Pull out the MPC!

Unfortunately, i didnt have much to begin with so I sold most of it off last century when scale trains in 3 rail was growing by leaps and bounds.

Have always been partial of the FM train masters!

I was 12 when I bought the North Western when it came out.  Worked at a nursery to buy trains.

Love it! That's a GREAT lineup.

Stu

Those low-tech beauties won’t ever let you down!

JohnA

If more folks would be inclined to post some pictures, I could go dig up and unpack some more.

Here you go...all MPC except the LionChief Plus 2.0 Berkshire in the last photo.

Never had the red G.  The PC was our first and got the 4935 when it came out.  Had the Amtrak and cars for a while but sold them years ago.  Always wanted to take a mint series G and put the presidential cars behind it.

@HSD68 posted:

Had to move some boxes for a closet project so I pulled out some of the girls. Lets see yours.

I love MPC and while it gets shown no love lets face facts. Clean crisp graphics simple to run and easy to repair. Yes they are not scale but many of those big scale steamers will be dead when MPC keeps right on running. This Christmas I brought out my first MPC a PC GP9 that I converted over to simple TMCC. Simple smooth and it runs ! !

All of the engines in those pictures have been packed away for a long time.  The D&H  was converted to magnatraction tears ago.  It will pull anything but not as much as the FM.   I have a couple that I run but not having a layout we are stuck with running through the house on the floor from time to time.

Here's another photo for you HSD68. The B&O F3 on the left is a single motor F3 from MPC shown side by side with the "Neil Young" edition F3 from several years ago.

Despite the single motor, this MPC model is a robust puller and the original (and noisy) e-unit is still going strong. I've resisted the urge to upgrade my MPC's to more modern electronics even though I operate in a TMCC environment. There's something nostalgic about the original electronics, although maintaining those e-units is a challenge!

Here’s a recent acquisition that has wet my appetite for MPC. 1971 Illinois Central set.

I found the unpowered add on diesel, fun!

@franktrain posted:

Here’s a recent acquisition that has wet my appetite for MPC. 1971 Illinois Central set.

I found the unpowered add on diesel, fun!

Now that is a great looking MPC set!

How's it run?

here's my multi-unit head end power consist.

When I started buying my own trains, MPC was all the rage. They really did produce some great stuff!!!

A 783 Hudson:

A 785 Hudson:

A set of NYC & PRR 15” aluminum Passenger Cars:

As it happens, I was running my GP-9 around my test loop just yesterday.  It ran smooth as silk.  Much smoother than I remember.

Love all those D&H units.  The ones that I have were converted to magnatraction.  They still run like all of the  3 axle engines run, but will pull a LOT.  Like to run them with a piggyback train.

When I was a teenager, If you wanted a B&O coal train you had one choice, the 9110.  In the early 80's, you could find these at York for 2-5$.

Here is a few of them

@Sean007 posted:

Now that is a great looking MPC set!

How's it run?

Runs great! The 8254 unpowered unit was upgraded with a powered chassis by the previous owner so I can run with two motors.

I also picked up the 9200 IC boxcar that must have been changed out of the set for the 9301 mail car.

Here's a later issue1985 GP9 8587 the JC Penny Wabash special with prototype engine number 484 also with electronic horn.

Here's the first MPC catalog cover from 1970.

Have fun running and collecting your MPC they made some great trains.

Great thread. Can't kill 'em, easy to fix if you do, what's not to like.

I've considered upgrading some to ERR, at a minimum I may swap out the e-units for Dallee boards.

A lot of fond memories with MPC as me, my brothers and Dad had a lot of fun running and collecting these in the 1980’s.  Here are a few that I still run today among the DCS and TMCC/Legacy modern locos.  Solid runners, never an issue other than routine maintenance.

Forgot this BAR GEEP and matching caboose.

Look Ma... no Cab2 (just a handle on an old ZW transformer). An MPC set of NYC (what else ) F3’s pulling a consist of 15” aluminum passenger cars at “post war” speed!!!

Canada only,uncatalogued  OB with English /French inst.

Here are a couple of MPC repaints done 35 years ago.  They were N&W and PC junkers picked up real cheap. The WM short hood was cut off and sliced in half and a new windshield made.  Did some F's too.

Used to run a large, 3 track, 072 L shaped thing in my friends basement on the rug.  The MPC GP's and F's all run great together so you can run a couple on front and 2 or 3 as pushers on 80-90 car trains and have no problems.  Used to have small black rubber bands for any problem couplers.

I've only got a few engines with the fancy electronics (and I only run them conventionally), everything else is the dependable Postwar and MPC. I'm not set up for photos since I have a cheap flip phone and have trouble working it anyway - I'm a dinosaur!

I have a flip phone as well.  Just use a digital camera

Back during the 80's and 90's we always tried to have 500 different brand new MPC freight cars for people to pick from.

Here are a few of the piggyback cars.  Kind of like having your own store.

Here are a couple of the few I have from the early 80’s, when my daughter was younger. San Diego Zoo Car, and the Traveling Aquarium Car. Most of my stuff is earlier post war, or 90’s and later.

Some great 1970s and 1980s sets at Richard Kughn's Carail Museum.  Had a chance to see the museum at the 1993 and 2000 LCCA conventions.

Hi Jim Sutter

Do you still have any of that stuff from the store or is it all gone now?.

Jim, your train shop must have been amazing. Love the way you displayed the rolling stock. I’m an impulse buyer so being displayed like that would have been terrible for my wallet. Love the pictures.

I always enjoy seeing MPC stuff.  I wish I could get more into collecting and running it but I just don’t have the space to keep it all… I’d have to sell my HO off first!

HSD68, Sorry, every thing is gone. My wife and I had a good thirty year run. The only thing that's left are wonderful memories and I have a lot of them.

romiller49 Thank you Rod for that very nice comment.

@HSD68 posted:

Here are a few of the piggyback cars.  Kind of like having your own store.

Nice! I have the SP ones. Hard to beat MPC on a fun-per-dollar basis.

HDS68, I love your collection of MPC piggyback cars. Your Chicago Northwestern and your Illinois Central Gulf  where always tough to fine.

Well I have lot of MPC stuff as I only re-entered into the Lionel era after my sons were born in the early 70's.  So most of my new train buying was MPC.  In collecting I tend to go for the pre-war struff but I mostly run MPC...reliable, easy to fix, maintain.  Here is one I got just this Saturday at a train show in Plano, Tx.

Lionel MPC #8551 Santa Fe Alco  from 1973-75  This engine was only sold as a stand alone "A" unit.

Here is a little video with a short train, note IC boxcar is MPC as well.

Best Wishes

Don

Love mpc. Low cost and made in good old USA . Have a lot of mpc and post war. At 57 , my first trains were mpc and I still have them ! I will take some pics and post.

@jim sutter posted:

Mark Holmgren, I love your collection of MPC piggyback cars. Your Chicago Northwestern and your Illinois Central Gulf  where always tough to fine.

That belongs to HSD68! I was just saying I have the SP ones.

dogdoc and others...I have to say, despite many opinions to the contrary, that MPC remains,esp for the small operator, a fantastic buy.  I just left a train show in Plano Tx and as you can imaging there was lots of MPC for sale.  When you can get box cars (new in box) for $15-20, switcher locomotives also nearly new for $75 and I got a really neat chemical tank car ("White Pass") with die cast frame and fully sprung die cast trucks for $10.  I tell you that you can't touch these prices with the modern stuff.  OK its not as prototypical and it doesn't make noises or talk and yea you have to put up with the "e" unit but hey...these are hobby items.  Anyway I like this stuff because it makes for reasonable cost hobby fun.

Don

dogdoc - I'm with you. This post has me digging out my MPC stuff for a Sunday after Church run session.

Don't forget the colorful cabooses offered by MPC.

View from my desk.

This thread got me thinking... I knew I had this (a 6-18003 4-8-4... inherited from my mother from whom I got my love of trains!!!), but it hasn’t seen the light of day in over 30 years. And even at that, it has probably only seen, at most, 30 minutes on the tracks. So off I went digging and found it. According to the label on the end of the box, it has magne traction, the infamous electronic mighty sound of steam, and, long before modern times, “steam emissions from the steam chest” My understanding is that the DL&W referred to them as Poconos, not Northerns - and living in the Poconos for the last 25 years, it is so appropriate!!!

Apples55

run that engine! If I had one from my mom, it would be my treasured !

I don't know Pocono's or Northern's, but that is a beautiful engine.  The MPC era was fine for me, aside from the nefarious Sound of Steam.  Those were the years when we dusted off our post-war trains and rebuilt the train table.  My wife purchased FARR #3 (late 90's) and gave it to me for Christmas, it came with a Berkshire #3100 in dark green with Elephant Ears (?) and a nice set of cars.  Last year I picked up several other MPC engines because as others have said, the prices are good.  I found another  #3100 GN with box; a #6200 PRR Turbine (no box), a #8210 "Joshua Cowen" Hudson with box; and the #8006 "Silver Shadow" Atlantic Coast Line Hudson without a box.  What I like about these engines is that they are colorful, most are two-tone, have a touch of detail and run great.  You can't go wrong it if runs and the price is right.  Except for the silly noise.  So, the Northern is 4-8-4, and the Berk is 2-8-4, is that about right?

Hi Jim

Thanks.  There are doubles and triples of some of them.  I think I have a whole case of the NKP's.  The CP was a recent addition.  The ICG I think came out of the Rocky Mountain set.  There are a few cars I missed in the day that I have been looking for.  Right now, I am waiting on delivery of my first couple prewar large 800 series cars.

I think of all the cars, I have more boxcars and reefers than anything.  Going to take a big yard to hold all of those cars.  I also have painted a few cars over the years. 

Harold

@Apples55 posted:

This thread got me thinking... I knew I had this (a 6-18003 4-8-4... inherited from my mother from whom I got my love of trains!!!), but it hasn’t seen the light of day in over 30 years. And even at that, it has probably only seen, at most, 30 minutes on the tracks. So off I went digging and found it. According to the label on the end of the box, it has magne traction, the infamous electronic mighty sound of steam, and, long before modern times, “steam emissions from the steam chest” My understanding is that the DL&W referred to them as Poconos, not Northerns - and living in the Poconos for the last 25 years, it is so appropriate!!!

That's a beauty Paul, plus a great backstory. Clean it up and run it.

Bob

I have the Rock Island version of that engine.  A good clean and lube and make sure the board in the tender is not loose.  Not sure if they were still using the sticky foam at this time or not.

I blocked the steam chest emission on my engines.  All it ever did for the J and others was blow oil all over the sides.  Kept the rods lubricated.

Time to start collecting DL&W hopper cars.

Paul that's a beauty and one I haven't seen very often if at all.  I think it will fit right in on your layout.  I'm sure there's some Phoebe Snow passenger cars around your place somewhere looking for that engine.

That New York Central passenger train is running at just the right speed.  I've got no idea what mph it scales out at but in my mind it looks right for interurban passenger travel.

Let’s not forget about these…..The Trainmaster’s

Or the other end of the size spectrum….a few motorized units. Always fun to have running around the layout.

I could probably Google this and get some answers, but some of you folks who collect MPC would likely know the answers.

Is the MPC era from the early 1970s to the mid 1980s?

Is top of the line MPC very good, but most of it cheap plastic and not so good?

How does top of the line MPC compare in quality to top of the line post war from the early and mid 1950s?

What are some examples of top of the line MPC, and how much does it cost compared to top of the line post war?

Hi Paul

Here is the Rock Island version of your engine

Arnold...here are a few answers to your questions.  NOTE...some of your questions like "quality" etc depend on your point of view.  I am a simple operator.  Stop,Go, Reverse, lights, smoke, and reliable operation make "quality" to me.  If you are into extensive electronics, crew sounds, special steam effects you won't find them in MPC (after all it stops in 1985).

a.  MPC era...1970-1985

b. I don't agree.  Much of MPC especially the early versions is really later Lionel post war but with "fast angle" wheels that makes the pull load much lower.  Graphics all around are top notch, prototypical dimensions not so much.  Yes there is a lot of plastic but then there is a lot of great molded in detail and the plastic used (at least in my view) seems quite durable.  So, my view, like any product line you sort of get what you pay for.  Lionel in those days made some dc only very cheap trains (sort of follow on to the "Scout" idea) and they were not very good.  But their GP's, larger steamers, early diesels were quite good.

c. The answer to this is sort of "it depends"...remember Lionel in the 1950's was at the peak of its popularity and developed much of its best line...the 736 for example, dual motored F-3's, etc.  MPC took quite awhile to come up to speed and in the early days (say up to 1975) concentrated on the Lionel of the 1960's which was not the same.  I personally think the quest for what may go to quality is over rated.  The MPC I run on my small layout (which is about the same scale as yours) runs great, stops, goes, reverses and runs on and on.  I like the great graphics and the ability to run short trains (can't run long ones anyway).  So to me, that's high quality especially when compared to what I paid for most of it.

d. I really can't answer, MPC did make some really good steamers which are probably top of the line, but they are not my focus. I leave that to others.  I like the diesels, switchers, and freight and passenger cars.  The short passenger cars, equivalent to the Lionel 2400 type post war cars are really great and came in some neat color schemes.  The diesels and trainmasters were very good and came in a large number of liveries.  My humble opinion (ok so not so humble )is that the MPC line sort of matches the Lionel of the late 50's or early 60's except the choice of RR and liveries is much greater and the color schemes available are much better.

Well anyway Arnold, that is my opinion and I am sure you can find those on both parts of the question.  Its really a question of what you want to do and how much you can invest.  I have small level layout , and like to see trains run around.  I can't pull much more than 8 or so freight cars and maybe 5 passenger cars.  I have some "Lion Chief" type engines but that is about as far as I got with non transformer control and normally rely on my ZW.  I like the fancy steam sounds ... but made an inadvertent discovery recently...all those sound effects are in the tender!  So now my MPC steamers (and my Marx steamers) sometimes pull a modern Lionel tender and I get all the steam sounds I want!  I simply cannot invest in some $2000 for a new Lionel top of the line engine and I could not run it anyway. I do have (products of a more cash free youth) a MPC GS-4 and Hudson but they can't run on my layout anyway (radii too small).  I have the MPC Blue Comet that I think of as sort of top of the line and it will run on my layout and I like it but that's about as elaborate as it go.

Best wishes, by the way, I always enjoy your posts and I really liked the series you did on constructing the baseball park.

Don

@Arnold D. Cribari posted:

Is the MPC era from the early 1970s to the mid 1980s?

Is top of the line MPC very good, but most of it cheap plastic and not so good?

Arnold,

You have the date range pretty much correct:  about 1970 - 1986.

Now, I am going to talk about one of the "cheap" sets and show you why MPC detractors deserve nothing but low-quality, high sulpher coal in their stockings.

First, an over view of a set my grandfather gave me in 1972.  The first train he gave me was Marx (in 1965); this was my first Lionel. I was 8 years old.  It was leftover inventory from the previous year, so far as I can tell, a Double Diesel set,  repacked by either Sears or Lionel, without one of the cars and the B unit and a Wheaties boxcar substituted for a bigger boxcar.  If Grandpa got a box, I never saw it.

(Sorry about the picture quality:  my camera hates looking into a bright light, and I can't extinguish the sun.)

Now, let's look at the engine, a run-of-the-mill 8020 Santa Fe Alco, dime-a-dozen.  This engine has I-have-no-idea how many 100s of hours on it.  The brushes have been replaced once.  Once, when I tossed it into my toybox (yes, I was a kid, and it was a toy), the rear (metal) coupler broke off.  A quick trip to the Service Center (remember when MPC actually maintained the Postwar service Center network, which is more than we can say for today's Lionel) set that problem to rights.  I also had to buy a replacement horn.  There are scratches on the paint and decals, and the luster of the silver suffers from dust.  But this engine runs Every. single. time. I put power to it, and it can haul quite a bit more than its own train.  I cannot say as much for ANY of my TMCC or Legacy engines.

Next, the first car (this train ALWAYS runs in this order simply because this was the order Grandpa set it up ion the first time I saw it).

The 9140 Burlington Gondola is derived from the bigger of the PW gons and has a sharp green paint scheme.  One coupler is a dummy, but the trucks have metal wheels.

The next two cars.

The 9040 Wheaties boxcar is derived from the Scout boxcar and has no working coupler, but it does have metal wheels.  Its paint scheme was General Mills tooting its own horn a bit, but it is certainly colorful!

The PC 9300 Log Dump Car still has its original three logs.  The mechanism works just fine and has survived unbroken.  It has 2 working couplers and metal wheels.  Because of the stripped-down nature of the set, I never had the activating track and had to dump the car manually.  I do still have the plastic tray into which the logs rolled.

The last two:

Knowledgeable collectors' eyes will see that the GN 9011 hopper is a rare car.  About 3 billion of them were made in sky blue, but this much darker, brighter, Royal blue is genuinely rare on this car.  Roland Lavoie labels it "Very rare" and notes a $120 (EXC)/$265 (MNT) value (p 243 of the 1970-1991 Motive Power and Rolling Stock guide).  It is by far the "cheapest" car, with one dummy/one working couplers and plastic wheels.

Finally, the 9061 Santa Fe caboose; again, one of many, many.  I really admired the car when I was a kid because it had end railings and ladders.  It has only one coupler (though it it works).

None of these cars has ever needed any repair.  The wheels--even the plastic ones--are the fast-angle profile, a significant contribution MPC made to the model RRing world.  It came with a blue 4150, 50-watt transformer and a figure eight of track.

Yes, it was cheap.  Some plastic wheels, plastic gears on the engine, 2- position e-unit, many dummy couplers, derived from the near-bottom of the PW line. Only one car sparks any interest among collectors.  The others are literally common as dirt.

But "not so good"?  Oh, my friend:  this set is very, VERY good!   It has given me untold hours of enjoyment, taken all the abuse I have thrown at it nearly without complaint, and it retains most of its vibrant colorfulness and all of its functionality.  No postwar set would have given me any more fun or joy.  No modern (Digital Era) set would have been remotely as trouble-free and reliable.

MPC deserves a much better reputation than PW snobs and later-era electronic junkies have given it.   Long Live MPC!

palallin :  YEA!  I am with you.  See my answers to Arnold, just before your post.  I think that we may have to recall that this a "hobby" which means many things to many different users and that for "hobby" /  TOY trains  MPC is a great supplier at what is today very modest cost.  I can take my $75 MPC GP9 and run it till the brushes disappear  then put it on the shelf and buy another.  I can do this 20 X for the price of one modern Lionel $2000 top of the line diesel. Given that I am 77 and that my current GP9 has been running fine for nearly 50 years, doing this 20X is unlikely to happen. As I posted above, my 8351 Santa Fe Alco A which a the similar vintage as yours, which I just purchased for $40,  runs great 47 years  after manufacture and still pulls my little trains around my simple layout.

Don

Running a store for thirty years means I have a lot of great MPC memories. I also have a lot of great Weaver and MTH memories. At one time I ate this stuff, drank this stuff and slept with it. Trains were my life. I loved it.

Don and Pallalin, I very much enjoyed reading your replies. You both make a great case for MPC, and you educated me about its virtues: economy, reliability, durability, fast angle wheels, good quality plastic, good graphics, etc.

Since I prefer the Lionel Postwar of the early and mid 1950s to the Lionel of the late 1950s and early to mid 1960s, MPC (which has much in common with the later post war), is not that attractive to me. I like the dual motors, metal and heft of the earlier Lionel postwar.

I love the moderately priced modern Lionel including LC+, LC+2.0), MTH Railking PS 1, 2 and 3) including DCS, and some Williams and K Line.

However, I keep a lid on the modern technology because too much technology makes me anxious. For instance, I limit my DCS operations to speed control, horn/whistle, bell, smoke and elecrocoupling, running my MTH PS 2 and 3 like they were LC+ locomotives.

Arnold

One more thing: I try to keep costs under control by purchasing early postwar that is in good working order, not mint, and limit my pricey modern to just a few.

For instance, I have no Visionline and only 1 Legacy. My Legacy is a $750 NY Central 10 wheeler with whistle steam, which is the perfect locomotive for my layout that has features in common with The Put.

I have no plans for purchasing any more Legacy.

Would I love a Visionline steamer that has steam/smoke coming out of every crevice and runs well on 031 curves? Absolutely. But, if I ever get one, it will be my 1 and only Visionline to keep costs under control.

Arnold

Arnold, you are the perfect reason this hobby appeals to many.  There is room "at the inn" for many guests with many preferences.  Thanks for responding and please continue to post on your layout and projects I always enjoy reading them.

Best wishes

Don

Well, this thread has been a wonderful trip down memory lane!!! Thanks for all the kind comments on my Pocono steamer. In keeping with this Forum’s tradition of been full of bad influencers, after clearing a ton of heavy, wet snow earlier, I felt obliged to open up the tender for a look-see (not an easy choice for an admitted Techno-peasant!!!). Fortunately, I found that the sound board was supported by a plastic base, so no problem with disintegrated foam. As a consequence, tomorrow, I will (may the Train Powers-That-Be forgive this unforgivable transgression) disconnect Legacy from my layout (Mea Culpa... Mea Culpa... Mea Maxima Culpa...), and give the Pocono a run through the Poconos!!! Film at 11

I have to agree with those who think that MPC has gotten a bad rap. In my opinion, part of the issue is that we are looking at those golden oldies through the prism of current trains. For those of you who, like me, remember when MPC was the rage, I think you will have to agree that, when they came out, they were really the bees knees (did I just say that???). Remember the vast improvement that the much maligned Electronic Sound of Steam was over the post-way “sounds”??? Were there clunkers amongst the gems??? Of course - but you have to admit, somethings never change!!! I admit that I have been totally taken in by the lure of the new, more detailed, scale offerings, but that doesn’t mean that that I completely reject the trains of my youth. While I have gifted a number of my MPC engines to other who have the need for items which will run on small curves, I still have a number of them that have sentimental value (my first GG1, the Pocono, two sets of F3’s with aluminum passenger cars, etc.). Long live History

I seem to remember a problem with the DL&W and its sister Rock Island Loco. The problem had to do with the motor armature shaft bushings. These were delivered out of tolerance. If I remember correctly this motor is essentially the same as the post war 736 motor. When MPC Lionel re-manufactured the motor they updated it motor with out of spec bushings. I believe replacing these bushings with the original postwar 736 spare part bushings solves the problem. There may be others on the forum that have a better memory on this issue than I. If so, please comment.

Denis

Hi Paul

Glad to hear that someone is going to unplug the electronics  and take over the ship.  The modern control systems are great but there is nothing like being in front of a couple Z's and KW's trying to keep everything moving and under control.  Once the engines make a few rounds and warm up,  everything starts to run good.

I always noticed that the  Pullmore's run better after they are warmed up.  Only have one can motor in the first WM shay and it's never been run.

Harold

@Bob Paris posted:

Beautiful train room and collection. The lighted cabinets are a nice touch.

Bob

Hi Bob

Is that Railrax shelving?.

Yes, it is RailRax

Bob Paris, your train room looks great. Nice work. I love your cabinets.

So far this is my only MPC era engine, the FARR Southern 4501. I had the IHC model as a kid in HO and after moving to O had been hunting for one of these for awhile till it showed up on my 21st birthday. Only other car I have from the set aside from the tender is the caboose, which I intend to repaint to resemble an actual Southern bay window that's parked outside a school near where I live. I do have all 5 of the MPC era Crescent Limited passenger cars though, which make an excellent pairing with 4501. The wreath was just for the holiday show at the Greenhouse.

@joe krasko posted:

Canada only,uncatalogued  OB with English /French inst.

I think those CN units came out about thevdame time as the Daylight SP's.  The SP's had EMD road BB trucks.

Lionel should have made CN SUPERCONTINENTAL and SP DAYLIGHT 2400 sized passenger cars for these.

A blue and yellow VIA Alco Diesel and 2400 set would sell.

And D&H 2400's with those Alco's would be nice.  Odd, because at the time, D&H was running a passenger train for Amtrak with a PA and D&H cars.  Not scale, but would make a nice O27 set.

The 8025 CN Alco is an uncataloged item from 1971. It actually appears in the 1972 Canadian catalog. In 1976 the three piece CN Alco A-B-A set was offered, item numbers 8656, 8657 and 8658.

@ed h posted:

The 8025 CN Alco is an uncataloged item from 1971. It actually appears in the 1972 Canadian catalog. In 1976 the three piece CN Alco A-B-A set was offered, item numbers 8656, 8657 and 8658.

right you are Ed...

My favorite MPC...it took me forever to find the B unit.

John

Palallin - Your 1972 set may be Sears set 1292, as it had just an Alco A unit powered. The rest of the rolling stock matches closely to your set. Keep in mind in the early days of MPC is wasn't uncommon for Lionel to swap out a piece of rolling stock with a different road name. I've attached the 1972 Sears catalog info.

Could be wrong...usually am...My understanding was that the car swapping occurred at the point of sale to accommodate customer whims. LHS's were loath to let a customer walk over rolling stock quibbles. That's why you sometimes have wonky sets.

John

@Don McErlean posted:

dogdoc and others...I have to say, despite many opinions to the contrary, that MPC remains,esp for the small operator, a fantastic buy.  I just left a train show in Plano Tx and as you can imaging there was lots of MPC for sale.  When you can get box cars (new in box) for $15-20, switcher locomotives also nearly new for $75 and I got a really neat chemical tank car ("White Pass") with die cast frame and fully sprung die cast trucks for $10.  I tell you that you can't touch these prices with the modern stuff.  OK its not as prototypical and it doesn't make noises or talk and yea you have to put up with the "e" unit but hey...these are hobby items.  Anyway I like this stuff because it makes for reasonable cost hobby fun.

Don

Agree completely with your assessment. One correction: the White Pass tank cars were cataloged in 2013, a long time after the end of the MPC period, but the mold is the same. Like many of these from the MPC period, this is an 8,000 gallon tank car. A lot of folks don't realize it, but - although they seem compact, they're actually scale in size.

@ed h posted:

Palallin - Your 1972 set may be Sears set 1292, as it had just an Alco A unit powered. The rest of the rolling stock matches closely to your set. Keep in mind in the early days of MPC is wasn't uncommon for Lionel to swap out a piece of rolling stock with a different road name. I've attached the 1972 Sears catalog info.

Interesting!  Thank you for that image, Ed!  I have never been able to find a copy of that year's catalog.  This may indeed be the right one.  Never had any canisters or the uncoupler.  Wish I had the box!

I have seen about a dozen boxed variations of the Double Diesel and the Twin Diesel sets from that early-'70s period.  Obviously, all were made up out of the same limited selection of rolling stock.  Smart use of limited assets to create the highest level of variety possible.

@John Meyncke posted:

Could be wrong...usually am...My understanding was that the car swapping occurred at the point of sale to accommodate customer whims. LHS's were loath to let a customer walk over rolling stock quibbles. That's why you sometimes have wonky sets.

John

I have seen the leftover pickings after store clerks and customers sort through the stock to get what the customers want, and I have no doubt that, sometimes, the leftovers really are slim pickings.

Related:  went to the same Sears store with my grandparents in 1976 in late December to select my train for that year (ended up being my grandfather's last Christmas, and I think he knew it).  Anyway, on the shelves were a few odd cars, some individual track pieces, and a pair of Santa Fe 8351s (I will swear that one of them had a front coupler, but that story is for another day); slim pickings, indeed.  I told Grandpa I would be very happy with the 8351s, but he insisted that I get a full set.  We ended up at JC Pennys with a TYCO Chattanooga Choo-choo.  I will forever be grateful to him for getting me into trains, but I sometimes grouse about the detour into HO interfered with playing with real trains

@Palallin,  I went through the same deal at Blair's Toys in San Bernardino where I grew up.  Dealer "accomodations" were the S.O.P. at that time. I appreciate your recollections about your Grandfather. By mentioning them, they endure.

John

@John Meyncke posted:

Could be wrong...usually am...My understanding was that the car swapping occurred at the point of sale to accommodate customer whims. LHS's were loath to let a customer walk over rolling stock quibbles. That's why you sometimes have wonky sets.

John

Yes, this car swapping certainly may have happened at the point of sale. But certainly in the early days of MPC it went on right at the factory.  There have been documented brand new early MPC sets found where a piece of two of rolling stock was substituted. For example a gondola shown in the set illustration or catalog photo, may have a different gondola substituted.

@palallin posted:

Interesting!  Thank you for that image, Ed!  I have never been able to find a copy of that year's catalog.  This may indeed be the right one.  Never had any canisters or the uncoupler.  Wish I had the box!

I have seen about a dozen boxed variations of the Double Diesel and the Twin Diesel sets from that early-'70s period.  Obviously, all were made up out of the same limited selection of rolling stock.  Smart use of limited assets to create the highest level of variety possible.

Here is a link for the 1972 Sears Christmas Wishbook, lots of other Christmas Wishbooks are on the same website. See page 531.

https://christmas.musetechnica...Sears-Christmas-Book

Two photos I found of set 1292 and the box.  The set box is a generic style which was used for other uncataloged sets in the same time frame.

Thank you very much again, Ed!

Yes, I have seen that box used for all sorts of sets with different configurations of generic, individual foam protectors.  The link and the pics go a long way toward helping me!

breezinup...Right you are!  That White Pass Tank car of mine was too late to be MPC.  Thanks to Jerry Williams, who gave me the information, I located it in a Lionel catalog and now know it was part of a 3 car "add on" set to the White Pass basic set...Neat to know that it really is close to scale...I got a kick out of the lettering..."kerosene service only"... lot a lamps to fill I guess.  Still its a really great car for $10 (P.S. as a life long engineer I am genetically CHEAP!).

ed h:  Thanks for posting the Sears set picture.  I just got that 1972 MPC Santa Fe Alco A at our first train show in nearly 2 years.  I will look in my compendium of Sears toy offerings to see if I can find the set to get a grip on the rolling stock that came with it.

Bob Paris: That may be the most beautiful train room I have ever seen.  Now I am embarrassed with my pile of old Lionel boxes under the layout!  Beautiful job!

Best wishes to all

Don

I am slightly embarrassed to say that 60% of my trains are MPC.   10% MTH PS-1,  15% postwar (nearly all accessories or engines) and 15% LTI.   For me the high end MPC engines and cars have been fabulous performers.  The vivid, sharp graphics and colors are a joy.  I can easily pull 30 or more non die cast cars.  No worries about engine electronics failures, power spikes,, resets or ground planes.  I love the smell of ozone,, smoke pellets, the engine noise and the clickety clack track noise.

It's  definitely not the ultimate in toy trains, but it is for me. 

I would not be embarrassed to say that 60% of your trains are MPC. You collect what you like and what makes you happy.  I started this thread to see some MPC and to get people talking and sharing their stories which has been nice.

Most folks who look down on MPC are probably not going to read a topic called Pull out your MPC.

@HSD68 posted:

I would not be embarrassed to say that 60% of your trains are MPC. You collect what you like and what makes you happy.  I started this thread to see some MPC and to get people talking and sharing their stories which has been nice.

Most folks who look down on MPC are probably not going to read a topic called Pull out your MPC.

Don't worry, you're among friends. One of the longest and most enthusiastic threads (full of great pictures) ever posted here was about MPC trains.  This was probably 6-7 years ago. It reappears every now and then.

Now I need to go get out some of my MPC.

@aussteve posted:

I am slightly embarrassed to say that 60% of my trains are MPC.   10% MTH PS-1,  15% postwar (nearly all accessories or engines) and 15% LTI.   For me the high end MPC engines and cars have been fabulous performers.  The vivid, sharp graphics and colors are a joy.  I can easily pull 30 or more non die cast cars.  No worries about engine electronics failures, power spikes,, resets or ground planes.  I love the smell of ozone,, smoke pellets, the engine noise and the clickety clack track noise.

It's  definitely not the ultimate in toy trains, but it is for me.

There is nothing wrong with MPC, and don't be embarrassed. I am a big fan of MTH and Postwar Lionel and I still buy select MPC stuff I like. I am working on collecting the 9700 Series of cars now and recently picked up 2 MPC Locomotives and 1 Non Powered MPC Locomotive.

MPC made some great engines. Yes, they did make some crap but so did the Lionel Corp. And don't forget the steamers with real RR markings, not just Lionel Lines. Tons of colorful boxcars. I would welcome them back, And fast-angle wheels.

@John Meyncke posted:

My favorite MPC...it took me forever to find the B unit.

John

I just picked this up 2 weeks ago from a very very small local shop. Walked in and said this is talking to me and brought it home. I found the B unit at Grzyboski Trains (my 3 hour away LHS).

Bill, Good for you! I've always liked this NH scheme. My B unit search was a multi step process as well. I got the AA set from Charles Siegal mail order years ago when he was still in Pennsylvania. Shipped to me in Southern California.

The B unit, shell only, came from Train World on a blow out sale. I think the shipping was more than the shell even years ago when they used to run multi page ads.

The elusive B unit frame came about years later when I realized the Williams' Golden Memories B unit frame is an exact fit for MPC shells. I think I got that mail order from Train World on blowout as well. I gave the shell it came with ( oddball road name) to a friend and the frame fit my project perfectly.

Like I said, it's one of my favorite sets. Smooth running, crazy sounding horn, great paint scheme.

John

One of my favorite sets from 1980, the Chessie System Royal Limited.  Very colorful locomotive, the first re-release of the Radioactive Waste car, a crane car and also a JLC boxcar.  These sets today can be found in new condition right around their original 1980 price ($175 - $200).

@ed h posted:

One of my favorite sets from 1980, the Chessie System Royal Limited.  Very colorful locomotive, the first re-release of the Radioactive Waste car, a crane car and also a JLC boxcar.  These sets today can be found in new condition right around their original 1980 price ($175 - $200).

Mine, too. Bought the set sealed in the box about 10 years ago. I think this one and the Quaker City Set are my favorites of those "limited edition" sets.

Hard to believe the earliest MPC pieces are now 50 years old. . . Time flies.  

Modern Lionel has features that those of us growing up in the 70s and 80s could only dream about, but nothing beats Postwar and MPC in my book.  After a day of battling ‘smart’ everything just to start a car, call someone or watch TV, it’s nice to go downstairs, move one throttle and it all just works.  

Lots of great other sets from the mid 1970s to early 1980s. 

I remember back when the limited edition sets, service station sets, FARR sets, and many of the engines were hot items.  Some were up around 1000.00.  Most were still sealed.  And the 15 inch pass sets, NYC, IC, N&W, SP, UP, PRR and the smaller Chessie, Blue Comet, Wabash, Southern etc.  The SP pass set was usually well over 2000.00.  The GG1s, SP steam, Wabash FM, N&W steam, and other FMs also had high prices along with certain cars.  The Lifesavers tank car and CNW Hopper car were over 125.00 and the 5712 LL lines reefer was 200.00 to 300.00.  They were great pieces just overpriced for a time.

I think the high end MPC and LTI pieces were the best "Lionel scale" pieces ever issued.  And ultimately the prices came back to earth.

In the mid 70’s, TrainWorld opened a store on Ave. M, a couple of blocks from where I was living in Brooklyn - right next to the subway station I used every weekday. While not an enormous store, they had shelves on all the walls that went nearly from counter height to the ceiling lined with colorful MPC and other trains. They were the first dealer I knew who did [a lot of] “set breakups”. Since I was paying my own college tuition at the time, I didn’t have a lot of money for trains, so I couldn’t afford whole sets, but I could usually get one or two nice cars from a set. I think I have one car from each of the FARR sets.

I also picked up two of the BN boxcars from the first unit train I ever remember seeing from Lionel.

The boxcars were Std. O and appeared so much larger than the 6464 sized cars I was used to up until then... I think this was the beginning of my decent into scale madness

@ed h posted:

Lots of great other sets from the mid 1970s to early 1980s.

I have the Maple Leaf Limited... I’ve always liked the CP paint scheme. And the British Columbia is also very striking.

My "proof of concept" for a display railroad I built in the 1980's:

Rusty

I wonder about that depressed center car with the transformer that came with the Mid-Atlantic Set. It must be one of the longest pieces of rolling stock Lionel ever made. Or maybe the longest?  I have that set but it's packed away. Should get the car out and measure it.

@johnstrains posted:

I wonder about that depressed center car with the transformer that came with the Mid-Atlantic Set. It must be one of the longest pieces of rolling stock Lionel ever made. Or maybe the longest?  I have that set but it's packed away. Should get the car out and measure it.

Regarding MPC, there were two different cars that had four trucks.  A xfmr car and a bridge girder car.   Both of those cars are still usually pricey today.   Other than passenger cars,  I can't think of any car that had more distance between the trucks.  And nothing with more trucks.  The fast angle wheels were a huge innovation in the MPC era, especially on these cars and pass cars.

@joe krasko posted:

right you are Ed...

Stand corrected.  But the 60's CN noodle livery, especially on cab units, have survived the test of time.

On Sears sets, there could have been swaps for their sets.

The paint job on the Chessie diesel out of the Royal limited set is unbelievable. My favorite MPC tank car is the British Columbia from the Maple Leaf set. My favorite MPC caboose is the New York Central bay window from the New York Central Empire Express set. Also, from the Empire Express set is my favorite box car the Great Northern. Except for the electronics and the remote control features, these sets are far nicer than the sets they are making today.

Hello All:

Here is the MPC portion of my overall collection to date. I'm always looking to add to the roster constantly.  Quite a few items I purchased from fellow forum members.

Michael

A few more top of the line sets, these are all from mid 1970s. Looking closely at the Chessie U36B, the engine shell appears to be a mockup, especially the top of rear radiator.

@Tommy_F posted:

After a day of battling ‘smart’ everything just to start a car, call someone or watch TV, it’s nice to go downstairs, move one throttle and it all just works.  

MPC was Lionel when I returned from Germany in the mid-70s.  That was back when Mike Wolf was a simple retailer of Lionel before he established a competing brand.  Ordering from the price lists when they were first released, I ensured that MPC became and remains a stalwart part of today's O Gauge Paha Sapa Lines RR in eastern Wyoming.  An almost complete collection of 9200, 9700, and 9400 series boxcars provide most of the wall decor in the train room.

Wow, Bill, that layout is impressive.

Nice collections, all!

As to the four truck depressed center flats with transformers or bridge girders, they were first made in the mid-fifties post war era.

Here is the B&O set and cars.  Lets see the other two.

I wish I could show my MPC. I have just about the entire collection of all the top of the line sets, service station sets, limited editions,  engines, cars, JC Penny items, variations etc and about 30 sealed 6-8190 Diesel B unit horn kits :-)....Unfortunately it is currently in a warehouse storage until my fiancé and I build a new house with a big basement for me....I would love to get another updated MPC guide out someday

Did somebody @ZWPOWER13 say JC Penny? Here are two uncataloged engines.

@Rich Wiemann posted:

Did somebody @ZWPOWER13 say JC Penny? Here are two uncataloged engines.

I have two of those SD18’s- one with the case and one without.  Thought the first one had a bad power truck and got a good price on the second… fixed the truck and now keep one on display while I run the other lol.

ZWpower13, make sure that when you get your new train room, you start a post and show some pictures.

@mlavender480 posted:

I have two of those SD18’s- one with the case and one without.  Thought the first one had a bad power truck and got a good price on the second… fixed the truck and now keep one on display while I run the other lol.

Picked up the pair of used Santa Fe SD-18s for $15 a few yrs ago because the pwr truck was stripped.   Found a NOS pwr truck for $30 at York.   I had a set MOB but was afraid to run them.  The trucks were non repairable (basically) with the side frames swedged on.  I had been told the worm gear was plastic.  So I never ran them to avoid stripping the gear out.   When I bought the NOS truck at York for $30 it had a metal worm gear and I thought it was a later production piece.  I got home to repair the $15 unit and found it had a metal truck also. The armature was not bolted into the motor making it seemed to be stripped.  I looked at my brand new unrun Sd-18 and it had a metal gear also.  So I had not run the SD18’s in fear of stripping out a plastic gear that turned out to be metal after all.  I like the 6 wheel trucks.  MPC 6 wheel cranes also look good to me.

@HSD68 posted:

ZWpower13, make sure that when you get your new train room, you start a post and show some pictures.

Absolutely!

Here's the depressed center transformer car that I mentioned above from the Mid-Atlantic Set.

16 inches from coupler to coupler. Easily one of the longest pieces of rolling stock Lionel ever made.

aussteve  You said,"I am slightly embarrassed to say that 60% of my trains are MPC."

It is my understanding that "MPC" stands for "My Personal Collection" - so the only question I have is,"Who owns the other 40%?"

  I will always view MPC trains as being something special because when I returned from the service shortly after a Thanksgiving a long time ago and went over to the local hobby shop it was MPC trains that welcomed me back from exile.  The dealer had a number of sets and various cars and engines for sale.  I was interested in the Milwaukee Road Heavyweights but I didn't care for the engine that came with the set.  The dealer said no problem - pulled the cars out of one set box - and asked me what my pleasure would be with respect to head end power.  I chose the #8206 Hudson and that train was the first thing I ran after assembling a layout on the rec room floor.

I received this MPC set for my birthday in April 1980:

Long live MPC!

I love my MPC-era rolling stock, but have replaced my MPC engines with LionChief Plus or LionChief Plus 2.0 engines.  Love the speed control and improved sounds and lighting with the new LionChief Plus engines.  LionChief Plus engines running with MPC-era rolling stock is my happy place. 

Here's my MPC Milwaukee Road passenger cars running with a LionChief Plus Milwaukee Road Hudson:

This is about 1/3 of my MPC Stuff, poor photo but the shelfs are 24 feet long and the Southern and Blue Comet set both have the add on Diner Lionel brought out over 20 years ago and the Milwaukee Road set also has the Diner, FDR Car and all the add on and coupon cars. That little locomotive can't even think about pulling all of the cars. The 9700 Series cars are on the other side of the wall and most of the Motive Power is in a display under glass. Nothing wrong with MPC it is some great stuff and very well done.

@johnstrains posted:

I wonder about that depressed center car with the transformer that came with the Mid-Atlantic Set. It must be one of the longest pieces of rolling stock Lionel ever made. Or maybe the longest?  I have that set but it's packed away. Should get the car out and measure it.

@johnstrains posted:

Here's the depressed center transformer car that I mentioned above from the Mid-Atlantic Set.

16 inches from coupler to coupler. Easily one of the longest pieces of rolling stock Lionel ever made.

Here's one I have on display, with a custom load I fixed for it. Yup, 16 inches long coupler end to coupler end; body is 14 7/8 inches. Great cars. It should be mentioned that these are all diecast metal! I added some decals to letter it for Union Pacific, and also painted the deck ends with a textured paint to give those more of an appearance of wood.

If I remember correctly, I believe a lot of those cars came with broken insulators. Lionel also made this car with two plastic girders. The car came with blue rubber bands. A lot of the rubber bands came dry rotted. Both of these cars were also made back in the fifties.

Lionel MPC era RDC cars.

I have a lot of MPC and just about everything they made with New York Central inscribed on it.  This is the set that lured me back into the Lionel Train hobby at the ripe old age of 24 in 1977. Still warms my heart to look at this set.

@jim sutter posted:

If I remember correctly, I believe a lot of those cars came with broken insulators. Lionel also made this car with two plastic girders. The car came with blue rubber bands. A lot of the rubber bands came dry rotted. Both of these cars were also made back in the fifties.

I had several of those plastic transformers, but the insulators were ok. The transformers were easily available. The no. 6509 was a grey depressed-center flatcar with two tuscan colored bridge girders. I think the rubber bands were just to hold the girders in place in the box during shipping.

@johnstrains posted:

Here's the depressed center transformer car that I mentioned above from the Mid-Atlantic Set.

16 inches from coupler to coupler. Easily one of the longest pieces of rolling stock Lionel ever made.

Not only is it long, its quite heavy with a diecast frame and 4 diecast trucks.  I remember having the 8770 EMD NW-2 switcher from the 1977 Cargo King set and with the transformer car and just one or two other pieces of rolling stock the 8770 had a tough time getting the train moving.

@franktrain posted:

Here’s a recent acquisition that has wet my appetite for MPC. 1971 Illinois Central set.

Boy, does this bring back memories!  My first Lionel train set was the 1972 incarnation of the Cross Country Express.  In addition to the IC GP9 and caboose, it had a Southern boxcar, B&O silver double door boxcar, a brown N&W hopper, L&N flat with bulldozer and scraper kits and Shell tank car.  I got it for Christmas that year.  It turned out to be a "Family Gift".  When I opened the box on Christmas morning there was only the locomotive, caboose, Southern boxcar, N&W hopper and Shell tank car, along with an oval of track and the transformer.  My grandparents (on both sides), aunts and uncles proceeded to give me the remaining components later in the day at various Christmas parties.

I still have the train set, but the locomotive power truck failed several years ago.  i just haven't taken the initiative to get it fixed.  The transformer is in use on my current layout as an accessory power supply.

I sure had a lot of fun with the MPC stuff!

Tom

@NYC Fan posted:

I have a lot of MPC and just about everything they made with New York Central inscribed on it.  This is the set that lured me back into the Lionel Train hobby at the ripe old age of 24 in 1977. Still warms my heart to look at this set.

That was a hot set back in the day, with some very desirable cars, particularly the colorful Great Northern boxcar, the Southern Big John hopper, the chrome Pennzoil tank car, and the NYC "Road to the Future" bay window. I remember there was a lot of discussion back then about the "P & E" annotation on the caboose, and what division of the NYC that represented.

@ed h posted:

A few more top of the line sets, these are all from mid 1970s. Looking closely at the Chessie U36B, the engine shell appears to be a mockup, especially the top of rear radiator.

I fell in love with the 8470 Chessie U36B locomotive when I saw it in the catalog.  I had to have one, so I asked my parents for it for Christmas.  I was told that it was only available in the set and they could not afford to get me another set.  I resigned myself to the fact that I wouldn't own this engine.

A couple of weeks before Christmas my father asked me to get something out of the trunk of the car for him.  Being we kept the car in our attached garage, the keys were always left in the ignition.  When I went out to the car the keys weren't there.  Puzzled, I reached under the seat thinking they might have fallen on the floor.  My hand ran into a box under the seat.  Lo and behold, there was the Chessie U36B locomotive.  After admiring it for several minutes I carefully put it back where I found it and spent the next weeks playing dumb.  I acted surprised on Christmas morning when I opened the package.

I still have this locomotive and it still runs like new.

Tom

@RJT posted:

This is about 1/3 of my MPC Stuff, poor photo but the shelfs are 24 feet long and the Southern and Blue Comet set both have the add on Diner Lionel brought out over 20 years ago and the Milwaukee Road set also has the Diner, FDR Car and all the add on and coupon cars.

If you want to complete that Milwaukee set, you may want to check out the no. 52402, a special issue ice car reefer put out by the Lionel Milwaukee Railroad Club a number of years ago. It's meant to go with the MPC era Milwaukee passenger cars, and matches the colors. Pretty hard to find, although Grzyboski's has one listed for sale right now. Kind of fun that this car was issued, long after the MPC cars were made. I have these Milwaukee cars running behind a MPC era no. 8558 MIlwaukee EP-5, which is a perfect color match, and the set looks like the shot below.

I put the Milwaukee EP-5 shell on a PWC (Post War Celebration) series EP-5 chassis (was a New Haven EP-5) (very easy to do), which gives it TMCC, RailSounds, directional constant lighting, electrocouplers, and crew figures. I'm a big fan of PWC, and besides the EP-5, have also converted some MPC F3s and Geeps with PWC chassis'.

@John Meyncke posted:

My favorite MPC...it took me forever to find the B unit.

John

I got this locomotive set when a local hobby shop was going out of business.  They had the AA set at MSRP and I wasn't going to pay that much for a locomotive that I didn't find particularly attractive.  I went into the shop several times to buy rolling stock during the going out of business sale and eyed the set every time I was in there. It was starting to grow on me. One day several weeks later my brother came home and told me that they had just announced that everything was 75% off.  We jumped in his truck and made a bee-line for the shop.  I walked in and grabbed the locomotive set.  As I was walking toward the counter a gentleman walked in the door and stopped in his tracks as he saw me holding the F3's.  He dropped his head and turned around, walking back out the door.  As I was leaving, another gentleman saw me in the parking lot and approached me, inquiring if I was interested in selling the engines.  Needless to say, I turned him down.  It turned out I made a good decision as these units had dual motors and were extremely good pullers.  I found a B unit at Trainworld to complete the set.

Tom

breezinup,

The tank car in the N.Y.C. Empire Express Set was a chrome Sunoco Tank Car not Pennzoil. Also back then the chrome on the Sunoco tank car got funny looking.

Take away the electronics and remote control features the sets that Lionel is making today are not as nice as these.

@jim sutter posted:

breezinup,

The tank car in the N.Y.C. Empire Express Set was a chrome Sunoco Tank Car not Pennzoil. Also back then the chrome on the Sunoco tank car got funny looking.

Take away the electronics and remote control features The sets that Lionel is making today are not as nice as these.

Right, Jim, it was the Sunoco tank car. I completely agree that the MPC sets are unsurpassed by what's made today.

The annual Limited boxed sets, including the Milwaukee Road, Chessie Royal Ltd., Southern Pacific, Great Northern Rocky Mountain, Reading Quaker City, CP Maple Leaf, among them, were all extremely nice, with very attractive colors and variety of cars. The FARR (Famous American Railroads) series was also great, including the Great Northern, UP, Santa Fe, Pennsy, and Southern. A number of those had Berkshires for engines, built the same as the highly-regarded Postwar variety. Better, in fact, because of their interesting prototypical paint schemes.

Acquiring some of these sets, or even just the cars and running them behind a LionChief engine, if command control and cruise is desired, would yield a lot of railroading enjoyment.

@breezinup posted:

Right, Jim, it was the Sunoco tank car. I completely agree that the MPC sets are unsurpassed by what's made today.

The annual Limited boxed sets, including the Milwaukee Road, Chessie Royal Ltd., Southern Pacific, Great Northern Rocky Mountain, Reading Quaker City, CP Maple Leaf, among them, were all extremely nice, with very attractive colors and variety of cars. The FARR (Famous American Railroads) series was also great, including the Great Northern, UP, Santa Fe, Pennsy, and Southern. A number of those had Berkshires for engines, built the same as the highly-regarded Postwar variety. Better, in fact, because of their interesting prototypical paint schemes.

Acquiring some of these sets, or even just the cars and running them behind a LionChief engine, if command control and cruise is desired, would yield a lot of railroading enjoyment.

Since I have the Royal Limited set, I picked up the LionChief Chessie U36B from set 82324 for a very attractive price and can run it with the Royal Limited cars.  Kind of like having a retro set with modern features.

I will offer up a bit of a counterpoint to the love being shown MPC in this thread.  Make no mistake, I have my share of MPC and some of it is pretty nice, but that wasn't always so.  My first train set was the Black River Freight, which I got for Christmas in about 1977.  That set was sold at a garage sale a couple of years later, but nostalgia directed me to buy a new one a couple of years ago.  This set was brand new, never opened.  See pics.

Upon opening the set, you see you got a lot of cool stuff.  You got a steam engine with the bbs rattling around in it to simulate the sound of a locomotive, a freight consist, a cardboard mountain, train station, and tunnel, a set of trestles, telephone poles, signs, LCL load for the gondola, and stakes for the flatcar.  All pretty cool!

However, it wouldn't (and won't now) stay on the track.  The hopper car is okay, but the others are essentially massless and are easily string-lined off the track.  The locomotive is similarly too light and easily derailed.  Most of the couplers are fixed, and the hopper has a single electrocoupler, the only one in the set.  

When I was a kid, I didn't get much enjoyment out of the set.  My dad's postwar stuff stayed on the track and had nifty operating features mine did not.  

Now that I have the set as an adult, I'm torn between leaving it as-is and running it only rarely for a few minutes at a time, or adding weight to the cars and putting a light and interior in the caboose.  If I modify it, it's just not the same. I'm just torn what to do.

My modern stuff is better in every way, but this old MPC set isn't without its charm.  So, when you look back at MPC, don't let yourself get too swept away in the nostalgia.  In some ways, the MPC-era's poor reputation is well-earned.

@Mark Holmgren 110217 posted:

I will offer up a bit of a counterpoint to the love being shown MPC in this thread.  Make no mistake, I have my share of MPC and some of it is pretty nice, but that wasn't always so.  My first train set was the Black River Freight, which I got for Christmas in about 1977.  That set was sold at a garage sale a couple of years later, but nostalgia directed me to buy a new one a couple of years ago.  This set was brand new, never opened.  See pics.

Upon opening the set, you see you got a lot of cool stuff.  You got a steam engine with the bbs rattling around in it to simulate the sound of a locomotive, a freight consist, a cardboard mountain, train station, and tunnel, a set of trestles, telephone poles, signs, LCL load for the gondola, and stakes for the flatcar.  All pretty cool!

However, it wouldn't (and won't now) stay on the track.  The hopper car is okay, but the others are essentially massless and are easily string-lined off the track.  The locomotive is similarly too light and easily derailed.  Most of the couplers are fixed, and the hopper has a single electrocoupler, the only one in the set.  

When I was a kid, I didn't get much enjoyment out of the set.  My dad's postwar stuff stayed on the track and had nifty operating features mine did not.  

Now that I have the set as an adult, I'm torn between leaving it as-is and running it only rarely for a few minutes at a time, or adding weight to the cars and putting a light and interior in the caboose.  If I modify it, it's just not the same. I'm just torn what to do.

My modern stuff is better in every way, but this old MPC set isn't without its charm.  So, when you look back at MPC, don't let yourself get too swept away in the nostalgia.  In some ways, the MPC-era's poor reputation is well-earned.

I assume the cars have plastic wheelsets?  I had some of the low end cars like this and I switched the wheelsets to metal ones.  Made a big difference in the tracking of the cars. 

Tom

@Mark Holmgren 110217 posted:

I will offer up a bit of a counterpoint to the love being shown MPC in this thread.  Make no mistake, I have my share of MPC and some of it is pretty nice, but that wasn't always so.  My first train set was the Black River Freight, which I got for Christmas in about 1977.  That set was sold at a garage sale a couple of years later, but nostalgia directed me to buy a new one a couple of years ago.  This set was brand new, never opened.  See pics.

Upon opening the set, you see you got a lot of cool stuff.  You got a steam engine with the bbs rattling around in it to simulate the sound of a locomotive, a freight consist, a cardboard mountain, train station, and tunnel, a set of trestles, telephone poles, signs, LCL load for the gondola, and stakes for the flatcar.  All pretty cool!

However, it wouldn't (and won't now) stay on the track.  The hopper car is okay, but the others are essentially massless and are easily string-lined off the track.  The locomotive is similarly too light and easily derailed.  Most of the couplers are fixed, and the hopper has a single electrocoupler, the only one in the set.  

When I was a kid, I didn't get much enjoyment out of the set.  My dad's postwar stuff stayed on the track and had nifty operating features mine did not.  

Now that I have the set as an adult, I'm torn between leaving it as-is and running it only rarely for a few minutes at a time, or adding weight to the cars and putting a light and interior in the caboose.  If I modify it, it's just not the same. I'm just torn what to do.

My modern stuff is better in every way, but this old MPC set isn't without its charm.  So, when you look back at MPC, don't let yourself get too swept away in the nostalgia.  In some ways, the MPC-era's poor reputation is well-earned.

@Tom Densel posted:

I assume the cars have plastic wheelsets?  I had some of the low end cars like this and I switched the wheelsets to metal ones.  Made a big difference in the tracking of the cars.

Tom

This Black River Freight set was a very inexpensive basic 0-27 starter set. Even the steam engine is made of plastic, not heavy diecast metal like most Lionel engines. That is a big reason it doesn't track very well. The cars are small and very light, with fixed couplers - as basic as you can get.  It was really made for small children as a starter set, so you shouldn't expect a lot out of it. The majority of MPC sets that have been discussed here are in a completely different league.

Tom Thank You for that information I just ordered it. To think for all these years I thought I had the complete set.

I've had a crescent limited set for a while and the SOS in the tender was shot. I just added a pickup to the tender and installed a railsound package. I'll have to get the matching cars out for a video.

@ed h posted:

Since I have the Royal Limited set, I picked up the LionChief Chessie U36B from set 82324 for a very attractive price and can run it with the Royal Limited cars.  Kind of like having a retro set with modern features.

I considered getting a LionChief Plus D&H RS3 to run with my Coastal Freight set.  Those LTI service station sets seemed to have nice cars with die cast trucks etc, but cheaper starter-set locomotives.  I wonder why?

@RJT posted:

Tom Thank You for that information I just ordered it. To think for all these years I thought I had the complete set.

Glad you got it. Interesting that Grysboski happened to have one when this topic came up. They don't show up very often. They sold out pretty quickly when they came out a number of years ago, I recall. I run it as a head-end car as an express reefer.