Skip to main content

Hey, All

You would think that with a store full of modern high Tech. trains I would loose my interest in simple conventional items. I keep finding myself drawn to the trains of my childhood and trying to bring back the joy I felt as a child. My first train was a Marx hand me down from an older brother, it was a Marx CP 3000 that I ran the snout out of. I loved Marx Trains and I still collect them today and then I got my first Lionel and I was hooked. My first Lionel was an MPC Allegheny set with Sound of Steam, I thought that was high-tech for the time. I know this thought has been expressed by other people but thought it would be fun to share my feelings about this Hobby. Customers ask me if I get sick of toy trains and I have to admit that I am still hooked and play with them on a regular basis. I would like to also thank all of the OGR Forum members for sharing their memories and supporting my store.

Thanks

Happy railroading

Pat

WWW.PATSTRAINS.COM

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Pat,

I share similar feelings for MPC.  Though I love the modern, big, scale stuff, I miss the charm of MPC / Marx trains.  I have kept all of my childhood trains just for that reason, they are a blast to run and I love the smell of fried ozone each time!  Plus I get a kick out of watching them.  Makes me feel like an 8 yr old again.

 

I always enjoyed the tobacco cars.  There was a certain charm in this era-like the State Set and the Mickey Mouse Train.  I really wish I would have bought the Mickey train-passed on it and now really regret it.

 

Or how about the BN and Chessie SD-40 sets?  UP or IC passenger sets, which are still really desirable.  Great stuff, thanks MPC for the memories.

 

 

I could say the same about Lionel Trains Inc. engines. These ones are sort of a happy medium of all three eras: prewar tinplate (Lionel Classics), postwar classics, and modern scale. Nonetheless, there are many favorite trains that are MPC era, and provide a lot of nostalgia.

 

I run both conventional and command frequently, and MPC, LTI, and later TMCC as well as current Legacy share the loops often.

I think we are very blessed do to the MPC ERA. THIS might be called the General Mills Era as this saved Lionel from possibly going out of business. Then, out of his Love for Toy Trains, Richard Kughn, Bought Lionel and This was the Beginning of What we have Today.

So, Many of us saw some nice engines being reproduced, The Norfolk &Western J, the IC Passenger set with beaitiful ABA's, and one at a time great Post War Reproductions...

Then, TMCC,LEGACY, and Now The I -Pad ERA.

Yes, Lionel has survived for many Decades, and that's because, they have always given us Their Best Shot, And we are the reason for Their Success, WE BUY THEIR PRODUCTS.

Happy Railroading!!

 

I have about nine of those very first MPC (by way of Pola) "Standard O" boxcars and reefers. NO add-on details except the brakewheels, but nice diecast sprung trucks and colorful bodies.

 

And I also have the Milwaukee Special set and the add-on cars (except the diner). Engine has Sound of Steam with the whistle and both work fine!

 

 

 

 

 

The Milwaukee Special was the one of the first and the best of The Mighty Sound of Steam. The original configuration of the system came with a tender with it's own roller pick ups allowing you to disconnect the tether from the engine and still have the capability to operate the whistle. As the Mighty Sound of Steam was offered in later years The premium engines such as the Southern Crescent  and Blue Comet didn't even include a whistle. The whistle came back on the Chicago on Alton set with a downward facing speaker to improve sound but you still didn't have the ability to operate the whistle independently of the sound of steam. That was the down fall of the MPC era they took what had the potential to be a great system, never really did anything to improve it and only looked for ways to make it cheaper.
 
The Milwaukee Special is still the King of My railroad and rises above any other train displayed.
 

 
 
 
 
Originally Posted by Tinplate Art:

And I also have the Milwaukee Special set and the add-on cars (except the diner). Engine has Sound of Steam with the whistle and both work fine!

 

 

 

 

 

 

Other then those like myself with sentimental memories who lived through those early e MPC years, I can't imagine anyone knowing what is available today having any interest in it...

In this slowly evolving highly repetitive hobby after fifty some years, the best place for those colorful early MPC era pieces today is a display shelf. 

Joe 

 

 

My MPC motive power was limited to a couple of small steamers, my plastic 0-4-0, and that was good for up to 10-12 cars at a scale 40MPH. I may have gotten that particular train up to 15 lightweight cars before I added another switcher (8516 NY Central) to double-head it, but by that time the LTI era was in full swing . The only other MPC loco I have is an 8506 0-4-0, which being die-cast wasn't at a loss for pulling power.

 

I do have a fair amount of MPC rolling stock, but the only sub-category I'm actively adding to is the MPC-style autorack, whenever they show up in the catalogs from time to time:*

While the rest of my MPC fleet is pretty much dormant due to the influx of scale-sized equipment, I have no plans to retire any of it--it's just a matter of time before it gets its turn to run.

 

---PCJ

*(Edit: I see the 81003 CP is in stores now--(goes to check usual sources) a 40' train of these is now a certainty)

Last edited by RailRide

I still have a few, but no special affection for them. I've been getting rid of them at train shows for the past several years. Many MPC items are waxy-looking, unpainted plastic and have shiny, ugly plastic trucks. I bought most of my MPC stuff when I was just getting back into the hobby, before Lionel and MTH started making a lot of better-quality scale items. It was OK then for what it was, but it hasn't got much going for it now. 

"Nope.  Engines couldn't pull their own shadow"

 

Never heard it put that way; its not only funny, but true!  I know there has been debate if the hobby is "toys" or "models".  I don't care one way or another, however, MPC for the most part were toys hands down (IMHO).  Some higher end steamers and passenger cars were decent, but for the most part they were cheaply produced and poorly engineered.  I have some MPC where the plastic has become brittle and shows stress cracks.  I picked a good time (MPC) to take a hiatus from the hobby.

 

Stack 




quote:
 I can't imagine anyone knowing what is available today having any interest in it...




 

One reason some folks might like MPC is their price point. For the most part MPC trains are much less expensive then the newly made stuff, or postwar.

 

Several folks have commented about a lack of pulling power. I guess my trains were not long enough. I never noticed.

 

To each their own!

Originally Posted by joe krasko:

Love MPC era Lionel...in years to come they will still run...can't say the same for big bucks electronic trains...Gotta love "E" units...joe

I retained four representative samples of MPC motive power in my collection of largely tinplate as I consider them to be plastic tinplate ( Plastic-plate?):

1. Colorful graphics

2. More artful characterization of the prototype than "realistic"= toy-like

3. Mechanically simple

4. Inexpensive

The motto on my road is as follows" "Any resemblance to realism is purely coincidental"

P.S I can redecorate them "anxiety free"

 

Last edited by electroliner

I missed that era. My first train was an old Gilbert AF set. Then all my friends received HO sets for Christmas, so that was the thing to do. By the time I found Lionel (mid-90s), MPC was ancient history.

 

I think I have one car from that time period. It's a gondola that I bought for $2-3 not long after I got back into trains. I still run it; it's loaded with rolled coins for weight and sports a 3M Scotch-Brite pad squeezed in snugly underneath. Best track-cleaning car for the money! (I guess with its dedicated coin rolls it is worth more like $10-15 )

Over the years I've acquired many basic MPC cars from various sets. In the last year I decided to repaint them. I've only done the base paint and have not detailed or weathered them yet. But for the price I paid and a couple of cans of spray paint, I figure I'm ahead -- at least for return on investment.

 

Gondolas_unpainted

 

Gondolas_primed

 

Gondolas

These are just the ones I turned grey. I've also done some in black and Tuscan red. With a load of scrap iron these will just blend into the layout.

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Gondolas
  • Gondolas_primed
  • Gondolas_unpainted

I like 'em.  I try to avoid the bottom of the barrel stuff with non-operating couplers and unpainted sides.  I find the middle of the road and up items from that era quite enjoyable.  I prefer William's flywheel and can motor drive but will buy a MPC engine if the price is right.  Is there a good guide online to servicing the MPC era engines?

 

I have some books that explain postwar era servicing but haven't been able to find anything on MPC.  

 

I love MPC. It brought me back into the hobby. The variety of road names and improved graphics vs. postwar helped sustain the Lionel name and brand following the disastrous "Cohn Era". Although looked down upon by many, MPC was critical in  producing attractive, colorful trains and enjoyable accessories thus saving Lionel from extinction.

Thank you for the kind words.

 

While the manual is somewhat disorganized, at least Lionel makes it available. If the other guys do, I'd appreciate someone posting the links.

 

We have to remember that the manual was designed for hardcopy. Each supplement was intended to be broken up and inserted into the base manual.

While I have an original hardcopy, with all of the supplements, I never merged them.

I purchased my copy from Lionel, before they offloaded the manual to Greenberg.

 

The Lionel manual binders are red. Most are marked directly on the binder. Some came unmarked, and a few had stickers.

The Greenberg manuals are dark grey or maybe black, marked directly on the binder.

 

MPC was readily available, more affordable than PW, and much better rolling than PW when I was young.   The colorful locomotives and cars drew me in.  It did not matter to me that they created a lot of fantasy designs.  They looked good to me and being a toy train guy, I didn't worry about sweating the details.  Most items were durable and I only had one engine where I developed a stutter gear problem from pulling almost 100 MPC cars with a single locomotive.  Lack of pulling power was never a problem.  I really appreciate the lower cost of these items today and am still an avid collector.  MPC is one of the best values out there today in O gauge.

Oh, I forgot, The Lionel GG1 8753, is What re-kindled my interest in collecting Lionel Trains. I found this engine by accident in one of the model railroader magazines. Chris Model Trains had a package deal if we ordered 12 of these engines, although one had to take a lot of other low end products to get the deal of $185 per engine. i ordered the package deal and had no problem selling the other 11 engines...This engine was a great puller and although it was conventional, it reminded us of those great Post War GG1's.

WOW...Although WE loved the MPC ERA,  Times are better now, and Lionel makes trains for every collectors needs. It's a Great time to be in this hobby.

Without MPC, we wouldn't be where we are today with Lionel IMO. I had just gotten out of the USMC, was in a new civilian job a few years when I happened to find Train Express in Indianapolis (along with one local hobby shop) as I was based out of Indy.

Once I saw the Southern Crescent set, and then the Blue Comet and Alton Limited sets, I was back on the bandwagon adding to my Postwar items I'd held on to since high school.

The decoration was light-years ahead of anything produced in the PW period, and the mechanicals were essentially PW designs with some updates (nylon gearing was NOt one of the improvements) but at least you could update parts if needed. Fast-angle wheels rolled way easier than PW had allowing longer trains with single motor engines.

i still have my Maple Leaf Limited, UP Gold Coast, and CP Rail Limited sets along with the JLC memorial set. Still great runners and good looking IMO as well. We were lucky MPC came along when they did.

I would guess that nearly half of what I own is MPC. It is brighter and more colorful than most postwar offerings (which makes up nearly the other half...) and the cars are a lot easier to pull. I don't own many of the engines from the time frame, but the ones I do own pull plenty good enough for my needs (15 to 20 9700 series boxcars and a caboose is a long train for me):

 

 

I really like their SD-18. I wish they would have found a way to squeeze 2 pullmors in there. The one in the picture has a lot of added weight to it and one of those Model Power sound systems in it.

 

I recently discovered the "gold box" cars with the die cast trucks. I really like these cars and have bought quite a few in the past year.

 

J White

 

I still have every MPC engine I ever purchased.  Not a lot of them to be sure because at that time I had young children and trains were lower on the priority list.  However, the five that I did purchase were higher end items and all still run perfectly to this day.  I still run them from time to time and still get a kick out of the Mighty Sound of Steam.  As has been stated that was high tech for the times.  I enjoy collecting and running trains from the different eras so I can have the opportunity to watch and listen to the technological progression which has occurred in our hobby over the last 100 years or so.  Some people may belittle and denigrate the MPC era but it kept the torch burning. 

I cut my teeth in model railroading with Lionel MPC.  I've moved away from it during the early 1980s when the non - scale look & proportions became unappealing to me and started getting the early Weaver Quality Craft freight car kits and some Standard O until before high school.  After college then the military, I've been doing 3 rail scale for well over 15 years since and have been  loving it, rivet counting and all.

Having said that, over this past year I've been finding myself going back to those MPC roots and have been breaking out those trains from back then as well as acquiring new ones from that era. 

While agreed that MPC wasn't exactly the pinnacle of Lionel toy train history, I don't think it deserves the bad rap it seems to get at times; it certainly wasn't any worse  than the autumn years of the postwar era during the 1960s IMHO, and some improvements actually came out of it such as the fast angle wheels & delrin trucks as others mentioned which greatly reduced rolling resistance so much that postwar equipment was like dragging bricks around by comparison.  Coupled with the crisper graphics, more vibrant color varieties, and  wider range of roadnames offered compared to postwar I think contributed to the gradual revitalization of Lionel trains and relevance in the hobby.

Plus, as a kid I totally dug the building kits they came out with too during that time; certainly offered something different and better proportioned than most Plasticville structures that were prevalent before then.
Last edited by John Korling
Originally Posted by John Korling:

While agreed that MPC wasn't exactly the pinnacle of Lionel toy train history, I don't think it deserves the bad rap it seems to get at times; it certainly wasn't any worse  than the autumn years of the postwar era during the 1960s IMHO,

It was quite a time...

 

The MPC era was certainly a lively era.  There was just as much excitement and anticipation for the next catalog back then as there is today.

 

It was also a pretty heady "collector" period.  Right or wrong, some MPC items increased in value rapidly shortly after hitting the dealer shelves (or swap tables...)

 

When an ad said "call for price," it usually meant higher than retail...

 

The search was on trying to find who had break ups and the "rare" car from a boxed set.  For the lowest possible price of course...   And, just like today, if you wanted to be sure of getting something, you pre-ordered it.  Yeah, I got caught up in it too.

 

And the stuff was fun to run.  No command control.  Basic and crude sound if any, just put it on the track and let 'er rip.  If it ran poorly, it usually was a simple postwar-style fix.

 

 

scan0013

Even though my MPC trains are long gone, I don't regret participating in the era.

 

Rusty

Attachments

Images (1)
  • scan0013
Yep, That Chicago Alton set sure is something special. I know it's one of my favorites and has plenty enough pulling power even without its magnatraction fully functional on Atlas track it pulls all of it's six passenger cars with no problem. Though I do like to make the wheels spin for kicks. It's something other's should look up to.
 
 

 
 
 
 
Originally Posted by D&H 65:

Without MPC, we wouldn't be where we are today with Lionel IMO. I had just gotten out of the USMC, was in a new civilian job a few years when I happened to find Train Express in Indianapolis (along with one local hobby shop) as I was based out of Indy.

Once I saw the Southern Crescent set, and then the Blue Comet and Alton Limited sets, I was back on the bandwagon adding to my Postwar items I'd held on to since high school.

The decoration was light-years ahead of anything produced in the PW period, and the mechanicals were essentially PW designs with some updates (nylon gearing was NOt one of the improvements) but at least you could update parts if needed. Fast-angle wheels rolled way easier than PW had allowing longer trains with single motor engines.

i still have my Maple Leaf Limited, UP Gold Coast, and CP Rail Limited sets along with the JLC memorial set. Still great runners and good looking IMO as well. We were lucky MPC came along when they did.

 

Last edited by Matthew B.
Originally Posted by John Korling:
While agreed that MPC wasn't exactly the pinnacle of Lionel toy train history, I don't think it deserves the bad rap it seems to get at times; it certainly wasn't any worse  than the autumn years of the postwar era during the 1960s IMHO, and some improvements actually came out of it such as the fast angle wheels & delrin trucks as others mentioned which greatly reduced rolling resistance so much that postwar equipment was like dragging bricks around by comparison.  Coupled with the crisper graphics, more vibrant color varieties, and  wider range of roadnames offered compared to postwar I think contributed to the gradual revitalization of Lionel trains and relevance in the hobby.

Plus, as a kid I totally dug the building kits they came out with too during that time; certainly offered something different and better proportioned than most Plasticville structures that were prevalent before then.

I agree with this 100%. 

 

The other thing to keep in mind for people, including me, who like to complain is that today's introductory, basic starter sets are far nicer than the basic starter sets that were available when I was a kid in the 70s, or that were available during late postwar period.  The Lionel, MTH, and WBB starter sets that are offered today at the relative lower price points of the hobby are terrific.  So while MPC offered some dodgy starter sets, it wasn't really any different than what Lionel Corporation did during the, say, 1960s.

 

So that's a long way of saying that in many respects today we are spoiled by the quantity and quality of innovative O gauge offerings available today.

I'm 43. My childhood memories of Lionel trains are from the MPC-era. The Cannonball was my first set bought for me by my Father, Christmas 1976. Important enough I remember the year! A couple years ago I found the set NIB. Ya, I bought it. I display it, along with my first accessory, the mechanical crossing gate, and silver Rio Grande boxcar that my Dad traded the yellow flatcar from the set for, because it was broken.

 

I think I've got about every book, catalog, and flyer concerning the MPC-era. Don't buy MPC anymore, but I'll keep what I have, and I still look through those catalogs every once in a while.

FARR sets, expensive add-on boxcars (they wanted $12.00 for them in the magazines!), bunkcars, cranes, and all lettered for real railroads, not Lionel Lines.

  

I have just about a complete collection of the "Collector Line" of MPC and love them all! All those Boxed Limited Sets, Aluminum Passenger Sets, FARR Series, Fallen Flag Series, Service station sets,  and all of the End of Year Specials. They still appeal to me to this day, and can usually be obtained for a good price. I still buy postwar, LTI, and the postwar reissues, but there is just something about MPC that I truly love. 

Originally Posted by Tiffany:

hello guys and gals............

 

I loved those early MPC era F-3's but not with the single motor and plastic gears and hollowed pot metal wheels which sometimes are out of round. Guys when did the MPC era ended and what was after that LTI ?

 

the woman who loves the S.F.5011,2678,2003,200

Tiffany

Tiffany,

 

LTI did succeed MPC, and that was in late 1986/early 1987.

IMG_1285

IMG_4984

 

This topic is posted every few months,but here is my reply again:

I collect and run O scale trains from the 1920s through today.The ones I like the most and that I usually run are the Lionel MPC trains I had when I was a kid.I guess it is the nostalgia factor,run what you know and like.

Dan 

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_1285
  • IMG_4984
Last edited by Dan986

I'm rather fond of the MPC era, as one can do Things to them without any twinge of conscience...

Here's "Lil Stinky",  the Razorback Tracton Co.'s trolleycar steam loco:
GEDC0372
With 4 ounces of Harbor Freight wheel weights, Lil' Stinky becomes a stump puller:



gedc0254

And of course, the only Lionel two-foot gauge equipment out there...

GEDC0829

;-)

Mitch

Attachments

Images (3)
  • GEDC0372
  • GEDC0829
  • gedc0254
Originally Posted by Mikado 4501:
Originally Posted by Tiffany:

hello guys and gals............

 

I loved those early MPC era F-3's but not with the single motor and plastic gears and hollowed pot metal wheels which sometimes are out of round. Guys when did the MPC era ended and what was after that LTI ?

 

the woman who loves the S.F.5011,2678,2003,200

Tiffany

Tiffany,

 

LTI did succeed MPC, and that was in late 1986/early 1987.

Hello Mikado 4501

 

Thank you, smile. Another question  Is the LTI engines better made and made in America?

 

The woman who loves the S.F.5011,2678,2003,200

Tiffany

I have to admit there is something about the MPC Southern Crescent and MPC Blue Comet sets. These were a huge step forward with Painted Engines and SOS sound. I saved all of my money to buy these sets. If memory serves me, The Crescent was under $200.00 for the set and the Blue comet was around $249.00. I remember the feelings of want and lust for these items that I have never felt again. 

 

Originally Posted by PATSTRAINS:

I have to admit there is something about the MPC Southern Crescent and MPC Blue Comet sets. These were a huge step forward with Painted Engines and SOS sound. I saved all of my money to buy these sets. If memory serves me, The Crescent was under $200.00 for the set and the Blue comet was around $249.00. I remember the feelings of want and lust for these items that I have never felt again. 

 

 

 

To me, I really dug the Burlington Northern set headed up by their new SD40 models, in addition to the Santa Fe SD40s.  Also liked the Santa Fe SD-18s back then also.

 

As a Southern Pacific fan even back then, the selections were pretty slim though for that roadname; the only motive power that really stood out was the SP "black widow" F-M and later on the "Daylight F3s" (even as a kid I preferred the bloody nose paint scheme so neither was hot on my list).   I didn't also care for the SP U-36c they offered in the experimental paint scheme they used on their MK TE70-4S engines.  Too gaudy and similar to the "Burger King" engine they offered in their fast food set.

Add me to the list of folks who really like MPC stuff. I have a bunch of it I've kept, and no way I'll get rid of it. I could go on and on about all the great things Lionel did during the MPC period, but suffice it to say there were dozens of really great innovations and some beautiful engines and cars produced.

 

The graphics and paint on many of the cars (and engines) are just outstanding, and I run many of them with the scale stuff and it's fine. And of course there's the nostalgia because that's when I really got into O gauge.

 

I've never understood the complaints about pulling power - maybe these people didn't have much experience with a lot of MPC engines. Some of the single motored jobs were challenged with longer trains, that's true, although adding some weight improved things and was easy. But many of the other engines were right out of the Postwar period - virtually the same - such as FMs, most all of the steam engines, dual motored F-3s, GG-1s, and many other engines, and they pull just fine.

Last edited by breezinup

I like the color and affordability of MPC.  They look great on my layout and my shelves. 

 

The Thread "MPC Fan" is nine pages long  with tons of pictures. It spans over two years, so, yes,  I think there is a lot of interest in MPC.

 

https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/t...pc-fan-thread?page=1

 

 

 

 MPC is on the top and bottom rows as well as the row with the Northern Pacific cars.

 

DSC_0758

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSC_0758
Last edited by Former Member

What's not to like about these reasonably priced, good running and colorful trains?

 

Yes, everything coming out now is super amazing and the features are unbelievable to someone raised on MPC, but it is still fun to run the older stuff every now and then. I don't plan on picking up any MPC stuff beyond what I have left from my childhood.

 

However, I love firing up the Amtrak RDCs, Amtrak Lake Shore Limited (swapped the original engine chassis for a post war version, cut out the front end for the coupler, pulls extra nice), Chicago & Alton steam set and of course the ever popular BN SD40 set.

 

 

Great stuff in your picture, Dave (Brewman1973)!

 

Another thing that's interesting about MPC that I enjoy, from a historical perspective, are the real early pieces, from 1970-71-72, when Lionel was transitioning from the Postwar Lionel corp. to the MPC era. In many cases, parts from the Postwar Lionel Corp. parts bins were being used to put together the early MPC cars. Even for cars with the same number, there are sometimes different body style types used (the Greenberg Guide describes these different styles - different rivet patterns, boxcar ends, door types and railing types and positions, etc.), and different paints were often used with color variations. Sometimes the same cars would even be packaged in different style boxes, like the famous "Banner Boxes."

 

I have collected three different 9200 Ill. Central and 3 different 9204 Northern Pacific boxcars, for example. Among each of the 3 9200s and 3 9204s, each car has a different style body, with different rivet patterns and ends and doors and door railings, and the paint textures and colors are all different. In fact, one of the 9204s is such a different shade of green that it looks like a completely different car from the other 9204s.  

Last edited by breezinup

To reiterate on the variety offered during the MPC/Fundimensions era, just look at the 6517 bay window caboose from the postwar period.  That caboose was essentially offered in just two roadnames:  Lionel Lines & Erie (three if you want to include the "TCA Convention" variation and if you want to call that a roadname).  That's it.  And also just two colors:  Red for the Lionel Lines and Erie, & Orange for the TCA car.  Yes there were variations in the shade of color but those were still just the two colors offered.

 

When General Mills took over Lionel train production, we literally saw an explosion of different road names & colors offered on that same caboose since then.

 

Ditto for the postwar near-scale non-operating refrigerator car that came out in just 2 roadnames, Santa Fe (6672) & the REA (6572).  Under General Mills, you also saw an explosion of different roadnames and paint schemes offered just like the bay window caboose.

 

So it's more than fair to give General Mills credit for giving Lionel trains a much needed cosmetic "face lift" to make them more appealing to a wider range of collectors & hobbyists.

Hard not to notice in this thread, in just about every response about MPC, it  ends with some variation of how they still operate, kitbash or use it for parts.

Which got me wondering, is there anyone here other then me who owns MPC to enjoy as "collectibles" rather then good cheap trains to do their thing with?

The few pieces I own probably will not see the rails as long as I own it simply because of its sentimental attachment from the early days.

Bottom line.. Am I alone?  I understand folks like me are far and few in between, but Is anyone else willing to "come out" in this hostile operators environment and profess love and preservation for pristine MPC??  Rather then boasting over the beating to death of so called near worthless obsolete trains?  

Joe 

Last edited by JC642
Nope, but when your done with your dust collectors I hope you'll give me the opportunity to throw em the first punch.
 
Originally Posted by JC642:

Hard not to notice in this thread, in just about every response about MPC, it  ends with some variation of how they still operate, kitbash or use it for parts.

Which got me wondering, is there anyone here other then me who owns MPC to enjoy as "collectibles" rather then good cheap trains to do their thing with?

The few pieces I own probably will not see the rails as long as I own it simply because of its sentimental attachment from the early days.

Bottom line.. Am I alone?  I understand folks like me are far and few in between, but Is anyone else willing to "come out" in this hostile operators environment and profess love and preservation for pristine MPC??  Rather then boasting over the beating to death of so called near worthless obsolete trains?  

Joe 

 

an observation - I never had any MPC, but in the course of liquidating an area estate, I've now become very familiar with these products, particularly the engines. I've gone through cleaning and testing almost 300 engines in this project, and while many of the modern examples don't run properly because of battery or circuit board issues, I've never had one MPC example I couldn't get running like a watch in 5 minutes. I'm impressed, convinced, and now into them.

 

Tim

For what it was, it was great, and General Mills/Fundamensions did keep the brand active! I especially liked the billboard reefers back in the day!

 

The only MPC I currently have is the venerable "Milwaukee Special" set plus FIVE matching add-on cars, and NINE of the POLA/MPC "Standard O" reefers & boxcars, including the iconic Stroh's reefer.

I have some MPC that are collectible specimens. Special production such as Glen Uhl's Timken boxcar in orange.  I have several mint starter sets from the early 1970s as well, in their original neat-looking boxes. MPC got be back into this hobby so  you won't find me knocking it!

 

Remember: if it wasn't for MPC, we wouldn't have any new Lionel offerings to enjoy today.

>>>when your done with your dust collectors I hope you'll give me the opportunity to throw em the first punch.<<
 
Sounds like a classic case of toy abuse to me. 
What's not to like about MPC? Its beautiful stuff from a different era..All American made to boot.
Maybe a article on a different and unique piece of MPC every issue in OGR's collectors corner would re-ignite latent interest in collecting it.
But then again, collectors corner in OGR went poof too. Make more room for more discussion on Thomas the Tank or another Polar Express add on car...  
Joe
 
 
 
 

S7001385

Attachments

Images (1)
  • S7001385
Last edited by JC642

The small 41 / 53 style switchers were probably my favorite MPC production items. I purchased most of them as they came out, as well as the other motorized units, such as the #52 style fire cars and the #54 style ballast tampers.

The ballast tampers were over produced. I believe it was Charles Ro who had some painted in other paint schemes in order to sell them.

RGS did some very nice custom paint jobs on burro cranes too.

Originally Posted by Ace:

Yes, MPC made some good stuff. And the free-rolling fast-angle wheels were a real improvement over the old Postwar Lionel wheel sets.

 

Yep, one of the biggest operational pluses.  The biggest bone of contention I had with the General Mills era (I really don't like using MPC since they were only involved with Lionel production the first 3 years or so during the birth of the Modern Era) is the odd choice of using that obscure Symington-Wayne truck design; certainly nowhere close to being representative of mainstream freight car trucks.  They should have either stuck with the AAR style trucks that they did utilize briefly from the postwar period, or chosen a more common 70 or 100 ton Barber-style roller bearing truck similar to what LTI ended up using after 1989.

Originally Posted by John Korling:
... odd choice of using that obscure Symington-Wayne truck design; certainly nowhere close to being representative of mainstream freight car trucks ...

Yeah, I've wondered about that. But what was worse, I thought, was some of the 1960's Lionel cars with arch-bar trucks under modern cars!

Last edited by Ace

Great stuff. Here's just a few of mine. Amazing innovation, design, graphics and paint application, much of which we take for granted today. An interesting curiosity on the last car shown, the 9873 Ralston Purina reefer, is the "car used" date information. As far as I know, that's unique, although perhaps some other cars had it. It would be interesting to know the story behind that.

 

 

2014-09-05 005

2014-09-05 010

2014-09-05 017

2014-09-05 020

2014-09-05 026

2014-09-05 028

2014-09-05 038

Attachments

Images (7)
  • 2014-09-05 005
  • 2014-09-05 010
  • 2014-09-05 017
  • 2014-09-05 020
  • 2014-09-05 026
  • 2014-09-05 028
  • 2014-09-05 038

Not sure what MPC stands for, but what I can say about my post war trains, such as my 2328 Geep, and 2055 Hudson is that they are over 60 years old, and will run for another 100+ years.  Simple electro-mechanical technology ensures that you can fix them yourself and keep them going.

I do admit however that I prefer realism over toy trains. For that need I will use the smaller scales.  

Originally Posted by RB211:

Not sure what MPC stands for ...

 

Model Products Corporation

 

I think "the company" still exists today in one form or another, although its relationship with Lionel toy train days is distant history.  MPC was a division of General Mills during the 1970's, and that's when toy train enthusiasts are most familiar with it.  

 

Although Lionel's General Mills "MPC era" is typically referred to as 1969-1986, production under MPC only occurred for a few years in the early 70's after which the Lionel products became part of General Mill's Fundimension division in 1973 until Richard Kughn came along in 1986 to start the Kughn/LTI era of Lionel toy trains.

 

David

Last edited by Rocky Mountaineer
Originally Posted by Steamer:
Originally Posted by M. Mitchell Marmel:

I will say this:  A consist of MPC era Pennsy heavyweights looks durned good behind my restored 2025... 

 

 

Mitch

I run a set of the MPC PRR Baby Madison's behind my 675, they do look good.

I was just about to post the same thing!  Yeah, my 675 and MPC PRR passenger cars were made for each other.

 

Originally Posted by Rocky Mountaineer:
Originally Posted by RB211:

Not sure what MPC stands for ...

 

Model Products Corporation

 

I think "the company" still exists today in one form or another, although its relationship with Lionel toy train days is distant history.  MPC was a division of General Mills during the 1970's, and that's when toy train enthusiasts are most familiar with it.  

 

Although Lionel's General Mills "MPC era" is typically referred to as 1969-1986, production under MPC only occurred for a few years in the early 70's after which the Lionel products became part of General Mill's Fundimension division in 1973 until Richard Kughn came along in 1986 to start the Kughn/LTI era of Lionel toy trains.

 

David

Hello Rocky Mountianeer.........

When did the lionel LTI started and ended ? and was those trains in that time period made in America such as the blue and yellow F-3's #18117 AA units and 18121 B unit ?

 

the woman who loves the S.F.5011,2678,2003,200

Tiffany

Richard Kughn purchased Lionel Trains in 1986, and formed LTI (Lionel Trains, Inc.). In 1995, Wellspring Associates LLC (limited liability company) acquired LTI, and set up the company as Lionel LLC. Richard Maddox became president in 1999, and, among other things, was charged with the responsibility of moving Lionel production overseas. Over the period of roughly 2000 to 2002, all Lionel production was moved to the Far East. 

 

The blue and yellow Santa Fe freight F-3s, no. 18117, etc., were produced in 1993 in the Michigan plant, well before production was moved overseas.

Last edited by breezinup
Originally Posted by breezinup:

Richard Kughn purchased Lionel Trains in 1986, and formed LTI (Lionel Trains, Inc.). In 1995, Wellspring Associates LLC (limited liability company) acquired LTI, and set up the company as Lionel LLC. Richard Maddox became president in 1999, and, among other things, was charged with the responsibility of moving Lionel production overseas. Over the period of roughly 2000 to 2002, all Lionel production was moved to the Far East. 

 

The blue and yellow Santa Fe freight F-3s, no. 18117, etc., were produced in 1993 in the Michigan plant, well before production was moved overseas.

Hello breezinup....

thank you, I learned something new today. It is NICE to have a American made diesel for change.

 

the woman who loves the S.F.5011,2678,2003,200

Tiffany

Steamer posted:

picked this up a couple of months ago for what the cars are worth(what I was really after). My Wife talked me into it(she's done this on several occasions when I saw something I really wanted, but was dragging my feet)

 

PTDC0007

Hi guys,

I'm just curious...can someone give me the background on the steam locomotive in this set... Did it ever exist in "real" life?

Thanks,

Mark

Marek posted:
Steamer posted:

picked this up a couple of months ago for what the cars are worth(what I was really after). My Wife talked me into it(she's done this on several occasions when I saw something I really wanted, but was dragging my feet)

 

PTDC0007

Hi guys,

I'm just curious...can someone give me the background on the steam locomotive in this set... Did it ever exist in "real" life?

Thanks,

Mark

As Lionel offered it in these sets, it was a 4-4-2 Atlantic.  The model was a modified from the postwar 2018/2036/2037, which was a 2-6-4.

Now, Pennsy Atlantics did exist in real life, but they tended to not look like mini-NYC Hudsons as the model appears as.

4-4-2 PRR 7683

Rusty

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 4-4-2 PRR 7683
Rusty Traque posted:
Marek posted:
Steamer posted:

picked this up a couple of months ago for what the cars are worth(what I was really after). My Wife talked me into it(she's done this on several occasions when I saw something I really wanted, but was dragging my feet)

 

PTDC0007

Hi guys,

I'm just curious...can someone give me the background on the steam locomotive in this set... Did it ever exist in "real" life?

Thanks,

Mark

As Lionel offered it in these sets, it was a 4-4-2 Atlantic.  The model was a modified from the postwar 2018/2036/2037, which was a 2-6-4.

Now, Pennsy Atlantics did exist in real life, but they tended to not look like mini-NYC Hudsons as the model appears as.

4-4-2 PRR 7683

Rusty

Awesome Rusty, thanks!

Actually, those passengers cars from the Broadway Limited set are what got me loving trains.

My mom found them at a garage sale when I was 3 years old, but I never had the original locomotive...

Then I saw this auction, and I told myself I had to get it:
Lot 374: Lionel 6-1487 Broadway LTD Train Set - Incomplete

... once owned by Richard P. Kughn himself!

The set is actually as old as I am. They're also the reason I'm in O scale...I tried HO, but...just...couldn't...do it!

A good auction nonetheless - got me the Century Club F3s (brand new) for $280, some NYC rolling stock bundle for $90, and a Lionel D&H Alco C-420 #412 brand new for $210...

Mark

Last edited by Marek

I got into trains in the MPC era and had allot of it. It was great, loved it until the scale items came along. I have bought and sold allot of my scale trains. 

Even though I still like to run scale sized trains and beings I'm retired the days of buying the trains they are making today (I.E. cost) is over.

I now run smaller prototypes from the likes of railking scale and freight cars from the new MPC, Menards. Great products at a great price.

Still having fun. 

Dave

 

 

A lot of nice MPC equipment is still out there, and the prices keep coming down. Though it is important to learn a little about the exact models you're interested in as some of them were complete junk, others had most of the qualities of the post war stuff. I've liquidated 2 large collections of mainly MPC trains in the last few years, and I got to say I developed a real appreciation for some of these.

Tim

_TJS4037_TJS4201_TJS4167365_1_TJS4252366_1364_1_TJS3991_TJS4193

Attachments

Images (9)
  • _TJS4037
  • _TJS4201
  • _TJS4167
  • 365_1
  • _TJS4252
  • 366_1
  • 364_1
  • _TJS3991
  • _TJS4193

Heck yeah i love mpc  and the kughn era too the beginnings of tmcc and railsounds 

the days before fastrack some of my favorite sets that i hope to own one day are mpc

the grand national 

illinois central freight

rocky mountain special 

n&w spirit of america 

north american express

chessie steam special 

the one with the cp gp9 can't recall the name 

75th anniversary set 

mickey mouse express 

southern pacific limited

This whole MPC thread is very interesting at least for me. My family has had Lionel Trains since the early 50's. In the late 60's, like so many other teenagers, I kind of lost interest in playing around with the trains. In the 70's, I bought a several MPC cars for our layout even though I wasn't directly involved with the trains. 
These days, I'm trying to figure out just how to get back into things. Reading some of these posts and looking at the pictures of the MPC era products, makes me realize that had I stayed on top of things, I probably would have a LOT of MPC era stuff today. Just recently, I bought a MoPac MPC era boxcar, and I plan to buy more MPC era rolling stock whenever possible. I sure wish I had the Life Savors tank car in my collection. LOL! 

I'm also grateful for the link to the MPC thread on the forum. I'm enjoying all the pictures. 

 

Marek posted:

Then I saw this auction, and I told myself I had to get it:

Lot 374: Lionel 6-1487 Broadway LTD Train Set - Incomplete

... once owned by Richard P. Kughn himself!

A good auction nonetheless - got me the Century Club F3s (brand new) for $280, some NYC rolling stock bundle for $90, and a Lionel D&H Alco C-420 #412 brand new for $210...

Was wondering when I saw the ad for that auction if the claim to be part of the Kughn collection was legitimate.  Specifically, broken trains and incomplete sets seemed suspect, as even I don't own anything in such a state and certainly am not at Kughn's level.  Can anyone confirm?

What, me worry? 

Last edited by Alfred E Neuman
Alfred E Neuman posted:
Marek posted:

Then I saw this auction, and I told myself I had to get it:

Lot 374: Lionel 6-1487 Broadway LTD Train Set - Incomplete

... once owned by Richard P. Kughn himself!

A good auction nonetheless - got me the Century Club F3s (brand new) for $280, some NYC rolling stock bundle for $90, and a Lionel D&H Alco C-420 #412 brand new for $210...

Was wondering when I saw the ad for that auction if the claim to be part of the Kughn collection was legitimate.  Specifically, broken trains and incomplete sets seemed suspect, as even I don't own anything in such a state and certainly am not at Kughn's level.  Can anyone confirm?

What, me worry? 

There's this article: For the Love of Lionel: The Collection of Richard P. Kughn

Mark

jim sutter posted:

I have always wondered, why Lionel has never re-issued the Life Savers tank car.

Jim, it was reissued, but as a TTOS Cal Stewart meet car, in 2007. An earlier re-issue was cataloged in 2001 Vol. 1 as no. 19629, but that car was cancelled, for some reason. Here's a little discussion on the two lifesavers cars that have been produced, that I put in a thread back in 2015:

There have been two versions of this car made by Lionel - the no. 9278 from 1978, and the no. 52476, a special issue done for the Cal-Stewart train show in 2007. They are slightly different. I've attached some photos of the cars to show the differences. 

The later 52476 added die cast sprung trucks, whereas the 9278 has plastic trucks (although die cast trucks can be added), and the 52476 has some added rivet detail near the end caps (Lionel changed the mold prior to this). Also, the logo and other decoration are somewhat different (the 52476 is the one with the blue background behind the Lifesavers lettering, and there are other differences as well).

 In addition, the colored striping decoration is painted on with the 52476, and on the 9278 it is a separately applied covering put on with some kind of adhesive, presumably (paint processes back then were not available as they are today to do applications like this, at least at reasonable cost). Finally, the colored portions of the 52476 have a flat finish, whereas the 9278 has a shinier finish.

My personal preference is the earlier 9278 car, primarily because (at least to me) the shinier finish is nicer looking. One of the main challenges in finding the 9278 is getting one that has the chrome finish in nice shape. Sometimes, if they have not been carefully handled, the chrome finish can deteriorate and get dull (they are, after all, 36+ years old at this point).

2015-01-13 014

2015-01-13 017

2015-01-13 009

2015-01-13 021

2015-01-13 022

2015-01-13 037

2015-01-13 038

Lionel MPC is what got me back into the hobby.  I purchased the heartland Express from the old Nicholas Smith store at 11th and Arch in Philly, in 1977.  After that initial purchase I became hooked and bought many MPC items.  They had great graphics.  They performed well and best of all, were reasonably affordable to me.  

Marek posted:
Alfred E Neuman posted:
Marek posted:

Then I saw this auction, and I told myself I had to get it:

Lot 374: Lionel 6-1487 Broadway LTD Train Set - Incomplete

... once owned by Richard P. Kughn himself!

A good auction nonetheless - got me the Century Club F3s (brand new) for $280, some NYC rolling stock bundle for $90, and a Lionel D&H Alco C-420 #412 brand new for $210...

Was wondering when I saw the ad for that auction if the claim to be part of the Kughn collection was legitimate.  Specifically, broken trains and incomplete sets seemed suspect, as even I don't own anything in such a state and certainly am not at Kughn's level.  Can anyone confirm?

What, me worry? 

There's this article: For the Love of Lionel: The Collection of Richard P. Kughn

Mark

Thanks for the link to that article, but it plays to my initial impression maybe the good stuff really was from the Kughn collection and P&H threw in odds and ends without disclaiming.  Will presume it was all on the up and up since it's too late to participate.  Congratulations on your purchases.

What, me worry?

 

Alfred E Neuman posted:
Marek posted:
Alfred E Neuman posted:
Marek posted:

Then I saw this auction, and I told myself I had to get it:

Lot 374: Lionel 6-1487 Broadway LTD Train Set - Incomplete

... once owned by Richard P. Kughn himself!

A good auction nonetheless - got me the Century Club F3s (brand new) for $280, some NYC rolling stock bundle for $90, and a Lionel D&H Alco C-420 #412 brand new for $210...

Was wondering when I saw the ad for that auction if the claim to be part of the Kughn collection was legitimate.  Specifically, broken trains and incomplete sets seemed suspect, as even I don't own anything in such a state and certainly am not at Kughn's level.  Can anyone confirm?

What, me worry? 

There's this article: For the Love of Lionel: The Collection of Richard P. Kughn

Mark

Thanks for the link to that article, but it plays to my initial impression maybe the good stuff really was from the Kughn collection and P&H threw in odds and ends without disclaiming.  Will presume it was all on the up and up since it's too late to participate.  Congratulations on your purchases.

What, me worry?

 

Actually there are two more auctions... This was part three of five ~

Next one is November 6th I believe... 

Mark 

MPC/Fundimentions/General Mills came about when the original Lionel exited the model train business. It was a time when many guys in their post college years started taking interest in train collecting. MPC purchased the molds/tooling and went about reissuing some of the older catalog items along with some new things. I like MPC trains as they represent a significant period of model train collecting. Some MPC rolling stock is a bit stark looking (unpainted plastic color rolling stock) and their engines were not always very detailed but they are American made,  great runners, reliable and are now very affordable.

About 3/4 of my collection is MPC.   Love the stuff.  Colorful, simple, easy to maintain, and the price is right.   I like just flipping the switch and watching them go.   

It's also fun to collect since there are enough variations to keep it interesting, like with Cracker Jack car, but it's not at the Postwar level of variation insanity.  

The complaints about pulling power I feel are overblown.  MPC engines were designed to pull MPC cars, not strings of postwar operating cars or heavyweight passenger sets.   Give these engines 12-15 cars of similar vintage and they do fine.   (That said, once I had 60 cars tailing my 1985-vintage Illinois Central F-3--I think it could have easily pulled 90).

Tommy_F posted:

The complaints about pulling power I feel are overblown.  MPC engines were designed to pull MPC cars, not strings of postwar operating cars or heavyweight passenger sets.   Give these engines 12-15 cars of similar vintage and they do fine.   (That said, once I had 60 cars tailing my 1985-vintage Illinois Central F-3--I think it could have easily pulled 90).

Has anyone noticed some MPC engines seem to get unusually hot rather quickly running on a 180W PowerHouse through a Legacy PowerMaster, particularly when pulling a long consist of illuminated passenger cars?

Last edited by hobby-go-lucky
hobby-go-lucky posted:
Tommy_F posted:

The complaints about pulling power I feel are overblown.  MPC engines were designed to pull MPC cars, not strings of postwar operating cars or heavyweight passenger sets.   Give these engines 12-15 cars of similar vintage and they do fine.   (That said, once I had 60 cars tailing my 1985-vintage Illinois Central F-3--I think it could have easily pulled 90).

Has anyone noticed some MPC engines seem to get unusually hot rather quickly running on a 180W PowerHouse through a Legacy PowerMaster, particularly when pulling a long consist of illuminated passenger cars?

Which passenger cars? As Tommy F noted, many MPC locos were not designed to pull long strings of heavy cars.

My SUV is not large enough to pull my son's equipment  trailer. That doesn't make it a bad car, or mean my car is underpowered.

ZWPOWER13 posted:
johnstrains posted:

Did somebody day MPC? Great stuff.

Chessie Royal Limited lead by the 8061.

IMG_20171016_185943231

IMG_20171016_190014121

IMG_20171016_190105886

IMG_20171016_190032570

 

John, you need the add on car for this set. The 6208 Chessie Gondola to go with the crane car...

Yes I do, Mark!

But here's the real omission. Was wondering if anyone would call me on it. Missing from my pics (it's still in original box stashed somewhere in the basement) is the 6818 Western Maryland reefer. It's noticeable in Ed H.'s post up above.

Mpc brought back the General and GG-1  

And the majority of my stock is mpc; because of price. 

But it wasn't all sunshine. Gramps cried over MPCs tarnishing of Lionel quality and stopped ordering sight unseen after about 43 years of "just build it and send it". I scoffed at MPC can motor starter sets and debated on HO; I wanted a brush motor even as a kid.

The AC steam was fine. It was the MPC ac diesels than seemed to suffer from "Monday morning factory lemon syndrome", switchers especially. I've lost more mpc engines to age than any other company/era. (Only lost one Marx ever)

They also introduced platic wheels (what?...is this S guage?) and unrectified DC can motors into starter sets without much fanfare or warning ; and that IMO threw the biggest wrench in the box right into the gears of public perception of "military grade" reliability and ruggedness that was still synonymous with Lionel branding at the time.

    I.e. Mpc saved Lionel, but not without some bad toe stubs from stepping off path. I saw stacks of dc starter trains at Kmart burnt up on postwar transformers because the change was downplayed as far as warnings went....and mpc gave them a hard time about accepting them...so Lionel was dropped at Kmart, its last stand in dept. stores here for a long while.

I attribute much of the drop in the prestige of O to MPC. There was also already/still a company making cheap colorful trains...Marx. MPC sort of stomped on their market. I think if Marx would have dropped the "wheel flap trucks" or at least painted them, they would have done much better against MPC in dept. stores; they were very comparable other than that, and Marx was way lower priced.

I keep a sticker of the gram weight under each car I own because as the MPC cars grew in number, so did the stringline derailments that are far more common on the 0-27 curves; light MPC cars MUST go to the tail end. ....my longer trains tend to have a age progressive look from head end to tail end, older to newer, and those great cast cabooses get somewhat limited use now too.

It's been a love/hate relationship between me and Lionel since 1969.

Growing up in the 80's, my dad introduced us to a lot MPC stuff he bought in the 70's and 80's. He also had a fair amount of Postwar stuff that was pretty cherished. Dad would give stuff to me and my brothers for birthdays and running trains was pretty common. We always liked looking at the higher end MPC offerings that he picked up though. He still has his new-in-box & never ran Hudson that he bought new in 83. 

It was pretty obvious to us though that the MPC stuff was cheap and that kind of also help diminish our interests in trains... As kids, we wanted more from our trains.

The 90's rolled around and dad bought some of our first MTH Protosound engines and an articulated steamer and that resparked a lot of interest. The MPC stuff was just laughable and the Postwar stuff was seen as quality but to rare/expensive to run.  We haven't bought much Lionel since,  dad said that he has paid enough money for their stuff which was pretty much the same thing every year with different paint. 

While the MPC era wasn't a bright spot in Lionel history, it did keep the company and the hobby going. I think with the condition of the hobby, economy, and the limited technical resources, MPC trains did about as well as they could do at the time.

The MPC stuff that I have now (given to me by my dad) has great sentimental value and I hope to pass it down to my kids soon.  It still brings me back to the simpler days of running trains and going to large train shows with family. I like the ones that I have, but wouldn't buy anymore no matter how good of a deal it is.

Running my mpc and postwar is very boring, because they always work.   (Granted I only have the middle and high end stuff, but not everything Ford and Chevy have made were perfect; Pinto, Explorer and Corvair to name a few).  

Course that's better than:

-Stuck in reverse

-Engine wont respond to controller 

-Smoke unit burned up because...

-Oh, that's the wrong kind of sinewave for your engine

-Your software level is wrong

-Must be a bad aclu, dclu, tio, tos or "fill in the blank" circuit board.

Except for a SF reefer, I think everything I've bought so far at York has been mpc or postwar.

I am addicted to the price and the quality. 

Last edited by aussteve

The MPC/Fundimensions era were the trains of my formative years. I remember the late postwar era in the 1960's but the 1970's really stick in my mind. I started buying a lot of the rolling stock in the mid 70's. the offerings of this era seem to be a natural progression from the postwar era. I ran large consists of 9700 boxcars behind postwar steam locomotives so the trains were quite impressive. I was delighted when the 8100 N&W Powhatan Arrow passenger set was released in 1981. I removed the old SOS guts and replaced it with Railsounds II tender (Swapped the tender shells). It still runs extremely well. Gotta love those MPC/Fundimensions trains!

C W Burfle posted:

But it wasn't all sunshine. Gramps cried over MPCs tarnishing of Lionel quality and stopped ordering sight unseen after about 43 years of "just build it and send it".

MPC did make some junk, but late Postwar Lionel (1968-69) production stuff wasn't so great either.

Agreed CW but Lionel LLC has had more than it's fair share of "stinkers". Some of the recent starter sets are so cheap, silly looking and miserable it turns my stomach to even see the Lionel name on them. And don't get me started on the Lionel branded battery powered G gauge!

Boomer posted:
C W Burfle posted:

But it wasn't all sunshine. Gramps cried over MPCs tarnishing of Lionel quality and stopped ordering sight unseen after about 43 years of "just build it and send it".

MPC did make some junk, but late Postwar Lionel (1968-69) production stuff wasn't so great either.

Agreed CW but Lionel LLC has had more than it's fair share of "stinkers". Some of the recent starter sets are so cheap, silly looking and miserable it turns my stomach to even see the Lionel name on them. And don't get me started on the Lionel branded battery powered G gauge!

The Dino Diesel Switcher R-T-R set. My local Menards can't give that thing away.

C W Burfle posted:
hobby-go-lucky posted:
Tommy_F posted:

The complaints about pulling power I feel are overblown.  MPC engines were designed to pull MPC cars, not strings of postwar operating cars or heavyweight passenger sets.   Give these engines 12-15 cars of similar vintage and they do fine.   (That said, once I had 60 cars tailing my 1985-vintage Illinois Central F-3--I think it could have easily pulled 90).

Has anyone noticed some MPC engines seem to get unusually hot rather quickly running on a 180W PowerHouse through a Legacy PowerMaster, particularly when pulling a long consist of illuminated passenger cars?

Which passenger cars? As Tommy F noted, many MPC locos were not designed to pull long strings of heavy cars.

My SUV is not large enough to pull my son's equipment  trailer. That doesn't make it a bad car, or mean my car is underpowered.

For example, the 8970 F3-A pulling F3-AB dummies and the eight MPC Congressional Limited cars.  The dual Pullmor motors are up to the task, but the powered locomotive seems to get much hotter much quicker than using an MRC Tech II Trainpower O27 transformer.  Same with the 8302 4-4-2 "Atlantic" pulling nine Baby Madisons comprising the MPC Broadway Limited set.  Just wondering if the 140-watt difference, which does improve pulling performance in terms of speed, is too much if applied too long.  Also using FasTrack with the 180W 18' O72 loop versus O27 profile tubular with the 40W 12' O54 loop.

Boomer posted:
C W Burfle posted:

But it wasn't all sunshine. Gramps cried over MPCs tarnishing of Lionel quality and stopped ordering sight unseen after about 43 years of "just build it and send it".

MPC did make some junk, but late Postwar Lionel (1968-69) production stuff wasn't so great either.

Agreed CW but Lionel LLC has had more than it's fair share of "stinkers". Some of the recent starter sets are so cheap, silly looking and miserable it turns my stomach to even see the Lionel name on them. And don't get me started on the Lionel branded battery powered G gauge!

Agreed.  My son received an O scale Thomas set for Christmas a couple years ago.  That thing gives me fits.  Defective couplers, the drive train sounds like it's about to disintegrate, and the whistle makes Sound of Steam seem authentic

Every era has its lemons--Winner, Scout, DC powered sets, etc.   Lionel isn't all 700Es and aluminum cars

I acquired a taste for MPC, because I have bought Lionel product over the years, including when MPC was new. I initially thought nothing could compare with PW Lionel. Wrong. MPC has a flavor all its own.  For example, I acquired the VGN, NH, and CR rectifiers and built variations of the PW VGN rectifier set (the one with the Timken box car) using MPC pieces, which then generated new enthusiasm.

Last edited by barrister.2u
barrister.2u posted:
  For example, I acquired the VGN, NH, and CR rectifiers and built variations of the PW VGN rectifier set (the one with the Timken box car) using MPC pieces, which then generated new enthusiasm.

I know that VGN set well. Very colorful.

I like to build PW sets one car at a time. The pursuit is fun and can usually do it more cheaply than paying auction prices for complete sets. I've been known to slip in MPC pieces when needed!

Last edited by johnstrains
Marty Fitzhenry posted:

Some MPC rolling stock was ok.  Engines are not ok.  

I have had long lasting success with the MPC engines with metal gears.  I actually prefer several of them over my postwar, like the Fallen Flags engines; the NYC , Union Pacific. &Illinois Central F3's;  and several steamers like the Chessie, Blue Comet. Chicago &Alton. Also the FM's I have had run really well, as do the nicer GP's (NYC, Wabash , & Milwaukee Road).

But then maybe I've just been lucky.

johnstrains posted:
barrister.2u posted:
  For example, I acquired the VGN, NH, and CR rectifiers and built variations of the PW VGN rectifier set (the one with the Timken box car) using MPC pieces, which then generated new enthusiasm.

I know that VGN set well. Very colorful.

I like to build PW sets one car at a time. The pursuit is fun and can usually do it more cheaply than paying auction prices for complete sets. I've been known to slip in MPC pieces when needed!

I had the set of the Virginian SD18s at one time. Wish I hadn't sold them. They were a beautiful set.

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • mceclip0
breezinup posted:
johnstrains posted:
barrister.2u posted:
  For example, I acquired the VGN, NH, and CR rectifiers and built variations of the PW VGN rectifier set (the one with the Timken box car) using MPC pieces, which then generated new enthusiasm.

I know that VGN set well. Very colorful.

I like to build PW sets one car at a time. The pursuit is fun and can usually do it more cheaply than paying auction prices for complete sets. I've been known to slip in MPC pieces when needed!

I had the set of the Virginian SD18s at one time. Wish I hadn't sold them. They were a beautiful set.

 

You asked for it and here they are. We can offer you Free Shipping.

Thanks

Pat

 

ZOOM
$119.99
Lionel 8072 Virginian SD-18 Dummy (Mint)
Stock Number:
6-8072
Gauge:
O/O-27 Gauge
Manufacturer:
Lionel
Product Type:
USED - Modern 1970-Present
Availability:
In Stock
 

ZOOM
$159.95
Lionel 8072 Virginian SD-18 Powered (Mint)
Stock Number:
6-8071
Gauge:
O/O-27 Gauge
Manufacturer:
Lionel
Product Type:
Locomotives
Availability:
In Stock
breezinup posted:
johnstrains posted:
barrister.2u posted:
  For example, I acquired the VGN, NH, and CR rectifiers and built variations of the PW VGN rectifier set (the one with the Timken box car) using MPC pieces, which then generated new enthusiasm.

I know that VGN set well. Very colorful.

I like to build PW sets one car at a time. The pursuit is fun and can usually do it more cheaply than paying auction prices for complete sets. I've been known to slip in MPC pieces when needed!

I had the set of the Virginian SD18s at one time. Wish I hadn't sold them. They were a beautiful set.

 

LOL, over the years I sold off 99% of my MPC/LTI holdings but for some odd reason I kept that set.   BTW, that dummy unit was sold in a year end special where dealers had to buy over $6000 worth of trains & track in that end of year deal  to get just one piece.  It's probably the hardest to find dummy unit in the entire MPC collection.  Call them classic toys from a bygone era.   Nothing inside or out, from Pulmors & E units down to the type of paint used resembles todays offshore production.    Except for those who truly appreciate the added value of holding an iconic toy built in America one piece at a time, you'll be hard pressed to find anyone who still cares about  stuff like that.

joe 

In general, I'm not a huge fan of modern toy trains (my definition of "modern" is anything with a knuckle coupler), but I'll always have an appreciation for MPC-era trains since those were my first. I still have my 8204 C&O steamer, 8200 Kickapoo Valley switcher, and 8030 Illinois Central GP9s. They were the first trains I received as a kid, they have a lot of miles on them, and they have never needed any service other than a little lube. Growing up the son of a tinplate collector, that's really my first love and always will be. 

 

John

Last edited by BlueComet400

I have a collection of MPC that filled a gap for me.  I came back into trains in the MPC era, but I was focused on post-war.  So back when you wanted everything (I used to say I was limiting my collection.  All I wanted has one of everything) I would pick up MPC because that's what was new.  I did appreciate the graphics and the fast angle wheels.  What I didn't appreciate was what I felt to be crummy engines.  I know that they weren't all bad, but too many were.

If you want to run trains on the cheap MPC is great rolling stock (though some cars need to be weighted).  But I've sold all of the engines I had acquired. There weren't many, but they're gone.  I'd sell the rolling stock just to clean up things, but they're really not worth much.  I really did like the Standard O cars.  In their time they were really nice, but even those aren't worth much today.

Alan

Former Member posted:
C W Burfle posted:

But it wasn't all sunshine. Gramps cried over MPCs tarnishing of Lionel quality and stopped ordering sight unseen after about 43 years of "just build it and send it".

MPC did make some junk, but late Postwar Lionel (1968-69) production stuff wasn't so great either.

Agreed CW but Lionel LLC has had more than it's fair share of "stinkers". Some of the recent starter sets are so cheap, silly looking and miserable it turns my stomach to even see the Lionel name on them. And don't get me started on the Lionel branded battery powered G gauge!

You to !Well I had a few lionel sets plastic locomotives.The thing that rubbed me the wrong way.Was the price of these trains.A down payment on a car for any locomotive of any size.But I feel sorry for all who brought the rock island locomotives.They had plastic worm gears.And we all know plastic will wear down faster than metal.

For the time, MPC made pretty good trains. The fewer the features, the less to go wrong. I had very good luck with the engines, even the cheaper ones. A lot more trouble these days with malfunctioning electronics right out of the box.  And, of course, the prices! You could go to a train show in the 1980s and pick up a new MPC Geep or such for around $100. Imagine...

I agree with Dave W.  MPC made trains that were fun to run.  No gimmicks or gadgets to worry about, like electronics getting fried because our train derailed.  

MPC brought out some very nice items that were never made by Lionel prior to 1969.  The heavy weight passenger cars in more road names than you can shake a stick at.  And what about the SD series diesels with their six wheel trucks !   

In this day and age of high priced scale or near scale trains, MPC is a breath of fresh air.  If and when our high-tech society burns out all of it's transistors, we will still be able to run MPC trains !

I'm sorry but i can't tell an SD70 from a 45 or 90.  Same goes for the position of the trucks. Horn, windshield wipers,  fuel tank, handrails, vents, brake lines, valve covers, or cheese grater .  

On a mpc engine I can add some fancy sound system and tmcc if i like.  If it ever quits working I can strip the goods out and throw it away, buy a new for less than the shipping and aggravation and new engine warranty returns.

The crew talk,  , , well after you've heard it six times it begins to sound stupid.  

Most all of my smoke units are turned off except postwar. Mpc and LTI.   Just another thing to burn out on the newer engines. 

Bottom line is they're cheap, reliable and easy to handle without the piping, chains, delicate horns, etc to break off.

Not necessarily for everyone, but I prefer reliability and value.

I loved the offerings and most other Lionel fans did too at that time. 

I vividly remember the start of the General Mills era (MPC/Fundimensions) in 1970. I was so excited when saw the ad in a 1970 Model Railroader for the new Lionel catalog that opened into a poster. 

I remember when the first new sets hit Penney's,Sears,Western Auto and Otasco. 

With my only source of train funds mowing lawns and raking leaves (My parents did not give me an allowance-I had to earn it) I bought mostly rolling stock,especially the 9700 series boxcars, to run behind my post war locomotives. I thought they were a great buy for $4-8 each. I did not buy any locomotives until 1977 when they released the FM Trainmasters. I think the high water mark for this era was 1980-82. In the 1980's I collected quite a bit of the new trains but eventually thinned everything out except the best items of that period. The UP,SP,NYC and N&W passenger sets are my favorites and I still have them. The 8150 Green GG1 is still a stunner. The 783 and 784 Hudsons are proudly displayed with their Postwar and Modern Era siblings. 

Sure there were some "stinkers" but there were also some "rotten eggs" in the Postwar era,the LTI era and continuing into the present Modern era. 

However you see it,this era was critical for Lionel to continue as a viable/profitable train manufacturer.

Ricky 

 

@seaboardm2 The Rock Island Northern wasn't an MPC piece, the MPC era officially ended in 1985.  1986 was a hybrid year, and in 1987 LTI took over.  LTI made some great products too, but the Northern (based on a postwar Berkshire chassis) definitely had some issues!

MPC was pretty conservative with their product choices.  But I would put their dual-motored diesels on par with Postwar.  And I think the small Alco FA and SW switchers were better than their postwar 200- and 600-series counterparts.  Once fully broken in, the 783 is a decent alternative to the 773, maybe better than the '60s version.  MPC kept the fires burning, and if you're not obsessed with realism, IMO it represents a good value today.

I was enamored of the PW stuff when I was a kid in the 50-early 60s.   and some was obviously the "good" stuff to envied as my buddy had a Southern F3 set, an EL Train Master and a set of RDCs that I thought were neat.  

Later when I grew  up, I got some MPC stuff and found it disappointing.    To me, it just did not look as nice and seemed to be a lot less well built.   A lot of stuff was press fit or riveted vs screws on the older stuff.    It was harder to repair because everything seemed flimsy to me.    Even the colors looked more toylike to me that the older stuff.

So I don't like the MPC stuff much at all.    But it probably all depends on what we grew up with.

paigetrain posted:

Forgive my ignorance but wasn't the original sd40 that Lionel made an MPC release? Around like 1985 or 87 I don't have my modern Lionel guide on me right now I am at school

The first SD40, the No. 8265 Santa Fe, was introduced in 1982. Still the Fundimensions (MPC)) era. Kughn bought the company in 1986.

johnstrains posted:
barrister.2u posted:
  For example, I acquired the VGN, NH, and CR rectifiers and built variations of the PW VGN rectifier set (the one with the Timken box car) using MPC pieces, which then generated new enthusiasm.

I know that VGN set well. Very colorful.

I like to build PW sets one car at a time. The pursuit is fun and can usually do it more cheaply than paying auction prices for complete sets. I've been known to slip in MPC pieces when needed!

I added postwar trucks with Magnatraction to my Virginian electric runs extremely well.

When I think about it, I don't even give MPC stuff a first look, let alone a second, when at a show. And I don't own any. That may be due to the fact that during those formative years of mine, I was more interested in N and HO.  So, while it obviously does not have much appeal to me,  I have to confess Jim Sutter's store sure had an impressive collection!

Tuscan Jim posted:

When I think about it, I don't even give MPC stuff a first look, let alone a second, when at a show. And I don't own any. 

Other types of trains appeal to many folks, certainly. However, the MPC stuff is ideal for the LionChief line of engines, which are extremely popular. And given the positive reception to the Menards line, there certainly seems to be a demand for these kinds of items.

Last edited by breezinup
jim sutter posted:

TUSCAN JIM,

Thank you, for your nice comment about our store. We always tried to maintain a inventory of 500 to 600 different Lionel freight cars. Each one was new never run. Back in the late 90's when we were eliminating Lionel from our store, we sold all the different box cars at $18.00 each.

That was a huge inventory!

$18.00 in January 1998 - be about $29.00 in today's dollars, for example.

MPC/Fundimensions/General Mills carried the torch when Lionel quit train production. The products were simple, affordable and made well enough to run well. I have several MPC engines and many pieces of rolling stock. Today they sit mainly on the shelf as later Lionel items kicked off during the Kuhn era provided more detail and improved operating characteristics.  If anyone wishes to get into this hobby on a budget MPC is the ticket.

I received an MPC Conrail rectifier in the mail, yesterday, that I purchased from an Ebay seller.  It's the first MPC piece I've had in a long time.  Sold all my previous stuff years ago.  I'm very impressed with it.  I had forgotten how well they run, even at relatively slow speed.  

I also have a Lionel Lines SD28 Flat Top diesel coming soon.  Always liked the look of six wheeled trucks on Lionel diesels.  

Last edited by Former Member
Tuscan Jim posted:

B'up,

I do enjoy Lionchief (scale, as rare as that is) and also own some Menards rolling stock. I've never thought of mixing in any MPC, perhaps I should consider that.

I regularly run MPC rolling stock with LionChief engines. They're great together. There's a lot of great MPC cars available (including passenger cars), colorful and interesting with terrific graphics, at very reasonable prices. Same size as most Menards cars, but much more variety available. Just looking at beverage cars, for example, strings of the soft drink cars, liquor cars and beer cars are crowd-pleasers, to name just a few of the choices.

breezinup posted:
Tuscan Jim posted:

B'up,

I do enjoy Lionchief (scale, as rare as that is) and also own some Menards rolling stock. I've never thought of mixing in any MPC, perhaps I should consider that.

I regularly run MPC rolling stock with LionChief engines. They're great together. There's a lot of great MPC cars available (including passenger cars), colorful and interesting with terrific graphics, at very reasonable prices. Same size as most Menards cars, but much more variety available. Just looking at beverage cars, for example, strings of the soft drink cars, liquor cars and beer cars are crowd-pleasers, to name just a few of the choices.

Don’t forget the politically incorrect Tabacco cars! Ironic that cigarette companies got their product logos on Lionel box cars.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×