Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hi,

 

Don't know whether you are still interested or not, or even if it's still available, but I just bought the same bus but with different graphics.  The MTH catalog (30-50067) lists these as scale, which I took to mean 1:48 at best, 1:43 at worst and so I went ahead with confidence.  Unfortunately, it's got to be 1:50.  It was so small that I thought an HO model was sent by mistake!

 

I will probably keep it as I got it on sale from a forum sponsor and I think it will be fun to load it up with people.  However, it doesn't look the way I envisioned next to my trains nor my trolley.  And next to my 1:42 Dodge Power Wagon Kinsmart trucks (the only other vehicles I currently have) ... Well, you don't want to go there!  Visually it's just too tiny to put next to any of those.  If you have a big layout, it might look nice in the back somewhere given the colorful graphics of the eBay example.  Alas, my layout is too small to hide such a dramatic scale mismatch. Not that this ever bothered me as a kid ... :-)

 

Tomlinson Run Railroad

Last edited by TomlinsonRunRR

Here's a photo of the MTH bus (Milwaukee Road) next to a Corgi bus (a GMC Yellow Coach 743). It does look a bit small, as the Yellow Coach was a smaller prototype compared to the later model represented by the MTH bus. I think it's OK on a layout as long as it's carefully positioned so as not to be next to something with which it's not in proportion. If it's driving down the road by itself,or in a bus station that's in the background, it should be fine. I wouldn't put it next to a 1:43 1938 Cadillac. I got it as a flat car load and it looks OK in that role. 

 

BUS - MTH vs Corgi

Attachments

Images (1)
  • BUS - MTH vs Corgi

It's a Corgi 1:50 model, so it a very close match for O-gauge 1:48. I have both Corgi and MTH models and they are the identical castings, etc. Southwest Hiawatha's photos shows two buses that are both Corgi models, just of different buses - one is earlier and a bit smaller than the other.   Corgi makes a variety of 1:50 buses and some of those made in the 30s are quite small (as they were) and some made decades later much larger, as they were.  

 

I have a number of Corgi, MTH, and similarly licensed Corgi-casting buses on my layout, many converted to 'Streets.  They are good looking, nicely detailed, and close to scale. 

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Suite 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×