Skip to main content

Couple of us have already contacted @MrMuffin'sTrains. He’s interested but if Lionel agrees he will need at least 50 orders for it to happen.  Here’s a video and a few pics.  Post below if interested.

you can see the different shades of green.  I want that style of lettering Kline used What’s it called? Kind of like the darker green on my MTH Hudson

AFE02C6A-8731-4EC0-B0FB-D0A2B990A96FEA4975AC-2745-4534-B02E-39C5FEAB239F56AE576D-E155-49D6-9DAB-BC1C5E5F07F6AE1BC26F-40A8-4321-A249-327387063C9B

Attachments

Images (4)
  • AFE02C6A-8731-4EC0-B0FB-D0A2B990A96F
  • EA4975AC-2745-4534-B02E-39C5FEAB239F
  • 56AE576D-E155-49D6-9DAB-BC1C5E5F07F6
  • AE1BC26F-40A8-4321-A249-327387063C9B
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Whose model is the one in your top two photos Gary?  I like the darker tender and green on that one as well. We have the K-Line model at our club and I find the light green 'odd' more often than not. They have an amazing level of detail however and are beautiful locomotives!

I am offering my similar B&M Legacy Berk in the FS thread if anyone wants one NOW  :-)

@0-Gauge CJ posted:

Just curious, what is the prototype history of the green B&A berk? I recently picked up one of the K-Line ones. I am set on getting one of the Vision Class A engines and I want to pick up a few other things, but I'd add this to the list of serious contenders for things I'd consider.

Most of the history. Has been lost to time.  I’ve been told one berk and one Hudson were painted this way for some special event in the late 30’s.  Others have stated it was normal practice for several engines to be painted this way.  Their are no known color pics of this.  Most if not all in the know have left us.   So were berks Hudson painted this way on the B&A?  To some extent yes.

I was able to find some "informal" paint information for an issue of a B&A O gauge Hudson.  Evidently, the green color of the boiler and that of the tender differed.  I referred the manufacturer to Bob Buck, now deceased, who owned Tucker's Hobbies.  Bob saw these engines as a boy and, as a photographer and modeler, was able to view the manufacturer's samples of various greens and made that decision for them.  (I originally received this manufacturer request as a Director of the NYCSHS.)  This FWIW.  I never followed up with Buck to try to determine how many Hudsons and Berkshires were painted this color.  My understanding, however, is that it was more common on B&A Hudsons "as delivered".  I do not have any information re how many, if any, Berks were painted in these shades of green.

@Hudson5432 posted:

I was able to find some "informal" paint information for an issue of a B&A O gauge Hudson.  Evidently, the green color of the boiler and that of the tender differed.  I referred the manufacturer to Bob Buck, now deceased, who owned Tucker's Hobbies.  Bob saw these engines as a boy and, as a photographer and modeler, was able to view the manufacturer's samples of various greens and made that decision for them.  (I originally received this manufacturer request as a Director of the NYCSHS.)  This FWIW.  I never followed up with Buck to try to determine how many Hudsons and Berkshires were painted this color.  My understanding, however, is that it was more common on B&A Hudsons "as delivered".  I do not have any information re how many, if any, Berks were painted in these shades of green.

Cool story, ….soooo,…which mfr. got it right?..

Pat

BW photos online of the prototype 1426 Berk look like a lighter shade than the color of the MTH Hudson’s, more like the k-line Berk, but who knows. I’d post the photo here but it’ll get deleted since it’s not mine. Personally, I prefer the k-line green because it stands out.

Before we worry about the color, we’ll have to just get enough orders for the minimum.

@superwarp1 posted:

Couple of us have already contacted @MrMuffin'sTrains. He’s interested but if Lionel agrees he will need at least 50 orders for it to happen.  Here’s a video and a few pics.  Post below if interested.

you can see the different shades of green.  I want that style of lettering Kline used What’s it called? Kind of like the darker green on my MTH Hudson

AFE02C6A-8731-4EC0-B0FB-D0A2B990A96FEA4975AC-2745-4534-B02E-39C5FEAB239F56AE576D-E155-49D6-9DAB-BC1C5E5F07F6AE1BC26F-40A8-4321-A249-327387063C9B

Something to bring to Steve’s (Mr Muffins) attention is that the sand dome, & all the other piping & parts are all supposed to be black on this Berk. Only the boiler & the cylinders are green. K-line & MTH didn’t do this model correctly. The brass loco is correct. And I definitely think the darker green & darker silver for the front is the way to go. Let’s hope it happens! Cheers.
DJ

Seeing no color photos exist of this scheme or if a Berkshire was even painted this way.  It’s hard to say What shades are correct. That brass model is a few years old and retailed for around $2500.00.  I can’t imagine Lionel going to that level of detail paint wise. I hope you guys can get one made. Harry could probably detail one up like that. That brass version has to be one of the sharpest looking freight steamers ever made.

@Dave_C posted:

Seeing no color photos exist of this scheme or if a Berkshire was even painted this way.  It’s hard to say What shades are correct. That brass model is a few years old and retailed for around $2500.00.  I can’t imagine Lionel going to that level of detail paint wise. I hope you guys can get one made. Harry could probably detail one up like that. That brass version has to be one of the sharpest looking freight steamers ever made.

These were indeed painted this way, and if Kline could get it close, why can’t it be done today?…..any painter worth his salt could accomplish this, …..it’s not an ancient Chinese secret…..😉

Pat

Something to bring to Steve’s (Mr Muffins) attention is that the sand dome, & all the other piping & parts are all supposed to be black on this Berk. Only the boiler & the cylinders are green. K-line & MTH didn’t do this model correctly. The brass loco is correct. And I definitely think the darker green & darker silver for the front is the way to go. Let’s hope it happens! Cheers.
DJ

That would be fantastic, but I doubt you’d see that level of detail happen on a 3 rail die cast model…..especially on cast in details……not to say it can’t be done, but more than likely not happening ….so break out your finest pinstriping brush and go to town….😉

Pat

I'm just waiting for Steve to pop up and say "We're green lit" and ready to roll. With the catalog being somewhat of a yawn I guess you could say for me, this would be the best thing to come out from it. Now does that mean I'm sidelining the Class A? Well, sort of. Having a green Berkshire done up by Steve really puts it in a class by itself. I just can't wait.

@superwarp1 posted:

No clue, haven't heard anything from @MrMuffin'sTrains since Friday.  I think he's also working on a special run for the Class A as well.

Well, Steve is the miracle man as far as I'm concerned. He just sees the right things to do. I really would have been interesting if he could have gotten Lionel to bite on his Mohawk idea. They said no way right from go. It would have been something.

A new road number is great. Do we know what other road numbers were green? From what I can see, maybe 1425 and 1442?

No clue as I haven't talked with Steve. Whatever it would be would definitely be something that is searchable and real. Steve likes to get as real as possible. He cheated just a bit with the Pacific's in the last catalog, but it was somewhat close enough for some.

Well, we got the word from Lionel today and we are in for a green B&A Berkshire.... not added to my website yet - but will be - what road number? I hear the no #1426

We have a few more custom runs they have scheduled for us - more on that soon!

#1425 would be fine or pic it out of a hat.  No one knows which engines were painted green anyway.   Can we have Roman lettering (font style) also????

Again, thanks for going to all the trouble.  Now to decide if I should get it weathered?????   

Now we need to bug Lionel for a proper caboose.  This is the third run of this engine over the last twenty years.  Kline didn't do a proper caboose, Lionel hasn't and it's about time.  I'm going to bug Ryan when I see them in 1 1/2 weeks.  Need others as well.

Last edited by superwarp1

I'm getting excited over this engine. Very few engines of color in my fleet, mostly black. It'll be interesting to have a green monster running around the rails. Makes me wonder if the Hudson's come back around if would could get a green B&A like what Gary had talked about once before(I believe).

Yes, my MTH B&A hudson which is green.  More than likely I wouldn't be in for another one.  I had that engine converted to Legacy and she's a dream to run.

Again a big Thankyou to @MrMuffin'sTrains for doing all these special runs and to Lionel for seeing there's a market for special runs. 

Now just have to wait for Steve to pop it up on the website, pictures to start with, then the artwork. Hope this thing is a wonderous beauty just waiting for us. I can't wait. Good thing I'm ordering light again in the catalog. I wouldn't have ordered the as cataloged B&A engine, as it just looks to unexciting.

My black Kline berk is in dire need of a weathering job,  the one in the catalog would look great weathered.

Certainly hope they research the color extensively as for me personally, this 'K-Line Green' is rather unsightly after awhile. Ours sits on the club layout most of the time and looks somewhat odd at times. Hopefully it is closer to the beautiful HO model that Gary posted earlier. Just my personal opinion fellas...

IMG_9119green

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_9119green
@Norton posted:

Slightly off topic but this version would get me to open my wallet. SP bought ten of them from the B&M and then converted them to oil using this tender. Homely beasts but I love them. Lionel’s version is also correct as they were used for a short time burning coal.

A3CEF9FF-B504-4CEE-9059-70C1DEC20DB72EF0A85C-0961-4547-A191-336B859B268E

Pete

I always keep my fingers crossed that a whaleback tender shows up someday.  Lucky for us Dave Olson is a SP fan and, I think sometime in the future, we will get one.

-Brian

@c.sam posted:

Certainly hope they research the color extensively as for me personally, this 'K-Line Green' is rather unsightly after awhile. Ours sits on the club layout most of the time and looks somewhat odd at times. Hopefully it is closer to the beautiful HO model that Gary posted earlier. Just my personal opinion fellas...

IMG_9119green

Same I do like that green.

  I’ve got a few of the A&R DVD’s. The B&A one has some great footage. The Central Vermont ones are a good watch. I believe it was one of the New Haven ones that had some bonus footage at the end. A B&A Berk. struggling up a hill with a Mikado pusher on the rear. The Mike had a switching style tender. It was probably just used in pusher service or on locals. I purchased the parts for the tender Lionel’s 1/2 off sale. This is something I really want to duplicate on my RR. Just need a donor Legacy Mike.  Someday it will get done.

@superwarp1 posted:

Same I do like that green.

I like this green too, question is will the engine be painted like the K line model where “everything past the smoke box is green, or like the brass model, only the boiler jacket & cylinders are green. Correct me if I’m wrong but I believe the brass model is much more accurate to the prototype

Last edited by Dj'sOgaugetrains

I like this green too, question is will the engine be painted like the K line model where “everything past the smoke box is green, or like the brass model, only the boiler jacket & cylinders are green. Correct me if I’m wrong but I believe the brass model is much more accurate to the prototype

It will be painted like the Kline version.  It's beyond Lionel's capability to paint individual parts like the brass model.  MR. Muffin has asked Harry Heike on what he can do so stay tuned.

Last edited by superwarp1
D63D24FE-4047-4DB8-9B9C-3D7F3948BBA094E4A743-B1C2-4E08-ACC5-C95B441D65D4@superwarp1 posted:

It will be painted like the Kline version.  It's beyond Lionel's capability to paint individual parts like the brass model.  MR. Muffin has asked Harry Heike on what he can do so stay tuned.

So I’m glad Steve is inquiring with Harry to enhance these models but what I don’t understand is why is it beyond lionels capacity to just do a green boiler jacket. They did it with the VL challenger, and they do it all the time with non vision engines. Take a look at  this uncataloged legacy Russian iron blue camelback just released not long ago by the NLOE.  Not trying to stirr the pot. I’m just trying to understand.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • D63D24FE-4047-4DB8-9B9C-3D7F3948BBA0
  • 94E4A743-B1C2-4E08-ACC5-C95B441D65D4
Last edited by Dj'sOgaugetrains
@superwarp1 posted:

That's something you would have to bring up with Lionel.  I can only repeat what I've been told.

I'm not understanding also with that pic.  If they can do it with one why not the other.  Complexity with all the piping in the way maybe?

Ryan replied basically saying he’s willing to do what customers want and is waiting on artwork. He encouraged me to reach out to Steve. Artwork for custom runs comes from the dealers. I sent Steve another email showing him the pics I posted on here. Hopefully we can get the model to look more accurate.

@superwarp1 posted:

I have just seen the Lionel's artist rendition of the green berk from Mr Muffins.   I can say you all are going to be very very happy with the final product.

Yeah, I just looked at it as well and am pretty happy. I guess by next week we'll have the number on orders as I asked and we all know Steve will respond where things stand sometime then.

@superwarp1 posted:

I ask and it’s getting made

Glad to read that this one is getting made, waiting to hear if the custom run I preordered made the cut.

Steve sent this to me as well. If Lionel delivers on the artwork it’ll be an incredible engine!

Yes it will.  Unfortunately there is always the possibility of differences like in the case of the J3A from a couple years ago.

BandABerk

Super excited about this... I am near 40 orders now, so if you want one, please preorder it so I know how many I will need to have Lionel make.

Steve, you are the bomb. So far, this will make my 4th custom run purchase that you offered. Nothing makes me happier than something that is unique and a great project. You see what should be and make it happen. As long as you keep doing what you're doing, I will always be interested in purchasing a custom run(as long as I have money, lol).

@Norton posted:

Slightly off topic but this version would get me to open my wallet. SP bought ten of them from the B&M and then converted them to oil using this tender. Homely beasts but I love them. Lionel’s version is also correct as they were used for a short time burning coal.

A3CEF9FF-B504-4CEE-9059-70C1DEC20DB72EF0A85C-0961-4547-A191-336B859B268E

Pete

Seems to me that the latest Lionel version of the SP/ATSF ex-B&M Berk cheats by using the B&A boiler casting with the Coffin hung on the front rather than the Elesco, unlike the original K-Line versions that used the correct, different boiler castings. Or, maybe I'm just having "catalogue blindness".

(No, I just looked - the catalogue shows the B&A boiler on the B&M/ATSF/SP locos, which is incorrect, Coffin or not.)

Sure would like a whaleback tender, though.

SP did receive the Coffin feedwater versions. There is an HO Balboa model on the auction site that shall not be named now. I also have pics but of course can’t post here. It kept its coal tender until the 50s, then the whaleback when converted to oil and finally the coffin heater was removed at the end.

Pete

Steve, you are the bomb. So far, this will make my 4th custom run purchase that you offered. Nothing makes me happier than something that is unique and a great project. You see what should be and make it happen. As long as you keep doing what you're doing, I will always be interested in purchasing a custom run(as long as I have money, lol).

Think Gary (superwarp1) is the one to thank for idea to produce this one.

@Norton posted:

SP did receive the Coffin feedwater versions. There is an HO Balboa model on the auction site that shall not be named now. I also have pics but of course can’t post here. It kept its coal tender until the 50s, then the whaleback when converted to oil and finally the coffin heater was removed at the end.

Pete

Whaleback tender would be nice and a correct early short tender for the B&A would be nice also but you figure with the prices we are paying these days it wouldn’t be to much to ask for a not mass produced tender done to save a few bucks.  

@Arthur posted:

Think Gary (superwarp1) is the one to thank for idea to produce this one.

Yeah, Gary was one of the select few to put the words to Steve's ears. I would never take away what someone put forth to get things rolling. The great thing is that Steve is going forward to get it made with Lionel. I know Steve has tried a few ideas that were his own, some have obviously made it, others have not. I do also know that there has been a great number of suggestions on engines(and other things) to any number of dealers to try and get things made. Sometimes it's a hit, other times it doesn't get made. I really would have liked to have seen a Mr. Muffin's custom Mohawk, but Lionel told him a flat out no.

@superwarp1 posted:

Whaleback tender would be nice and a correct early short tender for the B&A would be nice also but you figure with the prices we are paying these days it wouldn’t be to much to ask for a not mass produced tender done to save a few bucks.  

I don’t see Lionel doing one unless it was a hybrid. No other applications for it except a few other SP engines like a Mogul.

I am hoping a 3rd Rail one comes along anyway.

Pete

Really excited about this project - we are over 40 now..... how many extras should I make?.... BTW, if you want to order the black one, and have already ordered the green one, use discount code "SecondBerk" for an additional discount on the black version (2231340).  I can't post the discount here - violates Lionel's rules - but once it's in your cart, you can see it.

Yeah, Gary was one of the select few to put the words to Steve's ears. I would never take away what someone put forth to get things rolling. The great thing is that Steve is going forward to get it made with Lionel. I know Steve has tried a few ideas that were his own, some have obviously made it, others have not. I do also know that there has been a great number of suggestions on engines(and other things) to any number of dealers to try and get things made. Sometimes it's a hit, other times it doesn't get made. I really would have liked to have seen a Mr. Muffin's custom Mohawk, but Lionel told him a flat out no.

Just to be clear, and fair, sometimes when Lionel says "no" to something I propose it's because they have plans to run it themselves in a future catalog. I don't think it's fair to them to disclose that model by model - theirs's to tell - but it's all pretty exciting. I just want to see the thing get made, whether it's cataloged in the future or a special run.



Diesels outsell steam, and we know that, so I don't get how all of the SD40-2's I have proposed from this catalog, and previous catalogs, don't get much interest.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×