Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Consider, if you will, these two Bing Swift Reefers:

Reefer #1

Bing_Car_Reefer_Swift

...and Reefer #2

Bing_Car_Reefer_Steel_Door_Swift

 At first glance, other than the roof color and the fact the #2 is a bit glossier than #1, there doesn't seem to be much difference.  However, notice the doors.  Reefer #1 has lithographed wood doors whereas Reefer #2 doesn't.  Indeed, the lithography for the doors on #2 gives the impression of steel doors ...and there is more.

  If we take a closer look at the doors we see the reporting marks and the numerical ID do not match the #7300 of the Swift car.

Steel_Bing_Door

so.... if we rummage through the photo files we find the following:

Bing_Pabst_Door_ID

  The doors on the Swift reefer are actually the doors for the Bing Pabst reefer sans the litho treatment for wood sided doors.  Note the MRTCO designation on the door of the Pabst reefer and the matching M.R.T.X identifier in the bottom corner of the Pabst reefer which indicates these doors belong with the Pabst reefer.  So what happened?  At this late date it is anyone's guess.  Whatever the reason, I rather like the look of the "steel" doors on the second Swift reefer it reminds me of the re-built wood reefers that were a part of everyday life on the real railroads back in the first third of the 20th Century.

Attachments

Images (4)
  • Bing_Car_Reefer_Swift
  • Bing_Car_Reefer_Steel_Door_Swift
  • Steel_Bing_Door
  • Bing_Pabst_Door_ID

The Hornby Gods were a little kind to me so for Christmas I have some new treasures coming

An early No.00 or M1(?) loco and tender from around 1923-6 This was one of the cheapest loco's and unusually does not have the fixed key with it being a short shaft version   .. Cheap Cute and Survived

Hornby was a little confused in marketing/labelling these trains they started life as "The Hornby Clockwork Train" in 1920 then as the Model No.0 then as the cheaper set was made the Model No.00 , then copped description in some circles as the (M1) ,then with the George the Fifth versions arrived they were renamed the M-Series No.3 ( M3) and again cos we werent confused enough, Mr Hornby in 1928 allocated the M3  to an entirely different bodied edition LOL!

As part of the deal I also got a spare locomotive and three more tenders ( of differing numbers/sets, M1 M3)

This loco as you can see DOES have the fixed key clockwork movement and I think that makes the top photo locomotive a first run of the series still having the unit from the original Hornby Clockwork Train , the top locomotive is also nut and bolt construction indicating its early

 

Last edited by Fatman
Fatman posted:

The Hornby Gods were a little kind to me so for Christmas I have some new treasures coming

An early No.00 or M1(?) loco and tender from around 1923-6 This was one of the cheapest loco's and unusually does not have the fixed key with it being a short shaft version   .. Cheap Cute and Survived

Hornby was a little confused in marketing/labelling these trains they started life as "The Hornby Clockwork Train" in 1920 then as the Model No.0 then as the cheaper set was made the Model No.00 , then copped description in some circles as the (M1) ,then with the George the Fifth versions arrived they were renamed the M-Series No.3 ( M3) and again cos we werent confused enough, Mr Hornby in 1928 allocated the M3  to an entirely different bodied edition LOL!

As part of the deal I also got a spare locomotive and three more tenders ( of differing numbers/sets, M1 M3)

This loco as you can see DOES have the fixed key clockwork movement and I think that makes the top photo locomotive a first run of the series still having the unit from the original Hornby Clockwork Train , the top locomotive is also nut and bolt construction indicating its early

 

Fatman, where to start. Well, the loco in the top picture is an M1, the M3 was a different loco and it appears to have had the mech changed, going by the wheels. These locos were always slot and tab construction too.

 

And you appear to have confused about 4 different locos in your 3rd paragraph! ๐Ÿ˜Š  "The Hornby Clockwork Train" was the original Hornby set in 1920, nut and bolt construction, and became the No1 loco and tender in 1921. The other train introduced in 1920 was the tinprinted train, sold as such without the Hornby name. It became the No 00 around1925. This later became the M3, and was replaced when they ran out of bits around 1928, with the very rare version of the M3, which was a No 0 loco without buffers of company lettering.

Complicated, isn't it?! ๐Ÿ˜Š

Cheers, Mark

 

Fixed the headlight.  She is really running great.  This engine sat on a shelf for 4-5 years because I thought it didnโ€™t run and I didnโ€™t run any trains for 3 due to a health issue.  Really glad this set came together.  Thanks for the help.  Just gave her a โ€˜spit shineโ€™ and she is lookin extra sporty now.  

Enjoy your weekend!       W1

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 94A981C8-E700-4754-8902-43ADDB4E3895
Videos (1)
E1D83CE6-35A3-4103-BF23-A5A18435BE1F
Last edited by William 1

got a few items this week but have not taken photos of them yet. They were a #103 red Joyline loco and short red tender (looks like a repaint) and a Joyline 5-car set headed by a #104 bullet nose with headlight.

I also got this Chad Valley Ubilda loco (sans box)

17841 ubilda no box

and a Lionel 1688E missing one side rail and its front truck. Already have a front truck on order to install. The truck cost me more than the loco. 

1688

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 1688
  • 17841 ubilda no box

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×