What type of product are you referring to? In a locomotive, Proto 3 does not require a battery whereas Proto 2 does. In my opinion, it's best not to ever have to bother with replacing a battery. So I would recommend Proto 3. You could accomplish the same thing by installing a BCR in a Proto 2 setup - but why do it that way unless cost is a significant issue?

MELGAR

the ps 2  5 volt boards fail quite frequently but also some of there boards last a long time? ps2 3 volt were good boards and usually only suffer a amp ic when you get track shorts, but shorts can kill  any boards including ps 3. ps2 3 volt boards can generally be repaired, ps2 5 volt boards can not be repaired and ps3 board sometimes can be repaired! the difference between ps2 3 volt n ps 3 boards is ps2 3 volt boards can take a 2 meg sound file and ps 3 boards I believe can take up to  a 4 meg sound file.

certified MTH ASC tech and train repairs august 2019

repairs down to component level on all electronics

repair computers and reload windows 10 and windows 7

been in tv radio and all electronic repair since 1962

board repair also!

yes John but the ps2 3 volt boards  ready to run  sets only used the 1 meg memory file!

certified MTH ASC tech and train repairs august 2019

repairs down to component level on all electronics

repair computers and reload windows 10 and windows 7

been in tv radio and all electronic repair since 1962

board repair also!

PS-3 replaced obsolete tech in PS-2.  Just like PS-2 3V replaced the very early and first PS-2 5V boards.

Basically PS-3 gives more memory for sound files, more features, LED lights versus Bulbs, No battery, DCS and DCC capability, Ability to detect DCS on any rail when 2R-3R engine, and some other stuff on the tech side.

It is the last from MTH and what is supported the easiest.  G

MTH Authorized Service Center

Authorized ERR Dealer

Lionel Independent Repair Tech

Virginia Train Collectors Member

Add Reply

Likes (1)
Post
This forum is sponsored by MTH Electric Trains
OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
330-757-3020

www.ogaugerr.com
×
×
×
×
×