Skip to main content

Hello everyone trainfam here,



About 5 months ago, I purchased a early Lionel 29 day coach or 3 trolley. from “the bay”. The car has obviously been restored at some point and the trucks have either been replated or are most likely Jimmy Cohen repros. Anyhow, I’m not sure if the cars body is actually a original Lionel piece, or a reproduction. There are not tags or forms of identification to tell me wether or not it’s a Jimmy Cohen piece or a pridelines. From what I’ve seen all Cohens have a tag identifying them as such. And all pridelines are embossed with the pridelines name. Sounds like a original, right? Well here’s the catch. There is no “LIONEL MFG CO. NY” embossing on the bottom of the car. Strange. In my greensburg guide book, it notes that in 1907, Lionel did produce a number 3 trolley that did NOT have a floor embossing. Maybe I have that trolley, but the trucks have been swapped? If anyone has any ideas on what I have please let me know in this forum. Here are some photos:

5D517AB8-D366-458B-A820-38ADC72DA95F

7E0DE7DB-8083-4348-BE8E-8B5D7AAFD6CF

09755D3C-2135-4606-A0AD-B98920C9143C

12497519-DF0F-432E-8E47-402E8536A15A

85AFC57B-1A65-4B74-9B27-32FD393B414C



                                                Trainfam

Attachments

Images (5)
  • 5D517AB8-D366-458B-A820-38ADC72DA95F
  • 7E0DE7DB-8083-4348-BE8E-8B5D7AAFD6CF
  • 09755D3C-2135-4606-A0AD-B98920C9143C
  • 12497519-DF0F-432E-8E47-402E8536A15A
  • 85AFC57B-1A65-4B74-9B27-32FD393B414C
Last edited by TrainFam
Original Post

Here’s something else I’ve just noticed,

The windows on my car are embossed around the cut outs. The variations of the number 3 and 4 trolleys that don’t have “LIONEL MFG. CO. NY” embossed on the bottom of the car do NOT have embossed windows and simply have cut out windows. The plot thickens….



                                                  Trainfam

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×