Skip to main content

I took my 44-Ton locomotive apart and started seeing if I could come up with electrocouplers for the upcoming command conversion.  I ordered an assortment of Lionel's shortest couplers and lined them up on the bench.  I selected the 610-1912-050 as the most likely candidate based on it's mounting.  It has a big block of metal that I could grind away to make whatever mount I needed. 

 

The object of the exercise is to have the coupler at the correct height and to be able to use the existing centering spring, otherwise I doubt I could have the coupler center properly.

 

The first issue is the oddball offset nature of the mount, it's clear that no coupler is going to just drop in.  I ended up grinding off pretty much all of the mounting end and creating the offset mount using some fiberglass board material I had around.  The following pictures are what I came up with on my first cut.  I used a #6 screw as the shaft, and I'll Loctite the nut on the top and cut off the excess screw to finish up.  The end result did end up about 1/4" longer, I couldn't see any way around that with any of the electrocouplers.

 

I welcome comments, criticism, or better ideas.

 

 

44-Ton EC N0

44-Ton EC N1

44-Ton EC N2

44-Ton EC N3

44-Ton EC N4

44-Ton EC N5

Edit: Fixed type on part number.

Attachments

Images (6)
  • 44-Ton EC N0
  • 44-Ton EC N1
  • 44-Ton EC N2
  • 44-Ton EC N3
  • 44-Ton EC N4
  • 44-Ton EC N5
Last edited by gunrunnerjohn
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

That looks like a totally different mount Mike.  The big issue with the Williams is that offset mount, you don't have a straight shot to the mount point.  The truck comes close to the pilot, the only space you have in there is over the truck, and it's tight clearance.  It ended up I needed to pretty much duplicate the shape of the Williams coupler mount to make it fit.

 

 

Will an S-gauge coupler even couple to O-gauge?  I've never tried...



I doubt any standard coupler would work, if you look at the side view of the stock coupler, the dogleg in the mount is the real issue.  That is done so the coupler clears the truck.  I'm building my second coupler and I'll see how they work once the upgrade is complete.

Last edited by gunrunnerjohn

I'm following this with interest; I was disappointed to see that the 44T did not use a std/typical coupler mount. I may or may not upgrade it, and this will come into play -

plus, the original couplers look better than any conversion that anyone could do with

available parts. After all, enjoying CC/cruise does not require e-couplers.

 

This is not criticism - your work looks great - but as an old basher myself, sometimes I have found that leaving it alone is the kindest thing.

 

But I may, anyway...keep us posted.

Thanks for taking on this task. I'm interested in the 44 for doing what it was designed for, switching, and electro couplers is #1 to accomplish this task. I'm not interested in taking up track and adding uncoupler tracks for this engine, but for it to be able to accomplish this anywere on  the layout.

Maybe there will be an outlet for shorter couplers for this engine, seems to be very popular. Again, your doing good.

I will admit you won't equal the look of the stock couplers, but I'm getting better.  My second one is about 1/8" shorter, and not much longer than the stock coupler.  I did have to adjust my thinking on the return spring, the stock one was problematic, so I just took some spring wire and made one that contacts the frame to center the coupler.  This works better than the stock one anyway.

 

The whole reason for the electrocouplers is this is a switcher, it's pointless to have one with command that you can't do any switching with!

 

Another idea I was toying with is lopping the mount off the stock couplers and grafting it onto the 1.44" couplers for the Trackmobile.  In looking, I don't think that will do much better than my second coupler that I shortened a bit.  I may just get another set of the ones I used here and "improve" on the first one.  I suppose I could also just hack the extension off and start over as well.

 

 

 

Originally Posted by gunrunnerjohn:

I will admit you won't equal the look of the stock couplers, but I'm getting better.  My second one is about 1/8" shorter, and not much longer than the stock coupler.  I did have to adjust my thinking on the return spring, the stock one was problematic, so I just took some spring wire and made one that contacts the frame to center the coupler.  This works better than the stock one anyway.

 

The whole reason for the electrocouplers is this is a switcher, it's pointless to have one with command that you can't do any switching with!

 

Another idea I was toying with is lopping the mount off the stock couplers and grafting it onto the 1.44" couplers for the Trackmobile.  In looking, I don't think that will do much better than my second coupler that I shortened a bit.  I may just get another set of the ones I used here and "improve" on the first one.  I suppose I could also just hack the extension off and start over as well.

 

 

 

That 1/8" might be the limit, and a great improvement. I could live with that.

John,

It looks great - funny how just today i was wondering when we were going to see your results of this project. Of course, with taxes and selling our house in VT, etc. i haven't found time to even take mine apart.

Can't quite see where or how you added the fiberglass to create the offset mount and what cement you used there.

Now for your next great money making project, when are you going to offer these as ready to install upgrade kits? Especially before Lionel runs out of couplers we're all running out to order!!!

 

jackson

Originally Posted by Rusty Traque:
Originally Posted by gunrunnerjohn:

The whole reason for the electrocouplers is this is a switcher, it's pointless to have one with command that you can't do any switching with!

 

Seems like the big boys in prototypeland have been switching OK without benefit of electrocouplers and command for well over a century.

 

They have extra crew on the ground to help with those tasks.  When the activity is on the other side of your layout next to a pop-up hole, are you going to crawl over there and do the honors?

 

No chance of me making these in quantity, too labor intensive!

 

The fiberglass is 1/8" stock, the whole part of the coupler that is above

coupler detail

Attachments

Images (1)
  • coupler detail
Last edited by gunrunnerjohn

Very interesting, John although i would have thought you would have had the production line already up and running by now!

Without them to look at side by side, would the 620 8447 550, 1.44" 'C' mount coupler have worked (possibly by building up the "V" notch flat with J-B Weld)? I guess i'm just curious because i'm wondering about the strength of that fiberglass tab you engineered.

 

jackson

You can't use the V of the 1.44" one, ALL of the mounting is on a different axis. I have two of those, and another short set.  None of them looked to be suitable.  You need to look at the stock coupler to see all the metal on every Lionel coupler is off-axis for the mount.  Whatever you do, you're going to be fabricating the whole mount.

 

As far as the strength of the mount, I'm more worried about the Loctite 380 giving out than the fiberglass, that stuff isn't going anywhere!  It's 1/8" plate, and I can put a piece of it between two bricks and stand on it!  If it breaks, it'll be the adhesive, and I've had really good luck with the Loctite 380 for stuff like this.

 

I think the problem John and anyone else who tries this has to deal with is the location of the truck so close to the end of the body and length of the coil on the coupler. Unless someone finds a coupler with a shorter coil you won't be able to get much closer. If you mounted the coupler to the truck you would have to do away with the steps.

Post war coils are about the same length as modern couplers.

 

Pete

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×