Skip to main content

TrainMan1225 posted:
NotInWI posted:

I don’t know if the 4014 will ever get East of the Mississippi, but I would sure like to see it without having to go that far west.  

Ben

If that thing came to Chicago, game over.

Well,  FWIW 3985 made it to Chicago back in the 90's. Maybe its possible?  

Hotwater, any clearance issues for the bigboy IF it ever came to Chicago?

Hot Water posted:
Tranz4mr posted:

Who will be the second engineer?

A better question is who will fire the 2 engines?

A better question is who will fire the 2 engines?

Apparently he overlooked his buddy Ted.

 

 It looks like Ted Schulte is the other engineer.

Who will fire? Austen, a retiree, someone else currently working with UP steam, an outside person

Last edited by Tranz4mr

1 Trans New May 15 2019

Trains Magazine:  Associate Editor Brian Schmidt and Digital Editor Steve Sweeney.  Talk about the come back of the Big Boy 4014 and they will be in Cheyenne along with others from Trains Magazine to cover the Big Boy on May 4, following a 9:30 a.m. MT christening ceremony at the historic Cheyenne Depot and arrive in Ogden for the May 9 celebratory event culminating in the Big Boy joining with The Living Legend No. 844.

Source: Trains Magazine News Wire, March 15, 2019

To watch the video click this link:

http://trn.trains.com/photos-v...e-video-for-march-15

Note: Trains Magazine & The Union Pacific Railroad have posted the come back of the 4014 with AP, Associated Press.

Gary: Rail-fan

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 1 Trans New May 15 2019
Chuck Sartor posted:

I have heard some bad news regarding to trip. Before posting I want to be sure it is not just rumor, but not thinking so.  Sorry for being so vague. Maybe one of the other guys, (Kent, Gary) can give more info.

1A March 15, 2019 UP Steam Shop

HI fellow member Chuck Sartor

Above is the latest official photo from the Union Pacific Steam Shop posted March 15, 2019. On the Union Pacific Steam Club Page by: an employe of the Union Pacific Railroad.

There is an old saying in journalism: “If your mother tells you she ‘Loves You’, then find three sources to back up this statement before going to press.”

If you would like to name your source on this thread or e-mail me the name of your source, I would look into your question.

Take care • Hope this helps • Gary: Rail-fan

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 1A March 15, 2019 UP Steam Shop
Last edited by trainroomgary
Hot Water posted:
Tranz4mr posted:

UP 4014 Cab - right side March 2019

So,,,,they are going all the way to Ogden, Utah and back without ANY insulation or jacketing on the whole backhead? 

Or, as you very well know. They are sorting all of the backhead pipes, valves, gauges, etc.. before just guessing in where to drill holes in the jacketing. 

People listen to you Hotwater. While you are very much in your right to have animosity towards the current administration of UP Steam management. I cannot help to wonder why are you just trolling? It’s beneath your well earned place in the steam community.

eldodroptop posted:
Hot Water posted:
Tranz4mr posted:

UP 4014 Cab - right side March 2019

So,,,,they are going all the way to Ogden, Utah and back without ANY insulation or jacketing on the whole backhead? 

Or, as you very well know. They are sorting all of the backhead pipes, valves, gauges, etc.. before just guessing in where to drill holes in the jacketing. 

With that statement, I'll have to assume that you have not been involved in a steam locomotive major overhaul or restoration. Look carefully at that photo, and you will see that virtually everything has been reinstalled, even the fancy wood flooring. Now, given the short time remaining, there is no way that all that stuff that has already been installed, will be removed for insulation and jacketing application.

 

Hot Water posted:
eldodroptop posted:
Hot Water posted:
Tranz4mr posted:

UP 4014 Cab - right side March 2019

So,,,,they are going all the way to Ogden, Utah and back without ANY insulation or jacketing on the whole backhead? 

Or, as you very well know. They are sorting all of the backhead pipes, valves, gauges, etc.. before just guessing in where to drill holes in the jacketing. 

With that statement, I'll have to assume that you have not been involved in a steam locomotive major overhaul or restoration. Look carefully at that photo, and you will see that virtually everything has been reinstalled, even the fancy wood flooring. Now, given the short time remaining, there is no way that all that stuff that has already been installed, will be removed for insulation and jacketing application.

 

Bull.

That is exactly how it’s done when you are making major changes to the back head “plumbing” and further, you have zero reference material (Old jacketing). Assemble EVERYTHING, get it right, make templates, then work the new jacketing. It’s a process that is not exclusive to rebuilding steam, sir.

eldodroptop posted:

Bull.

That is exactly how it’s done when you are making major changes to the back head “plumbing” and further, you have zero reference material (Old jacketing). Assemble EVERYTHING, get it right, make templates, then work the new jacketing. It’s a process that is not exclusive to rebuilding steam, sir.

Well, I for one can't imagine installing lagging and jacketing with all that hardware already applied. Unless the jacketing will be made up of hundreds of little puzzle-pieces that will need to be placed around and under the plumbing.  How will the lagging be installed?

That is going to be one HOT cab!

smd4 posted:
eldodroptop posted:

Bull.

That is exactly how it’s done when you are making major changes to the back head “plumbing” and further, you have zero reference material (Old jacketing). Assemble EVERYTHING, get it right, make templates, then work the new jacketing. It’s a process that is not exclusive to rebuilding steam, sir.

Well, I for one can't imagine installing lagging and jacketing with all that hardware already applied. Unless the jacketing will be made up of hundreds of little puzzle-pieces that will need to be placed around and under the plumbing.  How will the lagging be installed?

That is going to be one HOT cab!

That’s just it, you don’t apply all that jacketing with EVERYTHING already installed. You assemble everything, make templates, work the new sheetmetal, dissemble the backhead “stuff” as needed for final assembly, then do final installation of the insulation and finished jacketing. It is the right way to do the job, and it is indeed as it sounds.. Frustrating and time consuming.

eldodroptop posted:
smd4 posted:
eldodroptop posted:

Bull.

That is exactly how it’s done when you are making major changes to the back head “plumbing” and further, you have zero reference material (Old jacketing). Assemble EVERYTHING, get it right, make templates, then work the new jacketing. It’s a process that is not exclusive to rebuilding steam, sir.

Well, I for one can't imagine installing lagging and jacketing with all that hardware already applied. Unless the jacketing will be made up of hundreds of little puzzle-pieces that will need to be placed around and under the plumbing.  How will the lagging be installed?

That is going to be one HOT cab!

That’s just it, you don’t apply all that jacketing with EVERYTHING already installed. You assemble everything, make templates, work the new sheetmetal, dissemble the backhead “stuff” as needed for final assembly, then do final installation of the insulation and finished jacketing. It is the right way to do the job, and it is indeed as it sounds.. Frustrating and time consuming.

Just because I don't know, what is your experience in the steam community?

eldodroptop posted:
smd4 posted:
eldodroptop posted:

Bull.

That is exactly how it’s done when you are making major changes to the back head “plumbing” and further, you have zero reference material (Old jacketing). Assemble EVERYTHING, get it right, make templates, then work the new jacketing. It’s a process that is not exclusive to rebuilding steam, sir.

Well, I for one can't imagine installing lagging and jacketing with all that hardware already applied. Unless the jacketing will be made up of hundreds of little puzzle-pieces that will need to be placed around and under the plumbing.  How will the lagging be installed?

That is going to be one HOT cab!

That’s just it, you don’t apply all that jacketing with EVERYTHING already installed. You assemble everything, make templates, work the new sheetmetal, dissemble the backhead “stuff” as needed for final assembly, then do final installation of the insulation and finished jacketing. It is the right way to do the job, and it is indeed as it sounds.. Frustrating and time consuming.

How do you accurately lay a piece of sheet metal over an installed valve handle that sticks out four inches from the backhead, and know where to drill the hole? Far easier to make templates with everything removed. Notice there are air lines installed. Why did they need to be installed before the jacket?

I think I agree with Hot Water that nit appears from your statement that you don't have much experience in steam locomotive restoration.

Last edited by smd4
TexasSP posted:
eldodroptop posted:
smd4 posted:
eldodroptop posted:

Bull.

That is exactly how it’s done when you are making major changes to the back head “plumbing” and further, you have zero reference material (Old jacketing). Assemble EVERYTHING, get it right, make templates, then work the new jacketing. It’s a process that is not exclusive to rebuilding steam, sir.

Well, I for one can't imagine installing lagging and jacketing with all that hardware already applied. Unless the jacketing will be made up of hundreds of little puzzle-pieces that will need to be placed around and under the plumbing.  How will the lagging be installed?

That is going to be one HOT cab!

That’s just it, you don’t apply all that jacketing with EVERYTHING already installed. You assemble everything, make templates, work the new sheetmetal, dissemble the backhead “stuff” as needed for final assembly, then do final installation of the insulation and finished jacketing. It is the right way to do the job, and it is indeed as it sounds.. Frustrating and time consuming.

Just because I don't know, what is your experience in the steam community?

I saw a Steam Locomotive once? Hehehehe!!

But this is not about restoration of a Steam Locomotive, this is common fabrication. It’s not a lost art, nor is it witchcraft. 

 

smd4 posted:
eldodroptop posted:
smd4 posted:
eldodroptop posted:

Bull.

That is exactly how it’s done when you are making major changes to the back head “plumbing” and further, you have zero reference material (Old jacketing). Assemble EVERYTHING, get it right, make templates, then work the new jacketing. It’s a process that is not exclusive to rebuilding steam, sir.

Well, I for one can't imagine installing lagging and jacketing with all that hardware already applied. Unless the jacketing will be made up of hundreds of little puzzle-pieces that will need to be placed around and under the plumbing.  How will the lagging be installed?

That is going to be one HOT cab!

That’s just it, you don’t apply all that jacketing with EVERYTHING already installed. You assemble everything, make templates, work the new sheetmetal, dissemble the backhead “stuff” as needed for final assembly, then do final installation of the insulation and finished jacketing. It is the right way to do the job, and it is indeed as it sounds.. Frustrating and time consuming.

How do you accurately lay a piece of sheet metal over an installed valve handle that sticks out four inches from the backhead, and know where to drill the hole? Far easier to make templates with everything removed. Notice there are air lines installed. Why did they need to be installed before the jacket?

I think I agree with Hot Water that nit appears from your statement that you don't have much experience in steam locomotive restoration.

For what its worth I've seen paper templates used multiple times before for making backhead jacketing. They are later laid out and fit to the actual sheet metal for fitting so perhaps that is what he is referring to. 

smd4 posted:
eldodroptop posted:
smd4 posted:
eldodroptop posted:

Bull.

That is exactly how it’s done when you are making major changes to the back head “plumbing” and further, you have zero reference material (Old jacketing). Assemble EVERYTHING, get it right, make templates, then work the new jacketing. It’s a process that is not exclusive to rebuilding steam, sir.

Well, I for one can't imagine installing lagging and jacketing with all that hardware already applied. Unless the jacketing will be made up of hundreds of little puzzle-pieces that will need to be placed around and under the plumbing.  How will the lagging be installed?

That is going to be one HOT cab!

That’s just it, you don’t apply all that jacketing with EVERYTHING already installed. You assemble everything, make templates, work the new sheetmetal, dissemble the backhead “stuff” as needed for final assembly, then do final installation of the insulation and finished jacketing. It is the right way to do the job, and it is indeed as it sounds.. Frustrating and time consuming.

How do you accurately lay a piece of sheet metal over an installed valve handle that sticks out four inches from the backhead, and know where to drill the hole? Far easier to make templates with everything removed. Notice there are air lines installed. Why did they need to be installed before the jacket?

I think I agree with Hot Water that nit appears from your statement that you don't have much experience in steam locomotive restoration.

The templates are not made of sheetmetal. The templates are made from (in my experience) cardboard, or construction paper, or newspaper, or most anything you prefer to get the job done. 

Assemble everything, make a “paper” template of the exact size and hole spacing you need, trace the template to the finish material, then work that material, paint, remove valves or anything needed for reassembly, then reassembly and finishing. 

Be it any type of fabricating work, the motto of measure twice, cut once holds true.

AmeenTrainGuy posted:

So how many people are actually certified to run the BigBoy?

Give me any younger, experienced, FRA "certified" Engineer, male or female, that REALLY knows & understands train handling and their assigned district, plus the rules, and within an hour he/she could be taught how to run 4014, or any other large steam locomotive.  That said, the current manager has stated more than once, that he is the ONLY "steam certified Engineer on the UP system".

You know guys...I am getting very tired of getting tons of alerts to these kinds of threads.  The personal comments are getting old.  Sometimes I wonder why we even have a "real trains" forum since our magazine is focused more on the enjoyment of the hobby.  The arguments, know-it-alls, and just plain uninformed discussion sets a pretty poor example.  Clean it up and that goes for the "experts"....surely I don't have to start naming names. 

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×