Skip to main content

Does anyone own this engine? 20-3057-1

It's a beautiful piece and I've always kinda wanted one, but I don't know if it will fit on my layout.

The website claims a required curve of O-54. I have O-36. I know that sometimes the box has a different minimum curve than the website, and even then the engine will occasionally function completely fine on an even tighter curve. Since MTH skips O-36 and goes right down to O-31 on their tolerances, I'm wondering if there's any chance this engine will actually work on my layout.

If anyone has experience with this particular engine, I'd love to hear your input.

As a secondary question, this seems to be an engine in the early era of Proto-Sound 2. From what I've heard, those PS boards are not the best. Should I be concerned about that as well?

Thanks!

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Out of the 5(?) MTH u1F numbered locomotives has made over the years, I have managed to the 3 proto-sound 2.0 ones (6060, 6076, 6079).  Yet to acquire the 2 proto-sound 3.0 ones (6069, ????) for my collection so couldn't provide any info on hardware performance comparison... 

The locomotive is quite big and long actually and wouldn't risk it (again) on O-36 track.  Even had a derailment or two on O-72 fastrack (but I blame the track segment on that one!).

It is a very handsome and well running engine though, If you find one for a good price definitely go after it.  Part of me just wants to slowly build up a full set of 20 (with unique car consists) and renumber the remaining 15 to their prototypical numbering.... (but with MTH gone that's pretty much just a crazy and impossible dream)

@VonFrank posted:

Does anyone own this engine? 20-3057-1

It's a beautiful piece and I've always kinda wanted one, but I don't know if it will fit on my layout.

The website claims a required curve of O-54.  Since MTH skips O-36 and goes right down to O-31 on their tolerances, I'm wondering if there's any chance this engine will actually work on my layout.



From O-54, MTH track does go to O-42 before it goes down to O-31.

I run my Railking Triplex on O-31 instead of the recomended O-42 but I  had to rework the pilot truck and some things on the tender.     I run it carefully on my O-27 6 foot oval test track.

Aside from what GRJ says about the 5 volt board , I  would be concerned about the smaller diameter track mostly because of the large diameter rigid mount drive wheels .

It is a handsome unit though John M. 🙄

I appreciate the responses so far!

Seems like, realistically, this engine wont work on O-36. I kinda figured so, but hoped this might be one of those rare exceptions where the engine functions on smaller curves than you would expect... The curse of living in a condo: never enough room for trains.

I'm also not too keen on the idea of the PS-2 board potentially failing on me at some point in the near future. Especially since this engine would be a used purchase.

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by MTH Electric Trains

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×