Skip to main content

Don't you all laugh but last night I handled my first Train Master at my train club meeting.  I am sorry to say I think I may need one.  This one  is a Lionel in CNJ livery.  Are they considered scale locomotives?   Seems like almost all the manufacturers have offered Train Masters at one time so is there one which stands out.  It will need to run on O31 (which my quick perusal says they do) and run with conventional power.  Some sound would be desirable.  I did a search on "Train Master" in OGR  to see others comments and it seems like the MTH and K-line are well thought of.  Any thoughts?  Recommendations?

Last edited by Jeff Noll
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

All the FM Train Masters offered in 3RO are done to 1:48 dimensions - even the Lionel PW version.

To my knowledge, here is the 3RO Train Master scoop:

There are 2 standards to these 3RO items: the Lionel PW and the Williams and MTH copies of the Lionel PW version - these are essentially "models of a model". They are OK, but also continue the crudeness of the PW version's construction and tooling.

MTH and K-line/K-Lionel have also offered a much better model from new tooling. These are the ones to get, though they cost more.  If you only need one, get a nice one. These will run in conventional or their respective versions of command control.

Last edited by D500

The K-Line H24-66 in my opinion is the nicest one done in plastic O.  I got my conventional one for $100.00 which is what it originally cost through the K-Line Club.  It originally was going to be for a two-rail conversion and maybe someday I'll still do that.  The TMCC versions are harder to find.  The MTH is nicely done as well.  I also have a Williams and while the detail is not as crisp, it is a great runner.

H24-66s ran past my house way before I was born carrying commuters on the CNJ.  Love the two stripe green version.   

All very cool engines!  I do like FM Train Masters.  I even have a couple.

So the first is on old Williams that I bought from a good Forum member.  It needs a little work, because a bit of lubricant leaked out onto the traction tires, so it slips.  I haven't cleaned it up yet, because I haven't looked into the correct traction tires to get.

2017-02-12 17.53.212016-11-23 18.38.12

Now I just got this one recently from another good Forum member.  It is a Legacy N&W; really cool.  I am most familiar with DCS, but have a TMCC controller I bought from another member.  I haven't gotten the sound to work reliably, but I am just learning TMCC, and don't know what to expect with this Legacy.  It runs great though!

2017-07-01 19.41.30

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 2017-02-12 17.53.21
  • 2016-11-23 18.38.12
  • 2017-07-01 19.41.30
challenger3980 posted:
PRRronbh posted:

My MTH Premier Train Master engines.  These were mad with new tooling.

IMG_1970

IMG_1977

IMG_1986

NOTE prototypical pilot deck height for the respective roads.

IMG_1981

Would they have been Happier with Old Tooling? 

Doug

Just to enlighten those that do not know that MTH Premier is now built with new much more detailed "tooling."

The RK is made from the old tooling.

challenger3980 posted:

BTW, just curious, do you know the reason for the higher deck height on the short hood end of the Pennsy units?

Doug

Actually it was the Southern that required to lower deck for safety so crew would not have to jump down.

And yes I knew you were just kidding around but just had to come back.

As far as the "mad" probably just Freudian.  I am mad because have not received an USPS tracking confirmation that an USPS Priority Mail Envelope containing my MO for purchase of a special K-Line engine has been delivered.  Expected delivery is today.  Have confirmation that it departed Cincy distr. center at 0010.  By now someone could have walked across the Ohio River to the small town in KY.

Ron 

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×