little more PRR from my collection:

Picked these up nd delivered today from the MPC Era. I saw my dad had them in a very old photo I found but have no idea what happened to them so in his memory I acquired another set.

Finly got some of my Cabin Cars unpack on on display been 7 years [packed up.

My MTH E8's ABBA and the Fleet of Modernism along with several front end cars. I am still looking for a set ofMTH Premier20-2637-1 PRR C Liners fro m 2004  Vol 1 Catalog.

As a Oh By The Way I heard from MTH and the P5a's are on the water and should arrive in mid January and the really big news is the P5a Replacement Shells are about 2 months behind them per "L" at MTH parts.

Now that is a string of Cabin cars Very nice all!

Mark

@Sitka posted:

Now that is a string of Cabin cars Very nice all!

Mark

Mark Thank You, that is not all of them I still have some more to unpack and display and that is only the Pennsy ones I have at least 2 dozen of other Road names I really have a thing for Pennsy Cabin Cars and Cabooses .I think I have maybe 75 to a 100 of them total. Post War, MPC, Lionel and MTH.

Here are two photos from my  Pennsy passenger car pool.  The top photo is business car 120, an observation car.  This is a K line product.   IMG_0078

A custom interior resides inside this MTH Pennsy diner.   I purchased this car, in spring of 2019,  from a very nice and talented Canadian gentleman who created custom cars and sold them in the Orange Hall at York.  There are candles on every table inside the car with waiters in the isle and some passengers sitting at tables.  fullsizeoutput_69b

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_0078
  • fullsizeoutput_69b

Morning P.R.R. Fans, here is my 2332 GG-1 from 47-49, Looking at stripping and repainting in Brunswick Green and adding new gold stripes.  Also, my Williams P.R.R. Passenger cars, adding LED strips. And found a site on ebay that sells seats and other items for passenger cars and other items for cars. (SCALE CITY DESIGNS) not bad prices.

Attachments

Images (4)
  • mceclip0
  • mceclip1
  • mceclip2
  • mceclip3
Last edited by Sitka

Q2 takeover:



Norm;

Your layout is absolutely the most realistic I’ve ever seen. While I am not a fan of weathering equipment, your weathering seems just right - obviously hard working equipment without looking decrepit!!! And the Q2’s are beautiful engines. Now, I have to ask one dumb question... how did you film the parts from inside the shop??? Talk about realistic - amazing.

Well while no where near as neat as the beautiful engines that have been posted, the attached PRR ore car came from MPC in 1987.  While I have no idea how many or even if the PRR had any cars of this sort, Lionel felt that they were prototypical enough to produce them.  So here is the Lionel MPC 19300 PRR ore car.

Lionel PRR ore car sideLionel PRR ore car quarter

Best wishes for a great rest of the week

Don

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Lionel PRR ore car side
  • Lionel PRR ore car quarter

The PRR's Q1, a single prototype built in 1942, was an 4-6-4-4 duplex design with the rear cylinders reversed and under the firebox to allow larger drivers.  The engine was built for fast freight but the cylinder locations resulted in a smaller firebox that could not maintain boiler pressure under load, limiting its sustained speed.  It had streamlining when it was first built, but it was removed in 1944 because it interfered with maintenance and was not that effective at low speeds.  The engine was last used in 1948 and scraped in 1949.

20220116_22043420220116_220509

The is a 3rd Rail model.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20220116_220434
  • 20220116_220509
@CAPPilot posted:

The PRR's Q1, a single prototype built in 1942, was an 4-6-4-4 duplex design with the rear cylinders reversed and under the firebox to allow larger drivers.  The engine was built for fast freight but the cylinder locations resulted in a smaller firebox that could not maintain boiler pressure under load, limiting its sustained speed.  It had streamlining when it was first built, but it was removed in 1944 because it interfered with maintenance and was not that effective at low speeds.  The engine was last used in 1948 and scraped in 1949.

20220116_22043420220116_220509

The is a 3rd Rail model.

Ron beautiful pics always enjoy looking at your 40s layout

Last edited by lee drennen
@GG1 4877 posted:

Reminded me that I have a PW 2332.  It needs a thorough cleaning as last time I tried to run it I had some issues.  Nothing mechanically wrong, just dirty.  I got it as more of a display item anyway, but it would be nice to see it running someday.

20150831_192456

Thats how mine was, sold as is, don't work , front truck was broke made a repair, degreased and new brushes and brighter lights run like a clock, thinking should I repaint and new decals not sure yet.

As mentioned above, the PRR Q1 was an attempt to develop a powerful and dual purpose engine.  While it had its issues, its design led to the far more successful freight only Q2.  The Q2 had a more conventional duplex 4-4-6-4 wheel arrangement and was probably the most successful PRR design.  25 Q2s were built in 1945/6 but they lasted only until 1951 due to relatively high maintenance cost and the introduction of the diesel engine.

DSC_0036DSC_0037PRR Q2 & L2

The Q2 is MTH, and the L2 is K-Line.

Attachments

Images (3)
  • DSC_0036
  • DSC_0037
  • PRR Q2 & L2
@CAPPilot posted:

As mentioned above, the PRR Q1 was an attempt to develop a powerful and dual purpose engine.  While it had its issues, its design led to the far more successful freight only Q2.  The Q2 had a more conventional duplex 4-4-6-4 wheel arrangement and was probably the most successful PRR design.  25 Q2s were built in 1945/6 but they lasted only until 1951 due to relatively high maintenance cost and the introduction of the diesel engine.

DSC_0036DSC_0037PRR Q2 & L2

The Q2 is MTH, and the L2 is K-Line.

Nice looking engine CAP, thanks for all sharing some Pennsy Muscle.

Mark

Last edited by Sitka

My first T1 was MTH's initial release that I bought back in 2000, a PS1 engine.  I had it upgraded with PS2 shortly afterwards, and it ran well.

T1 sold

Unfortunately, I did little research on the engine before I bought it (I do that a lot). MTH's version of the T1 is based on the as delivered prototype engine, which only two were built in 1942.  These engines had the streamline fairings removed by 1943 to ease maintenance during the high usage of WWII.  Since the fairings were gone by my layout's era (1948/9), this engine no longer fit my needs so I sold it.  While the PRR ran these two engines until 1950 or so, there have been no O scale versions built without the streamlining.

The PRR liked this design, and ignoring the advances in diesel engine technology, built 50 more of the fast passenger engines between 1945 and 1946.  None of these engines had streamlining over the drivers, but still had a streamlined look.  Here is a photo from a post by prrhorseshoecurve of the as built production T1 engine.

Willliams-PRRT1b

Except for the last few built in 1946, the production engines had the port hole pilot.  Here again the streamlining effort interfered with efficient maintenance of the engine, so all earlier T1s had the port holes removed by 1948.  Here is my Lionel scale T1 in the T1's final configuration.

DSC_0048

Since only the non-port hole engines were around between 1948 and 1952 (when they were retired), this T1 configuration fits right into my layout's era.  It is one of my favorite engines and it is run a lot.

Attachments

Images (4)
  • T1 sold
  • sunset-models-3rd-rail-brass-T1
  • Willliams-PRRT1b
  • DSC_0048
@CAPPilot posted:

My first T1 was MTH's initial release that I bought back in 2000, a PS1 engine.  I had it upgraded with PS2 shortly afterwards, and it ran well.

T1 sold

Unfortunately, I did little research on the engine before I bought it (I do that a lot). MTH's version of the T1 is based on the as delivered prototype engine, which only two were built in 1942.  These engines had the streamline fairings removed by 1943 to ease maintenance during the high usage of WWII.  Since the fairings were gone by my layout's era (1948/9), this engine no longer fit my needs so I sold it.  While the PRR ran these two engines until 1950 or so, there have been no O scale versions built without the streamlining.

The PRR liked this design, and ignoring the advances in diesel engine technology, built 50 more of the fast passenger engines between 1945 and 1946.  None of these engines had streamlining over the drivers, but still had a streamlined look.  Here is a photo from a post by prrhorseshoecurve of the as built production T1 engine.

Willliams-PRRT1b

Except for the last few built in 1946, the production engines had the port hole pilot.  Here again the streamlining effort interfered with efficient maintenance of the engine, so all earlier T1s had the port holes removed by 1948.  Here is my Lionel scale T1 in the T1's final configuration.

DSC_0048

Since only the non-port hole engines were around between 1948 and 1952 (when they were retired), this T1 configuration fits right into my layout's era.  It is one of my favorite engines and it is run a lot.

CAP have you ever seen the PRR T1 Trust, they send out newsletters on the build, newsletter@prrt1steamlocomotivetrust.org, They have the tender for the T1. nice photos all. Mark

@CAPPilot posted:

Except for the last few built in 1946, the production engines had the port hole pilot.  Here again the streamlining effort interfered with efficient maintenance of the engine, so all earlier T1s had the port holes removed by 1948.  Here is my Lionel scale T1 in the T1's final configuration.

DSC_0048

Since only the non-port hole engines were around between 1948 and 1952 (when they were retired), this T1 configuration fits right into my layout's era.  It is one of my favorite engines and it is run a lot.

Ron;

Thanks for the history. While I am nowhere as road or era specific as you are, knowing some of the history behind these engines is great. Is your Lionel version one of the TMCC engines from around 2000??? I have one  packed away in the basement - it is a beautiful engine... I may just have to pull it out and give it a spin!!!

@Apples55 posted:

Ron;

Thanks for the history. While I am nowhere as road or era specific as you are, knowing some of the history behind these engines is great. Is your Lionel version one of the TMCC engines from around 2000??? I have one  packed away in the basement - it is a beautiful engine... I may just have to pull it out and give it a spin!!!

Yes, this is the 2000 engine.  Lionel released only this one production run because it got caught up in the lawsuit with MTH.  I would really like to see it released again with Legacy.

My engine has been modified.  It came without cruise control, so I has a TAS Engineer On Board installed.  The TAS EOB was a good board, although many did not like the built in slow acceleration.  This was not fixable, but I do not find it a problem (engines are suppose to start slow).  The one great thing about the TAS EOB board was it ability to change chuff rates between 2 and 4 chuffs/rev through the Cab1.  It is neat to hear the 4 double chuffs each rev.

The biggest issue was the too-wide center drivers as they would short out on some switches.  I had the drivers beveled which fixed that problem.

FYI - I became era and road specific to force me to keep my train buying under control.  Since then the research has become part of my enjoyment of the hobby.

The Pennsy had 1325 H30 covered hoppers built between 1935 and 1946.  Another 250 H30a cars were made starting 1951, with the only change being the bolsters (welded instead of cast).  There were still over a 1,000 of these cars by the start of the 70s.

This very well done Weaver car looks just like the prototype.  It is in the pre-1954 paint scheme.  Check out all the photos.

DSC_0001

Attachments

Images (5)
  • DSC_0001
  • DSC_001
  • DSC_0004
  • DSC_0009
  • DSC_0010
@CAPPilot posted:

Do you know if this is a D16?  If so, who made it?  A very few D16s made it to the late 40s.  Thanks.

This is an MTH model, more like an "as built" D16. See this great thread about it here.

3 D16sb's made it to the 1940s. Of course, 1223 was pulled aside in the late 30s as a "publicity engine" (world fairs, movies, and other smaller displays). The other two were mostly working on the DELMARVA peninsula during this time.

I believe 1223 was technically Penn Central's only operating steam locomotive - PRR leased the engine to Strasburg in 1965, and Penn Central transferred ownership to the RR Museum of Pa. in the 1970's. While 1223 wasn't on the PC roster, it was still owned by PC while operation at Strasburg!

@49Lionel - If you are still active on the forum, I'd love to see more pictures of your custom D16sb!

Last edited by Prr7688
@Prr7688 posted:

This is an MTH model, more like an "as built" D16. See this great thread about it here.

3 D16sb's made it to the 1940s. Of course, 1223 was pulled aside in the late 30s as a "publicity engine" (world fairs, movies, and other smaller displays). The other two were mostly working on the DELMARVA peninsula during this time.

I believe 1223 was technically Penn Central's only operating steam locomotive - PRR leased the engine to Strasburg in 1965, and Penn Central transferred ownership to the RR Museum of Pa. in the 1970's. While 1223 wasn't on the PC roster, it was still owned by PC while operation at Strasburg!

@49Lionel - If you are still active on the forum, I'd love to see more pictures of your custom D16sb!

Here are a few pics from several years ago:

PB230007PC310011

I still have it, and still haven't had those drivers replaced with 68" ones (which I have).  My interests have gone in other directions, but this is a great-looking and running model.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • PB230007
  • PC310011

I would love to be able to track down a Max Gray D16 one day.  I am not normally a fan of most 19th century American Standards, but the ones that were built and / or rebuilt in the 20th century I find fascinating.  While anachronistic, I would put a D16 next to my F3 mogul next to my postwar K4 in a heartbeat on my layout and not even concerned about the prototypical infidelity in a heartbeat. 

Here is an interesting piece I picked up at York a number of years ago.  It is a custom built HO GG1.  The frame is rigid so I don't even want to hazard a guess on the curves it needs.

20170604_163537

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 20170604_163537

OK fellows, Lee and Sitka have made it "open season" on PRR boxcars.  So to show that I can be nonsensical although I hope to provide  some fun here are a few down the years....

Here is the Lionel #800 PRR boxcar from 1915 - 1926

Lionel 800 Box side 2

Here is the Lionel #6454 PRR boxcar from 1949-1952 (quite a difference eh!)

Lionel 6454 PRR Box

Here is the Marx , PRR Merchandise Service boxcar from 1965...all of 6" long about the same length as the Lionel #800 from 1915...who says progress is always one dimensional .

Marx boxcar PRR

Well best wishes everyone.  Great pictures especially liked the discussion of the D16 loco, new information to me.  I also really liked the "for real" PRR box cars and merchandise service cars by Lee and Sitka.  CAPPilot - neat cars and I always like your discussion on the background / history from the real PRR.  Thanks all.

Have a great week everyone

Don

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Lionel 800 Box side 2
  • Lionel 6454 PRR Box
  • Marx boxcar PRR

OK fellows, Lee and Sitka have made it "open season" on PRR boxcars.  So to show that I can be nonsensical although I hope to provide  some fun here are a few down the years....

Here is the Lionel #800 PRR boxcar from 1915 - 1926

Lionel 800 Box side 2

Here is the Lionel #6454 PRR boxcar from 1949-1952 (quite a difference eh!)

Lionel 6454 PRR Box

Here is the Marx , PRR Merchandise Service boxcar from 1965...all of 6" long about the same length as the Lionel #800 from 1915...who says progress is always one dimensional .

Marx boxcar PRR

Well best wishes everyone.  Great pictures especially liked the discussion of the D16 loco, new information to me.  I also really liked the "for real" PRR box cars and merchandise service cars by Lee and Sitka.  CAPPilot - neat cars and I always like your discussion on the background / history from the real PRR.  Thanks all.

Have a great week everyone

Don

Don, Thank you for sharing this magic! Best, Willard

I found a car I wanted on Trainz web site and put it into the cart.  While in the site, I looked around and found three other cars that I ended up buying.  One was an Atlas 40' composite gondola.  I wasn't really looking for a gondola, but then I remembered I only had one PRR revenue gondola so I bought it.  Really nice looking car. Here is my total gondola fleet (not counting a MoW gon).

40' Composite gondola

DSC_0002DSC_0003

53' Gondola (Atlas Trainman)

DSC_0009

DSC_0010

Attachments

Images (4)
  • DSC_0009
  • DSC_0002
  • DSC_0003
  • DSC_0010
@CAPPilot posted:

I found a car I wanted on Trainz web site and put it into the cart.  While in the site, I looked around and found three other cars that I ended up buying.  One was an Atlas 40' composite gondola.  I wasn't really looking for a gondola, but then I remembered I only had one PRR revenue gondola so I bought it.  Really nice looking car. Here is my total gondola fleet (not counting a MoW gon).

40' Composite gondola

DSC_0002DSC_0003

53' Gondola (Atlas Trainman)

DSC_0009

DSC_0010

Nice looking cars Ron

Well its been awhile since I posted to this thread, but I thought I might have something to contribute today.  Here is my AMT BEEP in PRR livery doing a short caboose hop with a couple of classic Lionel Post War PRR freights.  Her train consists of the Lionel # 2758 Pennsylvania double door automobile car from 1945-46.  This was a "roll over" from an identical car in 1941-42 but with pre-war box couplers.   Another "roll over" is the Lionel # 2457 N5 caboose.  It came in tuscan brown vice red and with pre-war couplers in 1941-42 and was listed as the #2757

Lionel Caboose Hop - Beep gets clearLionel Caboose Hop1

Best wishes

Don

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Lionel Caboose Hop - Beep gets clear
  • Lionel Caboose Hop1
@ncdave posted: I’ve got the Weaver PRR B60b and the RPO with Clerestory roof....

Just want to clarify nomenclature for these cars.  While probably not a big deal for many modelers, I really think if you run Pennsy you need to know what you have.

Weaver called all their cars of this basic design a B60b.  There were actually two different baggage cars built by Weaver, but they just used the same box.  Reference the above images.

The B60, first built in 1906, had eight side panels and all were delivered with the clerestory roof.  The rectangular windows were replaced with round windows starting in the late 30s.  One source stated a few B60 cars may have gotten the round roof late in life, but I have not seen anything definite on that. (NOTE: The B60a was a B60 with end doors for automobile transport, and with a round roof.)

The B60b, first built in 1925, had 11 side panels and all were delivered with the round roof.  Nate's model is an as-built B60b with the rectangular windows.  Like the B60, these got round windows starting in the late 30s.

And while I have a couple of Weaver's RPOs with the clerestory roof that I run, the Pennsy never did have an RPO of this design.  I simulate Pennsy's BM70 with these cars when running my 18" passenger cars.

So:

Clerestory roof  with 8 panels - B60

Round roof with 11 panels - B60b

All delivered with rectangular windows.  Nearly all got round windows starting in late 30s.

ADDED: You can also get a B70 for your railroad.  GGD made a scale version, and Williams and MTH made almost full scale versions (less than a 1/2" short).  This is MTH's version.

DSC_0152

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSC_0152
Last edited by CAPPilot

I'll throw this out there, too... If you love the Pennsylvania Railroad and its remarkable history (including classic locomotives, other equipment, personnel, stations, etc.), I would highly recommend joining the PRR Technical & Historical Society. https://www.prrths.org/

There are great, thick and interesting issues every quarter of The Keystone. I've written several in the last few years including this cover story:

Front CoverR [002)

  Also, there is quarterly online magazine of The Keystone Modeler.

  I've belonged to several railroad historical societies over the years and the PRRT&HS's quarterly issue of The Keystone seems to cover the most wide ranging railroad topics...

  To join, go here: https://www.prrths.org/content...amp;module_id=451756

Tom

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Front CoverR (002)

GGD in my opinion did a creditable version of the BM70.    These came in sets of the B70, BM70 and PB70.    I think the PB70 is a bit too long because they used the same underframe as the P70 which includes 2 vestibules.    The PB70 should be about 3-4 scale feet shorter.   I don't remember measuring the B70 and BM70.    I guess I should do that just for grins and giggles.

American Standard did a kit for a good model of an M70 which I have.   It is a bit of a chore to assemble these kits but the result is worth it.   Unfortunately I have not seen this kit very often.

@PRR8976 posted:

I'll throw this out there, too... If you love the Pennsylvania Railroad and its remarkable history (including classic locomotives, other equipment, personnel, stations, etc.), I would highly recommend joining the PRR Technical & Historical Society. https://www.prrths.org/



Tom

@PRR8976

Tom:

I heartily second your endorsement. I have been a member of the PRRT&HS National Chapter since the early 1980's. My grandfather spent 42 years on the PRR and retired in 1953, so, being born in January of 1951, I have been a lover of the PRR for as long as I can remember.

I also want to add endorsements for the Philadelphia Chapter of the PRRT&HS as well as the Pennsylvania-Reading Seashore Lines Historical Society of which I am also a member of both.

@Sitka posted:

Thanks for the Post all, Show us some Turbines.

@Sitka

Your layout is beautiful with superb scenery. You have done well with the classic tubular track. Here is a suggestion for a final touch. Back before we used all Gar Graves track with wooden ties, we started with the same Lionel tubular track as have you. What my son and I did to enhace the tubular track was to add wooden ties between the exisitng 3 ties on each track section. I bought long strips of balsa wood that were about the same width and thickness as the Lionel metal ties. Cut pieces of the balsa the same length as the permanent track ties and stain the with a wood stain that was about the same color as the the metal Lionel ties. when they were dry we inserted them under the track to fill the larger gaps between the 3 premanent ties. From the size of your layout, yours will require many ties to fully complete this project, so, do it in sections so that you don't go nuts trying to cut and stain all of the ties at once. The result was great. Also, stain the ties after they have been cut to length rather than staining to entire strip prior to cutting. The ends of each tie will be visible and must have stain on them.

Thank You for the complement, always thought about ballast or adding some balsa wood, the problem I have now the train store had closed about 5 years ago and I can't locate any balsa wood, Hobby lobby don't have any in the area, on my other layout I did use Gargrave, Send a picture when you have a chance of your ties.

Thanks Again Mark

@Sitka

Your layout is beautiful with superb scenery. You have done well with the classic tubular track. Here is a suggestion for a final touch. Back before we used all Gar Graves track with wooden ties, we started with the same Lionel tubular track as have you. What my son and I did to enhace the tubular track was to add wooden ties between the exisitng 3 ties on each track section. I bought long strips of balsa wood that were about the same width and thickness as the Lionel metal ties. Cut pieces of the balsa the same length as the permanent track ties and stain the with a wood stain that was about the same color as the the metal Lionel ties. when they were dry we inserted them under the track to fill the larger gaps between the 3 premanent ties. From the size of your layout, yours will require many ties to fully complete this project, so, do it in sections so that you don't go nuts trying to cut and stain all of the ties at once. The result was great. Also, stain the ties after they have been cut to length rather than staining to entire strip prior to cutting. The ends of each tie will be visible and must have stain on them.

@Sitka posted:

Send a picture when you have a chance of your ties.

Thanks Again Mark

Mark:

The only photo of the wooden ties that I have is below. It is the section in the foreground just past the O-27 switch that is leading into a set of sidings. This is a very early itteration of our layout.

Several other thoughts for sources of wood are as follows. Some of Michaels Craft stores have displays of small pieces of balsa or basswood as carried by some hobby shops. Another thought is measure the space between the bottom bottom of your rail and the top of the platform. If my memory serves me correctly, that is a space of 1/4". If you have a table saw with a rip fence, you can cut strips equal to the width of one of the Lionel ties out of a small sheet of 1/4" Luan plywood sheet. Home Depot in our area sells small 2' x 2' sheets. Then use the length of a Lionel tie with one end of a Lionel tie against the blade, bring the the rip fence over to touch the other end of the giving you the length of a Lionel tie. You now can chop even sections off of the  2-foot long wood strips that you have just cut from the 2' x 2' sheet of plywood. You have now mass-produced wooden ties ready to be stained.

HPIM0016

Attachments

Images (1)
  • HPIM0016

Well PRR fans, I don't have too much to show for this thread but I can't resist posting my "BEEP" which I run quite a bit as it is very suited to my small tight layout.  So here she is:

Here she is showing off her PRR keystone.

Beep PA 3

Here she is hard at work ( this is on our summer place front porch layout).

Beep PA 2

Here she is on delivery day, foreman of engines looking over his new steed and comparing it to "old faithful" just behind.

PRR Switchers 1

Best wishes

Don

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Beep PA 3
  • Beep PA 2
  • PRR Switchers 1

@Sitka

Your layout is beautiful with superb scenery. You have done well with the classic tubular track. Here is a suggestion for a final touch. Back before we used all Gar Graves track with wooden ties, we started with the same Lionel tubular track as have you. What my son and I did to enhace the tubular track was to add wooden ties between the exisitng 3 ties on each track section. I bought long strips of balsa wood that were about the same width and thickness as the Lionel metal ties. Cut pieces of the balsa the same length as the permanent track ties and stain the with a wood stain that was about the same color as the the metal Lionel ties. when they were dry we inserted them under the track to fill the larger gaps between the 3 premanent ties. From the size of your layout, yours will require many ties to fully complete this project, so, do it in sections so that you don't go nuts trying to cut and stain all of the ties at once. The result was great. Also, stain the ties after they have been cut to length rather than staining to entire strip prior to cutting. The ends of each tie will be visible and must have stain on them.

Great pictures! Still have my Fathers 681 so I've always been partial to the PW turbines.

@jim sutter posted:

If I walk down stairs I can see (7) P.R.R. calendars.

@jim sutter

Jim:

Your layout and train room are GREAT!!!! However, every time I see your train room I all but kick myself. When I was very young in the 1950's, my maternal grandfather, a PRR retiree after 42 years of service, gave me a PRR calendar each year. I did not take care of them and they disappeared over the years. If I still had them in good condition, they would be really good in our finished basement with the trains.

I'm looking forward to June 11. I plan to run my PRR E6, no. 460 with only a Weaver B60 and Lionel Coach. Of course, you know why!

Edit: Research identifies a PRR B60b rather than a B60. I cut out the other mail express cars behind the PRR no. 460 Atlantic leaving the baggage car and coach. I took these stills along the route on a test run.

PXL_20220523_205322543PXL_20220523_205404883PXL_20220523_205557154.MP

Attachments

Images (3)
  • PXL_20220523_205322543
  • PXL_20220523_205404883
  • PXL_20220523_205557154.MP
Last edited by pennsynut

Anybody got a Congressional trainset running? I recently got a Williams GG-1 4866 in silver livery with their 4-car 60' semi-scale aluminum "Congressional" consist with dome observation (oops!) but don't have a big enough pike to run it yet. It would be fun to see others!

My time at PSU made me fall in love with the PRR! I rode the Amtrak Broadway during its last years to my parents' home in Chicago a couple of times. Wish I could have done that in the 1930's...

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×